The Challenge: What Ifs

2450 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

What if Nany wins the elimination against Ashley on WOTW2?

Nothing she would have been purged on the final first part she isn't beating anyone on either team in a puzzle

eh, sometimes puzzles can just be luck. I think she would have had a small chance. She would have at least gave me someone to root for, but I hated Paulie more than Rogan so I'm happy Paulie didn't win that season. 

what if Tonya didn't smack Veronica and Darrell didn't beat the crap out of Brad. Would final teams on the ruins be any different? 

 

 

What if Nany wins the elimination against Ashley on WOTW2?

Nothing she would have been purged on the final first part she isn't beating anyone on either team in a puzzle

eh, sometimes puzzles can just be luck. I think she would have had a small chance. She would have at least gave me someone to root for, but I hated Paulie more than Rogan so I'm happy Paulie didn't win that season. 

what if Tonya didn't smack Veronica and Darrell didn't beat the crap out of Brad. Would final teams on the ruins be any different? 

Veronica would've still lost. It probably would've been V vs Sarah in that pool/floating elimination, as Susie and Jo were in the majority alliance. Darrell probably would've had his 5th win. 

Brad also has to go against one of the Champ guys in another elimination, Darrell had made a deal to with JEK to get in the final and Johnny was the bitch of JEKD so he probably goes against Brad and loses. Final teams are likely Darrell, Evan, Derrick, Kenny, Susie & Johanna against Brad, KellyAnne & Sarah

Brad also has to go against one of the Champ guys in another elimination, Darrell had made a deal to with JEK to get in the final and Johnny was the bitch of JEKD so he probably goes against Brad and loses. Final teams are likely Darrell, Evan, Derrick, Kenny, Susie & Johanna against Brad, KellyAnne & Sarah

Remember Susie has to against Kim, so I think Jo would lose to Kim. Also with Dunbar loosing to John in the second to last elimination (there would;ve been one more if Brad was still in the game) it woudl've been Brad vs John in that bamboo kicking elimination. A crapshoot.

 

Brad also has to go against one of the Champ guys in another elimination, Darrell had made a deal to with JEK to get in the final and Johnny was the bitch of JEKD so he probably goes against Brad and loses. Final teams are likely Darrell, Evan, Derrick, Kenny, Susie & Johanna against Brad, KellyAnne & Sarah

Remember Susie has to against Kim, so I think Jo would lose to Kim. Also with Dunbar loosing to John in the second to last elimination (there would;ve been one more if Brad was still in the game) it woudl've been Brad vs John in that bamboo kicking elimination. A crapshoot.

Crapshoot or not, my money's on Brad over Bananas in basically anything

 

 

Brad also has to go against one of the Champ guys in another elimination, Darrell had made a deal to with JEK to get in the final and Johnny was the bitch of JEKD so he probably goes against Brad and loses. Final teams are likely Darrell, Evan, Derrick, Kenny, Susie & Johanna against Brad, KellyAnne & Sarah

Remember Susie has to against Kim, so I think Jo would lose to Kim. Also with Dunbar loosing to John in the second to last elimination (there would;ve been one more if Brad was still in the game) it woudl've been Brad vs John in that bamboo kicking elimination. A crapshoot.

Crapshoot or not, my money's on Brad over Bananas in basically anything

Fair point.

 

Brad also has to go against one of the Champ guys in another elimination, Darrell had made a deal to with JEK to get in the final and Johnny was the bitch of JEKD so he probably goes against Brad and loses. Final teams are likely Darrell, Evan, Derrick, Kenny, Susie & Johanna against Brad, KellyAnne & Sarah

Remember Susie has to against Kim, so I think Jo would lose to Kim. Also with Dunbar loosing to John in the second to last elimination (there would;ve been one more if Brad was still in the game) it woudl've been Brad vs John in that bamboo kicking elimination. A crapshoot.

If we still get the crapshoot. I could see them doing an entire different elimination now that it wasn't just the girls

What if CT never got kicked off any challenges? How many seasons would he have done and how successful would he be?

What if CT never got kicked off any challenges? How many seasons would he have done and how successful would he be?

He probably wins Inferno III, I think that's a pretty fair statement. Duel II who knows that was a pretty stacked cast. He probably end up on the ruins champs team, with a decent chance of winning depending on who he replaces. But he doesn't get the huge cutthroat moment that led to him coming back and being a fan favourite on Rivals, and there's a real possibility he never gets his redemption edit and he continues to be seen as an *******, so we don't have casuals threatening to quit watching every season when he's gone...so maybe he isn't on the show anymore

Brad also has to go against one of the Champ guys in another elimination, Darrell had made a deal to with JEK to get in the final and Johnny was the bitch of JEKD so he probably goes against Brad and loses. Final teams are likely Darrell, Evan, Derrick, Kenny, Susie & Johanna against Brad, KellyAnne & Sarah

What about tonya tho... Do you see her losing elimination? I cant really see her losing an elimination 

 

Brad also has to go against one of the Champ guys in another elimination, Darrell had made a deal to with JEK to get in the final and Johnny was the bitch of JEKD so he probably goes against Brad and loses. Final teams are likely Darrell, Evan, Derrick, Kenny, Susie & Johanna against Brad, KellyAnne & Sarah

What about tonya tho... Do you see her losing elimination? I cant really see her losing an elimination 

She probably has to beat Sarah or KellyAnne to make the final, since I don't really see JEK sending in Johanna or Susie over her. I don't think that happens, and I think she'd be sent in multiple times just for being at the bottom of the totem pole

What if Cory won Bloodlines. When would Cara snag her first win?

