The Challenge: What Ifs

2757 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

What if Aneesa beat Cara in the final elimination on Bloodlines in pole wrestle?  

Cory is a champion on his first season. Cory/Mitch already beat Jenna/Bri and wouldn't lose to Aneesa/Rihanna in a final. 

Aneesa and Rhianna could have won with that set up.  Jenna and the annoying one almost did but they couldn't eat.  Cory killed them on stage one of that final. 

you are insane if you think Aneesa & Rihanna woulda won that season. They would have gotten 3rd.  But you love to argue instead of just saying yeah Cory prolly wins 

what if all the eliminations on double agents had the genders reversed? 

example: Week 1 being male instead of female.

There's too many varying factors to determine who switches to who, who can win what challenges, but I think I have a somewhat decent idea. This took like an hour on and off but reading it over I think i have it.

CT v. Wes (Fire Escape)- I think CT? Although his weight is less in his muscles like Leroy atp so maybe he loses? But, I don't think Wes would move that fast. CT wins and stays with Ashley, maybe going to Tori.

Big T v. Nany (Ring of Spies)- Nany wins. Stays with Josh likely.

Nicole v. Natalie (Snapping Point)- Nicole had an injury so the elim is canceled.

Anessa v. Amber M (Hall Brawl)-Anessa. Poor Amber

Leroy v. Jospeh (Asset Destruction)- Joseph wanted to go in at some point anyway.

CT v. Kyle (Dead Ringer)- Theresa wanted Kam in with Ashley so keeping that in mind I think CT goes in twice and wins. Maybe Kyle. CT takes Tori, Ashley has a target.

Skulls: Nany, Anessa, Leroy, CT. Out: Kyle, Amber M, Devin, Nicole, Wes, Big T, Liv, Lio, Natalie, JosephPairs (From What I think Makes Sense): CT/Tori ; Nany / Josh ; Fessy / Anessa ; Leroy / Kaycee ; Ashley / Cory ; Jay / Theresa ; Lolo / Nam ; Gabby / Devin ; Darrell /  Amber B; Nelson / Kam. RA: Mechie.

Kaycee v. Theresa (Fire Escape)- Kaycee and Leroy probably still win and Kaycee wants her skull. I could see Kam wanting her but I think Kaycee wins out. Theresa had an injury so she’s out.

Kam v. Gabby (Asset Destruction II) - Let’s just say Kam still wins. Gabby gets voted in for an easy skull atp (the rookie girls don’t have the votes to get in Tori). Kam wins. I don’t know who she steals… Fessy? She wanted the BB alliance.

Darrell v. Jay (Snapping Point)  -Darrell and Amber won. Jay likely gets voted in and Darrell decides to face him.

Skulls: Nany, Anessa, Kam, Kaycee, Leroy, CT, Darrell.

Next challenge was kind of luck, but giving it to CT and Tori idk why. I can’t recall who was close. CT likely doesn’t go in because he think it’ll be a guys day (which is the likely pick).I’m going to say we get Cory v. Josh in Hall Brawl. Why? Josh wanted a skull so he gets voted in and if it happens to be a girls day CT helps Ashley get a skull so she can steal him back. So Cory goes in.Cory v. Josh (Hall Brawl)- Cory wins, honestly think he steals Kam. Nany takes Fessy. Ashley takes Nelson.

Skulls: Nany, Anessa, Kam, Kaycee ; Leroy, CT, Darrell, Cory.Pairs: CT/Tori ; Nany / Fessy ; Kam / Cory ; Kaycee / Leroy ; Ashley/ Nelson ; Amber B / Darrell ; Devin / Anessa ; Lolo / Nam.  RA: Mechie.Out: Kyle, Amber M, Devin, Nicole, Wes, Big T, Liv, Lio, Natalie, Theresa, Gabby, Jay, Josh

Next challenge was won by CT with Big T, I’ll just say he wins with Tori.Lolo quits before the double. Since she does it ends up being a guy/guy elimination like the show to even things out.Devin and Fessy go in. Tori doesn’t want to because she thinks it might be a guy/girl day initially and decides to send in Nelson. Not sure who the other guy is. I’m guessing Darrell.Fessy v. Darrell and Devin v. Nelson (Dead Ringer): Devin and Darrell win. Fessy might win but going with Darrell on this. Nelson just isn’t good at stuff like this.

