The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

14389 posts / 0 new
Last post

Not a cast but an idea to change the way partner challenges work, if you win the mission you can choose safety or shake up. Shake up meaning you can choose any two teams to switch partners, like switching Kyle & Mattie with Josh & Amanda, Kyle & Amanda and Josh & Mattie are the new teams. But to do this, you give up your safety for the week and could be sent in, do you choose the long term choice of switching partners or do you go for the safety?

The Challenge: Amazons

Champ paired with a Finalist

 

  • Ashley Kelsey & Devin Walker
  • Ashley Mitchell & Kyle Christie
  • Cara Maria & Paulie Calafiore
  • Kendall Sheppard & Hunter Barfield
  • Laurel Stucky & Cory Wharton
  • Sylvia Elsrode & Marlon Williams
  • Tori Hall & Mitch Reid
  • Veronica Portillo & Vince Gliatta
  • Alton Williams & Kam Williams
  • Brad Fiorenza & Kailah Casillas
  • Frank Sweeney & Cheyenne Floyd
  • Jordan Wiseley & Nany Gonzalez
  • Joss Mooney & Marie Roda
  • Nelson Thomas & Heather Cooke
  • Wes Bergmann & Nicole Zanatta
  • Zach Nichols & Tori Deal

Not a cast but an idea to change the way partner challenges work, if you win the mission you can choose safety or shake up. Shake up meaning you can choose any two teams to switch partners, like switching Kyle & Mattie with Josh & Amanda, Kyle & Amanda and Josh & Mattie are the new teams. But to do this, you give up your safety for the week and could be sent in, do you choose the long term choice of switching partners or do you go for the safety?

I love this.

The Challenge: AmazonsChamp paired with a Finalist 
  • Ashley Kelsey & Devin Walker
  • Ashley Mitchell & Kyle Christie
  • Cara Maria & Paulie Calafiore
  • Kendall Sheppard & Hunter Barfield
  • Laurel Stucky & Cory Wharton
  • Sylvia Elsrode & Marlon Williams
  • Tori Hall & Mitch Reid
  • Veronica Portillo & Vince Gliatta
  • Alton Williams & Kam Williams
  • Brad Fiorenza & Kailah Casillas
  • Frank Sweeney & Cheyenne Floyd
  • Jordan Wiseley & Nany Gonzalez
  • Joss Mooney & Marie Roda
  • Nelson Thomas & Heather Cooke
  • Wes Bergmann & Nicole Zanatta
  • Zach Nichols & Tori Deal

Amazons Eliminations 

  1. Cara & Paulie by Laurel & Cory
  2. Tori H & Mitch by Jordan & Nany
  3. Veronica & Vince by Nelson & Cooke
  4. Jordan & Nany by Zach & Tori D
  5. Ashley K & Devin by Frank & Chey
  6. Ashley M & Kyle by Sylvia & Marlon
  7. Frank & Chey by Zach & Tori D
  8. Hunter & Marie placed last in a challenge, after that challenge a “Partner Shakeup” was made

Teams After Partner Shakeup 

  • Zach & Kailh
  • Nelson & Cooke
  • Wes & Nicole
  • Brad & Tori D
  • Cory & Kam
  • Laurel & Marlon
  • Joss & Kendal
  • Alton & Sylvia

Amazon Eliminations Cont.

  1. Joss & Kendal by Zach & Kailah
  2. Wes & Nicole by Laurel & Marlon
  3. Zach & Kailah by Alton & Sylvia
  4. Brad & Tori D by Kam & Cory

Final Results

4th: Laurel & Marlon

3rd: Kam & Cory

2nd: Sylvia & Alton 

1st: Cooke & Nelson

Truuue about V and Tina but I think if they do an old school Coral is a MUST regardless lol idk which girls from that era would be able to hang maybe Tori or Jenn

They def need Coral on the team along with Tina and V but they have to cut her befire the final

