The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

14534 posts / 0 new
Last post

Since we briefly discussed this in a different threadThe Duel--2004 (replacing Battle of the Sexes II)   6 Road Rulers & 6 Real Worlders for balanceMen:  Abram Boise, Darrell Taylor, Mark Long, Dan Setzler, Theo Von, Timmy Beggy, Derrick Kosinski, Mike Mizanin, Eric Nies, Jamie Murray, Brad Fiorenza, CT Tamburello, Norman Korpi & Alton Williams (RR Alt:  Adam Larson & Shane Landrum   RW Alt:   Steven Hill, Ace Amerson & David Burns)Women:  Rachel Robinson, Emily Bailey, Holly Shand, Ayanna Mackins, Christena Pyle, Jodi Weatherton, Ellen Cho, Coral Smith, Beth Stolarczyk, Mallory Snyder, Julie Stoffer, Irulan Wilson, Robin Hibbard & Ruthie Alcaide (RR Alt:  Veronica Portillo, Tina Barta & Kina Dea   RW Alt:  Rachel Braband (side note:  I think I'm the only one that wished we saw more of her lol), Aneesa Ferreira, & Elka Walker)The politics and one-on-one eliminations on the female side would have been epic.  I don't have any clue how the male side would have played out.  I'm guessing Alton at least makes the final but it would have been great to watch.  

QUEEN ELKA SHOULD NOT BE AN ALTERNATE. as well as Rachel B lol.. I loved her too

I got Rachel winning for sure on the girls side with Jodi in a close second.. Guys in tougher but I can easily see Darrell Alton and CT being top 3

kvm1977 wrote:

Since we briefly discussed this in a different threadThe Duel--2004 (replacing Battle of the Sexes II)   7 Road Rulers & 7 Real Worlders for balanceMen:  Abram Boise, Darrell Taylor, Mark Long, Dan Setzler, Theo Von, Timmy Beggy, Derrick Kosinski, Mike Mizanin, Eric Nies, Jamie Murray, Brad Fiorenza, CT Tamburello, Norman Korpi & Alton Williams (RR Alt:  Adam Larson & Shane Landrum   RW Alt:   Steven Hill, Ace Amerson & David Burns)Women:  Rachel Robinson, Emily Bailey, Holly Shand, Ayanna Mackins, Christena Pyle, Jodi Weatherton, Ellen Cho, Coral Smith, Beth Stolarczyk, Mallory Snyder, Julie Stoffer, Irulan Wilson, Robin Hibbard & Ruthie Alcaide (RR Alt:  Veronica Portillo, Tina Barta & Kina Dea   RW Alt:  Rachel Braband (side note:  I think I'm the only one that wished we saw more of her lol), Aneesa Ferreira, & Elka Walker)The politics and one-on-one eliminations on the female side would have been epic.  I don't have any clue how the male side would have played out.  I'm guessing Alton at least makes the final but it would have been great to watch.  

QUEEN ELKA SHOULD NOT BE AN ALTERNATE. as well as Rachel B lol.. I loved her too

I also want Elka and Rachel B on the cast--likely over Robin & Irulan but I thought I'd be alone in that

I got Rachel winning for sure on the girls side with Jodi in a close second.. Guys in tougher but I can easily see Darrell Alton and CT being top 3

My money would be on Holly S for the girls but I really think a lot of them could win.  I have the same 3 guys although Mark, Jamie and Theo could surprise.

that cast is LIT, and it would finally tell us how Theo Von and Dan S stack up against people like CT, Alton, DerricK, Abram, and Brad.

The Challenge: Brains vs Brawn vs Beauty

——————

Brains

Amanda Garcia [AYTO?: Season 3]

Aneesa Ferreira [RW: Chicago]

Da’Vonne Rogers [Big Brother 17]

Marie Roda [RW: St. Thomas]

Michele Fitzgerald [Survivor: Season 32]

Natalie Duran [American Ninja Warrior]

Keith Klebacher [AYTO?: Season 6]

Paulie Calafiore [Big Brother 18]

Shane Landrum [RR: Campus Crawl]

Stephen Bear [Ex On The Beach UK]

Turbo Camkiran [Survivor Turkey]

Wes Bergmann [RW: Austin]

——————

Brawn

Faith Stowers [Vanderpump Rules]

Georgia Harrison [Love Island UK]

Janelle Shanks [BGC: Miami]

Mattie Lynn Breaux [Party Down South]

Nicole Zanatta [RW: Skeletons]

Sylvia Elsrode [RW: Skeletons]

