The Challenge: What Ifs

2775 posts / 0 new
Last post

I think its safe to assume he does

Is it? He seems a lot closer to Cara than Johnny, if he felt like he had a good group going with the cult, which he obviously did, then he probably stays with them

Yeah but he's still the biggest fan of his own bank account. I have no doubt he would side with either John or Paulie/Cara based on which way the wind was blowing.This piqued my interest though so I checked wiki

the alliance breakdown had Johnny won and switched to team UK would have been 6-6 on both teams (unless i ****** the count up) with CT as the deciding vote. CT had been riding the fence as much as he could at that time still. If he felt he had an opportunity with Bananas to turn the team around and take matters into his own hands instead of being a cog in the cult, just taking orders, the game could have been flipped on its head again.

On the flip side though, if Johnny had reason to belive CT WASNT going to side with him, we likely would have seen him try to throw another challenge leading to a mess of a tribunal vote on the US team as its 6-6 over there. Who knows how that would have ended up. With Johhny back after getting thrown in by Paulie the battle lines would be clearer then ever and I don't see either side on the U.S. team faltering and giving the other side the tribunal majority. Even with Kam, if Bananas is still in the game I don't think Leroy flips. Obviously all just speculation though

The eliminations of Wes, Laurel, and Nanners back to back to back was insane. Really changed the game. The season peaked early.

Im still sad Laurel went out but to me she was the most memorable part of that whole season. I think CT would have worked with Johnny if he ended up on the Brit side.  

What if Laurel didn't go home against Ninja? Do you think the outcome would have changed a lot? I mean Ashley flipped to her side as soon as Laurel threatened her so the numbers I feel would have went in Laurel's favor the rest of the game. 

anon23423234ffs...
Anonymous's picture

Im still sad Laurel went out but to me she was the most memorable part of that whole season. I think CT would have worked with Johnny if he ended up on the Brit side.  

What if Laurel didn't go home against Ninja? Do you think the outcome would have changed a lot? I mean Ashley flipped to her side as soon as Laurel threatened her so the numbers I feel would have went in Laurel's favor the rest of the game. 

That would've made the season way more entertaining. Ninja's so annoying.

What if Theresa beats laurel on the last elim in free agents ? Is Theresa now a challenge champion? 

What if Theresa beats laurel on the last elim in free agents ? Is Theresa now a challenge champion? 

If she gets Zach on the same leg that Laurel did, probably not

 

What if Theresa beats laurel on the last elim in free agents ? Is Theresa now a challenge champion? 

If she gets Zach on the same leg that Laurel did, probably not

Damn that means Nany would be a challenge champ lmao

 

 

What if Theresa beats laurel on the last elim in free agents ? Is Theresa now a challenge champion? 

If she gets Zach on the same leg that Laurel did, probably not

Damn that means Nany would be a challenge champ lmao

On an individual season nonetheless

 

 

What if Theresa beats laurel on the last elim in free agents ? Is Theresa now a challenge champion? 

If she gets Zach on the same leg that Laurel did, probably not

Damn that means Nany would be a challenge champ lmao

yeah I def see Nany winning that season for sure if that happened.

what If Jonna didn't mess up her passport and was on Fresh Meat 2 instead of Ev do you think we would have saw Ev on Rivals or would she have been done with the series post Ruins? 

 

 

 

What if Theresa beats laurel on the last elim in free agents ? Is Theresa now a challenge champion? 

If she gets Zach on the same leg that Laurel did, probably not

Damn that means Nany would be a challenge champ lmao

yeah I def see Nany winning that season for sure if that happened.

what If Jonna didn't mess up her passport and was on Fresh Meat 2 instead of Ev do you think we would have saw Ev on Rivals or would she have been done with the series post Ruins? 

I think she would've came back if the appearance fee was decent

What if the WOTW 2 final was individual? How do you think everyone would have placed?

this is my guess

  1. Tori
  2. Kam
  3. Ashley
  4. Cara
  5. Dee
  6. Ninja

 

  1. Zach
  2. Leroy
  3. Jordan
  4. CT
  5. Rogan
  6. Paulie

Also idk if it's been asked but

What if Bananas didn't take the money on Rivals 3, how many more times would we have seen Sarah?

 

 

What if Theresa beats laurel on the last elim in free agents ? Is Theresa now a challenge champion? 

If she gets Zach on the same leg that Laurel did, probably not

Damn that means Nany would be a challenge champ lmao

Omg lmaooo Nany an individual champ on her third season would have been amazing. Would have been a tight and fun final to watch though. 

No way ninja gets last she's great at puzzles. 

What if Cara & Kailah were originally partners on final reckoning? Assuming the melissa & Kaliah dq still happens how far could cara & Kam go? 

anon23423234ffs...
Anonymous's picture

This is more of a Real World question, but what if Kenny was on Austin instead of Wes? Assuming Wes was on the Fresh Meat side and Kenny was on the Veterans side, how would the season play out?

