The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

14163 posts / 0 new
Last post

Cookie, Nia, Theresa, Louise, Michaela and Shanley. Sounds legendary.

inb4 people whine "it's not Cutthroat without the draft"would never happen (10 rookies + no Cara, Johnny, or CT + Landon & Nia returning) but ***** I WOULD LIVElooks like the RetUrNers team would run away with it

Do people really think this? I've never seen anyone's include the draft 

 The challenge battle of the twisted year  

Location Thailand host Rob dyrdek 

The longest season in challenge history ,filmed for an entire year, 48 episodes, 50 cast members, 5 teams of 10, but the team that comes in last the first mission goes straight to redemption. The 4 teams compete in elims and missions as pairs, the winning team of the mission protects one team and the others vote a guy and girl into the elim called the fight zone. The pair that loses goes to redemption where they meet the team from the first mission. Then all 6 guys and 6 girls draw skulls, there are 2 skulls the white and gold that you want. Getting the white and gold skulls mean you are a pair, gold with gold white with white. the rest go home, the pair that wins the first redemption gets to join any team they want. After the second redemption, the teams are no more and its guy girl pairs, then each redemption after will change the format, from teams of four, to same *** pairs, or back to big teams again, making this the most unpredictable season ever.  In additon to this there will be heavy hitters brought in, purges, and the biggest twist, the reset button,  the reset button is the biggest twist in any season ever, it allows you to restart the game, EVERYONE WHO LOST WILL RETURN AND THE SEASON WILL START OVER AGAIN The way to find the reset button is to find it hidden in the redemption house as a way to save yourself a second or third time, but it costs everyone in the game have to restart. The fightzone will only be pairs and when the format changes to pairs, last place goes straight in and the pc picks who they face like other seasons. 

Orange Team -Bananas CT Zach Tony Leroy Cara maria Camila Nicole Jenna c Tori

Red Team- Kyle Vince Derrick H Paulie Brad Angela Faith Britini Natalie Danni

Yellow Team-Cory Dunbar Big easy Jozea Sebastian(survivor) Jasmine Chanel Ashley k Christina Chole(siestaKey) 

Blue Team-Paul(bb) MJ Dario Cody(stranded) Jamie Jemmye Jenna b(survivor) Brianna l Alicia Candace

pink team-Anthony (ayto) Raphy Alex(sisetakey) Donathan(survivor) Nate Kim J Rianna Emilee Brianna j Johanna

Since this is a Fantasy Cast forum, I've wished for several years that there could be The Challenge:  Time Capsule.  It would involve only the best of the best players at the time when they were at their very best (most of us who are veteran Challenge viewers know which ones I'm talking about).  It would be so great to see people like "Gauntlet 2" Derrick, any Challenge Landon, Mark Long, Holly Shand, Rachel Robinson, "Rivals" Evelyn and Laurel, etc. all in one place, especially in a completely individual Challenge (no partners at any time, no purges, no Redemption twists where nobody ever seems to get eliminated).  Frankly, I wouldn't even care who ended up winning because I'd just be all aquiver at seeing such great competitors when they were at their peak.  Obviously there's no way for this to happen but like I said, fantasy cast.  A person CAN dream, right?!

Exes 3

Wes/Kellyanne

Bananas/Natalie

Tor'i/Angela

Derrick K/Britni

Kyle/Cara

Paulie/Lexi

Abram/Coral

CT/Laurel

Nelson/Kayleigh

Anthony/Marie

Chuck/Rashida

Devin/Camila

Isaac/Jasmine

Final Reckoning (redone with Male/Female Teams)

Kayleigh & Nelson

Brad & Marie

Natalie & Shane

Joss & Sylvia

Amanda & Zach

Cory & Kailah

 Cara Maria & Kyle

Ashley & Melissa

Eddie & Kam

Devin & Tori

Britni & Chuck

Da’vonne & Paulie

Bananas & Jemmye

Angela & Derrick

CT & Veronica

Added: Ashley, Cory & Eddie

Dropped: Faith, Jenna & Jozea

Challenge 32: Battlegrounds

Reformulated Final Reckoning to be 4 teams of 8: Real World vs Are You the One vs Road Rules/Fresh Meat/Ex on the Beach US vs Other Shows (Big Brother, Geordie Shore, Ex on the Beach UK)

Real World

Brad, Zach, Johnny, CT

Marie, Sylvia, Kailah, Jenna

Road Rules/Fresh Meat/Ex on the Beach US

Shane, Tor’i, Mark Long, Chase

Veronica, Cara, Angela, Faith

Are You the One

Nelson, Devin, Derrick, Chuck

Amanda, Kam, Tori, Britni

Other Shows

Kyle, Joss, Paulie, Jozea

Kayleigh, Natalie, Melissa, DaVonne

...