Alton Williams [RW: Las Vegas ‘02]

Ashley Cain [Ex On The Beach UK]

Frank Sweeney [RW: San Diego ‘11]

Rodney Lavoie Jr [Survivor: Season 30]

Tony Raines [RW: Skeletons]

Zach Nichols [RW: San Diego ‘11]

——————

Beauty 

Angela Babicz [BGC: Twisted Sisters]

Kailah Casillas [RW: Go Big or Go Home]

Kam Williams [AYTO?: Season 5]

Kenya Scott [AYTO?: Season 7]

Melissa Reeves [Ex On The Beach UK]

Nany Gonzalez [RW: Las Vegas ‘11]

Cory Wharton [RW: Ex-Plosion]

Dario Medrano [AYTO?: Season 2]

Joss Mooney [Ex On The Beach UK]

Nelson Thomas [AYTO?: Season 3]

Scott Timlin [Geordie Shore]

Theo Campbell [Love Island UK]

That's one dumb *** brain team

The Challenge: Brains vs Brawn vs Beauty——————BrainsAmanda Garcia [AYTO?: Season 3]Aneesa Ferreira [RW: Chicago]Da’Vonne Rogers [Big Brother 17]Marie Roda [RW: St. Thomas]Michele Fitzgerald [Survivor: Season 32]Natalie Duran [American Ninja Warrior]Keith Klebacher [AYTO?: Season 6]Paulie Calafiore [Big Brother 18]Shane Landrum [RR: Campus Crawl]Stephen Bear [Ex On The Beach UK]Turbo Camkiran [Survivor Turkey]Wes Bergmann [RW: Austin]——————BrawnFaith Stowers [Vanderpump Rules]Georgia Harrison [Love Island UK]Janelle Shanks [BGC: Miami]Mattie Lynn Breaux [Party Down South]Nicole Zanatta [RW: Skeletons]Sylvia Elsrode [RW: Skeletons]Alton Williams [RW: Las Vegas ‘02]Ashley Cain [Ex On The Beach UK]Frank Sweeney [RW: San Diego ‘11]Rodney Lavoie Jr [Survivor: Season 30]Tony Raines [RW: Skeletons]Zach Nichols [RW: San Diego ‘11]——————Beauty Angela Babicz [BGC: Twisted Sisters]Kailah Casillas [RW: Go Big or Go Home]Kam Williams [AYTO?: Season 5]Kenya Scott [AYTO?: Season 7]Melissa Reeves [Ex On The Beach UK]Nany Gonzalez [RW: Las Vegas ‘11]Cory Wharton [RW: Ex-Plosion]Dario Medrano [AYTO?: Season 2]Joss Mooney [Ex On The Beach UK]Nelson Thomas [AYTO?: Season 3]Scott Timlin [Geordie Shore]Theo Campbell [Love Island UK]

This is awful....other than brawn (which is questionable--Tony lmao)

I think the cast is great & realistic, save for a few.

I tried to make it realistic and balanced. Which is why I gave beauty people like Theo & Joss, and gave brawn Tony. 

I love it, cup

I love it, cup

Battle of the Seasons

 

Partners are paired based on what season the debuted on the challenge

 

Bear & Mattie (WotW)

Joss & Kam (Vendettas)

Bruno & Kailah (Invasion)

Devin & Amanda (Rivals 3)

Cory & Nicole (Bloodlines)

Johnny & Nia (Free Agents)

Marlon & Cooke (Rivals 2)

Frank & Nany (BOTS 2012)

Leroy & Jonna (Rivals)

Chet & Emily (Cutthroat)

Brandon & Laurel (Fresh Meat 2)

Cohutta & KellyAnne (The Island)

Alton & Tina (The Guantlet)

Landon & Jodi (The Inferno II)

Brad & Kina (Battle of the Sexes 2)

CT & Kendal (The Inferno)

Wes & Melinda (Fresh Meat)

Shane & Rachel (Battle of the Sexes)

 

Alternates:

Adam & Averey (Exes 2)

Chuck & Faith (Final Reckoning)

Ammo & Tori (Dirty 30)

love this idea !

