The Challenge: What Ifs

2757 posts / 0 new
Last post

Anika getting tossed off the cliff by Jenna was an iconic moment >>>

When Anika actually won...

I still get angry when re-watching The Inferno II and seeing how Rachel/V/Tina but especially Dan treated Jodi.  And like her team wasn't even fighting back.  And Rachel is my all time fav, and I love how Veronica admitted in a confessional that she was just mad she didn't think of the loop hole first.  That episode made me hate Dan forever but he never came back again so oh well lol. That was such a weird elminiation too...lol. And I'm even more shocked that Jodi was never asked back or even got an avaialability call after The Duel.  She said so on her '15 Min of Blame' interview last year.  What If: Jodi had beat Veronica in the toilet paper spin elminiation.  Would she have made it to the end that season?  

Jodi was such a spineless wimp.  She pulled a shady move & had to suffer the consequences.  She deserved everything she got that season.

 

ChallengeFan00 wrote:

Anika getting tossed off the cliff by Jenna was an iconic moment >>>

When Anika actually won...

based off of what concrete fact tho? 

ChallengeFan00 wrote:

Anika getting tossed off the cliff by Jenna was an iconic moment >>>

When Anika actually won...

Here we go again..

Psy4potato wrote:

I still get angry when re-watching The Inferno II and seeing how Rachel/V/Tina but especially Dan treated Jodi.  And like her team wasn't even fighting back.  And Rachel is my all time fav, and I love how Veronica admitted in a confessional that she was just mad she didn't think of the loop hole first.  That episode made me hate Dan forever but he never came back again so oh well lol. That was such a weird elminiation too...lol. And I'm even more shocked that Jodi was never asked back or even got an avaialability call after The Duel.  She said so on her '15 Min of Blame' interview last year.  What If: Jodi had beat Veronica in the toilet paper spin elminiation.  Would she have made it to the end that season?  

Jodi was such a spineless wimp.  She pulled a shady move & had to suffer the consequences.  She deserved everything she got that season. 

How was it shady? Completely strategy and smart lmao. Androgen they were given an unfair elimination once princess Veronica was put into elimination, Jodi would’ve crushed her in anything else.

Jodi's move wasn't shady. It was smart even if it was really Julie's idea. That said when you do something like that be ready for the blow back. Dan Tina Rachel and Veronica accomplished what they wanted when they attacked her verbally.  They broke her. 

That whole Jodi thing was so ridiculous. I was moreso mad at the Good Guys team who were mostly quiet while she was getting attacked. V and the gang were mean but they got what they wanted out of it and lets face it they were just mad they didn't think of it first. 

The Good Guys knew that Jodi was a cry baby and should have stood up for her. TBH the real shady move was done by production. The ******** won the week before so they should have chosen second but after hearing the plan they swapped places to make it happen.

The Good Guys knew that Jodi was a cry baby and should have stood up for her. TBH the real shady move was done by production. The ******** won the week before so they should have chosen second but after hearing the plan they swapped places to make it happen.

And it gave us solid tv so I support this production move. 

It is shady to wait to see who the other team nominates before you make your choice.   It was a loophole that wasn't against the rules, but still shady nonetheless. 

Love all the Jodi love <3 Iconic Queen.

What If... 

The Challenges were still modeled like the good ol' days of "The Gauntlet' and 'The Inferno" - would Marie be a champ?  (Imo...yes, yes she would!)

It is shady to wait to see who the other team nominates before you make your choice.   It was a loophole that wasn't against the rules, but still shady nonetheless. 

Not shady at all. 

What if Exes 2 has no Exile twist? Who even wins the season and also means we probably dont get Rivals 3 being male/female since that season was built because John couldnt stop crying that Sarah threw him into elimination

anon23423234ffs...
Anonymous's picture

What if CT never fought anyone or got kicked off? How long would his Challenge career be?

That whole Jodi thing was so ridiculous. I was moreso mad at the Good Guys team who were mostly quiet while she was getting attacked. V and the gang were mean but they got what they wanted out of it and lets face it they were just mad they didn't think of it first. 

What if Exes 2 has no Exile twist? Who even wins the season and also means we probably dont get Rivals 3 being male/female since that season was built because John couldnt stop crying that Sarah threw him into elimination

Theresa/Wes were the top team so i see them taking the W and Sarah/Jordan 2nd but it would be super close 

What if CT never fought anyone or got kicked off? How long would his Challenge career be?

Does he win Inferno 3 instead of Derrick? Does Evan win The Duel?  It might change The Island and The Ruins since he was "benched" for those. 

