The Challenge: What Ifs

2757 posts / 0 new
Last post

Debut Album wrote:

AshtonMartin wrote:What if Dustin didn't throw a fit when he didn't get cast. Would he have become a regular after his probation is up?

I think he would've. He had about 4 shows under his belt at that point so I can definetly see him being cast again.

He's on probation!?   Sad day 

He WAS on probation. They just don't **** with him now.

Had Theresa won against Tina and Emily still went into the next elimination and beats Paula, how do you think Blue team would have done with 3 girls instead of 2?Probably still would have got 3rd, but the section with the tires would have been faster for them

What if they got a redo 2018. Theresa , Jenn , and Emily S in a final >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

DUSTin can stay gone. He really went and made me a fan on BOTS only to keep flopping **********.

"You wanna get street *****?" will never be topped, so no point in bringing him back Smile

HonestTea101 wrote:

Had Theresa won against Tina and Emily still went into the next elimination and beats Paula, how do you think Blue team would have done with 3 girls instead of 2?Probably still would have got 3rd, but the section with the tires would have been faster for them

What if they got a redo 2018. Theresa , Jenn , and Emily S in a final >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

All three of them are at their prime rn so no one could beat them if they were a team. Unless they went up against a team of Laurel & Ev 

What if Nia and Averey were the rivals 2 instead of Messica and Annatrasha . The boot order could have been different on the female's side.

MalikOnFleek wrote:

HonestTea101 wrote:Had Theresa won against Tina and Emily still went into the next elimination and beats Paula, how do you think Blue team would have done with 3 girls instead of 2?Probably still would have got 3rd, but the section with the tires would have been faster for them

What if they got a redo 2018. Theresa , Jenn , and Emily S in a final >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

All three of them are at their prime rn so no one could beat them if they were a team. Unless they went up against a team of Laurel & Ev 

Plus, with three of them in the Riot Act mission, they could have won that heat and had Derrick go in the final and win meaning they could have had Derrick for the final too.  It could have very well flipped the game.

Vegas II is waaayyyyyyyy past their prime nowadays. New Orleans II tho>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.

Vegas II is waaayyyyyyyy past their prime nowadays. New Orleans II tho>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.

Their guys available would not be able to hold their own...no way.

Vegas II is waaayyyyyyyy past their prime nowadays. New Orleans II tho>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.

Led by Jemmye? Lmaooo

Eh I'd rather a new influx of RW rookies.

Katrina, Tyara, Jennifer, Theo, even Peter

Dylan, Dione, CeeJai

the only person I want from NOLA2 is Ashlee MF Feldman.

Eric, Sahar, McKenzie, Preston, Ryan Leslie? hard pass

Knights dead, Prestons homeless,  Ryan's probably sleeping with his brother by now....  hard pass for me as well.  The first time around was perfect...they wouldn't come close to that so leave it alone.  I'd take Ashlee and McKenzie on a challenge though. 

What if Nia and Averey were the rivals 2 instead of Messica and Annatrasha . The boot order could have been different on the female's side.

I mean I like Ana and Jess but Nia and Averey had a legit reason to be rivals...that would have been a different season for sure and I would have loved to see it! 

What if Rachel was paired with Darrell instead of Aneesa for Battle of the Exes 1....

imo it would have been a different game and they would have easily made the top three. 

What if Rachel was paired with Darrell instead of Aneesa for Battle of the Exes 1....imo it would have been a different game and they would have easily made the top three. 

they probably would have won. I don’t see ANYONE beating a powerhouse of Rachel/Darrell. Even if they were thrown into a bunch of eliminations, all of the ones from that season were endurance and physical which plays to the strengths of both of them. Plus once those two are in a final, it’s over 

What if Ayiiia was brought on to be Sarah's partner, after Trishelle quit on Rivals 2? (She was an alt)

What if Derek Chavez was brought on to be Averey's partner, after Leroy was DQ'd on Rivals 3? (He accepted his call but wasn't used)

What if Ayiiia was brought on to be Sarah's partner, after Trishelle quit on Rivals 2? (She was an alt)What if Derek Chavez was brought on to be Averey's partner, after Leroy was DQ'd on Rivals 3? (He accepted his call but wasn't used)

I would have loved both of these outcomes.  

