The Challenge: What Ifs

2757 posts / 0 new
Last post

key west happened during hurricane katrina? 

key west happened during hurricane katrina? 

yeah, it filmed fall of 05, and they got hit by like 3 tropical storms.

If Kenny and Evan situation never happened, who would currently have the most championships?

If Kenny and Evan situation never happened, who would currently have the most championships?

Evan was basically done so Kenny or John

What if Genesis would have not nominated herself to be in the inner circle the first day of sexes 2? How long would she have lasted? I think she would have been there either as long as Cynthia trying to skate by or possibly would have made it closer to the end depending on how social she got since most people seem to like her. also would have been a totally different game if Tina or Rachel got sent home instead. 

 

If Kenny and Evan situation never happened, who would currently have the most championships?

Evan was basically done so Kenny or John

John

Kenny wasnt winning anymore after the TEAM ERA ended.

Evan would have had the new generation turn on him like he did to Coral on G3

What if Genesis would have not nominated herself to be in the inner circle the first day of sexes 2? How long would she have lasted? I think she would have been there either as long as Cynthia trying to skate by or possibly would have made it closer to the end depending on how social she got since most people seem to like her. also would have been a totally different game if Tina or Rachel got sent home instead. 

Genesis probably would have made it pretty far.  She was a decent competitor and everyone liked her.  That season there were not many individual missions.  

She would have been saved over all the newbies  (extreme and SD girls, Arissa and Sophia), Ayana, Tonya, and Cynthia

It is possible she would have been top 6

What if Genesis would have not nominated herself to be in the inner circle the first day of sexes 2? How long would she have lasted? I think she would have been there either as long as Cynthia trying to skate by or possibly would have made it closer to the end depending on how social she got since most people seem to like her. also would have been a totally different game if Tina or Rachel got sent home instead. 

Cynthia's boot always ****** me tf off.

Genesis makes a deep run for sure.

 

 

If Kenny and Evan situation never happened, who would currently have the most championships?

Evan was basically done so Kenny or John

John

Kenny wasnt winning anymore after the TEAM ERA ended.

Evan would have had the new generation turn on him like he did to Coral on G3

Kenny could still have won seasons...anything paired.  Seasons because if Kenny's still there that FM team looks different and probably have one from.the beginning. Plus if John could win Free Agents so could Kenny as Kenny crushed finals. Not a fan of him but gotta give credit where it's due. The only time he lost finals were when Easy died, Wes died and then Landon was Landon

 

 

 

If Kenny and Evan situation never happened, who would currently have the most championships?

Evan was basically done so Kenny or John

John

Kenny wasnt winning anymore after the TEAM ERA ended.

Evan would have had the new generation turn on him like he did to Coral on G3

Kenny could still have won seasons...anything paired.  Seasons because if Kenny's still there that FM team looks different and probably have one from.the beginning. Plus if John could win Free Agents so could Kenny as Kenny crushed finals. Not a fan of him but gotta give credit where it's due. The only time he lost finals were when Easy died, Wes died and then Landon was Landon

Kenny would have never made it to the Rivals final without Wes winning challenges and eliminations.  Kenny was awful that season.

I3 - Kenny won because he never saw an elimination.  There were only 4 male eliminations picked by the other team.

Island - Kenny was only in one elimination where Abram beat him.  He made it to the end by bullying the females

The Ruins- Was on a team that was a majority of his closest allies (Johnny, Evan, Derrrick, Johana).  He avoided elimination by ganging up on Wes.

Other than FM eliminations (basically mini finals) he is most likely not winning.  Wes carried him in Rivals and he lost to Nehemiah on The Duel.

Kenny was not going to manipulate his way out of eliminations with the newer cast.

I hated the rules for botsexes2

Kenny was def going to have the Bananas spot. Bananas was never really that much of a factor out of the 3. 

Evan I could have seen being like a Kellyanne and popping up every now and again but not on the regular. 

Evan might've showed up on D30 but he 100% does an All-Stars.

Kenny would still be here. Maybe one or two more wins, but honestly don't see him winning that much.

Considering Kenny had a beef with Wes I'd be interested to see how John got pushed, unless he started to outcompete Kenny. And, I do think John got much better as the years went on, he was outdoing Kenny in Rivals.

Eventually the two face off in elimination, but I do see Kenny taking a few seasons off at some point, before John does.

What if for one season they made the women's cast all lesbians?

What if for one season they made the women's cast all lesbians?

So that's how Nany wins omg 

 

What if for one season they made the women's cast all lesbians?

So that's how Nany wins omg 

Nany isn't beating Evelyn nor Laurel nor Nicole nor Ruthie nor Genesis nor Sophia.

she can beat Aneesa, Brooke, Big T and Kaycee if Kaycee throws it...

What if for one season they made the women's cast all lesbians?

So that's how Nany wins omg 

Basically every elite girl likes women, nany has no shot lol

Veronica, Coral, and Rachel would return as well. Nany ain't got no chance.

Negrotti would try to get on the cast with urgency, to be surrounded by as many lesbians as possible. She would compete with Nicole Z in trying to hook up with as many women as possible. Aneesa would be extremely jealous.

Finally, the men would be useless this season and there would be no polidicking to be done on their behalf. 

What if Frank didn't get sick on Free Agents?

What if Frank didn't get sick on Free Agents?

Lesbian Laurel still would've won. Next.

What if Frank didn't get sick on Free Agents?

He sucks Jordans **** and his one finger hand since They both gay.

 

What if Frank didn't get sick on Free Agents?

Lesbian Laurel still would've won. Next.

but does bananas still win for the guys

 

 

What if Frank didn't get sick on Free Agents?

Lesbian Laurel still would've won. Next.

but does bananas still win for the guys

yeah I think so

Aneesas first ride or die got covid and got sent home...what if they sent her home too? Never flew in Jordan? Never brought  back Kaycee and Kenny after they got covid? Would the other vacation alliance members have made the final?

Aneesas first ride or die got covid and got sent home...what if they sent her home too? Never flew in Jordan? Never brought  back Kaycee and Kenny after they got covid? Would the other vacation alliance members have made the final?

Moriah & Faysal are now challenge champions 

What if Avery/Nia and Dustin/Frank were duos for Rivals 2? I wonder who and how the cast would be rearranged.

Veronica, Coral, and Rachel would return as well. Nany ain't got no chance.

Negrotti would try to get on the cast with urgency, to be surrounded by as many lesbians as possible. She would compete with Nicole Z in trying to hook up with as many women as possible. Aneesa would be extremely jealous.

Finally, the men would be useless this season and there would be no polidicking to be done on their behalf. 

If this does not turn out to be the final result, I would lose all confidence for the Challenge.

I was rewatching Free Agents. I'm very curious if Theresa went to the final, would she have won? I think Nany would have snagged the win

I was rewatching Free Agents. I'm very curious if Theresa went to the final, would she have won? I think Nany would have snagged the win

If Theresa gets Zach on the mountain I can see her panicking and narrowly losing. I'd be a lot closer.

The biggest question is would Laurel have done another season after losing? I think she's on Exes 2 with Jordan.

Pages