The Challenge: What Ifs

2450 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if Josh doesnt throw in Wes on WOTW2? When does the US start to take each other out?

the next episode they can, cause Laurel said Wes' name so it set a precedence 

What if Manbaby (Zach) didn't mess up on the Breaking on Through elimination on Rivals II and won, keeping him and Trey in the game instead of Leroy and Ty? How would that change the season?

 

What if Josh doesnt throw in Wes on WOTW2? When does the US start to take each other out?

the next episode they can, cause Laurel said Wes' name so it set a precedence 

Probably should have specified that Laurel also doesnt say his name bevause Josh doesnt agree but youre not wrong 

What if Manbaby (Zach) didn't mess up on the Breaking on Through elimination on Rivals II and won, keeping him and Trey in the game instead of Leroy and Ty? How would that change the season?

I know Zach wanted Frank/John in elimination but i think it wouldve just been Marlon/Jordan v Zach/Trey in hall brawl with the winner having a spot in the final but i think a lot stays the same no one was beating CT/Wes that season 

 

 

What if Josh doesnt throw in Wes on WOTW2? When does the US start to take each other out?

the next episode they can, cause Laurel said Wes' name so it set a precedence 

Probably should have specified that Laurel also doesnt say his name bevause Josh doesnt agree but youre not wrong 

Ah, I thought Josh was the last person to vote. Well if that's the case, idk, most likely still happen. 

What if Laurel did get the win vs Ninja? How would that have changed anything since Ashley flopped to her side during that vote. 

Laurel gets thrown in at least 3 more times. Who knows if she wins what elims 

What if Bananas never got a second shot after Duel 1?

What if Big T beat Georgia? 

What if Big T beat Georgia? 

Then she goes home the next girls day instead

What if the vets didn't DQ on the gauntlet 3 finale and TJ gave the vets the win? What if Coral didn't quit The Gauntlet 3? Could she possibly have beaten EV? Would her team really throw her in when people like Casey exist on the team still? How would the rest of the season been?

 

What if Big T beat Georgia? 

Then she goes home the next girls day instead

Big t vs Nicole in that elimination would be hilarious 

What if Bananas never got a second shot after Duel 1?

The show would be in a better state...Although we'd probably still have to suffer through Kenny and Evan's Bullshit.

What if The Ruins allowed for you to switch teams after winning an elimination?

Speaking of The Ruins, what if Evelyn hadn't quit?  If things continued on as they did but with KellyAnne gone, that final could potentially have been Sarah vs. JEKD, Susie, and Evelyn.  And what if Sarah had been eliminated in a faceoff too?  I wonder if production ever thought about doing the math on that one?

Speaking of The Ruins, what if Evelyn hadn't quit?  If things continued on as they did but with KellyAnne gone, that final could potentially have been Sarah vs. JEKD, Susie, and Evelyn.  And what if Sarah had been eliminated in a faceoff too?  I wonder if production ever thought about doing the math on that one?

Wonder if Ev and Wes work together to throw challenges, not to mention Idont think we get Wes v Cohutta since Wes wanted to take him out because he was KA's ex, also I think they finishe the eliminations earlier but there's a chance Casey makes the final 

 

Speaking of The Ruins, what if Evelyn hadn't quit?  If things continued on as they did but with KellyAnne gone, that final could potentially have been Sarah vs. JEKD, Susie, and Evelyn.  And what if Sarah had been eliminated in a faceoff too?  I wonder if production ever thought about doing the math on that one?

Wonder if Ev and Wes work together to throw challenges, not to mention Idont think we get Wes v Cohutta since Wes wanted to take him out because he was KA's ex, also I think they finishe the eliminations earlier but there's a chance Casey makes the final 

what if the challengers would have been smart and sent in Casey over Brianna. They might have won a few more challenges.

 

 

Speaking of The Ruins, what if Evelyn hadn't quit?  If things continued on as they did but with KellyAnne gone, that final could potentially have been Sarah vs. JEKD, Susie, and Evelyn.  And what if Sarah had been eliminated in a faceoff too?  I wonder if production ever thought about doing the math on that one?

