The Challenge: What Ifs

2522 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if the Double Agents format was used on Bloodlines? How would that change the season?

THAT would have made that season super interesting!  Having the bloodlines change partners and whatnot.  I also thought it would have been interesting to have that season in an old school team format and have it be the bloodlines vs the actual cast members.  

The elimination format was so unfair that season with the partners going home without going into elimination

It's one of the (many) reasons that season is pretty much unwatchable.   That and one team throwing every mission

 

What if the Double Agents format was used on Bloodlines? How would that change the season?

THAT would have made that season super interesting!  Having the bloodlines change partners and whatnot.  I also thought it would have been interesting to have that season in an old school team format and have it be the bloodlines vs the actual cast members.  

The elimination format was so unfair that season with the partners going home without going into elimination

It's one of the (many) reasons that season is pretty much unwatchable.   That and one team throwing every mission

Who was throwing them? I don't remember thar

What if the Double Agents format was used on Bloodlines? How would that change the season?

THAT would have made that season super interesting!  Having the bloodlines change partners and whatnot.  I also thought it would have been interesting to have that season in an old school team format and have it be the bloodlines vs the actual cast members.  

The elimination format was so unfair that season with the partners going home without going into elimination

It's one of the (many) reasons that season is pretty much unwatchable.   That and one team throwing every mission

Who was throwing them? I don't remember thar

The Blue team lost every mission on purpose led by Aneesa (can't blame her didn't she want to risk Rianna going in)--Aneesa didn't even hide it very well  lol

What if the Double Agents format was used on Bloodlines? How would that change the season?

 If Cara and Jamie split up I think whoever they are paired up they get 1st and 2nd in whatever order 

 

Speaking of invasion...

What if the Rookies competed in the classic eliminations (Pole Wrestle, Balls In, Knot So Fast), and the Vets competed in the new ones (Tuk Tuk Bang Bang, Bell Ringer, Inside Out)?

 

Ill start with the underdogs:

Kailah Vs Sylvia (Pole Wrestle) I think Kailah takes it, but would be sent in again the next week against Jenna.  

Jenna Vs Kailah (Balls In) I think that Kailah once again takes it and sends Jenna home a week earlier.i'm  going to assume that there's the first part of the bloodbath in which Nicole is eliminated; making the final 3 underdog girls Kailah, Amanda, And Ashley. If knot so fast is the elimination, I can't see Kailah beating either girls. Amanda and Ashley make the final.  

  

How would there be a 3 way Knot So Fast? 

As much as I love Ashley and love her winning Invasion, I would probably give the edge to Kailah and Amanda. Kailah because she's definitely the strongest and the rope is heavy, and Amanda because she probably would have the best strategy. Knot So Fast seems like an elim that Ashley would panic in. 

Edit: On second thought I'm guessing whoever gets stuck with Amanda's rope gets eliminated between Kailah/Ashley, assuming that hers would be the most difficult to unravel.

 

 

Speaking of invasion...

What if the Rookies competed in the classic eliminations (Pole Wrestle, Balls In, Knot So Fast), and the Vets competed in the new ones (Tuk Tuk Bang Bang, Bell Ringer, Inside Out)?

 

Ill start with the underdogs:

Kailah Vs Sylvia (Pole Wrestle) I think Kailah takes it, but would be sent in again the next week against Jenna.  

Jenna Vs Kailah (Balls In) I think that Kailah once again takes it and sends Jenna home a week earlier.i'm  going to assume that there's the first part of the bloodbath in which Nicole is eliminated; making the final 3 underdog girls Kailah, Amanda, And Ashley. If knot so fast is the elimination, I can't see Kailah beating either girls. Amanda and Ashley make the final.  

  

How would there be a 3 way Knot So Fast? 

As much as I love Ashley and love her winning Invasion, I would probably give the edge to Kailah and Amanda. Kailah because she's definitely the strongest and the rope is heavy, and Amanda because she probably would have the best strategy. Knot So Fast seems like an elim that Ashley would panic in. 

