The Challenge: What Ifs

2450 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

What if AYTO: Second Chances never happened and the entire cast was available to do Invasion of the Champions? How would that change that season's cast and potentially future seasons?

It wouldnt have because Invasion ended on november 19th and Second chances started filming November 21st. None of those people were consider to en on for the exception of Devin.

I read on here that Adam Kuhn picked Second Chances over Invasion and he never got called after that. Did calls for both go out around the same time?

 

 

What if AYTO: Second Chances never happened and the entire cast was available to do Invasion of the Champions? How would that change that season's cast and potentially future seasons?

It wouldnt have because Invasion ended on november 19th and Second chances started filming November 21st. None of those people were consider to en on for the exception of Devin.

I was thinking the exact same thing. AYTO Second Chances probably helped out Tori get into the Challenge World. 

I think she probably gets on anyways since they were still casting a decent amount from AYTO at that point, even before SC her and Devin were the faces of the show

I'm so surprised that AYTO4 had such heavy presence on Second Chances (Tori Morgan Kaylen Asaf Gio Francesca Kam Mikala) - 4 out of the 10 teams - and then we only got Tori on The Challenge (and then Asaf for one episode like 7 years later)

what if on total madness jenny got eliminated at 5 and the f4 was dee,kaycee,bayleigh, and melissa? Who wins?

What if TJ retires. Whos the new host?

What if TJ retires. Whos the new host?

The "Great and Powerful" Mr. Johnny Bananas. I wouldn't be surprised.

 

What if TJ retires. Whos the new host?

The "Great and Powerful" Mr. Johnny Bananas. I wouldn't be surprised.

honestly ill take it over having him on the actual show lol 

 

What if TJ retires. Whos the new host?

The "Great and Powerful" Mr. Johnny Bananas. I wouldn't be surprised.

Would he be professional enough to do it? I can see The Miz doing it

Thinking about that, if Kayleigh doesn't quit on Vendettas, she'll probably stay around until the Ronda purge, where she would've been eliminated instead of Jemmye, making her an iconic resumee of getting out in her three seasons via a purge.

 

 

What if TJ retires. Whos the new host?

The "Great and Powerful" Mr. Johnny Bananas. I wouldn't be surprised.

Would he be professional enough to do it? I can see The Miz doing it

yeah I could see Miz doing it too, but I'm def for them bringing back Johnny Mosely and his vibe back to the show lol

What if TJ retires. Whos the new host?

I would love to see Coral, Day or Devyn because all three would call people out.  The Miz or even Mark Long would also make sense but TJ will never walk away from this.  It's an amazing job.

 

What if TJ retires. Whos the new host?

I would love to see Coral, Day or Devyn because all three would call people out.  The Miz or even Mark Long would also make sense but TJ will never walk away from this.  It's an amazing job.

coral would be outstanding 

what if on total madness jenny got eliminated at 5 and the f4 was dee,kaycee,bayleigh, and melissa? Who wins?

Dee, assuming Mel & Bay are still gone after day 1. Kaycee was never beating anyone

I'm so surprised that AYTO4 had such heavy presence on Second Chances (Tori Morgan Kaylen Asaf Gio Francesca Kam Mikala) - 4 out of the 10 teams - and then we only got Tori on The Challenge (and then Asaf for one episode like 7 years later)

i thought gio and Kaylen were supposed to be on dirty 30, but gio failed his psych test so they dropped them both

never heard that at all

 

what if on total madness jenny got eliminated at 5 and the f4 was dee,kaycee,bayleigh, and melissa? Who wins?

Dee, assuming Mel & Bay are still gone after day 1. Kaycee was never beating anyone

I wonder how Nany would have done if she eliminated Melissa.

never heard that at all

if you meant what I said, you missed a fun time on insta, gio had like a span of lives where he was like going off on the challenge being like you don't think I'm sane? And like punching a punching bag and operating a handsaw. It was a lot

jesus CHRIST!! so I guess I should stop waiting for him to show up on The Challenge then *****.

god, Dirty 30 is what could have been. I remember reading that Cody and Makani from Stranded were called from it, and some people from RW Bad Blood (Anna, Tyara). Of course Coral as well. Averey. And hold up, "When CT's passport was denied, Dylan Moore was flown to Columbia as a replacement in case CT couldn't get there. CT did arrive, Dylan got sent home without competing."