Maybe still vendettas?

Curious as to who would've been the 4th champ in invasions tho.

She would be wes partner for rivals 3 so they could def win. 

Maybe still vendettas?

Curious as to who would've been the 4th champ in invasions tho.

Considering the female alt was Sam it's possible they just scrap the champions theme. Cara probably does Rivals 3 though if she doesn't win Bloodlines, wonder who her partner would be? Off the top of my head Bananas & Wes are the only guy Rivals I remember for her from then and Bananas was always gonna be with Sarah

What if there was no redemption house and no mercenaries in final reckoning? How does that go? 

What if there was no redemption house and no mercenaries in final reckoning? How does that go? 

Way different game if there's also no opening purge, but the team that should have won in the first place probably gets it done which is Zach & Amanda, unfortunately that means Zach probably goes home a millionare

What if Dustin never got that casting producer in trouble when Bloodlines calls were going out? How many more seasons does he do and how would he perform?

What if Dustin never got that casting producer in trouble when Bloodlines calls were going out? How many more seasons does he do and how would he perform?

Maybe 2 or 3. I personally never found Dustin too annoying

She would be wes partner for rivals 3 so they could def win. 

I think so too. If only Wes (and Nany) cared that season - they could've made something happen. But Wes/Cara would've been the ultimate foil to Johnny/Sarah.

 

What if there was no redemption house and no mercenaries in final reckoning? How does that go? 

Way different game if there's also no opening purge, but the team that should have won in the first place probably gets it done which is Zach & Amanda, unfortunately that means Zach probably goes home a millionare

maybe Joss/Sylvia pull it out, but I agree that Zach/Amanda are the champs

I love the Ruins what if so I'm gonna ask one more.

what if Cara Z stayed on the cast, and Susie wasn't on it, how would that have changed anything - also would we have seen Susie again?

I love the Ruins what if so I'm gonna ask one more.

what if Cara Z stayed on the cast, and Susie wasn't on it, how would that have changed anything - also would we have seen Susie again?

Cara Z loses to Kim in Ragdoll for sure. I think we see Susie on Fresh Meat II instead of Evelyn TBH.

 

I love the Ruins what if so I'm gonna ask one more.

what if Cara Z stayed on the cast, and Susie wasn't on it, how would that have changed anything - also would we have seen Susie again?

Cara Z loses to Kim in Ragdoll for sure. I think we see Susie on Fresh Meat II instead of Evelyn TBH.

Evelyn was only on Fresh Meat II because Jonna lost her passport

What if Dustin never got that casting producer in trouble when Bloodlines calls were going out? How many more seasons does he do and how would he perform?

Need info on this. What did he do? Is that why he doesn't get contacted anymore?

 

What if Dustin never got that casting producer in trouble when Bloodlines calls were going out? How many more seasons does he do and how would he perform?

Need info on this. What did he do? Is that why he doesn't get contacted anymore?

Back when calls were going out, a casting producer told him that he couldn't be on because of legal issues. He called her boss and tried to get her in trouble. They took his name off the casting list after that.

What if Wes stayed retired after The Duel? What's his legacy and what happens to the show?

 

 

I love the Ruins what if so I'm gonna ask one more.

what if Cara Z stayed on the cast, and Susie wasn't on it, how would that have changed anything - also would we have seen Susie again?

Cara Z loses to Kim in Ragdoll for sure. I think we see Susie on Fresh Meat II instead of Evelyn TBH.

Evelyn was only on Fresh Meat II because Jonna lost her passport

Yeah so instead of Evelyn replacing Jonna, Susie replaces Jonna.

 

 

 

I love the Ruins what if so I'm gonna ask one more.

what if Cara Z stayed on the cast, and Susie wasn't on it, how would that have changed anything - also would we have seen Susie again?

Cara Z loses to Kim in Ragdoll for sure. I think we see Susie on Fresh Meat II instead of Evelyn TBH.

Evelyn was only on Fresh Meat II because Jonna lost her passport

Yeah so instead of Evelyn replacing Jonna, Susie replaces Jonna.

That's assuming that Susie agrees to be an alternate. Speaking of which I'm surprised Evelyn agreed to be an alt in the first place, is there any backstory on that?

 

 

 

 

I love the Ruins what if so I'm gonna ask one more.

what if Cara Z stayed on the cast, and Susie wasn't on it, how would that have changed anything - also would we have seen Susie again?

Cara Z loses to Kim in Ragdoll for sure. I think we see Susie on Fresh Meat II instead of Evelyn TBH.

Evelyn was only on Fresh Meat II because Jonna lost her passport

Yeah so instead of Evelyn replacing Jonna, Susie replaces Jonna.

That's assuming that Susie agrees to be an alternate. Speaking of which I'm surprised Evelyn agreed to be an alt in the first place, is there any backstory on that?

[/quote]

Yes. So random but I remember they had the dailies back then for the seasons where it was behind the scenes footage. The alumni were on the bus on their way to the challenge (no fresh meat yet) and Jillian and Danny were talking about Jonna not being there because of her losing her passport. Then Jillian said that Evelyn was supposed to be there but backed out last min for some reason and Jillian took her spot. I remember Jillian posted on social media that she had to pack fast for something so I guess Jillian was kinda an alternate at first and was asked to come last min when Evelyn dropped. Then when Jonna lost her passport they probably called Evelyn and she then agreed to come. 

 

 

Pages