Edit: On second thought I'm guessing whoever gets stuck with Amanda's rope gets eliminated between Kailah/Ashley, assuming that hers would be the most difficult to unravel.

I should've clarified I imagined the Bloodbath winner being safe then 2nd and 3rd place doing the elim. In which case Kailah v. Ashley and imo I think Ashley has it. She did well against Lolo in something similar and Kailah isn't the most strategic.

Had this happened I think Dario takes Nelson or Cory's place in the final. Laurel might take Camila's spot unless Cara wins Bell Ringer. I think Amanda 100% makes the final but that's only if the Bloodbath winner would be safe (cause a three-way Knot So Fast would be impossible).

 

 

 

Speaking of invasion...

What if the Rookies competed in the classic eliminations (Pole Wrestle, Balls In, Knot So Fast), and the Vets competed in the new ones (Tuk Tuk Bang Bang, Bell Ringer, Inside Out)?

 

Ill start with the underdogs:

Kailah Vs Sylvia (Pole Wrestle) I think Kailah takes it, but would be sent in again the next week against Jenna.  

Jenna Vs Kailah (Balls In) I think that Kailah once again takes it and sends Jenna home a week earlier.i'm  going to assume that there's the first part of the bloodbath in which Nicole is eliminated; making the final 3 underdog girls Kailah, Amanda, And Ashley. If knot so fast is the elimination, I can't see Kailah beating either girls. Amanda and Ashley make the final.  

  

How would there be a 3 way Knot So Fast? 

As much as I love Ashley and love her winning Invasion, I would probably give the edge to Kailah and Amanda. Kailah because she's definitely the strongest and the rope is heavy, and Amanda because she probably would have the best strategy. Knot So Fast seems like an elim that Ashley would panic in. 

Edit: On second thought I'm guessing whoever gets stuck with Amanda's rope gets eliminated between Kailah/Ashley, assuming that hers would be the most difficult to unravel.

I should've clarified I imagined the Bloodbath winner being safe then 2nd and 3rd place doing the elim. In which case Kailah v. Ashley and imo I think Ashley has it. She did well against Lolo in something similar and Kailah isn't the most strategic.

Had this happened I think Dario takes Nelson or Cory's place in the final. Laurel might take Camila's spot unless Cara wins Bell Ringer. I think Amanda 100% makes the final but that's only if the Bloodbath winner would be safe (cause a three-way Knot So Fast would be impossible).

Cara lowkey wins bell ringer as she was cool with both Laurel & Camila. So she could've pulled a Nelson and plan to work with both of them before hand like he did with shane/cory 

All they needed to do on Invasion to make it better is for the elimination to have been Champ vs. Underdog until the final 5.  Then they could have done the bloodbath.  The only change is then the winner of puzzle goes to the final with the other two coming from the 3way elimination.  

 

 

 

Speaking of invasion...

What if the Rookies competed in the classic eliminations (Pole Wrestle, Balls In, Knot So Fast), and the Vets competed in the new ones (Tuk Tuk Bang Bang, Bell Ringer, Inside Out)?

 

Ill start with the underdogs:

Kailah Vs Sylvia (Pole Wrestle) I think Kailah takes it, but would be sent in again the next week against Jenna.  

Jenna Vs Kailah (Balls In) I think that Kailah once again takes it and sends Jenna home a week earlier.i'm  going to assume that there's the first part of the bloodbath in which Nicole is eliminated; making the final 3 underdog girls Kailah, Amanda, And Ashley. If knot so fast is the elimination, I can't see Kailah beating either girls. Amanda and Ashley make the final.  

  

How would there be a 3 way Knot So Fast? 

As much as I love Ashley and love her winning Invasion, I would probably give the edge to Kailah and Amanda. Kailah because she's definitely the strongest and the rope is heavy, and Amanda because she probably would have the best strategy. Knot So Fast seems like an elim that Ashley would panic in. 