The Challenge: AmazonsChamp paired with a Finalist 
  • Ashley Kelsey & Devin Walker
  • Ashley Mitchell & Kyle Christie
  • Cara Maria & Paulie Calafiore
  • Kendall Sheppard & Hunter Barfield
  • Laurel Stucky & Cory Wharton
  • Sylvia Elsrode & Marlon Williams
  • Tori Hall & Mitch Reid
  • Veronica Portillo & Vince Gliatta
  • Alton Williams & Kam Williams
  • Brad Fiorenza & Kailah Casillas
  • Frank Sweeney & Cheyenne Floyd
  • Jordan Wiseley & Nany Gonzalez
  • Joss Mooney & Marie Roda
  • Nelson Thomas & Heather Cooke
  • Wes Bergmann & Nicole Zanatta
  • Zach Nichols & Tori Deal

Hunter's a champ not a finalist

The Challenge: Era Clash 36 challengers from across 3 different challenge Eras compete for title of best generation. Winning team is safe while the two losing teams must nominate one guy and one girl to represent their generation in elimination.-Old school (Orange Team): Conception-The Ruins. -Mid School (Green Team): FM2-Exes2. -New School (Yellow Team): Bloodlines-PresentOrange Team:Girls: Evelyn, Tina, Veronica, Coral, Rachel, KellyAnneGuys: Wes, Darrell, CT, Alton, Evan, LandonGreen Team:Girls: Laurel, Nany, Theresa, Emily, Cooke, NiaGuys: Noor, Brandon, Leroy, Frank, Jordan, ZachYellow Team:Girls: Kam, Kailah, Mattie, Nicole Z., Tori D., DayGuys: Turbo, Paulie, Nelson, Hunter, Bear, Tony I feel like an old school v new school season is  coming up and this is a spin on that, cutthroat style. And it’d easily be one of the most competitive seasons we’ve saw. Who y’all got?? I think Green team takes it.      

This is the format I want but I know we won't get it.

sourcup wrote:
The Challenge: AmazonsChamp paired with a Finalist 
  • Ashley Kelsey & Devin Walker
  • Ashley Mitchell & Kyle Christie
  • Cara Maria & Paulie Calafiore
  • Kendall Sheppard & Hunter Barfield
  • Laurel Stucky & Cory Wharton
  • Sylvia Elsrode & Marlon Williams
  • Tori Hall & Mitch Reid
  • Veronica Portillo & Vince Gliatta
  • Alton Williams & Kam Williams
  • Brad Fiorenza & Kailah Casillas
  • Frank Sweeney & Cheyenne Floyd
  • Jordan Wiseley & Nany Gonzalez
  • Joss Mooney & Marie Roda
  • Nelson Thomas & Heather Cooke
  • Wes Bergmann & Nicole Zanatta
  • Zach Nichols & Tori Deal

Hunter's a champ not a finalist

sourcup wrote:
The Challenge: AmazonsChamp paired with a Finalist 
  • Ashley Kelsey & Devin Walker
  • Ashley Mitchell & Kyle Christie
  • Cara Maria & Paulie Calafiore
  • Kendall Sheppard & Hunter Barfield
  • Laurel Stucky & Cory Wharton
  • Sylvia Elsrode & Marlon Williams
  • Tori Hall & Mitch Reid
  • Veronica Portillo & Vince Gliatta
  • Alton Williams & Kam Williams
  • Brad Fiorenza & Kailah Casillas
  • Frank Sweeney & Cheyenne Floyd
  • Jordan Wiseley & Nany Gonzalez
  • Joss Mooney & Marie Roda
  • Nelson Thomas & Heather Cooke
  • Wes Bergmann & Nicole Zanatta
  • Zach Nichols & Tori Deal

Hunter's a champ not a finalist

Joss is a champ. Hunter is a finalist. 