Darrell stays I guess, Devin takes Tori , Ashley takes CT, Nam takes Nany,  Mechie ends up with Anessa.

Nam leaves before the challenge.

Skulls: Nany, Anessa, Kam, Kaycee ; Leroy, CT, Darrell, Cory, Devin.Pairs: CT/Ashley ; Anessa / Mechie ; Kam / Cory ; Kaycee / Leroy ; Devin / Tori ; Amber B / Darrell .RA: Nany

Kaycee & Leroy won Up All Night before.  Even though this should be a guys day, since Lolo’s quit forces the guy/girl days to follow the pattern of the show… the girls go in.

Amber B v. Tori (Ring of Spies): Amber has a bit of speed but I don’t think she’s stronger, even though Tori is stronger now than she was then. I give it to Tori. Tori takes back CT, Nany goes to Leroy ; Ashley ends up with Darrell.Skulls: Nany, Anessa, Kam, Kaycee, Tori ; Leroy, CT, Darrell, Cory, Devin.Pairs: CT/Tori ; Anessa / Mechie ; Kam / Cory ; Nany / Leroy ; Devin / Kaycee ; Ashley / Darrell .

Now eliminations can go back to reverse order from the show.

Ashley v. Anessa (Snapping Point): Honestly Anessa is always low on the totem pole and Ashley either wins or gets sent. This was more of a sprint this time so Ashley wins. Ashley steals CT, Tori goes to Devin, Kaycee ends up with Darrell.

Skulls: Nany, Ashley, Kam, Kaycee, Tori ; Leroy, CT, Darrell, Cory, Devin.Pairs: CT/Ashley ; Kam / Cory ; Nany / Leroy ; Devin / Tori ;  Kaycee / Darrell . RA: Mechie

Next challenge was a puzzle so I’m giving it to CT and Ashley for the win. Devin and Tori would be close.

Voting wise it’s likely Kaycee and Darrell (he’s a champ and BB is gone). CT decides to send in Devin , I guess? Thinking it’s a guys day, Ashley wants to see Tori leave so she’s hoping it’s a girls day.

Darrell v. Devin (Hall Brawl): Darrell wins. I think he’d steal Kam if anything. Cory goes to Tori

Pairs: CT/Ashley ; Kam / Darrell ; Nany / Leroy ; Cory / Tori ;  Kaycee / Mechie.

Production tried to avoid a purge but I think Mechie is out. I considered just flipping things so the guys at least had another round and Mechie could get a skull but four guys would be safe for the final. I just think Mechie just doesn’t have place to get sent in and so late in the game no cares to partner with him. He just becomes an example.

Last challenge was largely based on Cory so I’m going with Tori and Cory winning. I think Kam gets sent in. Tori and Cory send in Ashley.

Ashley v. Kam (Hall Brawl): Kam wins but I think this would be an interesting matchup.

Whoever Kam doesn’t pick goes to Kaycee so I think she picks CT. Her and CT never paired up and don’t realize how badly they work together.

Final: CT/Kam ; Kaycee / Darrell ; Nany / Leroy ; Cory / Tori

4th: Kaycee/Darrell. Kaycee still hurts her leg. Darrell gets the short end of the stick.

3rd: Nany/Leroy.

First is a toss-up because CT killed the checkpoints but Cory actually did well this final and Tori isn’t bad at them.It’s either CT/Kam or Cory/Tori.

 

 

What if Aneesa beat Cara in the final elimination on Bloodlines in pole wrestle?  

Cory is a champion on his first season. Cory/Mitch already beat Jenna/Bri and wouldn't lose to Aneesa/Rihanna in a final. 

Aneesa and Rhianna could have won with that set up.  Jenna and the annoying one almost did but they couldn't eat.  Cory killed them on stage one of that final. 

you are insane if you think Aneesa & Rihanna woulda won that season. They would have gotten 3rd.  But you love to argue instead of just saying yeah Cory prolly wins 

Aneesa crushed the mini final that season.  We know she's good at puzzles and eating. That was the only season she was actually somewhat fit.  Mitch and Cory should win but rewatch stage 1 of that final.  The girls would have had a lead just like Jenna only they can eat and solve the math problem at the end. 