Battle of the Seasons Partners are paired based on what season the debuted on the challenge Bear & Mattie (WotW)Joss & Kam (Vendettas)Bruno & Kailah (Invasion)Devin & Amanda (Rivals 3)Cory & Nicole (Bloodlines)Johnny & Nia (Free Agents)Marlon & Cooke (Rivals 2)Frank & Nany (BOTS 2012)Leroy & Jonna (Rivals)Chet & Emily (Cutthroat)Brandon & Laurel (Fresh Meat 2)Cohutta & KellyAnne (The Island)Alton & Tina (The Guantlet)Landon & Jodi (The Inferno II)Brad & Kina (Battle of the Sexes 2)CT & Kendal (The Inferno)Wes & Melinda (Fresh Meat)Shane & Rachel (Battle of the Sexes) Alternates:Adam & Averey (Exes 2)Chuck & Faith (Final Reckoning)Ammo & Tori (Dirty 30)

Love the concept. Chetwas on The Ruins though so that one doesn't work. 

AshtonMartin wrote:

Battle of the Seasons Partners are paired based on what season the debuted on the challenge Bear & Mattie (WotW)Joss & Kam (Vendettas)Bruno & Kailah (Invasion)Devin & Amanda (Rivals 3)Cory & Nicole (Bloodlines)Johnny & Nia (Free Agents)Marlon & Cooke (Rivals 2)Frank & Nany (BOTS 2012)Leroy & Jonna (Rivals)Chet & Emily (Cutthroat)Brandon & Laurel (Fresh Meat 2)Cohutta & KellyAnne (The Island)Alton & Tina (The Guantlet)Landon & Jodi (The Inferno II)Brad & Kina (Battle of the Sexes 2)CT & Kendal (The Inferno)Wes & Melinda (Fresh Meat)Shane & Rachel (Battle of the Sexes) Alternates:Adam & Averey (Exes 2)Chuck & Faith (Final Reckoning)Ammo & Tori (Dirty 30)

Love the concept. Chetwas on The Ruins though so that one doesn't work. 

Deadass forgot he was on that one lmao

kvm1977 wrote:

AshtonMartin wrote:Battle of the Seasons Partners are paired based on what season the debuted on the challenge Bear & Mattie (WotW)Joss & Kam (Vendettas)Bruno & Kailah (Invasion)Devin & Amanda (Rivals 3)Cory & Nicole (Bloodlines)Johnny & Nia (Free Agents)Marlon & Cooke (Rivals 2)Frank & Nany (BOTS 2012)Leroy & Jonna (Rivals)Chet & Emily (Cutthroat)Brandon & Laurel (Fresh Meat 2)Cohutta & KellyAnne (The Island)Alton & Tina (The Guantlet)Landon & Jodi (The Inferno II)Brad & Kina (Battle of the Sexes 2)CT & Kendal (The Inferno)Wes & Melinda (Fresh Meat)Shane & Rachel (Battle of the Sexes) Alternates:Adam & Averey (Exes 2)Chuck & Faith (Final Reckoning)Ammo & Tori (Dirty 30)

Love the concept. Chetwas on The Ruins though so that one doesn't work. 

Deadass forgot he was on that one lmao

Understandably it was a short stay and he did nothing memorable 

After reading the what could’ve happened thread, I have decided to recast every season of the challenge from Battle of the Seasons (2012) to now. Cast & Elimination Order for my BOTS 2012 will be posted next, also these may interfere with my invasion cast because some people may or may not be champions. 

The Challenge: Battle of the Seasons (2012) 

 

Team St. Thomas 

  • Laura Waller
  • Marie Roda
  • Robb Schreiber 
  • Trey Weatherholtz

Team San Diego 

  • Sam McGinn
  • Ashley Kelsey 
  • Frank Sweeney 
  • Zach Nichols

Team New Vegas 

  • Dustin Zito
  • Heather Cooke
  • Leroy Garrett
  • Nany Gonzalez 

Team New Orleans 

  • Ashlee Feldman 
  • Jemmye Carroll
  • Preston Charles
  • Ryan Knight 

Team Cancun 

  • CJ Koegel 
  • Derek Chavez 
  • Jasmine Reynaud
  • Jonna Mannion 

Team Sydney 

  • Ashli Robson 
  • Dunbar Merrill 
  • Isaac Stout 
  • Kellyanne Judd 

Team Old Vegas 

  • Alton Williams 
  • Arissa Hill
  • Frank Roessler 
  • Trishelle Cannatella 

Team Road Rules

  • Darrell Taylor
  • Derrick Kosinski
  • Katie Doyle
  • Rachel Robinson 

 

