The Challenge: What Ifs

2450 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if Jenny didn't get to go against Amazing Race Jenn in the first elimination this season. Would the girls ever let her into an elimination as the game progresses?

I say yes, someone would've done it in hopes of sucking up to Jenny

What if Brad and Darrell were partners on Final Reckoning, instead of Brad and Kyle? 

What if Brad and Darrell were partners on Final Reckoning, instead of Brad and Kyle? 

Same placement, maybe edging Tony and Bananas if anything but just a much stronger team that would be screwed due to equalizer.

What if Cory & Mitch won Bloodlines? Does Mitch get called again, and when does Cara get her 1st win?

i think she does rivals 3 with wes and probably wins. 

What if Cara Maria and Paulie were on this season instead of Jenna and Josh? Would everyone be more miserable because of their presence and would this season still be horrific game wise?

What if Cara Maria and Paulie were on this season instead of Jenna and Josh? Would everyone be more miserable because of their presence and would this season still be horrific game wise?

All parties would be more miserable. Audiences, Cast, Production, Ratings. lol

i think she does rivals 3 with wes and probably wins. 

Depends if Wes comes on actually caring because originally him and Nany looked chekced out 

Interesting points. 

I think of Duel I and II. If they would not have rigged Push Me, Beth would have beaten Svetlana and may have been able to get Jodi in a Duel. It would have been a 50/50. CT smokes Brad and smokes Wes in the Final

Duel II - the whole dynamic changed with the CT/Adam fight. CT would have been a tough out especially with the type of eliminations. I’m not sure Brad or Evan would have made it as far. Definitely not Mark Long. Landon was robbed against Brad but that duel may have never happened if CT was in the game. Also, CT would have been smart enough to target Rachel for sake of Diem. Chances are we could have seen a Rachel vs Aneesa elimination, and respectfully back then 3 of the 5 eliminations favored Aneesa. 

 I was thinking of something. If you could play god, what one moment from every season would you change? What would the outcome be? This was my start;

Battle of the Seasons: Mike J. doesn't get DQ'ed for hoarding an inner-tube. Lindsay & Stephen eliminated, missing out on the inner circle, and likely sent home. I needed one more episode of Sharon!

Battle of the Sexes: Jamie trying to use the life-shield on Veronica was allowed. Anne would be sent home in her place. Ironically V would likely be sent home two episodes later when Shane uses the life-shield on Genesis.

The Gauntlet: Montana beats Katie on the bull. I've always loved Montana. I think even though the elimination order will be altered a little, the same people end up making the final. This is how I see it going for shits and giggles, the winner of each match up was determined by who went further in the actual competiton. Seemed fair b/c many of the gauntlets were *****************.  Ep.03 Steve beats Tonya,  Ep.04 Rachel B. Beats Tina, Ep.05 Sarah beats Montana, Ep.06 Coral beats Steve, Ep.07 Cara beats Matt Ep.08 LT beats Elka, everything goes back to normal after that

The Inferno: Piggy stays!!!! Tho in place of Christina she likely looses against Mallory with Mall making it to the finals and loosing with the RW team against RR sans Christina

Battle of the Sexes 2: Girls win first mission. Always felt badly for Genesis. Adam and Cameron would be eliminated first. Hard to predict anything beyond that. Who knows who would have replaced Cammy in the inner circle in ep 2. 

The Inferno 2: Somehow Dan wins the life-shield and makes it to the final, sending CT's paranoid *** in and losing to Landon.

The Gauntlet 2: The Rookies loose an additional guy's day challenge so the teams are even at the final. Would be interesting because Alton hinted his next choice to go in would have been Randy. I would have loved to see how Kina would have reacted  

 

I'd actually try and cast better people who would actually play the game and not throw challenge or eliminations and not have their agent tell them to throw it.

But Free Agents where Frank got sick I'd have he stay since he was getting better. (From what I remember)

what if this show didnt suck consistently since invasion

what if this show didnt suck consistently since invasion

I'd say the show started its decline at Bloodlines. I take Invasion and maaaaaybe Dirty 30 as outliers but every season after Cara won has been sub par.

What if the Fresh Meat team on BOTS consisted of Pete, Brandon, Mandi , Cara? How does everyone think that plays out?