WHAT?! he was screwed two seasons in a row ?!?

 

 

 

What if AYTO: Second Chances never happened and the entire cast was available to do Invasion of the Champions? How would that change that season's cast and potentially future seasons?

It wouldnt have because Invasion ended on november 19th and Second chances started filming November 21st. None of those people were consider to en on for the exception of Devin.

I was thinking the exact same thing. AYTO Second Chances probably helped out Tori get into the Challenge World. 

I think she probably gets on anyways since they were still casting a decent amount from AYTO at that point, even before SC her and Devin were the faces of the show

I have to disagree with you on Tori being the face of the show. The faces of the show was Gio, Kaylen, and Asaf. 

Second chances was able to show Tori's competitive side. 

 

jesus CHRIST!! so I guess I should stop waiting for him to show up on The Challenge then *****.

god, Dirty 30 is what could have been. I remember reading that Cody and Makani from Stranded were called from it, and some people from RW Bad Blood (Anna, Tyara). Of course Coral as well. Averey. And hold up, "When CT's passport was denied, Dylan Moore was flown to Columbia as a replacement in case CT couldn't get there. CT did arrive, Dylan got sent home without competing."

WHAT?! he was screwed two seasons in a row ?!?

I can't be too mad at CT making Dirty Thirty because that was the last season he truly competed.  Although it would have been interesting to have Dylan on there. Maybe replace Derrick from AYTO for Dylan. 

 

jesus CHRIST!! so I guess I should stop waiting for him to show up on The Challenge then *****.

god, Dirty 30 is what could have been. I remember reading that Cody and Makani from Stranded were called from it, and some people from RW Bad Blood (Anna, Tyara). Of course Coral as well. Averey. And hold up, "When CT's passport was denied, Dylan Moore was flown to Columbia as a replacement in case CT couldn't get there. CT did arrive, Dylan got sent home without competing."

WHAT?! he was screwed two seasons in a row ?!?

I can't be too mad at CT making Dirty Thirty because that was the last season he truly competed.  Although it would have been interesting to have Dylan on there. Maybe replace Derrick from AYTO for Dylan. 

dario was a waste of a spot that season. His only contribution was to be the butt of Jemmye's real world joke montage lol

dirty 30 truly did have some missed opportunities for casting. Beth not being asked at all and her saying she would do it is still a travesty in my book, among other alums. 

What if Key West (Bananas, Janelle, Paula, and Tyler) weren't dropped for Fresh Meat as Sydney's replacement? How would that affect the game?

What if Averey & Nia and Marie & Sam were on Rivals II as originally planned? How would that change the cast?

Averey & Nia likely make the final

Casey confirmed on challenge mania that she backed out of Exes at the last minute. So what if she didn't back out, and how would it affect Johnnys career from that point on?

What if Key West (Bananas, Janelle, Paula, and Tyler) weren't dropped for Fresh Meat as Sydney's replacement? How would that affect the game?

What if Averey & Nia and Marie & Sam were on Rivals II as originally planned? How would that change the cast?

I wonder if they would've paired with Austin and gotten more of an alliance started since Johnny was good at making alliances. I think Nia and Averey would have made it to the finals.

 

 

Casey confirmed on challenge mania that she backed out of Exes at the last minute. So what if she didn't back out, and how would it affect Johnnys career from that point on?

I definitely don't see him making it to the final with her. I still think he would've been back as many times as he was, we would have a different champion that season. I wish Mark and Robin were at that final 

Averey & Nia likely make the final

Nah. Nia was not that stellar in dailies and excelled in eliminations that suited her size, which none of the Rivals 2 girl eliminations were physical. Def see them making it at least half way tho.

Casey confirmed on challenge mania that she backed out of Exes at the last minute. So what if she didn't back out, and how would it affect Johnnys career from that point on?

It changes the entire season, since Johnny & Camilla won a couple missions early on. Wes probably is in a better position if Johns with Casey. I'd guess CT & Diem win, but possibly Mark and Robin

what if shauvon's implant never popped

what if shauvon's implant never popped

The challengers dont win the only one they did lol

Pages