Elimination Order

  • Jemmye & Knight by Arissa & Alton
  • Ashlee & Preston by Jonna & CJ
  • Laura & Trey by Rachel & Darrell 
  • Jasmine & Derek by Cooke & Leroy
  • Ashli & Isaac by Ashley & Frank 
  • Marie & Robb by Kellyanne & Dunbar
  • Kellyanne & Dunbar by Jonna & CJ 
  • Katie & Derrick by Trishelle & Alton 
  • Sam & Zach by Nany & Leroy 
  • Arissa & Frank by Nany & Dustin 
  • Jonna & CJ by Ashley & Frank 
  • Ashley & Frank by Rachel & Darrell

 

Final

  1. Darrell & Rachel 
  2. Cooke, Dustin, Leroy, Nany 
  3. Alton & Trishelle 

The Challenge: Rivals II

 

Female Pairs 

  • Aneesa & Diem (TC: The Duel)
  • Averey & Nia (RW: Portland)
  • Ayiiia & Cara (TC: Cutthroat)
  • Camila & Jonna (TC: Rivals)
  • Cooke & Naomi (RW: Vegas ‘11)
  • Jasmine & Theresa (TC: Rivals)
  • LaToya & Laura (RW: St. Thomas)
  • Marie & Sam (TC: BOTS 2012)

Male Pairs

  • Alton & Zach (TC: BOTS 2012)
  • CT & Ty (TC: BOTE1)
  • Dustin & Frank (TC: BOTS 2012)
  • Derek & Robb (TC: BOTS 2012)
  • Johnny & Wes (TC: I Don’t Even Care)
  • Jordan & Marlon (RW: Portland)
  • Knight & Preston (RW: New Orleans)
  • Leroy & Tyler (TC: Rivals)

 

Jungles 

  • Knight & Preston by Derek & Robb 
  • Marie & Sam by Camila & Jonna 
  • Derek & Robb by Jordan & Marlon 
  • Aneesa & Diem by Ayiiia & Cara 
  • Dustin & Frank by Alton & Zach 
  • LaToya & Laura by Cooke & Naomi 
  • Leroy & Tyler by Jordan & Marlon 
  • Jasmine & Theresa by Averey & Nia
  • Johnny & Wes by CT & Ty 
  • Cooke & Naomi by Averey & Nia 

 

Final

  • Camila & Jonna and CT & Ty 
  • Averey & Nia and Alton & Zach 
  • Ayiiia & Cara and Jordan & Marlon

The Challenge: Cutthroat II

 

Each Team is made up of 5 Challengers and 1 Champion as a captain

 

Red Team

Ashley C (Ex on the Beach UK)

Brad (Real World San Diego)

Dylan (Real World Go Big)

Aneesa (Real World Chicago)

Kailah (Real World Go Big)

Faith (Ex on the Beach USA)

 

Blue

Frank (Real World San Diego 2)

Marlon (Real World Portland)

Nelson (Are You The One 3)

Jonitta (Lindsay Lohan Beach Club)

Nany (Real World Las Vegas)

Shanley (Are You The One 1)

 

Yellow Team

Bear (Ex on the Beach UK)

Brent (Lindsay Lohan Beach Club)

Cheyenne (Ex on the Beach USA)

Ashley (Real World Explosion)

Laurel (Fresh Meat 2)

Melissa (Ex on the Beach UK)

 

Orange Team

Kwasi (Are You The One 7)

Mike (Lindsay Lohan Beach Club)

Zak (Are You The One 7)

Diandra (Are You The One 6)

Emily (Real World D.C.)

Maya (Ex on the Beach USA)

 

 

Purple Team

Devin (Are You The One 3)

Leroy (Real World Las Vegas)

Paulie (Big Brother)

Bria (Are You The One 7)

Coral (Real World New York)

Marie (Real World Saint Thomas)

 

Green Team

Jordan (Real World Portland)

Theo (Love Island)

Tony (Real World Skeletons)

Amanda (Are You The One 3)

Angela (Ex on the Beach USA)

Maria (Are You The One 7)

 

 

Cheyenne & Melissa by Mike & Maya

Zak & Diandra by Paulie & Bria

Devin & Coral by Brent & Ashley

Kwasi & Maya by Paulie & Marie

Theo & Maria by Mike & Emily 

Dylan & Faith by Nelson & Shanley 

Mike & Emily by Marlon & Jonitta

Nelson & Shanley by Bear & Laurel

Leroy & Bria by Ashley & Aneesa

Brent & Ashley by Paulie & Marie

Marlon & Jonitta by Brad & Kailah

Tony & Angela by Ashley & Aneesa

Bear & Laurel by Paulie & Marie

 

Final:

1st Place: Red Team (Ashley C, Brad, Aneesa, & Kailah)

2nd Place: Blue Team (Frank & Nany)

3rd Place: Green Team (Jordan & Amanda)

4th Place: Purple Team (Paulie & Marie)

ok but both Smash and Laurel are champs?

