The Challenge: What Ifs

2757 posts / 0 new
Last post

Do you not like my Aneesa pfp? Sad

 

 

If they could run any season again, same format, same cast which one would you want to see redone?

Inferno

with Piggy or Christena?

Piggy for sure!

The island could've been a decent season if it had been given a normal format 

The island could've been a decent season if it had been given a normal format 

no

i have yet to see a good show take place on an island besides survivor 

 

The island could've been a decent season if it had been given a normal format 

no

i have yet to see a good show take place on an island besides survivor 

You missed the point but I really don't care

If they could run any season again, same format, same cast which one would you want to see redone?

Fresh Meat 1 and Fresh Meat 2......without the Fresh Meat lol

What if nobody quit or DQ'd on WOTW2 ? 

 

If they could run any season again, same format, same cast which one would you want to see redone?

Cutthroat

5 of the Top 10 women of all time - Laurel, Cara, Camila, Emily S, AND Sarah R - plus multi-time champs Paula and Tori H - plus best-to-never-win Theresa and Jenn

then you also have Brad, John, Derrick, Abe, and Tyler - along with other finalists like Ty and Chet and Luke. the men are less exciting, but that's almost always the case LMAO

Cutthroat would be a top 3 option for me. I just want to recast Shauvon and Vinny lol

The island could've been a decent season if it had been given a normal format 

If the Island would have been a Duel it would have been awesome.  The cast was largely fine but the format was trash. 

Rivals 2 also should have been a Duel or Free Agents...something individual. 

What if nobody quit or DQ'd on WOTW2 ? 

Faith would've been in the middle. She probably ends up going into one or two eliminations, but considering who she'd be facing, I think she'd be fine. Probably gets eliminated at the last elimination or purged in the final. She said she wasn't good at puzzles. I think she'd compete well tho, idk how close to the cult she would've got since she wasn't cool with Kam or Cara fr. But, her being there might prolong Tori going in and switching sides, at least until that Hall Brawl.

Zahida probably gets eliminated by Faith if anything.

Turbo and Jordan would've settled it in the sand. Goes either way, if Jordan stays UK is weaker in the final, but Turbo also means an extra person for USA. But, the thought of just Rogan, Tori, CT, and Dee... idk I don't recall how anyone but Jordan and CT did and Tori probably still gets purged.

 

What if nobody quit or DQ'd on WOTW2 ? 

Faith would've been in the middle. She probably ends up going into one or two eliminations, but considering who she'd be facing, I think she'd be fine. Probably gets eliminated at the last elimination or purged in the final. She said she wasn't good at puzzles. I think she'd compete well tho, idk how close to the cult she would've got since she wasn't cool with Kam or Cara fr. But, her being there might prolong Tori going in and switching sides, at least until that Hall Brawl.

Zahida probably gets eliminated by Faith if anything.

Turbo and Jordan would've settled it in the sand. Goes either way, if Jordan stays UK is weaker in the final, but Turbo also means an extra person for USA. But, the thought of just Rogan, Tori, CT, and Dee... idk I don't recall how anyone but Jordan and CT did and Tori probably still gets purged.

I actually think zahida makes the final for this season which is crazy. 

What if nobody quit or DQ'd on WOTW2 ? 

Laurel beats Ninja in my scenario do to faith being there idk im biased

 

 

What if nobody quit or DQ'd on WOTW2 ? 

Faith would've been in the middle. She probably ends up going into one or two eliminations, but considering who she'd be facing, I think she'd be fine. Probably gets eliminated at the last elimination or purged in the final. She said she wasn't good at puzzles. I think she'd compete well tho, idk how close to the cult she would've got since she wasn't cool with Kam or Cara fr. But, her being there might prolong Tori going in and switching sides, at least until that Hall Brawl.

Zahida probably gets eliminated by Faith if anything.

Turbo and Jordan would've settled it in the sand. Goes either way, if Jordan stays UK is weaker in the final, but Turbo also means an extra person for USA. But, the thought of just Rogan, Tori, CT, and Dee... idk I don't recall how anyone but Jordan and CT did and Tori probably still gets purged.

I actually think zahida makes the final for this season which is crazy. 

Where did she stand with everyone in the house?

Not sure if she would've worked with the Cult or the other side the house. She might upset Dee's position if anything.

 

 

 

What if nobody quit or DQ'd on WOTW2 ? 

Faith would've been in the middle. She probably ends up going into one or two eliminations, but considering who she'd be facing, I think she'd be fine. Probably gets eliminated at the last elimination or purged in the final. She said she wasn't good at puzzles. I think she'd compete well tho, idk how close to the cult she would've got since she wasn't cool with Kam or Cara fr. But, her being there might prolong Tori going in and switching sides, at least until that Hall Brawl.

Zahida probably gets eliminated by Faith if anything.

Turbo and Jordan would've settled it in the sand. Goes either way, if Jordan stays UK is weaker in the final, but Turbo also means an extra person for USA. But, the thought of just Rogan, Tori, CT, and Dee... idk I don't recall how anyone but Jordan and CT did and Tori probably still gets purged.

I actually think zahida makes the final for this season which is crazy. 

Where did she stand with everyone in the house?

Not sure if she would've worked with the Cult or the other side the house. She might upset Dee's position if anything.