Cut: Jemmye

Added: Tor’i, Mark Long, Chase

This is a pretty realistic cast I threw together with a random format that is kinda designed to get some new blood in there along with the current big names

Legends (old school – debuted before AYTO inclusion)

Jemmye Carroll (Real World: New Orleans 2010), Marie Roda (Real World: St. Thomas), Veronica Portillo (Road Rules: Semester at Sea), Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)

Cohutta Grindstaff (Real World: Sydney), Leroy Garrett (Real World: Las Vegas 2011), Mark Long (Road Rules 1), Darrell Taylor (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)

 

Veterans (debuted post-AYTO inclusion, 3+ Challenge appearances)

Ashley Mitchell (Real World: Ex-Plosion), Kailah Casillas (Real World: GBOGH), Amanda Garcia (AYTO 3), Britni Thornton (AYTO 3)

Cory Wharton (Real World: Ex-Plosion), Devin Walker-Molaghan (AYTO 3), Hunter Barfield (AYTO 3), Nelson Thomas (AYTO 3)

 

Challengers (1-2 Challenges)

Averey Tressler (Real World: Portland), Nicole Zanatta (Real World: Skeletons), Melissa Reeves (Ex on the Beach), Kam Williams (AYTO 5)

Jamie Banks (Battle of the Bloodlines), Kyle Christie (Geordie Shore), Joss Mooney (Ex on the Beach), Paulie Calafiore (Big Brother)

 

Rookies (debut)

Katrina Stack (Real World: Bad Blood), Alexis Eddy (AYTO 6), Diandra Delgado (AYTO 6), Nurys Mateo (AYTO 6)

John Humphrey (AYTO 4), Clinton Moxam (AYTO 6), Kareem Fathalla (AYTO 6), Keith Klebacher (AYTO 6)

This is a pretty realistic cast I threw together with a random format that is kinda designed to get some new blood in there along with the current big namesLegends (old school – debuted before AYTO inclusion)Jemmye Carroll (Real World: New Orleans 2010), Marie Roda (Real World: St. Thomas), Veronica Portillo (Road Rules: Semester at Sea), Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)Cohutta Grindstaff (Real World: Sydney), Leroy Garrett (Real World: Las Vegas 2011), Mark Long (Road Rules 1), Darrell Taylor (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) Veterans (debuted post-AYTO inclusion, 3+ Challenge appearances)Ashley Mitchell (Real World: Ex-Plosion), Kailah Casillas (Real World: GBOGH), Amanda Garcia (AYTO 3), Britni Thornton (AYTO 3)Cory Wharton (Real World: Ex-Plosion), Devin Walker-Molaghan (AYTO 3), Hunter Barfield (AYTO 3), Nelson Thomas (AYTO 3) Challengers (1-2 Challenges)Averey Tressler (Real World: Portland), Nicole Zanatta (Real World: Skeletons), Melissa Reeves (Ex on the Beach), Kam Williams (AYTO 5)Jamie Banks (Battle of the Bloodlines), Kyle Christie (Geordie Shore), Joss Mooney (Ex on the Beach), Paulie Calafiore (Big Brother) Rookies (debut)Katrina Stack (Real World: Bad Blood), Alexis Eddy (AYTO 6), Diandra Delgado (AYTO 6), Nurys Mateo (AYTO 6)John Humphrey (AYTO 4), Clinton Moxam (AYTO 6), Kareem Fathalla (AYTO 6), Keith Klebacher (AYTO 6)

I love this format, I'd switch some people but this is definitely one Id want to see. I'd mostly want to get rid of Johnny, Cara and Leroy but they fit the bill it would be odd not to have them. Actually scrap Cara for Nany.  I'd switch Nurys for Shanley, and Clinton for Mike! (AYTO & Bad Blood) And Nicole for anyone else, she gives me predator vibes, she just gets away with it as she's female.

