The Challenge: What Ifs

2107 posts / 0 new
Last post

VCR14 wrote:
What if...-Katie had been Sarah's partner on Rivals 1 - Do we think they could have out performed Jenn and Mandi and made the final?-Tina and Coral had been on Dirty 30 as originally planned. Who's places do you think they would've taken?-Cory hadn't slammed Tony and been DQd. Do you think they would've had a chance at making the final?-Trishelle hadn't quit on Rivals 2. Do you think her and Sarah could've out performed Jonna/Nany, Theresa/Jasmine, Camila/Jemmye and Aneesa/Diem and possibly taken 3rd place?-Frank hadn't gotten sick on Free Agents 

I do really think Frank would have been in the final and probably won it.  He was a beast on this show competition wise and miss him a lot.

I don't think so. There was a lot of big guys that season and physical eliminations. I could see him losing to Zach, Leroy, Bananas, CT in most eliminations and maybe losing to others because of his size.

kvm1977 wrote:
Listen, I'm not saying Averey was going to be the next Coral or anything but Averey had potential and it would have been good to see more of her than just the same recycled cast year after year.  I thought she put up a hell of a battle against Nia in that elimination round.  One that I thought Nia should have killed her in.
Averey would’ve been called back more imo if she talked about something else other than Reilly and Nany.
I'm sure she spoke about more than just them two, but she was just used to juice the Reilly and Nany hookup for one more season.

Me and a friend are having a debate so

Hall Brawl (BOTSeasons Rules)

Abram & Laurel vs CT & Cara Maria who wins?

Me and a friend are having a debate soHall Brawl (BOTSeasons Rules)Abram & Laurel vs CT & Cara Maria who wins?

Just would depend on whether the tie-breaker round was male or female. CT wins for guys and Laurel wins for girls.

Would Bananas and Cara Maria be considered the faces of the show if Camila, Evan, and Kenny were still competing or would they have been on/mentioned less frequently?

Would Bananas and Cara Maria be considered the faces of the show if Camila, Evan, and Kenny were still competing or would they have been on/mentioned less frequently?

Kenny for sure would have still be the star, idk if Evan would have continued given the shape he was in on Rivals. If both of them were on Exes with Mark and John, Mark would have had a higher place in their totem pole thus John would have been viewed as disposable just like in the Ruins. Which in return might have made Camila not come back...

What If Camila didn't hit a producer? How far would she have gone in Vendettas? Whose spot would she have taken? Who would have been her partner in Final Reckoning?

I feel like she probably would have made the final again but who knows if she would have beaten Cara Maria. I think Amanda would have been her partner in FR.

What If Camila didn't hit a producer? How far would she have gone in Vendettas? Whose spot would she have taken? Who would have been her partner in Final Reckoning?I feel like she probably would have made the final again but who knows if she would have beaten Cara Maria. I think Amanda would have been her partner in FR.

Oh god. Probably the only team in which I wouldn't be able to root for Amanda lol.

There's no debating that Camila is a great competitor. She's very well-balanced and good at dailies and finals. I stand by the fact that I do think she's slightly overrated only because she's very lucky she's been given eliminations that favor her strengths. She, like Sarah, have never really been tested in a physical elimination (except vs Robin, who at that point almost anyone would've beaten). The closest to it was vs Teresa in Looper and she lost. I don't think she would've won Vendettas cause Cara beasted that puzzle. As for FR, she works terribly with partners. I don't see her making the end especially with the LL running the game.

They'd probably give Camila Leroy as a partner to show how much she's grown or whatever ******** justification they'd use for putting her on 

What if Jenna and Amanda were paired for FR. Would you think they would make it far?

What if Jenna and Amanda were paired for FR. Would you think they would make it far?
Absolutely further than Jenna/Jemmye did. One reason Zach dug Amanda out first was because she gave great directions to which grave she was buried in. Jenna is no slouch when it comes to cardio things, so I don't think she would have trouble digging A up. And as for making it in the game, both are reasonably good at dailies, and the Lavender Ladies were running the show. They could have finaled.

What if Jenna and Amanda were paired for FR. Would you think they would make it far?

well Jenna the doormat wouldn't have thrown herself into elimination and would have let Amanda make all the decisions so yeah probably. i think they could have flown utr and made the final

What if Kailah and Melissa never got disqualified and the teams stayed as Kam/Melissa and Kailah/Kayleigh?