Edit: On second thought I'm guessing whoever gets stuck with Amanda's rope gets eliminated between Kailah/Ashley, assuming that hers would be the most difficult to unravel.

I should've clarified I imagined the Bloodbath winner being safe then 2nd and 3rd place doing the elim. In which case Kailah v. Ashley and imo I think Ashley has it. She did well against Lolo in something similar and Kailah isn't the most strategic.

Had this happened I think Dario takes Nelson or Cory's place in the final. Laurel might take Camila's spot unless Cara wins Bell Ringer. I think Amanda 100% makes the final but that's only if the Bloodbath winner would be safe (cause a three-way Knot So Fast would be impossible).

But the bloodbath winner wasn't safe in the actual season so Amanda would still have to go into elimination... I still think she makes the final if it's a three way Knot So Fast, which would technically be possible. They all tangle their ropes and then rotate - for example Amanda gets Ashley's rope, Ashley gets Kailah's rope, and Kailah gets Amanda's rope and last person to untangle gets eliminated.

I made a new video all about this topic! This is my third part, I hope it is okay to post here!

https://youtu.be/qIyzX25Mz-s

I made a new video all about this topic! This is my third part, I hope it is okay to post here!

https://youtu.be/qIyzX25Mz-s

I don't have time to watch it right now but I have subscribed and I'll watch when I can. Smile

Just thought of this one watching Invasion.

"What if Bruno beat Tony in the first elimination" 

Seems simple but then you realize that Bruno would be in the house when Zach arrives and the rumor of him finger blasting Jenna goes around the house. We could have gotten a Bruno vs Zach fight and could have potentially lead to Bruno being on more seasons.

Just thought of this one watching Invasion.

"What if Bruno beat Tony in the first elimination" 

Seems simple but then you realize that Bruno would be in the house when Zach arrives and the rumor of him finger blasting Jenna goes around the house. We could have gotten a Bruno vs Zach fight and could have potentially lead to Bruno being on more seasons.

Who wanted hippie, homeless, vegan Bruno on more seasons? We only wanted sterioded, unstable, crazy Bruno. It was for the best.

What if Free Agents (season 25) actually followed the Double Agents format. Do you see the finalists/outcome at the end changing a bit? I wonder who would've paired off. Also, hard to see Bananas & Laurel both seeing 4 elims still.... 

Just thought of this one watching Invasion.

"What if Bruno beat Tony in the first elimination" 

Seems simple but then you realize that Bruno would be in the house when Zach arrives and the rumor of him finger blasting Jenna goes around the house. We could have gotten a Bruno vs Zach fight and could have potentially lead to Bruno being on more seasons.

lol I would have loved to see more Bruno mainly because Tony never did anything for me during her time on the show.  And hopefully that meant we wouldn't see Tony after Invasions lol

 

Just thought of this one watching Invasion.

"What if Bruno beat Tony in the first elimination" 

Seems simple but then you realize that Bruno would be in the house when Zach arrives and the rumor of him finger blasting Jenna goes around the house. We could have gotten a Bruno vs Zach fight and could have potentially lead to Bruno being on more seasons.

lol I would have loved to see more Bruno mainly because Tony never did anything for me during her time on the show.  And hopefully that meant we wouldn't see Tony after Invasions lol

Tony bloodlines debut was chaotic enough to have him back after invasion 

What if Free Agents (season 25) actually followed the Double Agents format. Do you see the finalists/outcome at the end changing a bit? I wonder who would've paired off. Also, hard to see Bananas & Laurel both seeing 4 elims still.... 

an idea of the starting pairs. Cara/CT. Leroy/Nany, John/Camila, Chet/Devyn, Jemmye/Preston, Swift/Latoya, Laurel/Jordan, Zach/Jonna (were they dating then?), Brandon/Theresa, Frank/Camila, Isaac/Aneesa, Reilly/Emilee (he wouldn't want Jasmine, Jess, or Nia), Nia/Dustin, Cohutta/Jasmine

