The Challenge: What Ifs

2450 posts / 0 new
Last post

Same what if regarding Looper:

Wes vs Bananas - I feel like that would be interesting who would come out on top

 

 

What if Dustin never got that casting producer in trouble when Bloodlines calls were going out? How many more seasons does he do and how would he perform?

Need info on this. What did he do? Is that why he doesn't get contacted anymore?

Back when calls were going out, a casting producer told him that he couldn't be on because of legal issues. He called her boss and tried to get her in trouble. They took his name off the casting list after that.

what were his legal issues?

 

 

 

What if Dustin never got that casting producer in trouble when Bloodlines calls were going out? How many more seasons does he do and how would he perform?

Need info on this. What did he do? Is that why he doesn't get contacted anymore?

Back when calls were going out, a casting producer told him that he couldn't be on because of legal issues. He called her boss and tried to get her in trouble. They took his name off the casting list after that.

what were his legal issues?

I don't remember offhand but Pink knows

 

 

 

 

What if Dustin never got that casting producer in trouble when Bloodlines calls were going out? How many more seasons does he do and how would he perform?

Need info on this. What did he do? Is that why he doesn't get contacted anymore?

Back when calls were going out, a casting producer told him that he couldn't be on because of legal issues. He called her boss and tried to get her in trouble. They took his name off the casting list after that.

what were his legal issues?

I don't remember offhand but Pink knows

he got a DUI and got in trouble for groping a woman at a bar and drunkenly slurring that she should like it because he's a TV star

 

 

 

 

 

What if Dustin never got that casting producer in trouble when Bloodlines calls were going out? How many more seasons does he do and how would he perform?

Need info on this. What did he do? Is that why he doesn't get contacted anymore?

Back when calls were going out, a casting producer told him that he couldn't be on because of legal issues. He called her boss and tried to get her in trouble. They took his name off the casting list after that.

what were his legal issues?

I don't remember offhand but Pink knows

he got a DUI and got in trouble for groping a woman at a bar and drunkenly slurring that she should like it because he's a TV star

Wow I did not know that, no wonder we never got to see him on the challenge anymore what a shame. 

What happens if Davonne does do WOW 2, how does the season change?

As she disliked Cara and Wes, I'd assume she'd work with Bananas, Leroy, Zach, Tori, Jordan, Laurel, etc. and can probably pull Josh in sooner. 

What about Ashley? Thinking she still sticks with Cara's group even tho her and Davonne are cool. I can see Kam fliipping though. 

What happens if Davonne does do WOW 2, how does the season change?

As she disliked Cara and Wes, I'd assume she'd work with Bananas, Leroy, Zach, Tori, Jordan, Laurel, etc. and can probably pull Josh in sooner. 

What about Ashley? Thinking she still sticks with Cara's group even tho her and Davonne are cool. I can see Kam fliipping though. 

Ashley would go wherever the numbers were, like she did during the actual season

Hard to say for me, I think there's a possibility that politics would sort of stay the same regardless of if Da'Vonne was there or not. I still see Laruel's elimination playing out the way it did given how her, Bananas and Wes were all playing the game, with Paulie having some pull to keep Da'Vonne around. So she'd either take Tori's place during her first elimination (lose or upset against Georgia) thus delaying Tori/Jordan's heats or she takes Ashley's place in the final elimination, still beating Nany and getting purged in the final.

What if Kenny is given the two wins from G3 and Rivals (should be his win more than G3) and never gets banned?

What if Kenny is given the two wins from G3 and Rivals (should be his win more than G3) and never gets banned?

Instead of JEK, it would be JK + about 3/4 of each Challenge cast sucking up to them forever more.  But like on The Ruins, J would probably find himself at the bottom of the pile again and K would be running the show.

Evelyn supposed to have 5 wins

Hard to say for me, I think there's a possibility that politics would sort of stay the same regardless of if Da'Vonne was there or not. I still see Laruel's elimination playing out the way it did given how her, Bananas and Wes were all playing the game, with Paulie having some pull to keep Da'Vonne around. So she'd either take Tori's place during her first elimination (lose or upset against Georgia) thus delaying Tori/Jordan's heats or she takes Ashley's place in the final elimination, still beating Nany and getting purged in the final.

You're overrating Georgia. Da'Vonne can beat Georgia, it wouldn't be an upset. 

Evelyn supposed to have 5 wins

Kenny should have 5 wins, Wes should have 3, CT should have 4 and Diem should have one. Not sure who else im missing 

 

Hard to say for me, I think there's a possibility that politics would sort of stay the same regardless of if Da'Vonne was there or not. I still see Laruel's elimination playing out the way it did given how her, Bananas and Wes were all playing the game, with Paulie having some pull to keep Da'Vonne around. So she'd either take Tori's place during her first elimination (lose or upset against Georgia) thus delaying Tori/Jordan's heats or she takes Ashley's place in the final elimination, still beating Nany and getting purged in the final.

You're overrating Georgia. Da'Vonne can beat Georgia, it wouldn't be an upset. 

Not from my lens, I think Da'vonne could talk her depending on the task. She's proven herself.

https://medium.com/@NovaRogue/updated-challenge-champions-list-if-there-were-no-f-ckery-from-stupid-rules-or-production-770f09a950eb

Interesting. Not here for Kenny being top dog but I'm here for everything else. Landon and his 4/4 wins >>>>>>>>>

I would add a what if for CT & Diem winning Exes just because that's what everyone WANTED.