As much as I don't like Kailah, I think the dynamic would've been interesting if she ended up staying because then all of the Dolphins (Kailah, Kam, Marie and Sylvia) would be in the house trying to run things, along with the LL and Sylvia would be forced to choose a side since she's also with the LL. Eventually, things would've gotten really messy with those two cliques. And I definitely think we would've seen an Amanda vs. Melissa fight at some point, which would've been iconic.

What if...-Katie had been Sarah's partner on Rivals 1 - Do we think they could have out performed Jenn and Mandi and made the final?-Tina and Coral had been on Dirty 30 as originally planned. Who's places do you think they would've taken?-Cory hadn't slammed Tony and been DQd. Do you think they would've had a chance at making the final?-Trishelle hadn't quit on Rivals 2. Do you think her and Sarah could've out performed Jonna/Nany, Theresa/Jasmine, Camila/Jemmye and Aneesa/Diem and possibly taken 3rd place?-Frank hadn't gotten sick on Free Agents 

I like most of the these...I wanna answer them lol

Katie and Sarah would have been a lot more fun to watch...I think they would have got farther than Sarah and Katelynn.  Jenn was tough...but I think Katie is stronger than Mandi so yes to that.   Tina and Coral would have hopefully taken the place of Simone and Nicole.  I'd prefer to say Britini or Amanda but I felt like Nicole was filler that season.  I WISH Coral would have walked through that door with CT though.  That Briana girl added nothing. I was happy Cory did that...cause I couldn't stand him or Devin but they would have made it farther but I doubt to the end.  I think Trishelle and Sarah would have made it to the end of Rivals 2...Trishelle proved when she tries she was a great competitor on Seasons 2, maybe Aneesa and Diem would have beat them but I think Sarah and Trishelle would have made it to the final and we might have seen more Trishelle if would have gotten the medical attention she needed and didn't quit.  As much as Frank bothered me back in the day I think he would have done decent on Free Agents.  He would have been in the top 6 or 7 for sure then it was just a **** shoot at that point with the dudes. 

 

 

What if Tyara Hooks was on Vendettas? Would she have been a regular

What if Tyranny was on Vendettas Over Kam? Would we have ever seen Kam?

What if Marie never returned to the challenge? Would we still have the trilogy? 

What if Jonna & Jasmine made the final of Rivals 1? What place would they have gotten 

What if CT didn’t win Rivals 2? 

What if Briana beat Britni on Dirty 30? Would she have been back for Vendettas?

What if Camila was disqualified on Dirty 30 after the altercation with Leroy? Who would’ve been the champ of Dirty 30?

  • No way Kam comes on after Vendettas, I wouldn't be surprised if we never saw someone come straight from ayto without doing eotb again
  • What does Marie even have to do with the trilogy happening? 
  • Jonna & Jasmine get last, maybe they beat Jenn if they were in the final still
  • Cara probably wins XXX, unless whoever made it instead of Camila(Jenna. Kailah) showed out in the final

What if Sylvia and Joss win Final Reckoning? Are they both cast on War of the Worlds, and if so - who do they replace? I can see them not casting Leroy if Joss were there, and if Ashley didn't win, either she or Amanda would get the cut in favour of Sylvia. Probably Ash.

What if Sylvia and Joss win Final Reckoning? Are they both cast on War of the Worlds, and if so - who do they replace? I can see them not casting Leroy if Joss were there, and if Ashley didn't win, either she or Amanda would get the cut in favour of Sylvia. Probably Ash.

Joss was an alternate for WOTW so he was very close to being on. If they won, i feel like hunter and Joss would have switched spots. Hunter’s initial storyline was the stuff with Ashley being a millionaire so from a production standpoint, he wouldn’t have been a priority. Would have been a lot more interesting to have Joss there since he’s a UK boy but now a vet. Sylvia would def retire if she won, she doesn’t wanna make a career of the show. Leroy would still be cast as they wanted John to have too many friends which lol cause both of them left early 

El Lobito wrote:
What if Sylvia and Joss win Final Reckoning? Are they both cast on War of the Worlds, and if so - who do they replace? I can see them not casting Leroy if Joss were there, and if Ashley didn't win, either she or Amanda would get the cut in favour of Sylvia. Probably Ash.