Battle of the Ages

6 teams of 6, grouped together by how many challenges they've done.

Mostly realistic. Yes, no Johnny, but we don't need him to carry a season, and with his *** tape just being leaked... MTV might not want that controversy.

 

 

Group 1: 0 previous challenges

Katrina, Alexis, Michaela, Keith, Asaf, Jay Starrett

Group 2: 1 previous challenge

Paulie, Marlon, Theo K-B, Cooke, DaVonne, Kendall

Group 3: 2 previous challenges

Averey, Melissa, Kam, Kyle, Trey, Jamie Banks

Group 4: 3-4 previous challenges

Frank S, Devin, Jordan, Sylvia, Amanda, Ashley

Group 5: 5-6 previous challenges

Nelson, Mark Long, Tony, Laurel, Theresa, Nany

Group 6: 7+ previous challenges

Wes, Shane, Zach, Jemmye, Sarah, Cara

 

 

Each episode/elimination will have 1 man and 1 woman go home. Losing team goes into elim, winning team gets to choose the other team that goes into elim. Then it's secret voting like Cutthroat to determine the man and woman who go into elim.

Same rules as battle of the seasons + elimination mercenaries

Same rules as battle of the seasons + elimination mercenaries

Cory instead of Nelzzzon, Faith instead of Angela, Ashley C instead of that random guy next to Keith, and Bri instead of Veronica. I’d replace John but I guess that wouldn’t happen.

 

Cutthroat 2

Blue Team:

Adam Kuhn, Amanda Garcia, Averey Tressler, Darrell Taylor, Derrick Kosinski, Hunter Barfield, Joss Mooney, KellyAnne Judd, Theresa Gonzalez, Veronica Portillo

 

Gray Team:

Abram Boise, Britni Thornton, Jenna Compono, Johnny Reilly, Nelson Thomas, Robb Schreiber, Sarah Rice, Sylvia Elsrode, Tori Deal, Wes Bergmann

 

Red Team:

Aneesa Ferreira, Ashley Mitchell, Brad Fiorenza, Chuck Mowery, Devin Walker-Molaghan, Jordan Wiseley, Marie Roda, Melinda Stolp, Nia Moore, Shane Landrum

 

love it, Alaska! no debuts though Sad Blue team got this on lock. especially if they shed Veronica ASAP. also, lol about Melinda

Old School and New School- Pairs, random selection like Fresh Meat

Landon and Amanda

Bananas and Ashley M

Brad and Kam

Wes and Britni

Shane and Sylvia

CT and Kailah

Abram and Faith

Veronica and Nelson

Rachel R and Devin

Coral and Joss

Cara and Shane R (gotta give her a bad partner)

Laurel and Chuck

Nany and Hunter

Jonna and Paulie

The Challenge : Triple Threat (33)

Nany 

Devyn 

Shauvon 

Parisa

Trisha

KellyAnne

Jodi 

Kina

Jillian

Aneesa

Jasmine

Kailah 

Jenna 

Leroy

Darrell

Mike Mizanin 

Randy orton

Finn balor

Shawne  merriman 

Chris tamburello

Terrell owens

Brandon swift

Kassius 

Alton

Wes 

Dunbar 

Ty ruff

Katie Doyle 

Veronica portillo 

Beth stolarczyk

Jon brennan

Nia moore

Dan renzi

Irulan

The Challenge: Braun & Brains

Challenge cast consisting of teams with one physical player and one strategic player. Challenge and elims alternate between physical and mental each week.

 

Braun:

Marlin (RW Portland)

Darrell (RR)

CJ (RW Cancun)

Leroy (RW Las Vegas)

Faysal (BB)

CT (RW Paris)

Zach (RW San Diego)

Laurel (FM2)/

Emily (RW DC)

Cooke (RW Vegas)

Kailah (RW GBGH)

Cara (FM2)

Sarah (Survivor)

Lolo (CvP)

 

Brains:

Scottie (BB)

Tyler (BB)

Frank (RW: San Diego)

Casper (CvS3)

Wes (RW Austin)

Devin (AYTO)

Keith (AYTO)

Amanda (AYTO)

Hayleigh (BB)

Dayvonne (BB)

Louise (CvS3)

Coral (RR)

Kam (AYTO)

Ashley M. (RW Explosion)

How y'all pairing them off (Same sex or M/F)?  & who winning? This cast would be lit!