 

https://medium.com/@NovaRogue/updated-challenge-champions-list-if-there-were-no-f-ckery-from-stupid-rules-or-production-770f09a950eb

Interesting. Not here for Kenny being top dog but I'm here for everything else. Landon and his 4/4 wins >>>>>>>>>

I would add a what if for CT & Diem winning Exes just because that's what everyone WANTED.

I gotta add Tori Deal for WotW2. and no, I don't think CT/Diem deserved a win on Exes 1. I would've preferred it but they had TWO chances to throw in Johnny/Camila against Ty/Emily and ****** it both times.

Here are some what ifs

What if Coral and Melissa Howard were on the Inferno 2 Bad *** team instead of Rachel and Beth like original my planned? How would the bad *** team perform now?

What if Trishelle, Coral, Veronica, and Tina agreed to do the Gauntlet 2 as originally planned? Who would they have replaced? And how would the vets do?

What would have happened if Svetlana was on the challenge Gauntlet 3 as it was planned instead of Melinda? Would she have made it to the end? Would she win?

What if Beth didn't quit on Gauntlet 2 and didn't let Coral win on Gauntlet 3? Would she have been able to make it to the end?

What if The Island turned out to be the Duel 2 as we all originally thought? With that cast who would have been the final 2 guys and girls? Who would win? Who would have been the people thrown in multiple times like Aneesa and Svetlana?

 

Gauntlet 2 could have been even more epic! I remember hearing the original vet girls was supposed to be Coral, Rachel, Tina, Veronica, Julie, Beth, Trishelle, and Katie. They were clearly trying to have some feud between the vet girls.  There were so many casting rumors for that season. I think I also remember the rookie girl cast was supposed to be Jodi, Angela, Irulan, Raquel (RR campus crawl), Sarah (philly), Melissa, Shavonda, and Frankie (san Diego, she said on her MySpace they tried real hard to get her to do this).

 

Here are some what ifs

What if Coral and Melissa Howard were on the Inferno 2 Bad *** team instead of Rachel and Beth like original my planned? How would the bad *** team perform now?

What if Trishelle, Coral, Veronica, and Tina agreed to do the Gauntlet 2 as originally planned? Who would they have replaced? And how would the vets do?

What would have happened if Svetlana was on the challenge Gauntlet 3 as it was planned instead of Melinda? Would she have made it to the end? Would she win?

What if Beth didn't quit on Gauntlet 2 and didn't let Coral win on Gauntlet 3? Would she have been able to make it to the end?

What if The Island turned out to be the Duel 2 as we all originally thought? With that cast who would have been the final 2 guys and girls? Who would win? Who would have been the people thrown in multiple times like Aneesa and Svetlana?

 

Gauntlet 2 could have been even more epic! I remember hearing the original vet girls was supposed to be Coral, Rachel, Tina, Veronica, Julie, Beth, Trishelle, and Katie. They were clearly trying to have some feud between the vet girls.  There were so many casting rumors for that season. I think I also remember the rookie girl cast was supposed to be Jodi, Angela, Irulan, Raquel (RR campus crawl), Sarah (philly), Melissa, Shavonda, and Frankie (san Diego, she said on her MySpace they tried real hard to get her to do this).

i loved the Gauntlet 2 cast, but damn that would have been amazing! 

What if Melissa didn't drop out of WOTW2?(She said she dropped out due to family issues on the CM Podcast) Lets say she replaces Esther due to her being a last minute replacement. 

What if Melissa didn't drop out of WOTW2?(She said she dropped out due to family issues on the CM Podcast) Lets say she replaces Esther due to her being a last minute replacement. 

She knows people from both sides(Joss, Rogan, Bear, Kayleigh & Kyle) but I'd guess she goes with Theo & Bear's side just because she's obviously close to Kyle, unless her and Kayleigh are on really good terms again(maybe she plays the middle a bit). That one number on the UK side probably makes a pretty big difference

What if CT, Dee, Ninja, and Turbo were never on War of the Worlds 2? How would the season play out?

4 less people in the Paulie alliance leads me to think that wouldn't have gone well for him, Ashley, or Cara

4 less people in the Paulie alliance leads me to think that wouldn't have gone well for him, Ashley, or Cara

Ashley wouldn't have been in that alliance if it had 4 less people

What if Kailah and Melissa don't get DQed on Final Reckoning? How far would the Kam/Melissa and Kayleigh/Kailah teams get in the game?

What if Kailah and Melissa don't get DQed on Final Reckoning? How far would the Kam/Melissa and Kayleigh/Kailah teams get in the game?

I think Kayleigh & Kailah leave early and if things work out right I could see Kam & Melissa making the final

 

What if Kailah and Melissa don't get DQed on Final Reckoning? How far would the Kam/Melissa and Kayleigh/Kailah teams get in the game?

I think Kayleigh & Kailah leave early and if things work out right I could see Kam & Melissa making the final

How good is Melissa as a competitor? 

 

 

What if Kailah and Melissa don't get DQed on Final Reckoning? How far would the Kam/Melissa and Kayleigh/Kailah teams get in the game?

I think Kayleigh & Kailah leave early and if things work out right I could see Kam & Melissa making the final

How good is Melissa as a competitor? 

Probably as good or slightly better than Kayleigh

Only if Kaliah/Cara were a pair on fr I think they would've done so well. 

What if Josh doesnt throw in Wes on WOTW2? When does the US start to take each other out?

Pages