Joss was an alternate for WOTW so he was very close to being on. If they won, i feel like hunter and Joss would have switched spots. Hunter’s initial storyline was the stuff with Ashley being a millionaire so from a production standpoint, he wouldn’t have been a priority. Would have been a lot more interesting to have Joss there since he’s a UK boy but now a vet. Sylvia would def retire if she won, she doesn’t wanna make a career of the show. Leroy would still be cast as they wanted John to have too many friends which lol cause both of them left early 

poor Hunter never being prioritized Sad good shout about Sylvia tho, she definitely would have retired if she got $500k

imallergic wrote:
El Lobito wrote:What if Sylvia and Joss win Final Reckoning? Are they both cast on War of the Worlds, and if so - who do they replace? I can see them not casting Leroy if Joss were there, and if Ashley didn't win, either she or Amanda would get the cut in favour of Sylvia. Probably Ash.
Joss was an alternate for WOTW so he was very close to being on. If they won, i feel like hunter and Joss would have switched spots. Hunter’s initial storyline was the stuff with Ashley being a millionaire so from a production standpoint, he wouldn’t have been a priority. Would have been a lot more interesting to have Joss there since he’s a UK boy but now a vet. Sylvia would def retire if she won, she doesn’t wanna make a career of the show. Leroy would still be cast as they wanted John to have too many friends which lol cause both of them left early 

poor Hunter never being prioritized Sad good shout about Sylvia tho, she definitely would have retired if she got $500k

Sylvia is probably done as it is. Most would probably agree that Joss and Sylvia actually won but producers needed their steal moment. Between getting cheated out of $500K and what happened to Amanda (she's spoken out on it), and the fact that she's disliked by casuals but less polarizing than Amanda and Ashley, she's probably done.

If Diem beats Tonya during the first elimination on The Ruins how does that change the show?   Would JEK have still been the face for the past decade?  Would Tonya have returned?

If Diem beats Tonya during the first elimination on The Ruins how does that change the show?   Would JEK have still been the face for the past decade?  Would Tonya have returned?

If Diem actually cared, I feel like that would have changed a lot of things bc that’s another girl the Challengers would have had who would have been good. That leads me into thinking would Brad have made the Casey deal and had gotten into that fight with Darrell? Which leads to a potential KA, Sarah, Diem, and Brad team which could have had a solid chance at winning. 

If anything Johnny wouldn’t be the face bc Evan and Kenny would have been front and centered. He probably wouldn’t have as many wins either. 

If Diem beats Tonya during the first elimination on The Ruins how does that change the show?   Would JEK have still been the face for the past decade?  Would Tonya have returned?

I think JEK would have lasted longer but I think Evan would have been gone by now. Kenny might still be a regular.  Tonya could have (hopefully) got cleaned up and honestly I think she would have showed up for Dirty 30.

 

What if Cara Maria and Marie would have pulled off an upset and won Final Reckoning?  Would they have split the money? (not gonna lie, they were the team I was rooting for lol #teammarie)

Wait what's the tea on Diem not caring on the Ruins? Did she throw it or just not want to be there?

What if Wes doesn’t come back after winning The Duel? What happens to the show and what’s his legacy if he stops after two seasons in which he made both finals

Wait what's the tea on Diem not caring on the Ruins? Did she throw it or just not want to be there?

 

she threw it cause she had work obigations. She went for the paycheck and then threw the elimination round

what if Alan didn't hurt himself this season? he finished 4th, after Ash, Bear, and Theo - and above Turbo.

Ash takes Kam, Bear takes Day, Theo takes Cara - and then who does Alan take?

he's a huge fan, so I assume he would take Ashley (since she's a champion), maybe Jenna (she makes a good sidekick), or Nany (since she performed well in the opening challenge).

What if Cara Maria and Marie would have pulled off an upset and won Final Reckoning?  Would they have split the money? (not gonna lie, they were the team I was rooting for lol #teammarie)

Hasn't Cara said she wouldn't split the money before?

Psy4potato wrote:
What if Cara Maria and Marie would have pulled off an upset and won Final Reckoning?  Would they have split the money? (not gonna lie, they were the team I was rooting for lol #teammarie)

Hasn't Cara said she wouldn't split the money before?

Think she said she would’ve done the same thing John did on Rivals 3

Pages