What if the earlier seasons were individual. Would Veronica still have 3 wins without those team challenges ? 

What if the earlier seasons were individual. Would Veronica still have 3 wins without those team challenges ? 

No but most of them wouldn't. Veronica and Coral still would have done very well. 

 

what if all the eliminations on double agents had the genders reversed? 

example: Week 1 being male instead of female.

There's too many varying factors to determine who switches to who, who can win what challenges, but I think I have a somewhat decent idea. This took like an hour on and off but reading it over I think i have it.

CT v. Wes (Fire Escape)- I think CT? Although his weight is less in his muscles like Leroy atp so maybe he loses? But, I don't think Wes would move that fast. CT wins and stays with Ashley, maybe going to Tori.

Big T v. Nany (Ring of Spies)- Nany wins. Stays with Josh likely.

Nicole v. Natalie (Snapping Point)- Nicole had an injury so the elim is canceled.

Anessa v. Amber M (Hall Brawl)-Anessa. Poor Amber

Leroy v. Jospeh (Asset Destruction)- Joseph wanted to go in at some point anyway.

CT v. Kyle (Dead Ringer)- Theresa wanted Kam in with Ashley so keeping that in mind I think CT goes in twice and wins. Maybe Kyle. CT takes Tori, Ashley has a target.

Skulls: Nany, Anessa, Leroy, CT. Out: Kyle, Amber M, Devin, Nicole, Wes, Big T, Liv, Lio, Natalie, JosephPairs (From What I think Makes Sense): CT/Tori ; Nany / Josh ; Fessy / Anessa ; Leroy / Kaycee ; Ashley / Cory ; Jay / Theresa ; Lolo / Nam ; Gabby / Devin ; Darrell /  Amber B; Nelson / Kam. RA: Mechie.

Kaycee v. Theresa (Fire Escape)- Kaycee and Leroy probably still win and Kaycee wants her skull. I could see Kam wanting her but I think Kaycee wins out. Theresa had an injury so she’s out.

Kam v. Gabby (Asset Destruction II) - Let’s just say Kam still wins. Gabby gets voted in for an easy skull atp (the rookie girls don’t have the votes to get in Tori). Kam wins. I don’t know who she steals… Fessy? She wanted the BB alliance.

Darrell v. Jay (Snapping Point)  -Darrell and Amber won. Jay likely gets voted in and Darrell decides to face him.

Skulls: Nany, Anessa, Kam, Kaycee, Leroy, CT, Darrell.

Next challenge was kind of luck, but giving it to CT and Tori idk why. I can’t recall who was close. CT likely doesn’t go in because he think it’ll be a guys day (which is the likely pick).I’m going to say we get Cory v. Josh in Hall Brawl. Why? Josh wanted a skull so he gets voted in and if it happens to be a girls day CT helps Ashley get a skull so she can steal him back. So Cory goes in.Cory v. Josh (Hall Brawl)- Cory wins, honestly think he steals Kam. Nany takes Fessy. Ashley takes Nelson.

Skulls: Nany, Anessa, Kam, Kaycee ; Leroy, CT, Darrell, Cory.Pairs: CT/Tori ; Nany / Fessy ; Kam / Cory ; Kaycee / Leroy ; Ashley/ Nelson ; Amber B / Darrell ; Devin / Anessa ; Lolo / Nam.  RA: Mechie.Out: Kyle, Amber M, Devin, Nicole, Wes, Big T, Liv, Lio, Natalie, Theresa, Gabby, Jay, Josh

Next challenge was won by CT with Big T, I’ll just say he wins with Tori.Lolo quits before the double. Since she does it ends up being a guy/guy elimination like the show to even things out.Devin and Fessy go in. Tori doesn’t want to because she thinks it might be a guy/girl day initially and decides to send in Nelson. Not sure who the other guy is. I’m guessing Darrell.Fessy v. Darrell and Devin v. Nelson (Dead Ringer): Devin and Darrell win. Fessy might win but going with Darrell on this. Nelson just isn’t good at stuff like this.