Bananasisoverrated wrote:

What if Exes 2 has no Exile twist? Who even wins the season and also means we probably dont get Rivals 3 being male/female since that season was built because John couldnt stop crying that Sarah threw him into elimination

Theresa/Wes were the top team so i see them taking the W and Sarah/Jordan 2nd but it would be super close 

Personally i don't see Wes/Theresa beating Jordan/Sarah in a final 

imallergic wrote:

Bananasisoverrated wrote:What if Exes 2 has no Exile twist? Who even wins the season and also means we probably dont get Rivals 3 being male/female since that season was built because John couldnt stop crying that Sarah threw him into elimination

Theresa/Wes were the top team so i see them taking the W and Sarah/Jordan 2nd but it would be super close 

Personally i don't see Wes/Theresa beating Jordan/Sarah in a final 

I lean Wes/Theresa because they did an endurance type daily where Wes/Theresa killed it while Sarah was puking and everything 

FromTheNorth wrote:

imallergic wrote:

Bananasisoverrated wrote:What if Exes 2 has no Exile twist? Who even wins the season and also means we probably dont get Rivals 3 being male/female since that season was built because John couldnt stop crying that Sarah threw him into elimination

Theresa/Wes were the top team so i see them taking the W and Sarah/Jordan 2nd but it would be super close 

Personally i don't see Wes/Theresa beating Jordan/Sarah in a final 

I lean Wes/Theresa because they did an endurance type daily where Wes/Theresa killed it while Sarah was puking and everything 

yea Jordan is amazing in a final but Wes said that him and Theresa were running like 10 miles every day. And he would have been a much better partner in terms of handling Theresa’s frustrations than Leroy. 

if Johnny/Nany don't return after Ex-ile on Exes 2, then Sarah doesn't throw him in, so a whole season is not built around their "vendetta."

so I think Rivals 3 would have been same-sex. maybe it would still be have been season 28, after Bloodlines, so we would've gotten teams like:

- Aneesa/Cara or Kellyanne

- Johnny/Dario

- Wes/Leroy

- Ashley M/Jamie Larson

- Nany/Theresa or Averey

- Nia/Sarah

- Reilly/Cohutta

- Devin/anyone from his AYTO season lol

- Cory/Brian or Raphy

- Tony/?

- Nicole R/Camila

- Layton/Anthony

Bananasisoverrated wrote:

What if Exes 2 has no Exile twist? Who even wins the season and also means we probably dont get Rivals 3 being male/female since that season was built because John couldnt stop crying that Sarah threw him into elimination

Theresa/Wes were the top team so i see them taking the W and Sarah/Jordan 2nd but it would be super close 

Leroy & Nia would’ve taken it home. 

imallergic wrote:

Bananasisoverrated wrote:What if Exes 2 has no Exile twist? Who even wins the season and also means we probably dont get Rivals 3 being male/female since that season was built because John couldnt stop crying that Sarah threw him into elimination

Theresa/Wes were the top team so i see them taking the W and Sarah/Jordan 2nd but it would be super close 

Leroy & Nia would’ve taken it home. 

With Leroy’s swimming I doubt it lmao

What if Johnny Reilly & Nany won Free Agents over Laurel & Zach?

imallergic wrote:

Bananasisoverrated wrote:What if Exes 2 has no Exile twist? Who even wins the season and also means we probably dont get Rivals 3 being male/female since that season was built because John couldnt stop crying that Sarah threw him into elimination

Theresa/Wes were the top team so i see them taking the W and Sarah/Jordan 2nd but it would be super close 

Leroy & Nia would’ve taken it home. 

Lol! come on, now

What if Veronica/Rachel/Coral/etc all wouldn't have jumped shipped around Gauntlet 2 time...would we have had a Fresh Meat season as soon as we did?  

What if Veronica/Rachel/Coral/etc all wouldn't have jumped shipped around Gauntlet 2 time...would we have had a Fresh Meat season as soon as we did?  

Nope--the show would have been very different

It is shady to wait to see who the other team nominates before you make your choice.   It was a loophole that wasn't against the rules, but still shady nonetheless. 

How's that shady? lmao. 

That was awesome game play and******* that were bothered were just bothered they didn't think of it ahead of time and got played. They were being haters. 

What if Johnny Reilly & Nany won Free Agents over Laurel & Zach?

Laurel would of been on exes 2 with Jordan and then would of won. QUEEN was going to have her win regardless

sourcup wrote:

What if Johnny Reilly & Nany won Free Agents over Laurel & Zach?

Laurel would of been on exes 2 with Jordan and then would of won. QUEEN was going to have her win regardless

I don't mind Laurel being the best challenger to never win. Or she could do a Rivals 4 with Paula to get her first win and Paula's third.

Psy4potato wrote:

What if Veronica/Rachel/Coral/etc all wouldn't have jumped shipped around Gauntlet 2 time...would we have had a Fresh Meat season as soon as we did?  

Nope--the show would have been very different

#dreams lol what a lovely show it could have been too.   Although I did love having the random old cast members in Gauntlet 2 appear.  The ending was a let downw ith only 1/3 of the final being played but I was glad the Xtreme girls plus Susie got a win.  I wish they would have gotten the next season to be something random other than fresh meat and started pulling from the randoms...we could have gotten some cool old faces back. 

What if...Nia wasn't kicked off Exes 2.  Would Nia and Leroy stood a shot at winning and beating Jordan and Sarah?  

Pages