The Challenge: What Ifs

2757 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if The Ruins had the option to switch teams after winning an elimination? 

What if The Ruins had the option to switch teams after winning an elimination? 

Wes would've definitely switched teams

What if The Ruins had the option to switch teams after winning an elimination? 

Wes would've definitely switched teams

Agreed but Casey still throw missions so I don't think much changes

 

What if The Ruins had the option to switch teams after winning an elimination? 

Wes would've definitely switched teams

Agreed but Casey still throw missions so I don't think much changes

Sarah switches imo, gets a win and it changes her whole challenge future 

Lol the messy format they use on the challenge now would have been so appropriate for that season. It really needed a twist 

What if The Ruins had the option to switch teams after winning an elimination? 

what if the challengers did the smart thing and sent in Casey over Brianna against Susie?

 

What if The Ruins had the option to switch teams after winning an elimination? 

what if the challengers did the smart thing and sent in Casey over Brianna against Susie?

Yeah, that's the real question

 

 

What if The Ruins had the option to switch teams after winning an elimination? 

what if the challengers did the smart thing and sent in Casey over Brianna against Susie?

Yeah, that's the real question

Def what should have happened.  Casey would have for sure had an early exit.  Brianna - not sure if she was strong or not, but def would have given them a strongER girl than Casey for other Challenges and eliminations.  

I feel like this might not be as big for some people but what if the champions could go against the challengers in invasion what does the final look like and who wins i think ct and laurel(sorry ashley i love you)

I feel like this might not be as big for some people but what if the champions could go against the challengers in invasion what does the final look like and who wins i think ct and laurel(sorry ashley i love you)

No rookie makes that final in that scenario.  Darrell probably wins along with Laurel.   Darrell-CT-John & Laurel-Camila-Cara.   The only way Darrell doesn't win IMO is if he was paired with Cara for the first part and they can't figure out the triangles

I personally wish that would have happened.  That season had great potential but I thought the set up was weird.  

What if Melissa and Coral had been on Inferno 2 instead of Rachel and Beth - any change on who makes a final?  Would that kill part of both Rachel & Beth's legacy on the show?  

I personally wish that would have happened.  That season had great potential but I thought the set up was weird.  

What if Melissa and Coral had been on Inferno 2 instead of Rachel and Beth - any change on who makes a final?  Would that kill part of both Rachel & Beth's legacy on the show?  

Coral wouldn't have seen an inferno. Without Rachel there she would have been the best girl IMO. Melissa definitely would have seen an inferno or two. She was ok but not amazing at challenges . I bet it would have gone down like: Robin vs Tina, Jodi vs Veronica, Julie vs Melissa, Shavonda vs Melissa or Tonya

Julie would prob be plotting to get Coral into the inferno against someone like Jodi...... but I think Coral would have gotten herself out of it.

Julie would prob be plotting to get Coral into the inferno against someone like Jodi...... but I think Coral would have gotten herself out of it.

Yeah, I think it would have been interesting.  I do think Julie goes into the first elimination though--Melissa, Veronica & Coral would have pushed hard for that.  And Melissa would have gone in too--she's basically a layup with no friends on the good guys team.

 

I feel like this might not be as big for some people but what if the champions could go against the challengers in invasion what does the final look like and who wins i think ct and laurel(sorry ashley i love you)

No rookie makes that final in that scenario.  Darrell probably wins along with Laurel.   Darrell-CT-John & Laurel-Camila-Cara.   The only way Darrell doesn't win IMO is if he was paired with Cara for the first part and they can't figure out the triangles

nicole might make the final, depending on the elimination she's thrown into.

Speaking of invasion...

What if the Rookies competed in the classic eliminations (Pole Wrestle, Balls In, Knot So Fast), and the Vets competed in the new ones (Tuk Tuk Bang Bang, Bell Ringer, Inside Out)?