Ohhh got you yeah that’s a fact. If they did then all eras might stand a decent chance in a final it’d be pretty competitive  

chefsaucy wrote:
Truuue about V and Tina but I think if they do an old school Coral is a MUST regardless lol idk which girls from that era would be able to hang maybe Tori or Jenn

They def need Coral on the team along with Tina and V but they have to cut her befire the final

Bmp and mtv need to take note lol this would be fire

chefsaucy wrote:
The Challenge: Era Clash 36 challengers from across 3 different challenge Eras compete for title of best generation. Winning team is safe while the two losing teams must nominate one guy and one girl to represent their generation in elimination.-Old school (Orange Team): Conception-The Ruins. -Mid School (Green Team): FM2-Exes2. -New School (Yellow Team): Bloodlines-PresentOrange Team:Girls: Evelyn, Tina, Veronica, Coral, Rachel, KellyAnneGuys: Wes, Darrell, CT, Alton, Evan, LandonGreen Team:Girls: Laurel, Nany, Theresa, Emily, Cooke, NiaGuys: Noor, Brandon, Leroy, Frank, Jordan, ZachYellow Team:Girls: Kam, Kailah, Mattie, Nicole Z., Tori D., DayGuys: Turbo, Paulie, Nelson, Hunter, Bear, Tony I feel like an old school v new school season is  coming up and this is a spin on that, cutthroat style. And it’d easily be one of the most competitive seasons we’ve saw. Who y’all got?? I think Green team takes it.      

This is the format I want but I know we won't get it.

kvm1977 wrote:
sourcup wrote:The Challenge: AmazonsChamp paired with a Finalist 
  • Ashley Kelsey & Devin Walker
  • Ashley Mitchell & Kyle Christie
  • Cara Maria & Paulie Calafiore
  • Kendall Sheppard & Hunter Barfield
  • Laurel Stucky & Cory Wharton
  • Sylvia Elsrode & Marlon Williams
  • Tori Hall & Mitch Reid
  • Veronica Portillo & Vince Gliatta
  • Alton Williams & Kam Williams
  • Brad Fiorenza & Kailah Casillas
  • Frank Sweeney & Cheyenne Floyd
  • Jordan Wiseley & Nany Gonzalez
  • Joss Mooney & Marie Roda
  • Nelson Thomas & Heather Cooke
  • Wes Bergmann & Nicole Zanatta
  • Zach Nichols & Tori Deal
Hunter's a champ not a finalist

Joss is a champ. Hunter is a finalist. 

looooooool

Challenge 17 wrote:
Not a cast but an idea to change the way partner challenges work, if you win the mission you can choose safety or shake up. Shake up meaning you can choose any two teams to switch partners, like switching Kyle & Mattie with Josh & Amanda, Kyle & Amanda and Josh & Mattie are the new teams. But to do this, you give up your safety for the week and could be sent in, do you choose the long term choice of switching partners or do you go for the safety?

I love this.

Tbh I don't know how many people would willingly give up safety tho lol. It would be interesting to see

The Challenge: Cutthroat 2

 

Red:

Amanda

Kam

Sarah

Ashley M

Jenna

Joss

Nelson

CT

Kyle

Jordan

 

Grey:

Marie

Nany

Davonne

Theresa

Kailah

Brad

Tony

Leroy

Wes

Zach

 

Blue:

Natalie

Nia

Averey

Sylvia

Camila

Devin

Bananas

Paulie

Cory

Hunter

 

 

Episode 1: To Wish Impossible Things

Winners: Grey

Voted in Red: Sarah and Jordan

Voted in Blue: Averey and Bananas

Eliminated: Averey and Jordan

 

Episode 2: What Comes After The Blues

Winners: Red

Voted in Grey: Davonne and Brad

Voted in Blue: Natalie and Bananas

Eliminated: Natalie and Bananas

 

Episode 3: The Lonesome Road

Winners: Blue

Voted in Red: Sarah and CT

Voted in Grey: Davonne and Wes

Eliminated: Davonne and CT

 

Episode 4: Don't You Want To Share The Guilt

Winners: Blue

Voted in Red: Amanda and Nelson

Voted in Grey: Marie and Brad

Eliminated: Amanda and Nelson

 

Episode 5: Crash Into You

Winners: Red

Voted in Grey: Marie and Tony

Voted in Blue: Nia and Paulie

Eliminated: Marie and Paulie

 

Episode 6: Resolve

Winners: Grey

Voted in Red: Sarah and Kyle

Voted in Blue: Nia and Devin

Eliminated: Nia and Devin

 