This is more of a Real World question, but what if Kenny was on Austin instead of Wes? Assuming Wes was on the Fresh Meat side and Kenny was on the Veterans side, how would the season play out?

Kenny having the blonde girl and Wes having Tina, too?I mean, Kenny would've been targeted for simply being Austin team, no?

 

What if the WOTW 2 final was individual? How do you think everyone would have placed?

this is my guess

  1. Tori
  2. Kam
  3. Ashley
  4. Cara
  5. Dee
  6. Ninja

 

  1. Zach
  2. Leroy
  3. Jordan
  4. CT
  5. Rogan
  6. Paulie

well if it were individual then they couldn't have the big gurney. maybe they would do weighted backpacks like on Bloodlines, but hopefully as a proportion of their bodyweight instead of 120lbs for all dudes. so still the math problem, eating the grub, lil catapult, swim, run, sleeping with snakes, and puzzle.

assuming that, I don't see anyone beating Jordan.

then Zach, Paulie, Rogan, Leroy, CT.

for the women, it's harder. Ashley then Ninja, Cara, Kam, Tori, Dee.

What if Cara & Kailah were originally partners on final reckoning? Assuming the melissa & Kaliah dq still happens how far could cara & Kam go? 

I wish they were. They have always had legit beef. If Cara/Kailah were partnered I think Kailah would've kept her head straight and not DQ'd. She knew she had no chance with Kayleigh so she didn't have much to lose getting into it with Melissa. She knew it would be good TV.

What if the WOTW 2 final was individual? How do you think everyone would have placed?

this is my guess

  1. Tori
  2. Kam
  3. Ashley
  4. Cara
  5. Dee
  6. Ninja

 

  1. Zach
  2. Leroy
  3. Jordan
  4. CT
  5. Rogan
  6. Paulie

It being individual changes the entire layout of the final, so it hard to know based on that final. that being said Jordan 100% wins no contest. 

What if the WOTW 2 final was individual? How do you think everyone would have placed?

this is my guess

  1. Tori
  2. Kam
  3. Ashley
  4. Cara
  5. Dee
  6. Ninja

 

  1. Zach
  2. Leroy
  3. Jordan
  4. CT
  5. Rogan
  6. Paulie

It being individual changes the entire layout of the final, so it hard to know based on that final. that being said Jordan 100% wins no contest. 

Yeah if it was individual I think Jordan and Ashley would have one for sure. 

What If Rachel wasn't pregnant and accepted the Invasion call, would she have taken over for Laurel, Cara Maria, Camilla, or Ashley K and would the thaw changed the outcome in the end?

anon23423234ffs...
Anonymous's picture

Yeah if it was individual I think Jordan and Ashley would have one for sure. 

What If Rachel wasn't pregnant and accepted the Invasion call, would she have taken over for Laurel, Cara Maria, Camilla, or Ashley K and would the thaw changed the outcome in the end?

I think she would've taken Ashley K's spot. It would be hard to tell since Camila, Cara Maria, and Laurel are all tremendous athletes, despite the first two's personalities.

Yeah if it was individual I think Jordan and Ashley would have one for sure. 

What If Rachel wasn't pregnant and accepted the Invasion call, would she have taken over for Laurel, Cara Maria, Camilla, or Ashley K and would the thaw changed the outcome in the end?

Def take Ashley K's spot and I can see her being put into all the eliminations like Darrell was. Prob beats Cara in the first one then loses to Laurel in the second one with Camila still making it to the end. 

Also idk if it's been asked but

What if Bananas didn't take the money on Rivals 3, how many more times would we have seen Sarah?

I think she was ready to be done after she got her win on Exes II and only came back because she knew she'd be partnered with Bananas and that she'd have a good shot at another win given how weak the casts were at that point

 

Also idk if it's been asked but

What if Bananas didn't take the money on Rivals 3, how many more times would we have seen Sarah?

I think she was ready to be done after she got her win on Exes II and only came back because she knew she'd be partnered with Bananas and that she'd have a good shot at another win given how weak the casts were at that point

If true that makes what happened to her all the more halarious.

Maybe already asked but what if Evelyn hadn't been sick and was able to be on "The Duel"... do you think Jodi would still have won?

 

I Don't see Ev meshing well with the drama mafia at all.  An Ev, Wes, Svet, Nehemiah, Aneesa (& in a perfect world, Tina) alliance would likely have toppled the main alliance & gotten a lot of them to the end with Evelyn winning that season whether Jodi is in the finals or not.  

The Duel female cast wasn't that strong, I don't really see Ev losing an elimination to any of them

Did Evelyn have any weaknesses? I only seen 2 seasons with her and her recent ones so I can't remember her being bad at anything lol 

Pages