The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

This is less of a hypothetical and more of a actually what would've happened ?

So in the second to last elimination of Seasons Jonna and Derrick went up against Frank and ****** and lost, but what if Cancun won and then there would be 4 teams left( Vegas, Brooklyn, Cancun, and San diego) would 4 teams have competed in the final or another challenge and elimination (or two more if brooklyn lost that elimination still leaving four teams??) and then who would've won the final if it were Brooklyn, Vegas, Cancun and San Diego?

Evan looked too out of shape during rivals. Leroy still would of win the last challenge. So the jek alliance would of had gone against each other. 



This is very true

This is less of a hypothetical and more of a actually what would've happened ?

So in the second to last elimination of Seasons Jonna and Derrick went up against Frank and ****** and lost, but what if Cancun won and then there would be 4 teams left( Vegas, Brooklyn, Cancun, and San diego) would 4 teams have competed in the final or another challenge and elimination (or two more if brooklyn lost that elimination still leaving four teams??) and then who would've won the final if it were Brooklyn, Vegas, Cancun and San Diego?

I think Dustin and Trishelle would've won, just on the fact that they would have handled the tires better than Derek and Jonna.

1st: Dustin/Trishelle

2nd: Derek/Jonna

Not sure about 3rd/4th 

This is less of a hypothetical and more of a actually what would've happened ?

So in the second to last elimination of Seasons Jonna and Derrick went up against Frank and ****** and lost, but what if Cancun won and then there would be 4 teams left( Vegas, Brooklyn, Cancun, and San diego) would 4 teams have competed in the final or another challenge and elimination (or two more if brooklyn lost that elimination still leaving four teams??) and then who would've won the final if it were Brooklyn, Vegas, Cancun and San Diego?

Zach and Sam would've still won.

I think Derek & Jonna, Chet & Sarah, Dustin & Trishelle, Zach & Sam would be a close race if those were the 4 teams in the final

what if cj and jasmine had beaten zach and sam and alton and nany had beaten robb and marie?

This is less of a hypothetical and more of a actually what would've happened ?

So in the second to last elimination of Seasons Jonna and Derrick went up against Frank and ****** and lost, but what if Cancun won and then there would be 4 teams left( Vegas, Brooklyn, Cancun, and San diego) would 4 teams have competed in the final or another challenge and elimination (or two more if brooklyn lost that elimination still leaving four teams??) and then who would've won the final if it were Brooklyn, Vegas, Cancun and San Diego?

I think Dustin and Trishelle would've won, just on the fact that they would have handled the tires better than Derek and Jonna.

1st: Dustin/Trishelle

2nd: Derek/Jonna

Not sure about 3rd/4th 

Trishelle would have still slowed Dustin down. Sarah/Chet would have won if it was just them two with Jonna/Derek not far behind. 

This is less of a hypothetical and more of a actually what would've happened ?

So in the second to last elimination of Seasons Jonna and Derrick went up against Frank and ****** and lost, but what if Cancun won and then there would be 4 teams left( Vegas, Brooklyn, Cancun, and San diego) would 4 teams have competed in the final or another challenge and elimination (or two more if brooklyn lost that elimination still leaving four teams??) and then who would've won the final if it were Brooklyn, Vegas, Cancun and San Diego?

I think Dustin and Trishelle would've won, just on the fact that they would have handled the tires better than Derek and Jonna.

1st: Dustin/Trishelle

2nd: Derek/Jonna

Not sure about 3rd/4th 

Trishelle would have still slowed Dustin down. Sarah/Chet would have won if it was just them two with Jonna/Derek not far behind. 

I took it as Brooklyn still being four. I agree that if it were Sarah/Chet v. Dustin/Trishelle v. Zach/Sam v. Derek/Jonna, Sarah and Chet would have won. If you replace Zach/Sam with Frank/Ashley though it's a different story. 

What if Emily lost to Paula on Cutthroat? LOL Like that would happen, but still..

What if Emily lost to Paula on Cutthroat? LOL Like that would happen, but still..

