The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

Wouldn't Nany of still gotten stuck. Maybe Jenna would get stuck too though.

The thought of them both just dangling there struggling to move makes me laugh.

Haha it is pretty awesome, now I wish that was the elimination we saw.

StuffAndThings
Anonymous's picture

Wouldn't Nany of still gotten stuck. Maybe Jenna would get stuck too though.

The thought of them both just dangling there struggling to move makes me laugh.

Haha it is pretty awesome, now I wish that was the elimination we saw.

I wonder what they would do if they both got stuck. Would the elimination keep going or...?

What if Jordan/Sarah voted in Banany instead of Leroy/Nia against Wes/Theresa in Hall Brawl? It would've been REALLY interesting because those teams hate each other so much. I think Bananas would win his heat (I hate to say this cause I'm #TeamWes) while Theresa would win her heat which would result in a sudden death match. 


Jordan and Sarah should've done that anyway.. punk******* but I agree

I don't know why they chose Leroy/Mia over banany. They claimed they wanted nia in the final and Jordan said they wanted Wes and Theresa gone because they were a threat in the final. Banany was also a threat in the final. Nany did well on last seasons final and bananas has won 5 of them. If Wes had beaten Leroy, Sarah and Jordan would have had to go against banany and Wes in the finals.

I don't know why they chose Leroy/Mia over banany. They claimed they wanted nia in the final and Jordan said they wanted Wes and Theresa gone because they were a threat in the final. Banany was also a threat in the final. Nany did well on last seasons final and bananas has won 5 of them. If Wes had beaten Leroy, Sarah and Jordan would have had to go against banany and Wes in the finals.

It made total sense to send in Leroy/Nia that time. Banany had a better chance at winning the next mission so they would've probably thrown in Jordan/Sarah for revenge had they won. But because Sarah threw in Leroy, Bananas had no vendetta towards Sarah prior to the rope mission.

What if Susie never replaced Cara on both Viewers' Revenge & The Ruins? (for those who didn't know Cara was originally supposed to be cast on both but had to drop out; Susie replaced her both times).

I always wondered what would have happened.  Cara wasn't weak, but I think if she ended up against KellyAnne or Sarah, or even Kim for that matter, she prob would have went home.  I'm sad we never saw Cara again.  I wish Cara would have been there instead of Johanna tht season.  

Actually, it was supposed to be cara, susie, and kina.. They were hoping to get the drama back going from the gauntlet 2

Actually, it was supposed to be cara, susie, and kina.. They were hoping to get the drama back going from the gauntlet 2

Seriously? I never knew Kina was supposed to be on that challenge...would have killed to see her back.  I think she would have made it to the end easily...she's strong.  Im guessing when she said know Ibis was called.

I meant for viewers revenge

Actually, it was supposed to be cara, susie, and kina.. They were hoping to get the drama back going from the gauntlet 2

Where did you hear this? From what I remember Veronica was always supposed to be apart of the cast.

What if Rivals II was Old School vs. New School? It was the perfect time for them to do that instead of the lame *** overstretched pairings.

What if Rivals II was Old School vs. New School? It was the perfect time for them to do that instead of the lame *** overstretched pairings.

would have been amazing. Especially if they could have grabbed some bigger names from the past like Coral, Veronica, Rachel, etc.

 

 

What if....

Robin, Veronica, and Ruthie had voted off Angela insted of Cynthia on Battle of hte Sexes 2...would Cynthia have never stepped up like she said and skated by to the end?
 

 

I don't think she would of made it to the end.  I can't see them voting coral, Sophia, ruthie, ibis, robin, Rachel  and Tina over her. 

 

What at if battle of the sexes 1 and 2 and battle of the seasons 1 had eliminations? Who do you think would have made the final? On bots guys would send two guys into elimination against each other, same for females. 

i think Rachel would of been on the final on both bots seasons. I think kina, Abe,  and Derrick would have lasted a lot longer on bots2. The miz would have been on the final team.

What if Averey and Nany became friends later? Haha I really like both girls so it sucks knowing that they don't really like each other. 

What if Averey and Nany became friends later? Haha I really like both girls so it sucks knowing that they don't really like each other. 

I actually still like Averey despite what I said about her during Exes. I was on Johnny's side with the whole breakup and I think she was acting bitter but aside from the Johnny/Nany shit I still liker her as a person. I hope her and Nany become friends one day as well.

What if Averey and Nany became friends later? Haha I really like both girls so it sucks knowing that they don't really like each other. 

 

averey and nia are friends now.  so i wouldnt be totally surprised if they become friends

What if Evan and Kenny never got banned? Do you think they both would have still continued to do challenges? 

Personally, I think Kenny would have maybe done 1-2 more after Rivals. I think Kenny could have been paired with Sarah on Battle of the Exes which would have made that season a **** of a lot more interesting and maybe Rivals II (depending if he would have a legit partner) or maybe Free Agents. 