 

What if Free Agents (season 25) actually followed the Double Agents format. Do you see the finalists/outcome at the end changing a bit? I wonder who would've paired off. Also, hard to see Bananas & Laurel both seeing 4 elims still.... 

an idea of the starting pairs. Cara/CT. Leroy/Nany, John/Camila, Chet/Devyn, Jemmye/Preston, Swift/Latoya, Laurel/Jordan, Zach/Jonna (were they dating then?), Brandon/Theresa, Frank/Camila, Isaac/Aneesa, Reilly/Emilee (he wouldn't want Jasmine, Jess, or Nia), Nia/Dustin, Cohutta/Jasmine

That would have been an interesting twist that season.   I still like the original fomat thoug - it was super fresh at the time.

 

What if the red skull twist didn't exisit in this current season Double Agents - where do you think we'd be at with what has aired so far?  Would more rookies be gone, or would the vets still be going at it?  

What if Free Agents (season 25) actually followed the Double Agents format. Do you see the finalists/outcome at the end changing a bit? I wonder who would've paired off. Also, hard to see Bananas & Laurel both seeing 4 elims still.... 

an idea of the starting pairs. Cara/CT. Leroy/Nany, John/Camila, Chet/Devyn, Jemmye/Preston, Swift/Latoya, Laurel/Jordan, Zach/Jonna (were they dating then?), Brandon/Theresa, Frank/Camila, Isaac/Aneesa, Reilly/Emilee (he wouldn't want Jasmine, Jess, or Nia), Nia/Dustin, Cohutta/Jasmine

Yeah, when I first saw this I was trying to think of the teams.  I'm pretty sure Zach and Jonna weren't on speaking terms that season.  You had Camila twice (Frank & John which is were I struggled as well)...also, I don't believe Jordan and Laurel knew each other at that point.  

I kind of think it might have gone down as 

CT/Cara (most obviously one), John/Laurel (they would see themselves as the power team), Frank/Jonna (Jonna was done with Zach but they were still close even after Rivals 2), Preston/Devyn (I feel like they would have been the last two), Chet/Jessica (for some reason they just make sense to me--I can't see Chet with Devyn), Isaac/Emilee (maybe?), Leroy/Camila (I know this is crazy now but due to being friends with John), Cohutta/Aneesa (I could see them working together plus we're low on options), Reilly/Nia (okay, obviously bad blood, but....), Brandon/Jasmine (ehhh), Swift/LaToya (St Thomas team), Zach/Jemmye (due to his friendship with Knight), Jordan/Theresa (some bad blood from Rivals 2 but strong competitors) & Dustin/Nany (they were close at this point for sure)

what if the challege here in canada and usa were all unrated uncut and uncensored like the seasons are on mtv uk

What if Nehemiah picked Jemmye for the last elimination against Jisela and Big E! Would they won or stil lost. 

What if Nehemiah picked Jemmye for the last elimination against Jisela and Big E! Would they won or stil lost. 

Women made no difference, sadly.

What if Nehemiah picked Jemmye for the last elimination against Jisela and Big E! Would they won or stil lost. 

Women made no difference, sadly.

Agreed--another stupid pair elimination

What if Wes replaces CT instead of Derrick on The Inferno 3? Does that change his and Kenny's friendship 

What if Wes replaces CT instead of Derrick on The Inferno 3? Does that change his and Kenny's friendship 

they were friends around that point in time, they probably wouldve grown closer and im pretty sure he wouldve won with them

Yeah didnt even say he hopes "my man Wes" was a possible replacement?

Who wins in a final:

CT and Amanda

Wes and Theresa

Bananas and Kam

Who wins in a final:

CT and Amanda

Wes and Theresa

Bananas and Kam

Wes & Theresa by far. 

Who wins in a final:

CT and Amanda

Wes and Theresa

Bananas and Kam

Wes/Theresa heck I still think they beat Sarah/Jordan in that Exes 2 final 

Pages