What if the Fresh Meat team on BOTS consisted of Pete, Brandon, Mandi , Cara? How does everyone think that plays out?

Not sure if they would have faired better. Pete is better than Easy but Mandi was really only good at missions that involved Running. IMO, the best fresh meat team would have been Laurel, Cara Maria, Noor, and Pete. Maybe Chanda over Cara even though she would have been boring TV.

 

What if the Fresh Meat team on BOTS consisted of Pete, Brandon, Mandi , Cara? How does everyone think that plays out?

Not sure if they would have faired better. Pete is better than Easy but Mandi was really only good at missions that involved Running. IMO, the best fresh meat team would have been Laurel, Cara Maria, Noor, and Pete. Maybe Chanda over Cara even though she would have been boring TV.

Tbh at that point I would've said Theresa was better than Cara

What if the Fresh Meat team on BOTS consisted of Pete, Brandon, Mandi , Cara? How does everyone think that plays out?

I think it's been said Laurel declined because she didn't want to be on a team with Big Easy, so there's a solid chance she's on this over one of the girls, and this was a pretty weak female cast so there's a solid chance she never gets eliminated

 

 

What if the Fresh Meat team on BOTS consisted of Pete, Brandon, Mandi , Cara? How does everyone think that plays out?

Not sure if they would have faired better. Pete is better than Easy but Mandi was really only good at missions that involved Running. IMO, the best fresh meat team would have been Laurel, Cara Maria, Noor, and Pete. Maybe Chanda over Cara even though she would have been boring TV.

Tbh at that point I would've said Theresa was better than Cara

Theresa was a better athlete than Cara, just had shit partners (save for Camila). Theresa also had one of the worst political games (save for Exes 2). Her and Laurel on FM team would've been a tough team, and I can see BK team being the second team to leave over FM if that's the case.

I wouldn't say Theresa was better, but she definitely had more endurance. If I remember correctly, Cara had the best results of the girls on Freshmeat 2. I remember when they did the 40yd dash, and Cara ran like a ******* deer. It was nuts.  if I remember correctly the girls, statistically fell like this during those pretrials: Cara, Laurel, Theresa, Sydney, Sandy, Mandi, Carley

 

 

What if the Fresh Meat team on BOTS consisted of Pete, Brandon, Mandi , Cara? How does everyone think that plays out?

Not sure if they would have faired better. Pete is better than Easy but Mandi was really only good at missions that involved Running. IMO, the best fresh meat team would have been Laurel, Cara Maria, Noor, and Pete. Maybe Chanda over Cara even though she would have been boring TV.

Tbh at that point I would've said Theresa was better than Cara

Theresa was a better athlete than Cara, just had shit partners (save for Camila). Theresa also had one of the worst political games (save for Exes 2). Her and Laurel on FM team would've been a tough team, and I can see BK team being the second team to leave over FM if that's the case.

This is a What If Veterans picked Prospects on WOTW, a complete season breakdown: https://medium.com/@allanaguirre_19131/challenge-war-of-the-worlds-what-if-the-vets-picked-their-partners-f5c910fe599f

what if Johnny pulled the kill card on Free Agents to face Jordan in Episode 3? Who would win Looper?

This is a What If Veterans picked Prospects on WOTW, a complete season breakdown: https://medium.com/@allanaguirre_19131/challenge-war-of-the-worlds-what-if-the-vets-picked-their-partners-f5c910fe599f

 

Ashley the elimination queen! Love to see it

What if instead of Rivals 2 we had Vets vs Newbies and had Mark Long, Kenny, Evan, Bananas, and CT all on one team together. And then the newbies could consist of Zach, Frank Sweeney, Jordan, Marlon, etc...

What if Jay beat Rogan? Would he still get sent into purgatory until he lost or would TJ or production step in since he would have all the red skulls?

What if Jay beat Rogan? Would he still get sent into purgatory until he lost or would TJ or production step in since he would have all the red skulls?

I would hope that TJ or production wouldn't step in. The rules were set in the beginning and they aren't breaking them by sending little Jay over and over again. I actually would have enjoyed seeing Jay get tossed in every time lol 

 I was thinking of something. If you could play god, what one moment from every season would you change? What would the outcome be? This was my start;

Battle of the Seasons: Mike J. doesn't get DQ'ed for hoarding an inner-tube. Lindsay & Stephen eliminated, missing out on the inner circle, and likely sent home. I needed one more episode of Sharon!