Episode 7: The Heart Brings You Back

Winners: Red

Voted In Grey: Theresa and Brad

Voted in Blue: Sylvia and Cory

Eliminated: Sylvia and Cory

 

Episode 8: Every Night Is Another Story

Winners: Grey

Voted in Red: Jenna and Joss

Voted in Blue: Camila and Hunter

*Heavy Hitters enter (Cara Maria and Shane)*

Cara Maria beats both... Shane loses to both

Eliminated: Jenna and Hunter

 

Episode 9: In The Room Where You Sleep

Winners: Grey

Voted in Red: Sarah

Voted in Blue: Camila

Eliminated: Camila

 

Episode 10: Hold My Hand As I'm Lowered

Winners: Grey (Nany,Theresa,Kailah,Brad,Tony,Leroy,Wes,Zach)

2nd: Red (Kam,Sarah,Ashley M,Joss,Kyle)

 

Chicken_breast wrote:
Challenge 17 wrote:Not a cast but an idea to change the way partner challenges work, if you win the mission you can choose safety or shake up. Shake up meaning you can choose any two teams to switch partners, like switching Kyle & Mattie with Josh & Amanda, Kyle & Amanda and Josh & Mattie are the new teams. But to do this, you give up your safety for the week and could be sent in, do you choose the long term choice of switching partners or do you go for the safety?
I love this.

Tbh I don't know how many people would willingly give up safety tho lol. It would be interesting to see

Paulie and Cara because they hate Kyle so much but yeah very few would

Challenge 17 wrote:
Chicken_breast wrote:
Challenge 17 wrote:Not a cast but an idea to change the way partner challenges work, if you win the mission you can choose safety or shake up. Shake up meaning you can choose any two teams to switch partners, like switching Kyle & Mattie with Josh & Amanda, Kyle & Amanda and Josh & Mattie are the new teams. But to do this, you give up your safety for the week and could be sent in, do you choose the long term choice of switching partners or do you go for the safety?
I love this.
Tbh I don't know how many people would willingly give up safety tho lol. It would be interesting to see

Paulie and Cara because they hate Kyle so much but yeah very few would

I really like the idea tho, of how much are you willing to risk, imagine on rivals 3 if someone switched Bananas & Sarah with Thomas & Simone or Nate & Christina, it's risky but you can change the entire game.

Since we briefly discussed this in a different thread

The Duel--2004 (replacing Battle of the Sexes II)   7 Road Rulers & 7 Real Worlders for balance

Men:  Abram Boise, Darrell Taylor, Mark Long, Dan Setzler, Theo Von, Timmy Beggy, Derrick Kosinski, Mike Mizanin, Eric Nies, Jamie Murray, Brad Fiorenza, CT Tamburello, Norman Korpi & Alton Williams (RR Alt:  Adam Larson & Shane Landrum   RW Alt:   Steven Hill, Ace Amerson & David Burns)

Women:  Rachel Robinson, Emily Bailey, Holly Shand, Ayanna Mackins, Christena Pyle, Jodi Weatherton, Ellen Cho, Coral Smith, Beth Stolarczyk, Mallory Snyder, Julie Stoffer, Irulan Wilson, Robin Hibbard & Ruthie Alcaide (RR Alt:  Veronica Portillo, Tina Barta & Kina Dea   RW Alt:  Rachel Braband (side note:  I think I'm the only one that wished we saw more of her lol), Aneesa Ferreira, & Elka Walker)

The politics and one-on-one eliminations on the female side would have been epic.  I don't have any clue how the male side would have played out.  I'm guessing Alton at least makes the final but it would have been great to watch.  