 

 

 

 

 

a whole team made up of men's razors? wow.

Some type of "Allies" theme, following a similar format as FR. I tried to make a "semi" realaistic cast, with some regulars, a good # of debuts, and some big returns:

F/F Teams:

  • Kendal Sheppard and Tori Hall 
  • Jenna Compono & Nany Gonzalez
  • Sarah Patterson & Susie Meister
  • Anna Strack & Katrina Strack
  • Da'Vonne Rogers & Natalie Negroti

 

M/M Teams:

  • Johnny Bananas & Leroy Garrett
  • Devin Walker & Wes Bergmann
  • Tony Raines & Zach Nichols
  • Josh Martinez & Paul Abraham
  • Hunter Barfield & Nelson Thomas

 

M/F Teams:

  • Amanda Garcia & Shane Landrum
  • Jordan Wiseley & Tori Deal
  • Angela Rummans & Tyler Crispin
  • Casper Smart & Louise Hazel
  • Bayleigh Dayton & Swaggy C Williams

 

Mercanaries can be like Cara Maria & CT/Paulie or something

I want an Allies season, but same-sex. So there are fair elimination rounds and also 4 winners.

Final Reckoning (re-casting)

M/F Teams

Alexis Eddy [AYTO 6] & Keith Klebacher [AYTO 6]
Amanda Garcia [AYTO 3] & Mike Crescenzo [RW Seattle: Bad Blood]
Da'Vonne Rogers [Big Brother 18] & Paulie Calafiore [Big Brother 18]
Jason Hill [RW: Skeletons] & Nicole Zanatta [RW: Skeletons]
Joss Mooney [Ex on the Beach 1]Sylvia Elsrode [RW: Skeletons]
Theo King-Bradley [RW Seattle: Bad Blood] & Tyara Hooks [RW Seattle: Bad Blood]

M/M Teams

Brad Fiorenza [RW: San Diego 2004]Kyle Christie [Geordie Shore]
Derrick Henry [AYTO 5] & Tor’i Brooks [Ex on the Beach US]
John Devenanzio [RW: Key West] & Tony Raines [RW: Skeletons]
Nelson Thomas [AYTO 5] & Shane Landrum [RR: Campus Crawl]

F/F Teams

Angela Babicz [BGC: Twisted Sisters] & Faith Stowers [Vanderpump Rules] 
Cara Maria Sorbello [Fresh Meat II] & Marie Roda [RW: St. Thomas]
CeeJai Jenkins [RW: Go Big or Go Home] & Kailah Casillas [RW: Go Big or Go Home]
Jemmye Carroll [RW: New Orleans 2010]Jenna Compono [RW: Ex-Plosion]
Kam Williams [AYTO 5]Melissa Reeves [Ex on the Beach 2]
Katrina Stack [RW Seattle: Bad Blood] & Jenn Geoghan [RW Seattle: Bad Blood]

Mercenaries.....

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ashley Mitchell [RW: Ex-Plosion] & Hunter Barfield [AYTO 5]

Cory Wharton [RW: Ex-Plosion] & Darrell Taylor [RR: Campus Crawl]

CT Tamburello [RW: Paris] & Marlon Williams [RW: Portland]