Darrell stays I guess, Devin takes Tori , Ashley takes CT, Nam takes Nany,  Mechie ends up with Anessa.

Nam leaves before the challenge.

Skulls: Nany, Anessa, Kam, Kaycee ; Leroy, CT, Darrell, Cory, Devin.Pairs: CT/Ashley ; Anessa / Mechie ; Kam / Cory ; Kaycee / Leroy ; Devin / Tori ; Amber B / Darrell .RA: Nany

Kaycee & Leroy won Up All Night before.  Even though this should be a guys day, since Lolo’s quit forces the guy/girl days to follow the pattern of the show… the girls go in.

Amber B v. Tori (Ring of Spies): Amber has a bit of speed but I don’t think she’s stronger, even though Tori is stronger now than she was then. I give it to Tori. Tori takes back CT, Nany goes to Leroy ; Ashley ends up with Darrell.Skulls: Nany, Anessa, Kam, Kaycee, Tori ; Leroy, CT, Darrell, Cory, Devin.Pairs: CT/Tori ; Anessa / Mechie ; Kam / Cory ; Nany / Leroy ; Devin / Kaycee ; Ashley / Darrell .

Now eliminations can go back to reverse order from the show.

Ashley v. Anessa (Snapping Point): Honestly Anessa is always low on the totem pole and Ashley either wins or gets sent. This was more of a sprint this time so Ashley wins. Ashley steals CT, Tori goes to Devin, Kaycee ends up with Darrell.

Skulls: Nany, Ashley, Kam, Kaycee, Tori ; Leroy, CT, Darrell, Cory, Devin.Pairs: CT/Ashley ; Kam / Cory ; Nany / Leroy ; Devin / Tori ;  Kaycee / Darrell . RA: Mechie

Next challenge was a puzzle so I’m giving it to CT and Ashley for the win. Devin and Tori would be close.

Voting wise it’s likely Kaycee and Darrell (he’s a champ and BB is gone). CT decides to send in Devin , I guess? Thinking it’s a guys day, Ashley wants to see Tori leave so she’s hoping it’s a girls day.

Darrell v. Devin (Hall Brawl): Darrell wins. I think he’d steal Kam if anything. Cory goes to Tori

Pairs: CT/Ashley ; Kam / Darrell ; Nany / Leroy ; Cory / Tori ;  Kaycee / Mechie.

Production tried to avoid a purge but I think Mechie is out. I considered just flipping things so the guys at least had another round and Mechie could get a skull but four guys would be safe for the final. I just think Mechie just doesn’t have place to get sent in and so late in the game no cares to partner with him. He just becomes an example.

Last challenge was largely based on Cory so I’m going with Tori and Cory winning. I think Kam gets sent in. Tori and Cory send in Ashley.

Ashley v. Kam (Hall Brawl): Kam wins but I think this would be an interesting matchup.

Whoever Kam doesn’t pick goes to Kaycee so I think she picks CT. Her and CT never paired up and don’t realize how badly they work together.

Final: CT/Kam ; Kaycee / Darrell ; Nany / Leroy ; Cory / Tori

4th: Kaycee/Darrell. Kaycee still hurts her leg. Darrell gets the short end of the stick.

3rd: Nany/Leroy.

First is a toss-up because CT killed the checkpoints but Cory actually did well this final and Tori isn’t bad at them.It’s either CT/Kam or Cory/Tori.

Your a Legend for this

What if CT and Cara Maria showed up on ROD instead of Verionca and Darrel

What if Jonna didn't lose her passport on Freshneat 2? She shows up and slays the boot camp thus becomes a rival of Laurel. Assuming Cara is out first, Laurel has her eyes on Jonna who slays a couple comps. They are then paired together on rivals 1. Cara is never invited back again. Jonna is a runner up on Rivals 2. Returns for BOTS with more confidence and volunteers for hall brawl and beats Sam. Cancun wins the entire season. She still beefs with Nany so they're paired on Rivals 2 and have a similar outcome but instead make the final due to no Cara/Cooke duo. 2nd place me thinks? She flops on free agents. Same outcome on exes 2. 

uhh... Jonna would not have even done the boot camp. she was a RW alum, so she would have been paired with one of the Fresh Meat ....