Since we briefly discussed this in a different threadThe Duel--2004 (replacing Battle of the Sexes II)   6 Road Rulers & 6 Real Worlders for balanceMen:  Abram Boise, Darrell Taylor, Mark Long, Dan Setzler, Theo Von, Timmy Beggy, Derrick Kosinski, Mike Mizanin, Eric Nies, Jamie Murray, Brad Fiorenza, CT Tamburello, Norman Korpi & Alton Williams (RR Alt:  Adam Larson & Shane Landrum   RW Alt:   Steven Hill, Ace Amerson & David Burns)Women:  Rachel Robinson, Emily Bailey, Holly Shand, Ayanna Mackins, Christena Pyle, Jodi Weatherton, Ellen Cho, Coral Smith, Beth Stolarczyk, Mallory Snyder, Julie Stoffer, Irulan Wilson, Robin Hibbard & Ruthie Alcaide (RR Alt:  Veronica Portillo, Tina Barta & Kina Dea   RW Alt:  Rachel Braband (side note:  I think I'm the only one that wished we saw more of her lol), Aneesa Ferreira, & Elka Walker)The politics and one-on-one eliminations on the female side would have been epic.  I don't have any clue how the male side would have played out.  I'm guessing Alton at least makes the final but it would have been great to watch.  

QUEEN ELKA SHOULD NOT BE AN ALTERNATE. as well as Rachel B lol.. I loved her too

I got Rachel winning for sure on the girls side with Jodi in a close second.. Guys in tougher but I can easily see Darrell Alton and CT being top 3

kvm1977 wrote:
Since we briefly discussed this in a different threadThe Duel--2004 (replacing Battle of the Sexes II)   7 Road Rulers & 7 Real Worlders for balanceMen:  Abram Boise, Darrell Taylor, Mark Long, Dan Setzler, Theo Von, Timmy Beggy, Derrick Kosinski, Mike Mizanin, Eric Nies, Jamie Murray, Brad Fiorenza, CT Tamburello, Norman Korpi & Alton Williams (RR Alt:  Adam Larson & Shane Landrum   RW Alt:   Steven Hill, Ace Amerson & David Burns)Women:  Rachel Robinson, Emily Bailey, Holly Shand, Ayanna Mackins, Christena Pyle, Jodi Weatherton, Ellen Cho, Coral Smith, Beth Stolarczyk, Mallory Snyder, Julie Stoffer, Irulan Wilson, Robin Hibbard & Ruthie Alcaide (RR Alt:  Veronica Portillo, Tina Barta & Kina Dea   RW Alt:  Rachel Braband (side note:  I think I'm the only one that wished we saw more of her lol), Aneesa Ferreira, & Elka Walker)The politics and one-on-one eliminations on the female side would have been epic.  I don't have any clue how the male side would have played out.  I'm guessing Alton at least makes the final but it would have been great to watch.  

QUEEN ELKA SHOULD NOT BE AN ALTERNATE. as well as Rachel B lol.. I loved her too

I also want Elka and Rachel B on the cast--likely over Robin & Irulan but I thought I'd be alone in that

I got Rachel winning for sure on the girls side with Jodi in a close second.. Guys in tougher but I can easily see Darrell Alton and CT being top 3

My money would be on Holly S for the girls but I really think a lot of them could win.  I have the same 3 guys although Mark, Jamie and Theo could surprise.

that cast is LIT, and it would finally tell us how Theo Von and Dan S stack up against people like CT, Alton, DerricK, Abram, and Brad.

The Challenge: Brains vs Brawn vs Beauty

——————

Brains

Amanda Garcia [AYTO?: Season 3]

Aneesa Ferreira [RW: Chicago]

Da’Vonne Rogers [Big Brother 17]

Marie Roda [RW: St. Thomas]

Michele Fitzgerald [Survivor: Season 32]

Natalie Duran [American Ninja Warrior]

Keith Klebacher [AYTO?: Season 6]

Paulie Calafiore [Big Brother 18]

Shane Landrum [RR: Campus Crawl]

Stephen Bear [Ex On The Beach UK]

Turbo Camkiran [Survivor Turkey]

Wes Bergmann [RW: Austin]

——————

Brawn

Faith Stowers [Vanderpump Rules]

Georgia Harrison [Love Island UK]

Janelle Shanks [BGC: Miami]

Mattie Lynn Breaux [Party Down South]

Nicole Zanatta [RW: Skeletons]

Sylvia Elsrode [RW: Skeletons]