Wonder if Ev and Wes work together to throw challenges, not to mention Idont think we get Wes v Cohutta since Wes wanted to take him out because he was KA's ex, also I think they finishe the eliminations earlier but there's a chance Casey makes the final 

what if the challengers would have been smart and sent in Casey over Brianna. They might have won a few more challenges.

Unfortunately, the challengers let Brad make the decisions and he was (or certainly appeared to be) doing the bidding of JEK, which is the only reason Casey lasted as long as she did.

Both Brad and Casey had an alliance with the Champs team. :/  So I guess the only way the challengers stood a chance is if they would have gotten rid of them.

Does anyone know which girls on the challengers teams were back ups. BC Devyn and Baya were originally cast for the ruins and then they both dropped out.

 

Evelyn supposed to have 5 wins

Kenny should have 5 wins, Wes should have 3, CT should have 4 and Diem should have one. Not sure who else im missing 

Diem and CT wouldn't have anymore wins, as much as i like Diem she was a weak competitor. Evan would have 3 wins, Kenny would have 5 and Johnny would probably still have 5/6 wins.

 

 

Evelyn supposed to have 5 wins

Kenny should have 5 wins, Wes should have 3, CT should have 4 and Diem should have one. Not sure who else im missing 

Diem and CT wouldn't have anymore wins, as much as i like Diem she was a weak competitor. Evan would have 3 wins, Kenny would have 5 and Johnny would probably still have 5/6 wins.

If you give Evan and Kenny an extra win that means CT and Diem also get it because they were on Kenny and Evan's team for the G3 final. John would have 5 since rivals now goes to Kenny and Wes 

To go along with the John question: what if Cara Maria never got a second shot after Fresh Meat 2's first elimination?

To go along with the John question: what if Cara Maria never got a second shot after Fresh Meat 2's first elimination?

Idk, Laurel might be Shauvon's rival, no? who else did Laurel have beef with on cutthroat?

 

To go along with the John question: what if Cara Maria never got a second shot after Fresh Meat 2's first elimination?

Idk, Laurel might be Shauvon's rival, no? who else did Laurel have beef with on cutthroat?

Abe.  But that wouldn't work for that season lol.  Prob would have gotten her someone from Fresh Meat 2 or just not used her.

What if Pauli's debut was Vendettas? Would CM hookup up with him instead of Kyle?

 

 

To go along with the John question: what if Cara Maria never got a second shot after Fresh Meat 2's first elimination?

Idk, Laurel might be Shauvon's rival, no? who else did Laurel have beef with on cutthroat?

Abe.  But that wouldn't work for that season lol.  Prob would have gotten her someone from Fresh Meat 2 or just not used her.

There you go, laurel probs wouldn't be on Rivals or maybe any other subsequent season?

What if Pauli's debut was Vendettas? Would CM hookup up with him instead of Kyle?

That would be intersting....I think she might still go for Kyle first.  She had a thing for his look and his accent.  A British accent is a game changer for sure lol

Another elimination hypothetical:

Nelson vs Joss and Cooke vs Kam in Looper who is winning.

I personally think this would be an interesting match up

Nelson & Kam win......

What if Bloodlines 2 was season 31?

What if darrell wasn't purged in Dirty 30.  ****, I want this man back on the show.

 

 

 

To go along with the John question: what if Cara Maria never got a second shot after Fresh Meat 2's first elimination?

Idk, Laurel might be Shauvon's rival, no? who else did Laurel have beef with on cutthroat?

Abe.  But that wouldn't work for that season lol.  Prob would have gotten her someone from Fresh Meat 2 or just not used her.

There you go, laurel probs wouldn't be on Rivals or maybe any other subsequent season?

They could have done a Laurel/Carley (bc of the reunion) or a Laurel/Theresa pairing, of course that gets rid of the Theresa/Camila pairing 

Pages