 

 

I feel like this might not be as big for some people but what if the champions could go against the challengers in invasion what does the final look like and who wins i think ct and laurel(sorry ashley i love you)

No rookie makes that final in that scenario.  Darrell probably wins along with Laurel.   Darrell-CT-John & Laurel-Camila-Cara.   The only way Darrell doesn't win IMO is if he was paired with Cara for the first part and they can't figure out the triangles

nicole might make the final, depending on the elimination she's thrown into.

True. That's a very good point 

Speaking of invasion...

What if the Rookies competed in the classic eliminations (Pole Wrestle, Balls In, Knot So Fast), and the Vets competed in the new ones (Tuk Tuk Bang Bang, Bell Ringer, Inside Out)?

 

Ill start with the underdogs:

Kailah Vs Sylvia (Pole Wrestle) I think Kailah takes it, but would be sent in again the next week against Jenna.  

Jenna Vs Kailah (Balls In) I think that Kailah once again takes it and sends Jenna home a week earlier.i'm  going to assume that there's the first part of the bloodbath in which Nicole is eliminated; making the final 3 underdog girls Kailah, Amanda, And Ashley. If knot so fast is the elimination, I can't see Kailah beating either girls. Amanda and Ashley make the final.  

  

What if Aneesa does every season since her debut? Does she ever win? 

What if Aneesa does every season since her debut? Does she ever win? 

maybe cutthroat? 

What if Aneesa does every season since her debut? Does she ever win? 

Hard to say. Honestly her best shot was gauntlet 2 and we saw how that worked out. I just wish she was in better shape so then she could win. 

 

Speaking of invasion...

What if the Rookies competed in the classic eliminations (Pole Wrestle, Balls In, Knot So Fast), and the Vets competed in the new ones (Tuk Tuk Bang Bang, Bell Ringer, Inside Out)?

 

Ill start with the underdogs:

Kailah Vs Sylvia (Pole Wrestle) I think Kailah takes it, but would be sent in again the next week against Jenna.  

Jenna Vs Kailah (Balls In) I think that Kailah once again takes it and sends Jenna home a week earlier.i'm  going to assume that there's the first part of the bloodbath in which Nicole is eliminated; making the final 3 underdog girls Kailah, Amanda, And Ashley. If knot so fast is the elimination, I can't see Kailah beating either girls. Amanda and Ashley make the final.  

  

Ooo Kailah vs Sylvia in Pole Wrestle would be a good match up. I can see either one winning imo.

What if Aneesa does every season since her debut? Does she ever win? 

She could have won The Gauntlet or The Inferno--after that I think it would have been tough for her.  She was in her best shape to win a final on Bloodlines.   So maybe Aneesa wins if she was on Exes 2 or Rivals III depending on her partner.  

I always wondered what the actual Gauntlet 2 final was supposed to be - and if that would have changed the outcome?  The rookies were more atheltically stacked imo.  Or if they didn't do the betting thing and told them to divide them up evenly between the events.  

What if Casey won Fresh Meat

What if the Double Agents format was used on Bloodlines? How would that change the season?

What if Casey won Fresh Meat

I wouldn't so much be wwondering about Casey - I'd be more upset hearing Wes gloat.  I'm glad they didn't - he was a horrible person towards her.  The Ruins would def have been different too

What if Casey won Fresh Meat

Aviv or Darrell would have needed to die before or during the race. Kenny or Tina too. Lol but nah that would have been hysterical 

What if the Double Agents format was used on Bloodlines? How would that change the season?

THAT would have made that season super interesting!  Having the bloodlines change partners and whatnot.  I also thought it would have been interesting to have that season in an old school team format and have it be the bloodlines vs the actual cast members.  

 

What if the Double Agents format was used on Bloodlines? How would that change the season?

THAT would have made that season super interesting!  Having the bloodlines change partners and whatnot.  I also thought it would have been interesting to have that season in an old school team format and have it be the bloodlines vs the actual cast members.  

The elimination format was so unfair that season with the partners going home without going into elimination

Pages