The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if Wes maintained he physique like in the old day (didn't Wes use to be ripped). I feel him and Leroy could've been more interesting.

What if Wes maintained he physique like in the old day (didn't Wes use to be ripped). I feel him and Leroy could've been more interesting.

What if..... Katie was casted on the inferno 2 instead of beth... Would tonya still be the whipping girl? Would katie be on tonya's side or the mean girls... Would veronica and katie go back to hating eachother

What if Zach was paired up with Ashley K instead of Jonna for Exes 2? I think they could've possibly made finals.

Zach & Ashley probably would have won. 8 can't see them doing bad in anything.

I Gotchu Babe: Possible Win.
Rounding The Bases: probably out 2nd Base
On Again, Off Again: Possible Win.
The Brush Off: Possible Win
Open Arms: Possible Win.
Don't Forget About Me: Possible Win.
Are You The One: Possible Win.
Speed Dating: Possible Win.
Wrecking Ball: Possible Win.
Don't Let Go: Possible Win.

I really can't see them struggling with anything physically their biggest problem would be communication, even though they seemed fine on BOTS.

Zach & Ashley probably would have won. 8 can't see them doing bad in anything. I Gotchu Babe: Possible Win. Rounding The Bases: probably out 2nd Base On Again, Off Again: Possible Win. The Brush Off: Possible Win Open Arms: Possible Win. Don't Forget About Me: Possible Win. Are You The One: Possible Win. Speed Dating: Possible Win. Wrecking Ball: Possible Win. Don't Let Go: Possible Win. I really can't see them struggling with anything physically their biggest problem would be communication, even though they seemed fine on BOTS.

I don't remember Ashley being that great. I mean I know she was a good competitor but your making it seem like she in on par with Laurel and Evelyn. What is with Ashley anyway? Is she done with challenges or is she open to coming back or what?

What if Zach was paired up with Ashley K instead of Jonna for Exes 2? I think they could've possibly made finals.

it all depends on if you think ashley would beat sarah in that hammer elimination.  

What if Zach was paired up with Ashley K instead of Jonna for Exes 2? I think they could've possibly made finals.

it all depends on if you think ashley would beat sarah in that hammer elimination.  

 

I honestly don't feel like they would've even seen that elimination.  Jonna was the obvious weak link on the team.  I don't necessarily think Ashley is the greatest but to me she did impress on Seasons.  Her cardio and will surpassed Sam's and most of the other girls on that cast.

 

I HOPE she comes back but I'm not sure if she ever would or what her story is.

What if..... Katie was casted on the inferno 2 instead of beth... Would tonya still be the whipping girl? Would katie be on tonya's side or the mean girls... Would veronica and katie go back to hating eachother

Has Tonya and Katie ever been on a challenge together in the Golden Era? Back when both where the whipping girl and had animosity with the mean girl/Veronica? I know they were on the Ruins, but Veronica wasn't a bully then.

Tonya & Katie were on The Gauntlet & BOTSexes 2 together but Tonya was still somewhat with the "in-crowd" on Sexes 2. I do remember there was a unaired scene during the "reunion" for Inferno 2 where Tonya called Katie on the phone & told her everything the other girls were doing...around the Gauntlet 2/Fresh Meat time period they actually started randomly hating each other **** Tonya said something about it on her True Life episode & both of them went into more detail about it on Kill Reality.

What if Zach was paired up with Ashley K instead of Jonna for Exes 2? I think they could've possibly made finals.

it all depends on if you think ashley would beat sarah in that hammer elimination.  

 

I honestly don't feel like they would've even seen that elimination.  Jonna was the obvious weak link on the team.  I don't necessarily think Ashley is the greatest but to me she did impress on Seasons.  Her cardio and will surpassed Sam's and most of the other girls on that cast.

 

I HOPE she comes back but I'm not sure if she ever would or what her story is.

heiiii. Jonna was not the weak link! Zach lost to guy with one hand in eliminationround where you need both hands. I think that already shows why they lost and sure as **** that was not Jonnas fault.