What if Frank and Dustin did not fight and fell in love. That would be beautiful.

El Lobito wrote:

What if Ayiiia was brought on to be Sarah's partner, after Trishelle quit on Rivals 2? (She was an alt)What if Derek Chavez was brought on to be Averey's partner, after Leroy was DQ'd on Rivals 3? (He accepted his call but wasn't used)

I would have loved both of these outcomes.  

El Lobito wrote:

What if Ayiiia was brought on to be Sarah's partner, after Trishelle quit on Rivals 2? (She was an alt)What if Derek Chavez was brought on to be Averey's partner, after Leroy was DQ'd on Rivals 3? (He accepted his call but wasn't used)

I would have loved both of these outcomes.  

What if Frank and Dustin did not fight and fell in love. That would be beautiful.

They probably had a ******** session after the season was over.

What if Rogan was brought back to replace Eddie on Vendettas, or one of the alternates was used (Corey Brooks from BB18 and Derrick K)?

I don't see Rogan or Corey winning "Who's Got Balls, but DerricK could have. And #Vendettas could have been anyone's game.

All 3 of them would be super hard to take out in elimination, though. They could handily beat Shane, Tony, and Devin. Good chance of taking out Johnny and Kyle too.

What a wasted ******* opportunity Eddie was. I'm so mad.

I more mad that slab of fine meat that is Rogan was gone after episode 1 and there hasn't been enough shirtless scenes of Joss....

What if Rogan was brought back to replace Eddie on Vendettas, or one of the alternates was used (Corey Brooks from BB18 and Derrick K)?I don't see Rogan or Corey winning "Who's Got Balls, but DerricK could have. And #Vendettas could have been anyone's game.All 3 of them would be super hard to take out in elimination, though. They could handily beat Shane, Tony, and Devin. Good chance of taking out Johnny and Kyle too.What a wasted ******* opportunity Eddie was. I'm so mad.

Derrick K should have been brought on when Eddie left.  No reason not to. 

What if Johnny was sent home instead of Abe on the Island....I like to think Queen Rachel would have lasted longer.  

Also what if Jenn/Paula/Robin/Ryan beat the A holes on the island...that would have been such a better ending to that season.  

 

El Lobito wrote:

What if Rogan was brought back to replace Eddie on Vendettas, or one of the alternates was used (Corey Brooks from BB18 and Derrick K)?I don't see Rogan or Corey winning "Who's Got Balls, but DerricK could have. And #Vendettas could have been anyone's game.All 3 of them would be super hard to take out in elimination, though. They could handily beat Shane, Tony, and Devin. Good chance of taking out Johnny and Kyle too.What a wasted ******* opportunity Eddie was. I'm so mad.

Derrick K should have been brought on when Eddie left.  No reason not to. 

Hell no. Derrick can forever stay his *** at home.

What if Wes sent in Jay & Jenna on Exes 2 instead of Thomas & Hailey?

Jenna wouldn’t have become a fan favorite, she wouldn’t have hooked up with Zach, and Hailey probably would have been a regular

I really dont think Hailey would become a regular. They would of been eliminated soon after and not only that, but Hailey is actually normal. I couldnt see her doing more than 3 shows.

I really dont think Hailey would become a regular. They would of been eliminated soon after and not only that, but Hailey is actually normal. I couldnt see her doing more than 3 shows.

Assuming they even ask her after Exes 2 which they wouldn't have.

El Lobito wrote:

What if Rogan was brought back to replace Eddie on Vendettas, or one of the alternates was used (Corey Brooks from BB18 and Derrick K)?I don't see Rogan or Corey winning "Who's Got Balls, but DerricK could have. And #Vendettas could have been anyone's game.All 3 of them would be super hard to take out in elimination, though. They could handily beat Shane, Tony, and Devin. Good chance of taking out Johnny and Kyle too.What a wasted ******* opportunity Eddie was. I'm so mad.

Derrick K should have been brought on when Eddie left.  No reason not to. 

I'm pretty sure Corey was the first alternate anyways.

Corey, Derrick K, whomever...they should have brought one of them on

Pages