Battle of the Sexes: Jamie trying to use the life-shield on Veronica was allowed. Anne would be sent home in her place. Ironically V would likely be sent home two episodes later when Shane uses the life-shield on Genesis.

The Gauntlet: Montana beats Katie on the bull. I've always loved Montana. I think even though the elimination order will be altered a little, the same people end up making the final. This is how I see it going for shits and giggles, the winner of each match up was determined by who went further in the actual competiton. Seemed fair b/c many of the gauntlets were *****************.  Ep.03 Steve beats Tonya,  Ep.04 Rachel B. Beats Tina, Ep.05 Sarah beats Montana, Ep.06 Coral beats Steve, Ep.07 Cara beats Matt Ep.08 LT beats Elka, everything goes back to normal after that

The Inferno: Piggy stays!!!! Tho in place of Christina she likely looses against Mallory with Mall making it to the finals and loosing with the RW team against RR sans Christina

Battle of the Sexes 2: Girls win first mission. Always felt badly for Genesis. Adam and Cameron would be eliminated first. Hard to predict anything beyond that. Who knows who would have replaced Cammy in the inner circle in ep 2. 

The Inferno 2: Somehow Dan wins the life-shield and makes it to the final, sending CT's paranoid *** in and losing to Landon.

The Gauntlet 2: The Rookies loose an additional guy's day challenge so the teams are even at the final. Would be interesting because Alton hinted his next choice to go in would have been Randy. I would have loved to see how Kina would have reacted  

 

MontanaGaveMeWine I love this!  I'll play with the same seasons:

Battle of the Seasons: Somehow get Piggy and Chadwick to stay for another week...Jisela & Adam I would send home their week instead.  Also I would want more Sharon too, she was a delight lol Flora and Mike could go home then since they were wallpaper that season.

Battle of the Sexes: Puck and David both sent home day 1 and they replace them with two other guys - Darrell and Dan S (Northern Trail) - with Anne there that could be interesting.  

The Gauntlet: Ugh....somehow Adam Larson getting voted in against either Elka or Rachel B or Irulan and get sent home.  I hated Adam this season.  And I was sad those three got sent home.  

The Inferno: I agree Piggy Stays! Also I'd have CT toss his cookies before Shane and then go home and never come back to the show.

Battle of the Sexes 2: Arissa going home at some point during the season, and either Rachel, Robin, or Ruthie making the fina with Coral and Sophia. (Genesis got screwed that season...horrible way to go out, sad she never came back)

The Inferno 2: Tina getting voted in either instead of Veronica (vs Jodi) or Tonya (vs Julie or  Shavonda) and going home allowing either Joid, Julie, or Shavonda to make it to the end and win.  

The Gauntlet 2: Beth staying and taking out Aneesa or Alton choosing Randy instead of Jermey. 

And I'm doing the Ruins too: The vets ban together and force JEK into every elimiantion till they go home.  

What if AYTO: Second Chances never happened and the entire cast was available to do Invasion of the Champions? How would that change that season's cast and potentially future seasons?

This is a What If Veterans picked Prospects on WOTW, a complete season breakdown: https://medium.com/@allanaguirre_19131/challenge-war-of-the-worlds-what-if-the-vets-picked-their-partners-f5c910fe599f

oh please, whoever wrote that tell them im reporting their website. Miss Shalegend would never go out first. Imagine thinking she'd even be in sent home first ever, whew. The delusions.

What if AYTO: Second Chances never happened and the entire cast was available to do Invasion of the Champions? How would that change that season's cast and potentially future seasons?

It wouldnt have because Invasion ended on november 19th and Second chances started filming November 21st. None of those people were consider to en on for the exception of Devin.

 

What if AYTO: Second Chances never happened and the entire cast was available to do Invasion of the Champions? How would that change that season's cast and potentially future seasons?

It wouldnt have because Invasion ended on november 19th and Second chances started filming November 21st. None of those people were consider to en on for the exception of Devin.

I was thinking the exact same thing. AYTO Second Chances probably helped out Tori get into the Challenge World. 

Pages