Also, Zach disgusting personality screwed things up. Jonna did really great this season. Only thing she screwed up was that mini finale.

And I do not think Ashley is THAT great. Tbh I have not seen her doing anything good. Next to Sam all SD team members looked better. Jfc how overrated this girl is. Kinda think she is like Mandi or something

Zach & Ashley probably would have won. 8 can't see them doing bad in anything. I Gotchu Babe: Possible Win. Rounding The Bases: probably out 2nd Base On Again, Off Again: Possible Win. The Brush Off: Possible Win Open Arms: Possible Win. Don't Forget About Me: Possible Win. Are You The One: Possible Win. Speed Dating: Possible Win. Wrecking Ball: Possible Win. Don't Let Go: Possible Win. I really can't see them struggling with anything physically their biggest problem would be communication, even though they seemed fine on BOTS.

You have real high hopes. They wouldn't have won the swimming related ones. Speed dating zach would have still messed up. 

What if Zach was paired up with Ashley K instead of Jonna for Exes 2? I think they could've possibly made finals.

it all depends on if you think ashley would beat sarah in that hammer elimination.  

 

I honestly don't feel like they would've even seen that elimination.  Jonna was the obvious weak link on the team.  I don't necessarily think Ashley is the greatest but to me she did impress on Seasons.  Her cardio and will surpassed Sam's and most of the other girls on that cast.

 

I HOPE she comes back but I'm not sure if she ever would or what her story is.

heiiii. Jonna was not the weak link! Zach lost to guy with one hand in eliminationround where you need both hands. I think that already shows why they lost and sure as **** that was not Jonnas fault. Also, Zach disgusting personality screwed things up. Jonna did really great this season. Only thing she screwed up was that mini finale. And I do not think Ashley is THAT great. Tbh I have not seen her doing anything good. Next to Sam all SD team members looked better. Jfc how overrated this girl is. Kinda think she is like Mandi or something

Agree, agree, agree.

I think she is better than Mandi.. But otherwise, agree 100%. I literally chuckled at Jonna being called the weak link.

What if Zach was paired up with Ashley K instead of Jonna for Exes 2? I think they could've possibly made finals.

it all depends on if you think ashley would beat sarah in that hammer elimination.  

 

I honestly don't feel like they would've even seen that elimination.  Jonna was the obvious weak link on the team.  I don't necessarily think Ashley is the greatest but to me she did impress on Seasons.  Her cardio and will surpassed Sam's and most of the other girls on that cast.

 

I HOPE she comes back but I'm not sure if she ever would or what her story is.

heiiii. Jonna was not the weak link! Zach lost to guy with one hand in eliminationround where you need both hands. I think that already shows why they lost and sure as **** that was not Jonnas fault. Also, Zach disgusting personality screwed things up. Jonna did really great this season. Only thing she screwed up was that mini finale. And I do not think Ashley is THAT great. Tbh I have not seen her doing anything good. Next to Sam all SD team members looked better. Jfc how overrated this girl is. Kinda think she is like Mandi or something

Trust me, I greatly prefer Jonna to Zach...he's one of the people I dislike the most...but I don't think it's true that she only had that one mess up. She panicked and fell during the first challenge (though she did have to pull the biggest guy there), she couldn't swim in the third one and had to hold onto Zach's back, and she got both of their wrong answers during trivia. She was much better than Zach gave her credit for, and he was a shit partner the whole time, but she still wasn't that good. 

I would take Ashley Kelsey over her though. She didn't put up a single bad performance on Battle of the Seasons and pretty much breezed through the final. 

What if Zach was paired up with Ashley K instead of Jonna for Exes 2? I think they could've possibly made finals.

it all depends on if you think ashley would beat sarah in that hammer elimination.  

 

I honestly don't feel like they would've even seen that elimination.  Jonna was the obvious weak link on the team.  I don't necessarily think Ashley is the greatest but to me she did impress on Seasons.  Her cardio and will surpassed Sam's and most of the other girls on that cast.