 Cheyenne & Melissa by Mike & MayaZak & Diandra by Paulie & BriaDevin & Coral by Brent & AshleyKwasi & Maya by Paulie & MarieTheo & Maria by Mike & Emily Dylan & Faith by Nelson & Shanley Mike & Emily by Marlon & JonittaNelson & Shanley by Bear & LaurelLeroy & Bria by Ashley & AneesaBrent & Ashley by Paulie & MarieMarlon & Jonitta by Brad & KailahTony & Angela by Ashley & AneesaBear & Laurel by Paulie & Marie Final:1st Place: Red Team (Ashley C, Brad, Aneesa, & Kailah)2nd Place: Blue Team (Frank & Nany)3rd Place: Green Team (Jordan & Amanda)4th Place: Purple Team (Paulie & Marie)

Marlon & Jonitta would *** Brad & Kailah up. 

ok but both Smash and Laurel are champs?

So is Frank and Nelson.

The Challenge: Free Agents 

 

Females

  • Aneesa Ferreira (Chicago)
  • Ashley Kelsey (San Diego ‘11)
  • Averey Tressler (Portland)
  • Cara Maria (Fresh Meat 2)
  • Devyn Simone (Brooklyn)
  • Heather Cooke (Las Vegas ‘11)
  • Joi Niemeyer (Portland)
  • Jonna Mannion (Cancun)
  • KellyAnne Judd (Sydney)
  • LaToya Jackson (St. Thomas)
  • Laurel Stucky (Fresh Meat 2)
  • Marie Roda (St. Thomas)
  • Nany Gonzalez (Las Vegas ‘11)
  • Nia Moore (Portland)
  • Camila Nakagawa (ALTERNATE)
  • Jessica McCain (ALTERNATE)

 

Males 

  • Brandon Nelson (Fresh Meat 2)
  • Brandon Swift (St. Thomas)
  • Dustin Zito (Las Vegas ‘11)
  • Eric Banks (Fresh Meat 1)
  • Frank Sweeney (San Diego ‘11)
  • Johnny Devenanzio (Key West)
  • Johnny Reilly (Portland)
  • Jordan Wiseley (Portland)
  • Leroy Garrett (Las Vegas ‘11)
  • Marlon Williams (Portland)
  • Noor Jehangir (Fresh Meat 2)
  • Trey Weatherholtz (St. Thomas)
  • Ty Ruff (DC)
  • Zach Nichols (San Diego ‘11)
  • CT Tamburello (ALTERNATE)
  • Cohutta Grindstaff (ALTERNATE)

 

Elims 

  • Devyn/Eric by Averey/Leroy
  • Kellyanne/Trey by Cara/Noor
  • Ashley/Johnny R. by Joi/Frank 
  • Nany/Dustin by Nia/Noor
  • LaToya/Johnny D. by Laurel/Swift
  • Jonna/Swift by Averey/Zach
  • Aneesa/Ty by Cooke/Leroy
  • Marie/Jordan by Nia/Marlon
  • Averey/Brandon by Joi/Frank
  • Cara/Frank by Laurel/Marlon
  • Laurel/Leroy by Cooke/Noor

 

Final

  • Heather Cooke & Noor Jehangir 
  • Nia Moore & Marlon Williams
  • Joi Niemeyer & Zach Nichols

El Lobito wrote:

ok but both Smash and Laurel are champs?

So is Frank and Nelson.

lol I'm just talking about legit, canon championships Blum 3

lol how is SWIFT taking out Johnny Bananas ?!

and are you saying Cooke and Noor win?

lol how is SWIFT taking out Johnny Bananas ?!and are you saying Cooke and Noor win?

Swift and Bananas is actually pretty even

Regulars vs Returners

 

Regulars (Appeared XXX- WOTW)

 

Darrell

CT

Nelson

Brad

Cory

Tony

Leroy

Ashley C

Bear

Kam

Cara Maria

Veronica

Nany

Ashley

Amanda

Kailah

Mattie

Georgia

 

Returners (Haven’t appeared since Invasion)

Theo

Cohutta 

Abram

Dustin

Frank

Marlon

Alton

Mark

Landon

Laurel

KellyAnne

Sarah

Nia

Theresa

Cooke

Emily 

Jenn 

Coral

Pages