The Challenge: What Ifs

2455 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

 

 

 

To go along with the John question: what if Cara Maria never got a second shot after Fresh Meat 2's first elimination?

Idk, Laurel might be Shauvon's rival, no? who else did Laurel have beef with on cutthroat?

Abe.  But that wouldn't work for that season lol.  Prob would have gotten her someone from Fresh Meat 2 or just not used her.

There you go, laurel probs wouldn't be on Rivals or maybe any other subsequent season?

They could have done a Laurel/Carley (bc of the reunion) or a Laurel/Theresa pairing, of course that gets rid of the Theresa/Camila pairing 

Laurel and Theresa sounds more realistic. Was Carley contacted for Cutthroat? Maybe she would've done that too and continue the Laurel rivalry post FM2 reunion.

Carley said yes for Cutthroat but wasn't used. no idea why they would rather cast Mandi rather than Champ Carley but here we are

Carley said yes for Cutthroat but wasn't used. no idea why they would rather cast Mandi rather than Champ Carley but here we are

So they should have kept casting her because Landon carried her *** for an entire season?

 

Carley said yes for Cutthroat but wasn't used. no idea why they would rather cast Mandi rather than Champ Carley but here we are

So they should have kept casting her because Landon carried her *** for an entire season?

What Mandi really do besides being manhandled by the troll that is Jenn

Carley said yes for Cutthroat but wasn't used. no idea why they would rather cast Mandi rather than Champ Carley but here we are

Mandi had a fight and was more attractive to the viewers, carley didnt really do anything the whole season 

What if Dustin and Heather never got DQ'd, I personally think they dont make it to the finals but have a shot to get pretty deep.

What if Dustin and Heather never got DQ'd, I personally think they dont make it to the finals but have a shot to get pretty deep.

I think they could make the final. They were a good team for the couple of challenges they did. And I think they had a good alliance going, or I remember them trying. I just wish Heather would have done more challenges. I thought for sure she was going to be a challenge regular.

What if Sarah finished faster than bananas during the final on rivals 3? Has she said she would take the money or split? 

What if Sarah finished faster than bananas during the final on rivals 3? Has she said she would take the money or split? 

I legit think she would have split it.  Based on what she has said on the podcast.

What if Rachel got Darrell as a partner instead of Aneesa on exes?  Would they win?

They would've ATLEAST made the final.

What if Kenny and Evan weren't banned after Rivals?

What if Kenny and Evan weren't banned after Rivals?

production wouldn't have used Bananas every season.

If I had to pick the one rodent from that tragic, show-ruining alliance to have done 20 seasons, it would've been Kenny. He was the only one with an actual personality.

I was glad there was a point where one or two of them would take a damn break so maybe had they not been so disgustuing we would have seen diffrent kind of dynamics... or not. I don't see Evan clicking with the same folks Kenny and Johnny were able to tag along

If I had to pick the one rodent from that tragic, show-ruining alliance to have done 20 seasons, it would've been Kenny. He was the only one that was attractive.

Honestly I think Evan still retires after Rivals as he seemed to be over the show at that point. Kenny on the other hand would've still done them and instead of kissing Backpacks *** they kiss Kenny's *** instead.

Honestly I think Evan still retires after Rivals as he seemed to be over the show at that point. Kenny on the other hand would've still done them and instead of kissing Backpacks *** they kiss Kenny's *** instead.

Well Evan was probably over the show for the same reason that he was banned from the show(based on him only doing rivals after the ruins, which was to help Kenny & John). If what happened to get them banned never happened, it's very possible he's down to continue for another decade

To go off the current sad subject.  What if what happened to Tonya didn't happen, and she didn't hit Veronica?  How long does she last on the Ruins and does she come back for future seasons?

To go off the current sad subject.  What if what happened to Tonya didn't happen, and she didn't hit Veronica?  How long does she last on the Ruins and does she come back for future seasons?

Tonya was not sane that season and there would have been another reason she would have been sent home. Not saying she deserved anything that happened but she shouldn't have been there to begin with. If she was sane I see her lasting until the champs were forced to put in Johanna and Tonya would have lost to a KellyAnne or Sarah easily. 