That would've been hilarious because Jenn would've competed in the final by herself as the only blue team member and she would still get $40,000 when she lost. The Red Team members all got $40,000 each when they won, which means it would feel like Jenn won too lol 

What if Emily lost to Paula on Cutthroat? LOL Like that would happen, but still..

That would've been hilarious because Jenn would've competed in the final by herself as the only blue team member and she would still get $40,000 when she lost. The Red Team members all got $40,000 each when they won, which means it would feel like Jenn won too lol 

I wonder how they would've did that stretcher part of the final with Jenn as the only one... And it was bullshit that they still got paid even though they were like way behind ****

What if Emily lost to Paula on Cutthroat? LOL Like that would happen, but still..

That would've been hilarious because Jenn would've competed in the final by herself as the only blue team member and she would still get $40,000 when she lost. The Red Team members all got $40,000 each when they won, which means it would feel like Jenn won too lol 

I wonder how they would've did that stretcher part of the final with Jenn as the only one... And it was bullshit that they still got paid even though they were like way behind ****

I just did the math and realized that Paula would come back into the red team for the final and they would all receve $32,000 and Jenn would still get $40,000 even though they beat her **** that would be funny as ****. She'd be the best loser in Challenge history for receiving the most money on a season without winning. 

What if Emily lost to Paula on Cutthroat? LOL Like that would happen, but still..

That would've been hilarious because Jenn would've competed in the final by herself as the only blue team member and she would still get $40,000 when she lost. The Red Team members all got $40,000 each when they won, which means it would feel like Jenn won too lol 

I wonder how they would've did that stretcher part of the final with Jenn as the only one... And it was bullshit that they still got paid even though they were like way behind ****

I just did the math and realized that Paula would come back into the red team for the final and they would all receve $32,000 and Jenn would still get $40,000 even though they beat her **** that would be funny as ****. She'd be the best loser in Challenge history for receiving the most money on a season without winning. 

OMG lol that would make Challenge history.. I think Jenn could've done it alone because I read somewhere that Emily was the reason they were behind or something like that. Still kinda weird that what they got each is what runner ups could get by themselves.

Sorry if this has already been said, but what happens if Jonna and Derek beat Ashley and Frank in the last elimination on BOTS?  My bet is Cancun would have won the final

What do you guys think would have happened If Exes 2 was C.T/Diem , Wes/Theresa , Bananas/Emilee , Isaac/Jasmine , Jonna/Zach , Eric/Sahar , Knight/Jemmye , Adam/Nany , Dustin/Cooke , Leroy/Naomi , Robb/Marie , Averey/Johnny , Jordan/Sarah & Marlon/Nia.

Elimination:

CT & Diem still would have been removed due to Diem's illness

1. Isaac & Jasmine

2. Eric & Sahar

3. Leroy & Naomi

4. Knight & Jemmye

5. Bananas & Emilee

6. Adam & Nany

7. Robb & Marie

8. Zach & Jonna

9. Marlon & Nia

10. Johnny & Averey

3rd in the Final- Dustin & Cooke

Runner Up- Wes & Theresa

Winners- Jordan & Sarah

This is less of a hypothetical and more of a actually what would've happened ?

So in the second to last elimination of Seasons Jonna and Derrick went up against Frank and ****** and lost, but what if Cancun won and then there would be 4 teams left( Vegas, Brooklyn, Cancun, and San diego) would 4 teams have competed in the final or another challenge and elimination (or two more if brooklyn lost that elimination still leaving four teams??) and then who would've won the final if it were Brooklyn, Vegas, Cancun and San Diego?

I think the 4 teams would have gone to the final but the 4th place team just wouldn't have made any money.

StuffAndThings
Anonymous's picture

What do you guys think would have happened If Exes 2 was C.T/Diem , Wes/Theresa , Bananas/Emilee , Isaac/Jasmine , Jonna/Zach , Eric/Sahar , Knight/Jemmye , Adam/Nany , Dustin/Cooke , Leroy/Naomi , Robb/Marie , Averey/Johnny , Jordan/Sarah & Marlon/Nia.