Final Reckoning (re-casting)M/F TeamsAlexis Eddy [AYTO 6] & Keith Klebacher [AYTO 6]Amanda Garcia [AYTO 3] & Mike Crescenzo [RW Seattle: Bad Blood]Da'Vonne Rogers [Big Brother 18] & Paulie Calafiore [Big Brother 18]Jason Hill [RW: Skeletons] & Nicole Zanatta [RW: Skeletons]Joss Mooney [Ex on the Beach 1]Sylvia Elsrode [RW: Skeletons]Theo King-Bradley [RW Seattle: Bad Blood] & Tyara Hooks [RW Seattle: Bad Blood]M/M TeamsBrad Fiorenza [RW: San Diego 2004]Kyle Christie [Geordie Shore]Derrick Henry [AYTO 5] & Tor’i Brooks [Ex on the Beach US]John Devenanzio [RW: Key West] & Tony Raines [RW: Skeletons]Nelson Thomas [AYTO 5] & Shane Landrum [RR: Campus Crawl]F/F TeamsAngela Babicz [BGC: Twisted Sisters] & Faith Stowers [Vanderpump Rules] Cara Maria Sorbello [Fresh Meat II] & Marie Roda [RW: St. Thomas]CeeJai Jenkins [RW: Go Big or Go Home] & Kailah Casillas [RW: Go Big or Go Home]Jemmye Carroll [RW: New Orleans 2010]Jenna Compono [RW: Ex-Plosion]Kam Williams [AYTO 5]Melissa Reeves [Ex on the Beach 2]Katrina Stack [RW Seattle: Bad Blood] & Jenn Geoghan [RW Seattle: Bad Blood]Mercenaries.....        Ashley Mitchell [RW: Ex-Plosion] & Hunter Barfield [AYTO 5]Cory Wharton [RW: Ex-Plosion] & Darrell Taylor [RR: Campus Crawl]CT Tamburello [RW: Paris] & Marlon Williams [RW: Portland]

Ohhhhhh so you got time for this but not the challenge? Lmaooooo

hardbitten wrote:
Final Reckoning (re-casting)M/F TeamsAlexis Eddy [AYTO 6] & Keith Klebacher [AYTO 6]Amanda Garcia [AYTO 3] & Mike Crescenzo [RW Seattle: Bad Blood]Da'Vonne Rogers [Big Brother 18] & Paulie Calafiore [Big Brother 18]Jason Hill [RW: Skeletons] & Nicole Zanatta [RW: Skeletons]Joss Mooney [Ex on the Beach 1]Sylvia Elsrode [RW: Skeletons]Theo King-Bradley [RW Seattle: Bad Blood] & Tyara Hooks [RW Seattle: Bad Blood]M/M TeamsBrad Fiorenza [RW: San Diego 2004]Kyle Christie [Geordie Shore]Derrick Henry [AYTO 5] & Tor’i Brooks [Ex on the Beach US]John Devenanzio [RW: Key West] & Tony Raines [RW: Skeletons]Nelson Thomas [AYTO 5] & Shane Landrum [RR: Campus Crawl]F/F TeamsAngela Babicz [BGC: Twisted Sisters] & Faith Stowers [Vanderpump Rules] Cara Maria Sorbello [Fresh Meat II] & Marie Roda [RW: St. Thomas]CeeJai Jenkins [RW: Go Big or Go Home] & Kailah Casillas [RW: Go Big or Go Home]Jemmye Carroll [RW: New Orleans 2010]Jenna Compono [RW: Ex-Plosion]Kam Williams [AYTO 5]Melissa Reeves [Ex on the Beach 2]Katrina Stack [RW Seattle: Bad Blood] & Jenn Geoghan [RW Seattle: Bad Blood]Mercenaries.....        Ashley Mitchell [RW: Ex-Plosion] & Hunter Barfield [AYTO 5]Cory Wharton [RW: Ex-Plosion] & Darrell Taylor [RR: Campus Crawl]CT Tamburello [RW: Paris] & Marlon Williams [RW: Portland]

Ohhhhhh so you got time for this but not the challenge? Lmaooooo

I've had this saved for days! But I promise I'll do the challenge tonight tho <3

Eskimo Brothers

Cara Maria & Faith (Kyle)

Angela & Natalie (Bananas)

Averey & Nany (Johnny)

Kam & Nia (Leroy)

Alyssa & Madison (Tony)

Alicia & Taylor (Cory)

Kayleigh & Nurys (Nelson)

Bria & Morgan (Zak)

 

Derrick & Jordan (Tori)

Bananas & Tor’i (Angela)

Abram & Thomas (Cara Maria)

Brian & Cory (Jenny)

Hunter & Kyle (Ashley M)

Ashley & Nelson (Kayleigh)

Frank & Marlon (Derek)

Cohutta & Wes (KellyAnne)

 

I feel like it’s a realistic cast that would still provide decent drama

 The island 2019
Bananas
CT
Dario
Derrick h
Donathan(survivor)
Jozea
Kyle
Leroy
Paul(big brother)
Tony
Vince
Zach
Girls
Angela
Britni
Camila
Cara maria
Christina
Dani(bad girls club)
Faith
Jenna
Jemmye
Natalie
Nicole z 
Tori

Coral Smith and 31 others...