Evan on the other hand, I think would have retired after Rivals anyway. He didn't seem himself on that challenge whatsoever and wasn't into it nearly as much as he was into any of his previous 5 challenges. You could tell he didn't want to be there at all.

What if Evan and Kenny never got banned? Do you think they both would have still continued to do challenges? 

Personally, I think Kenny would have maybe done 1-2 more after Rivals. I think Kenny could have been paired with Sarah on Battle of the Exes which would have made that season a **** of a lot more interesting and maybe Rivals II (depending if he would have a legit partner) or maybe Free Agents. 

Evan on the other hand, I think would have retired after Rivals anyway. He didn't seem himself on that challenge whatsoever and wasn't into it nearly as much as he was into any of his previous 5 challenges. You could tell he didn't want to be there at all.

Agreed. I think Rivals would have been Evan's last challenge regardless of the ban. He wasn't the same Evan at all. He doesn't post anything about the show anymore while Kenny still does so I think Kenny would have continued to do them.

What if Evan and Kenny never got banned? Do you think they both would have still continued to do challenges? 

Personally, I think Kenny would have maybe done 1-2 more after Rivals. I think Kenny could have been paired with Sarah on Battle of the Exes which would have made that season a **** of a lot more interesting and maybe Rivals II (depending if he would have a legit partner) or maybe Free Agents. 

Evan on the other hand, I think would have retired after Rivals anyway. He didn't seem himself on that challenge whatsoever and wasn't into it nearly as much as he was into any of his previous 5 challenges. You could tell he didn't want to be there at all.

Agreed. I think Rivals would have been Evan's last challenge regardless of the ban. He wasn't the same Evan at all. He doesn't post anything about the show anymore while Kenny still does so I think Kenny would have continued to do them.

True but Evan did come back for the Diem Special. It is obviously different but still. 

Actually, it was supposed to be cara, susie, and kina.. They were hoping to get the drama back going from the gauntlet 2

Sorr if this is a little late, but that's not true. Susie replaced Cara, they were never going to be cast together. Kina and Veronica were the original females who stuck with it.

What if Evan and Kenny never got banned? Do you think they both would have still continued to do challenges? 

Personally, I think Kenny would have maybe done 1-2 more after Rivals. I think Kenny could have been paired with Sarah on Battle of the Exes which would have made that season a **** of a lot more interesting and maybe Rivals II (depending if he would have a legit partner) or maybe Free Agents. 

Evan on the other hand, I think would have retired after Rivals anyway. He didn't seem himself on that challenge whatsoever and wasn't into it nearly as much as he was into any of his previous 5 challenges. You could tell he didn't want to be there at all.

Agreed. I think Rivals would have been Evan's last challenge regardless of the ban. He wasn't the same Evan at all. He doesn't post anything about the show anymore while Kenny still does so I think Kenny would have continued to do them.

True but Evan did come back for the Diem Special. It is obviously different but still. 

That's completely different.

Several people said Evan didn't want to be on Rivals at all and he just went to help Johnny/Kenny with some votes. He wanted to leave the whole time because he was focusing on school and missed his gf. I really think he was over the challenges.

What if Coral & Dave Malinosky were on the Duel 2 as they were originally supposed to be.

  What if Jonna wouldn't have lost her passport and got Pete, Noor or Luke as a partner?

landon and carley still would of won.  wes probably would of been eliminated earlier since he wouldnt have ev to back him him up.  

What if they sold challenge jerseys in stores. So you could go and buy a "Sarah" jersey from Exes 2 or a "Frank S" jersey from Rivals 2.

You could also personalize one to put your name. Tbh MTV could make a lot of money off that idea #yourewelcome

  What if Jonna wouldn't have lost her passport and got Pete, Noor or Luke as a partner?

That season would've been a little bit better considering Evelyn wouldn't have been on it.

  What if Jonna wouldn't have lost her passport and got Pete, Noor or Luke as a partner?

That season would've been a little bit better considering Evelyn wouldn't have been on it.

So, so true.

It would've been interesting to see Jonna in that house. For some reason, I always had a hard time imagining her with that cast. She had CJ, but that was it. Who knows what the draft order would've been, but if she got Pete I think they could've done pretty well.

It also depends how in shape Jonna was then. She seemed pretty fit on rivals

  What if Jonna wouldn't have lost her passport and got Pete, Noor or Luke as a partner?

That season would've been a little bit better considering Evelyn wouldn't have been on it.

So, so true.

It would've been interesting to see Jonna in that house. For some reason, I always had a hard time imagining her with that cast. She had CJ, but that was it. Who knows what the draft order would've been, but if she got Pete I think they could've done pretty well.

They would've killed Lost and Found, she's great runner and can solve puzzle, I see her struggling a little in Weight For Me.

Pages