Chile why y'all let me write all that knowing Jonna was a vet. I'm LIVID!!!

Jonna was def gonna be a first boot that season. None of the guys were good enough to change that. 

Jonna was def gonna be a first boot that season. None of the guys were good enough to change that. 

? maybe pete or noor. even her and brandon wouldnt be first boot.

Julie from the very first RW season should have competed at least once, most likely in an All Stars.

 

Jonna was def gonna be a first boot that season. None of the guys were good enough to change that. 

? maybe pete or noor. even her and brandon wouldnt be first boot.

Werent all the eliminations with weights? Jonna was the smallest one there she would have died carrying those things lol Plus most of the FM guys were average to me besides a couple above average.  

Maybe if she could somehow have gotten Laurel

 

 

Jonna was def gonna be a first boot that season. None of the guys were good enough to change that. 

? maybe pete or noor. even her and brandon wouldnt be first boot.

Werent all the eliminations with weights? Jonna was the smallest one there she would have died carrying those things lol Plus most of the FM guys were average to me besides a couple above average.  

Maybe if she could somehow have gotten Laurel

laurel would've complained about Jonna the whole season.

yoi could freely adjust the weight tho. thats why i think based on which variant of the exile she got she isnt an automatic loser lmao. 

What if the OPPOSITE team went home the first 3 eliminations on SLA?

Michaela/Renan magically beat Michele/Corey, Tracy/Kelz beat Emy/Ed, and Tacha beats Berna... how much BETTER would the season have been?

What if the OPPOSITE team went home the first 3 eliminations on SLA?

Michaela/Renan magically beat Michele/Corey, Tracy/Kelz beat Emy/Ed, and Tacha beats Berna... how much BETTER would the season have been?

I feel like Michaela and Kelz were about to show out, hell Renan might have been a surprise hook up wise at least. 

What if the OPPOSITE team went home the first 3 eliminations on SLA?

Michaela/Renan magically beat Michele/Corey, Tracy/Kelz beat Emy/Ed, and Tacha beats Berna... how much BETTER would the season have been?

Just change the first one.  Tracy, Kelz and Tacha would have gone basically immediately after that.

If they could run any season again, same format, same cast which one would you want to see redone?

If they could run any season again, same format, same cast which one would you want to see redone?

Inferno

If they could run any season again, same format, same cast which one would you want to see redone?

ruins

 

If they could run any season again, same format, same cast which one would you want to see redone?

ruins

That's a good one.

 

 

If they could run any season again, same format, same cast which one would you want to see redone?

ruins

That's a good one.

thank you!

 

What if the OPPOSITE team went home the first 3 eliminations on SLA?

Michaela/Renan magically beat Michele/Corey, Tracy/Kelz beat Emy/Ed, and Tacha beats Berna... how much BETTER would the season have been?

Just change the first one.  Tracy, Kelz and Tacha would have gone basically immediately after that.

I don't think Kelz would've been that easy to beat depending on his partner.

If they could run any season again, same format, same cast which one would you want to see redone?

Cutthroat

5 of the Top 10 women of all time - Laurel, Cara, Camila, Emily S, AND Sarah R - plus multi-time champs Paula and Tori H - plus best-to-never-win Theresa and Jenn

then you also have Brad, John, Derrick, Abe, and Tyler - along with other finalists like Ty and Chet and Luke. the men are less exciting, but that's almost always the case LMAO

Why did I open this thread to a 10 page essay about DA? Who has that kind of time?! I expect better from you GoldenRing!

Hell no!/gamervev

Like please GR you always have solid posts but that was....a lot to put it nicely. I-...

Hell no!/gamervev

 

If they could run any season again, same format, same cast which one would you want to see redone?

Inferno

with Piggy or Christena?

Why did I open this thread to a 10 page essay about DA? Who has that kind of time?! I expect better from you GoldenRing!

Hell no!/gamervev

That was three months ago atp.

Also, change your profile photo back

Pages