Alton Williams [RW: Las Vegas ‘02]

Ashley Cain [Ex On The Beach UK]

Frank Sweeney [RW: San Diego ‘11]

Rodney Lavoie Jr [Survivor: Season 30]

Tony Raines [RW: Skeletons]

Zach Nichols [RW: San Diego ‘11]

——————

Beauty 

Angela Babicz [BGC: Twisted Sisters]

Kailah Casillas [RW: Go Big or Go Home]

Kam Williams [AYTO?: Season 5]

Kenya Scott [AYTO?: Season 7]

Melissa Reeves [Ex On The Beach UK]

Nany Gonzalez [RW: Las Vegas ‘11]

Cory Wharton [RW: Ex-Plosion]

Dario Medrano [AYTO?: Season 2]

Joss Mooney [Ex On The Beach UK]

Nelson Thomas [AYTO?: Season 3]

Scott Timlin [Geordie Shore]

Theo Campbell [Love Island UK]

That's one dumb *** brain team

The Challenge: Brains vs Brawn vs Beauty——————BrainsAmanda Garcia [AYTO?: Season 3]Aneesa Ferreira [RW: Chicago]Da’Vonne Rogers [Big Brother 17]Marie Roda [RW: St. Thomas]Michele Fitzgerald [Survivor: Season 32]Natalie Duran [American Ninja Warrior]Keith Klebacher [AYTO?: Season 6]Paulie Calafiore [Big Brother 18]Shane Landrum [RR: Campus Crawl]Stephen Bear [Ex On The Beach UK]Turbo Camkiran [Survivor Turkey]Wes Bergmann [RW: Austin]——————BrawnFaith Stowers [Vanderpump Rules]Georgia Harrison [Love Island UK]Janelle Shanks [BGC: Miami]Mattie Lynn Breaux [Party Down South]Nicole Zanatta [RW: Skeletons]Sylvia Elsrode [RW: Skeletons]Alton Williams [RW: Las Vegas ‘02]Ashley Cain [Ex On The Beach UK]Frank Sweeney [RW: San Diego ‘11]Rodney Lavoie Jr [Survivor: Season 30]Tony Raines [RW: Skeletons]Zach Nichols [RW: San Diego ‘11]——————Beauty Angela Babicz [BGC: Twisted Sisters]Kailah Casillas [RW: Go Big or Go Home]Kam Williams [AYTO?: Season 5]Kenya Scott [AYTO?: Season 7]Melissa Reeves [Ex On The Beach UK]Nany Gonzalez [RW: Las Vegas ‘11]Cory Wharton [RW: Ex-Plosion]Dario Medrano [AYTO?: Season 2]Joss Mooney [Ex On The Beach UK]Nelson Thomas [AYTO?: Season 3]Scott Timlin [Geordie Shore]Theo Campbell [Love Island UK]

This is awful....other than brawn (which is questionable--Tony lmao)

I think the cast is great & realistic, save for a few.

I tried to make it realistic and balanced. Which is why I gave beauty people like Theo & Joss, and gave brawn Tony. 

I love it, cup

I love it, cup

Battle of the Seasons

 

Partners are paired based on what season the debuted on the challenge

 

Bear & Mattie (WotW)

Joss & Kam (Vendettas)

Bruno & Kailah (Invasion)

Devin & Amanda (Rivals 3)

Cory & Nicole (Bloodlines)

Johnny & Nia (Free Agents)

Marlon & Cooke (Rivals 2)

Frank & Nany (BOTS 2012)

Leroy & Jonna (Rivals)

Chet & Emily (Cutthroat)

Brandon & Laurel (Fresh Meat 2)

Cohutta & KellyAnne (The Island)

Alton & Tina (The Guantlet)

Landon & Jodi (The Inferno II)

Brad & Kina (Battle of the Sexes 2)

CT & Kendal (The Inferno)

Wes & Melinda (Fresh Meat)

Shane & Rachel (Battle of the Sexes)

 

Alternates:

Adam & Averey (Exes 2)

Chuck & Faith (Final Reckoning)

Ammo & Tori (Dirty 30)

Pages