Here's what should have happened following Seasons instead of Rivals 2 using most of that cast and trying to be realistic.

Old School:  Men--Brandon, CT, Dunbar, Johnny, Tyrie, Wes & ????????    Women--Aneesa, Cara Maria, Diem, Paula, Theresa, Trishelle & Sarah

New School:  Men--Frank, Jordan, Knight, Preston, Marlon, Trey & Zach  Women--Camila, Cooke, Emily, Jemmye, Jessica, Jonna & Nany

The last "old school" guy is tough.   Ideally Darrell or Landon but then the old schools guys would have been stacked.   Maybe Danny Jamieson, Adam King or Nehemiah Clark.  Possibly Mark Long.    I put FM2 with the old school because Cutthroat seemed like the logical break.  Kind of wanted to include Leroy but the only person I could really bump would probably be Trey.

The Challenge: Allies (Bloodlines Format)

Kendal and Tori H

Zach and Jenna

Dustin and Nany

Kailah and Marie

Nelson and Hunter

Devin and Chuck

Sylvia and Kam

Bananas and Leroy

Veronica and Shane

Joss and Rogan

Ashley and Amanda

Cara Maria and Natalie

Brad and Wes

Jordan and Tori D

Episode 1: 

Winners: Bananas and Leroy

Last: Veronica and Shane

Voted in: Devin and Chuck

Matchup: Shane vs Devin

Eliminated: Shane and Veronica

 

Episode 2: 

Winners: Nelson and Hunter

Last: Zach and Jenna

Voted in: Kendal and Tori H

Matchup: Jenna vs Tori H

Eliminated: Zach and Jenna

 

*Switch to Teams*

Blue Team:

Nelson

Jordan

Devin

Brad

Rogan

Leroy

Natalie

Kailah

Nany

Amanda

Kendal

Kam

 

Red Team: 

Hunter

Dustin

Chuck

Wes

Joss

Bananas

Tori D

Cara Maria

Marie

Ashley

Tori H

Sylvia

 

 

Episode 3:

Winners: Red

Voted in by Team: Rogan

Voted in by opposite team: Jordan

Eliminated: Jordan and Tori D

 

Episode 4:

Winners: Red

Voted in by Team: Kendal

Voted in by opposite team: Natalie

Eliminated: Natalie and Cara Maria


Episode 5:

Winners: Blue

Voted in by team: Dustin

Voted in by opposite team: Bananas

ELiminated: Dustin and Nany

 

Episode 6:

Winners: Blue

Voted in by team: Tori H

Voted in by opposite team: Sylvia

Eliminated: Tori H and Kendal

 

Episode 7:

Winners: Blue

Voted in by team: Bananas

Voted in by opposite team: Wes

Eliminated: Wes and Brad

 

Episode 8:

Winners: Red

Voted in by team: Kailah

Voted in by opposite team: Kam

Eliminated: Kailah and Marie

 

Episode 9:

Winners: Blue

Voted in by team: Bananas

Voted in by opposite team: Chuck

Eliminated: Chuck and Devin

 

*Back to teams*

Nelson and Hunter

Rogan and Joss

Leroy and Bananas

Amanda and Ashley

Kam and Sylvia

 

Episode 10:

Winners: Ashley and Amanda

Last: Nelson and Hunter

Voted in: Leroy and Bananas

Eliminated: Nelson and Hunter

 

Episode 11:

Winners: Leroy and Bananas

Last: Kam and Sylvia

Voted in: Ashley and Amanda

Matchup: Kam vs Ashley

Eliminated: Ashley and Amanda

 

Episode 12:

3rd: Rogan and Joss

2nd: Kam and Sylvia

1st: Bananas and Leroy

Pages