The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if Cara Maria was never called back after Fresh Meat ever again Sad

What if Cara Maria was never called back after Fresh Meat ever again

Then you'd have to find someone else to obsess over. 

What if Cara Maria was never called back after Fresh Meat ever again

Laurel actually wouldn't have a storyline because even without Cara all she has is Nicole. Not saying she wouldn't find a way to argue but her biggest plot thread is Cara.

Also, Rivals would be a snooze for the last part of the season. And WOTW2 is very different talking long term.

Like all the conflict on Grey in Cutthroat was Cara related.

I don't think I'd matter too much until Free Agents without her being there but that's actually a good what if.

Because Cara ATE.

Ate shit maybe

What if AmBer didn't win Double Agents Smile

What if AmBer didn't win Double Agents

What if there was never a redemption house on final reckoning Smile

 

What if AmBer didn't win Double Agents

What if there was never a redemption house on final reckoning

What if Amber had to solve the math equation in the Double Agents final to move on to Day 2 Sad

What if Da'vonne was rightfully cast on big brother 16 instead of Amber?

You don't come for Amber and I don't come for Da'Vonne okay? Let's not fight bc they are sistas! Smile

What if Da'vonne was rightfully cast on big brother 16 instead of Amber?

what if theo and olivia are found at a trump rally

What if Da'vonne was rightfully cast on big brother 16 instead of Amber?

what if theo and olivia are found at a trump rally

Then the sky is blue and grass is green. 

 

What if Da'vonne was rightfully cast on big brother 16 instead of Amber?

what if theo and olivia are found at a trump rally

Then the sky is blue and grass is green. 

What if all stars 5 only had rivalries that originated in the all star universe and/or OG days (pairs we got robbed of never seeing together). Who would you want to see?

 

that means no:

  • Ashley K/Dario
  • Nany/Turbo 
  • Davonne/Shane 
  • Sam/Frank 
  • Amber/Faysal 
  • Big T/Corey Lay 
  • Leroy/Devin 
  • Ashley/Aneesa 
  • Melissa/Nicole 
  • we would still have:  

  • Kellyanne/Sylvia 

  • Jonna/Beth 

  • Adam/Steve 

  • katie/veronica (if including OG rivalries. If not, katie/trishelle or katie/steve, but then we need partners for adam and veronica)

  • we could have: 

  • Kendall/kailah
  • Ayanna/jasmine or jodi
  • flora/tina
  • Yes/wes
  • Darrell/leah (its a stretch)
  • casey cooper/derrick
  • LT/ace (its a stretch) 
  • who else?

     

    Ayanna/ Kam (Jasmine as her alt since I believe she was pregnant)

    Irulan / Rachel

    Flora / Tina

    CT/ Karamo

    Coral / Julie

    Wes / Yes

    Alton / Darrell

    Nia / Kailah

    Ooooo Golden you ate with that!!! If coral ever agreed, her and Julie would be a must. And I would love to see how Karamo and CT would work.

     

    also your avi <333

    Could've been Ayanna and Sophia but don't none of y'all have any love for my good lesbian sis.

    I dont really want to see Abe back but him and Steve would be an interesting pair

    I dont really want to see Abe back but him and Steve would be an interesting pair

    you mean Abe and Adam off of that crazy fight for no reason on viewers revenge? That would work.., I don't remember Abe and Steve having problems in the gauntlet

    Ooooo Golden you ate with that!!! If coral ever agreed, her and Julie would be a must. And I would love to see how Karamo and CT would work.

     

    also your avi <333

    I never comment on it, but you still having my man as your pfp makes me scream. I wish he had a Rival I could've put him with.

     

    I dont really want to see Abe back but him and Steve would be an interesting pair

    you mean Abe and Adam off of that crazy fight for no reason on viewers revenge? That would work.., I don't remember Abe and Steve having problems in the gauntlet

    oops no youre right lmao. I always get basic white man names mixed up

    I never comment on it, but you still having my man as your pfp makes me scream. I wish he had a Rival I could've put him with.

    he will always be my favorite. Mhmm a REAL man. Ugh, I wish they could cast him on another show

    Could've been Ayanna and Sophia but don't none of y'all have any love for my good lesbian sis.

    Sophia and Ayanna <3

     

    Could've been Ayanna and Sophia but don't none of y'all have any love for my good lesbian sis.

    Sophia and Ayanna <3

    Lol Ayanna and Sophia would be good. Ayanna has a lot of options: Sophia, Aneesa, Janelle, Jasmine, Jodi, and Christian (even tho **** him btw).

    Ayanna/ Kam (Jasmine as her alt since I believe she was pregnant)

    Irulan / Rachel

    Flora / Tina

    CT/ Karamo

    Coral / Julie

    Wes / Yes

    Alton / Darrell

    Nia / Kailah

    Good list...we need Lando & Darrell for their 2 minute argument on Inferno 2.  Alton or Landon with Susie/Cara though Kina/Cara or Jillian/Cara is better.  Beth/Aneesa.   Jodi/Veronica.  Tina/Beth. Adam L/Derrick.  Nehemiah/Derrick.  Kendal/Mark. CT/Coral. Danny J/everyone (pretty sure everyone was against him at some point)  Jenn & Susie, Tori H, Aneesa, Evelyn, KellyAnne...also basically anyone. 

    What if The Gauntlet 2 had a regular final? Do the Rookies still win? Final team rosters:

    Veterans: Timmy, Mark, David, Aneesa, Julie, Robin, Katie

    Rookies: Alton, Landon, Jamie, MJ, Randy, Kina, Jodi, Susie, Ibis

    Methinks Rookies might still win but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    Love that idea soooo much better for AS5.  

    Kendal/Miz

    Emily/Veronica or Emily/RachelAnne/Ayanna (Anne rolled her eyes about Ayanna in a sexes confessional once so then we get Anne back)

    Julie / Coral or Trishelle / Coral

    Alton / Theo V

    Susie / Angel

    Sarah / Katie

    Julie / Melissa

    Elka / Miz

    so many -'others have said amazing pairs too. 

    in regards to gauntlet 2 - as much as I wish Robin would have gotten that win at some point in her career I think the Rookie's still have it in the bag.  

    What if The Gauntlet 2 had a regular final? Do the Rookies still win? Final team rosters:

    Veterans: Timmy, Mark, David, Aneesa, Julie, Robin, Katie

    Rookies: Alton, Landon, Jamie, MJ, Randy, Kina, Jodi, Susie, Ibis

    Methinks Rookies might still win but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    Unless the eating portion is a huge part of the final.... the Rookies lose with Ibis still there.

    What if Patrick from Xtreme did Battle of the Sexes 2 instead of boring Nick?  Does Patrick become a mainstory and derrick never becomes a regular. That means no career long challenge for derrick, which also means no scott yager. What a timeline.  

    Pages