This one leaves a sour taste in my mouth everytime I think about it lol. What if Landon beat Brad on the Duel 2 and made it to the final? I still believe Landon should have not received a penalty for "man-handling" Brad in that elimination and then Brad doesn't get any penalty for interfering with Landons ring. Def top 5 biggest bullshit things I have seen next to Laurel DQing to Ninja "Momo" and Wes and Kenny losing their 45 min lead in Rivals down  to like a 2 min head start. If Landon made it to the final on the Duel 2 I am very confident he would have won. That would mean Evan wouldn't be on the Champs team for the Ruins too which could have changed the game there.

This one leaves a sour taste in my mouth everytime I think about it lol. What if Landon beat Brad on the Duel 2 and made it to the final? I still believe Landon should have not received a penalty for "man-handling" Brad in that elimination and then Brad doesn't get any penalty for interfering with Landons ring. Def top 5 biggest bullshit things I have seen next to Laurel DQing to Ninja "Momo" and Wes and Kenny losing their 45 min lead in Rivals down  to like a 2 min head start. If Landon made it to the final on the Duel 2 I am very confident he would have won. That would mean Evan wouldn't be on the Champs team for the Ruins too which could have changed the game there.

Landon is the undisputed GOAT if he wins Duel 2 althoguh i think he already is and without Evan on the champs team depending on who they cast maybe Wes and Ev can make something happen and the challengers have a chance as well 

What if Dustin, Marie, and Nia were all on Bloodlines? Who would they replace and how would the season play out?

What if Tony never collapsed on Bloodlines and stayed in the game with Shane? How would that affect the rest of the season?

What if Camila got removed o.n Dirty 30 who do see winning and in the finals?

Dp

What if Dustin, Marie, and Nia were all on Bloodlines? Who would they replace and how would the season play out?

What if Tony never collapsed on Bloodlines and stayed in the game with Shane? How would that affect the rest of the season?

I think Marie/Victoria and Nia/Makeda replace Jenna/Brianna and Christina/Emily imo

Dustin is tricky since I think he would've been with his sister and Leroy, Cara, KellyAnne have more of a priority over him. They might pick him over Cohutta or just add another team

Tony gets eliminated mid way when Shane gets voted into elimination 

 

 

What if Dustin, Marie, and Nia were all on Bloodlines? Who would they replace and how would the season play out?

What if Tony never collapsed on Bloodlines and stayed in the game with Shane? How would that affect the rest of the season?

I think Marie/Victoria and Nia/Makeda replace Jenna/Brianna and Christina/Emily imo

Dustin is tricky since I think he would've been with his sister and Leroy, Cara, KellyAnne have more of a priority over him. They might pick him over Cohutta or just add another team

Tony gets eliminated mid way when Shane gets voted into elimination 

 

Dustin did an interview with Mike Lewis a couple of weeks ago and said he would've been on with his brother

I see the final being run by tori,Jenna, and Cara with it being close with Jenna & Cara all depending on who they get partnered with. Lowkey see Jenna having an easier time than Cara bc of the endurance. 

What if Camila got removed o.n Dirty 30 who do see winning and in the finals?

i think Cara Maria would have won. I think it could have gone many ways. If Camilla would have been kicked off right away it def would have changed things. Veronica had a killer season...if she didn't get sent straight to the redemption house I could see her making it to at least the last mission. I think either Jenna or Veronica would have taken the final spot with Tori and Cara Maria. Veronica is scrappy and easily could have beat Jenna & Kailah who just hung there during the final purge lol. I know I'm biased towards her but I guess she's my final choice. So Cara Maria, Tori and Veronica and they would come in that order for the final as well.  I just rewatched this season so it's pretty fresh in my mind. 

What if Dustin, Marie, and Nia were all on Bloodlines? Who would they replace and how would the season play out?

What if Tony never collapsed on Bloodlines and stayed in the game with Shane? How would that affect the rest of the season?

I would hope they would replace - Christina, Camilla, and Dario. I didn't care much for that season but those three teams didn't seem to do much to warrent memories. Man if all three of those teams were there it would have been amazing (mainly Nia & Marie)

I agree wirh another response, Shane gets put in elimination and gets sent home. 

What if Jenny didn't get to go against Amazing Race Jenn in the first elimination this season. Would the girls ever let her into an elimination as the game progresses?

Pages