Uhhh...Am I missing something?

 

What if Jemmye beat LaToya how far would Jemmye go on Free Agents ?

I feel like Jemmye would have taken Devyns spot in the final because Jemmye is weak but a lot of people are friends with her like: Camila, Theresa, Aneesa, Nany, Jonna, Frank, Preston, Chet. She could have made it far on a political game, if she didn't pull the kill card again

I think Derek & Jonna, Chet & Sarah, Dustin & Trishelle, Zach & Sam would be a close race if those were the 4 teams in the final

Brooklyn would have still had JD & Devyn, not just Sarah & Chet.

What do you guys think would have happened If Exes 2 was C.T/Diem , Wes/Theresa , Bananas/Emilee , Isaac/Jasmine , Jonna/Zach , Eric/Sahar , Knight/Jemmye , Adam/Nany , Dustin/Cooke , Leroy/Naomi , Robb/Marie , Averey/Johnny , Jordan/Sarah & Marlon/Nia.

Uhhh...Am I missing something?

I was thinking the same thing. When did they ever shack up?

I meant if JD & Devyn went home in a extra challenge/ elim.

What if Katelynn picked luke & Brandon got ev

they still would have lost to landon and carley. 

What if Kenny & Evan never chose to be scum and rape Tonya. How many/ what challenges do you think they would have been on.

i think kenny would have been on cuthroat, exes, rivals 2, seasons 2, free agents and maybe exes 2.  he would have gotten the bananas treatment.  evan didnt look like he wanted to be on the challenge.  he sacrificed himself to go against ct again and was out of shape.  on cuthraot, depending on which team he was on could have made the final. on exes it depends on which ex they gave him.  they could have stretched theresa, or given him sarah or laurel and he would have been in the final there as well.  on seasons 2, depending on the team could have went far.  maybe a team of kenny, brandon, camila and laurel.  i cant see him and laurel losing in an elimination.  i can see him and banaas working together to make it to the final in free agents. he's only missed one final so it not absurd to say he would have seen 3 or 4 more finals.  

I don't think Evan would have came back but Kenny definitely would have.

What if Kenny & Evan never chose to be scum and rape Tonya. How many/ what challenges do you think they would have been on.

I think Kenny would have only done Battle of the Exes after Rivals. Most likely would have been Sarah's partner.

I don't think Evan would have done any more after Rivals.

i think kenny would have been on cuthroat, exes, rivals 2, seasons 2, free agents and maybe exes 2.  he would have gotten the bananas treatment.  evan didnt look like he wanted to be on the challenge.  he sacrificed himself to go against ct again and was out of shape.  on cuthraot, depending on which team he was on could have made the final. on exes it depends on which ex they gave him.  they could have stretched theresa, or given him sarah or laurel and he would have been in the final there as well.  on seasons 2, depending on the team could have went far.  maybe a team of kenny, brandon, camila and laurel.  i cant see him and laurel losing in an elimination.  i can see him and banaas working together to make it to the final in free agents. he's only missed one final so it not absurd to say he would have seen 3 or 4 more finals.  

Cutthroat was before Rivals and he wasn't on it. 

I agree with everyone that's saying Evan probably would've been done after Rivals had the Tonya thing didn't happen.

Kenny probably would've done more but I think he would've stopped at some point too.

i think kenny would have been on cuthroat, exes, rivals 2, seasons 2, free agents and maybe exes 2.  he would have gotten the bananas treatment.  evan didnt look like he wanted to be on the challenge.  he sacrificed himself to go against ct again and was out of shape.  on cuthraot, depending on which team he was on could have made the final. on exes it depends on which ex they gave him.  they could have stretched theresa, or given him sarah or laurel and he would have been in the final there as well.  on seasons 2, depending on the team could have went far.  maybe a team of kenny, brandon, camila and laurel.  i cant see him and laurel losing in an elimination.  i can see him and banaas working together to make it to the final in free agents. he's only missed one final so it not absurd to say he would have seen 3 or 4 more finals.  

you do know cutthroat was b4 Rivals 1 right?

Pages