She was just perfectly positioned. She was besties with Kayleigh & tight with Kam so she would've been protected by the cult and Kayleigh's UK alliance, plus she was friends with Georgia, Theo, and Bear from their alliance on WOTW1.  

To me either she makes finals, or she loses the in the swim purge and Kayleigh makes finals. 

No way Zahida makes the final. She would have been in an elimination and definitely loses. That lil busted up plastic surgery lil girl has no athleticism in her.

What if the original bad *** girls on the inferno 2 had been Coral, Melissa, Veronica, Tina and Tonya as originally planned

omg coral/Melissa/probably Veronica vs. Julie...

That team would have been WILD

Beth needed to be on that season tho. It was her comeback to the challenge after not being on since sexes 1. Maybe Melissa could've *****slapped Julie and gotten kicked off so Beth could replace her and quit shortly after when Tonya throws her shit in the pool.

What if Theresa got a puzzle elim in DA and beat Kaycee? Could she make the final? 

What if Theresa got a puzzle elim in DA and beat Kaycee? Could she make the final? 

Yes

If Gauntlet 2 has a better format closer to the other two seasons, would it have had more drama and been as entertaining? Does Jo still breakdown episode 1? 

If Gauntlet 2 has a better format closer to the other two seasons, would it have had more drama and been as entertaining? Does Jo still breakdown episode 1? 

Yes to both questions. Jo was gonna flip out and become iconic no matter what. The format sucked *** too~

What if Fresh Meat 1 would've been Alumni vs. Fresh Meat? Who makes the final on each team assuming it's an Inferno-like format. 12 vs. 12 teamz.

 

If Gauntlet 2 has a better format closer to the other two seasons, would it have had more drama and been as entertaining? Does Jo still breakdown episode 1? 

Yes to both questions. Jo was gonna flip out and become iconic no matter what. The format sucked *** too~

I think if Jo wasn't captain and it would have been a normal season she still would have flipped but maybe made it till the first girls vote which means we would have at least had some Jo confessionals which would have been nice but her exit was so iconic that I might not change a thing.

I honestly think Melissa would have been in that first elimination instead of Tina. So Robin might have stayed around longer.

If Gauntlet 2 has a better format closer to the other two seasons, would it have had more drama and been as entertaining? Does Jo still breakdown episode 1? 

Jo probably leaves anyways. In her Mike Lewis interview she made it known the living conditions,  the filming schedule,  and the cast at the time really contributed to her leaving. She might have stuck around an episode or two longer but it sounds like she was gonna quit either way.

 

If Gauntlet 2 has a better format closer to the other two seasons, would it have had more drama and been as entertaining? Does Jo still breakdown episode 1? 

Jo probably leaves anyways. In her Mike Lewis interview she made it known the living conditions,  the filming schedule,  and the cast at the time really contributed to her leaving. She might have stuck around an episode or two longer but it sounds like she was gonna quit either way.

Yupp Jo quits regardless.  She had no idea what she signed up for. 

 

 

 

 

What if nobody quit or DQ'd on WOTW2 ? 

Faith would've been in the middle. She probably ends up going into one or two eliminations, but considering who she'd be facing, I think she'd be fine. Probably gets eliminated at the last elimination or purged in the final. She said she wasn't good at puzzles. I think she'd compete well tho, idk how close to the cult she would've got since she wasn't cool with Kam or Cara fr. But, her being there might prolong Tori going in and switching sides, at least until that Hall Brawl.

Zahida probably gets eliminated by Faith if anything.

Turbo and Jordan would've settled it in the sand. Goes either way, if Jordan stays UK is weaker in the final, but Turbo also means an extra person for USA. But, the thought of just Rogan, Tori, CT, and Dee... idk I don't recall how anyone but Jordan and CT did and Tori probably still gets purged.

I actually think zahida makes the final for this season which is crazy. 

Where did she stand with everyone in the house?

Not sure if she would've worked with the Cult or the other side the house. She might upset Dee's position if anything.

She was just perfectly positioned. She was besties with Kayleigh & tight with Kam so she would've been protected by the cult and Kayleigh's UK alliance, plus she was friends with Georgia, Theo, and Bear from their alliance on WOTW1.  

To me either she makes finals, or she loses the in the swim purge and Kayleigh makes finals. 

I feel like Faith would've been the one to take out Georgia then or at least would've faced her. And, Faith probably turncoats, Tori wouldn't go in until Hall Brawl and idk if they would pick Faith over Jenny but I doubt it.

But, I could see Zahida taking Dee's place on the hierarchy unless she's called out from playing sides, but something tells me Dee would've been the low-hanging fruit.

It's probably Dee facing off with Tori, Faith, or even Nany in the last elimination (Jordan v. Josh, not Nany vs. Ashley) since we would've needed to be a double. But, Zahida staying is worse for the UK, but I don't remember how the last daily went to state whether or not Zahida could stop the UK from winning that or the final.

But, Zahida is probably purged in the final and idk who would've survived between Ashley or Tori because I can't remember placements.

What if cutthroat had the mutiny twist like wotw2 or usa2? I know camila switches but who else do you guys see changing teams?

What if cutthroat had the mutiny twist like wotw2 or usa2? I know camila switches but who else do you guys see changing teams?

Brandon for sure. Maybe Laurel and Katie.

Pages