 

I HOPE she comes back but I'm not sure if she ever would or what her story is.

heiiii. Jonna was not the weak link! Zach lost to guy with one hand in eliminationround where you need both hands. I think that already shows why they lost and sure as **** that was not Jonnas fault. Also, Zach disgusting personality screwed things up. Jonna did really great this season. Only thing she screwed up was that mini finale. And I do not think Ashley is THAT great. Tbh I have not seen her doing anything good. Next to Sam all SD team members looked better. Jfc how overrated this girl is. Kinda think she is like Mandi or something

Zach didn't lose by much and neither did Jonna. it was a pretty darn close elimination. it was both Zach and Jonna's fault 50/50. If Zach got destroyed by Jonna then maybe i would say Zach screwed up, but he didn't.

Also i yes even I'll admit Zach was a major *****, but you have to realize Jonna didn't perform all that well this season. It wasn't just the mini-finale. Jonna screwed up on the truck mission, the first missin she fell, and in one of the swimming missions she had to piggy back on Zach. I'm not saying she is a terrible competitor as zach makes her out to be, but you can't deny Jonna was part of the reson for their downfall.

How she ****** up truck mission? If I remember correctly idiots big *** was the one who cost them the win.

I think someone might have said this on here but what if the Bad ***** team on Inferno II also had Coral and Katie, along with the other five girls? That would've made that season more awesome than it already was. A Coral vs. Julie Inferno would've been epic Dirol 

I think for On Again, Off Again they would have won because they seem to be decent swimmers and I feel Ashley could have held on longer to make up time (because Sarah fell early). So my "high hopes" are more calculated than you think buuut imma fall back and sip my tea

Jordan, Sarah, Wes are the best swimmers, not only in that challenge but overall(there are few more ofcourse). There is no way Zach and Ashley could have won that.

How she ****** up truck mission? If I remember correctly idiots big *** was the one who cost them the win.

Trust me, he will find a reason to blame Jonna for the reason why they didn't win that mission. He has a hard on for Zach.

What if there was no EX-ile on BTOE2? The house wouldn't have ganged up on Wes/Theresa (Leroy was on their side).

Jay/Jenna finish last on "Wrecking Ball," and gotten crushed by whoever would've been voted in.

And Wes/Theresa would've won the final. 

What if there was no EX-ile on BTOE2? The house wouldn't have ganged up on Wes/Theresa (Leroy was on their side).

Jay/Jenna finish last on "Wrecking Ball," and gotten crushed by whoever would've been voted in.

And Wes/Theresa would've won the final. 

I think they would have won. They would have beat Jordan/Sarah in the last elimination

(New here) Not sure if this has been said but what if zach hadn't screwed up speed dating and him and jonna won that challenge? 

(New here) Not sure if this has been said but what if zach hadn't screwed up speed dating and him and jonna won that challenge? 

Zach and Jonna send in Leroy and Nia against Jordan and Sarah.

What if Tina and Rachel were on The Ruins?

who wins between those two though? I would say Jordan and Sarah just because of technique but it's a toss up to me

How she ****** up truck mission? If I remember correctly idiots big *** was the one who cost them the win.

Trust me, he will find a reason to blame Jonna for the reason why they didn't win that mission. He has a hard on for Zach.

and i like it how u choose to ignore all my other evidences of Jonna messing up at a mission

(New here) Not sure if this has been said but what if zach hadn't screwed up speed dating and him and jonna won that challenge? 

Zach and Jonna send in Leroy and Nia against Jordan and Sarah.


Tbh it is hard one bc Zach and Jordan still get along altho Johnny R keeps them close, but at the same time there are Jenna and Wes ....

if Zach sended Leroy in, I think Leroy and Nia would have won bc Leroy is not that dumb like Zach is...

(New here) Not sure if this has been said but what if zach hadn't screwed up speed dating and him and jonna won that challenge? 

i think zach would have asked Jordan who he wanted, and Jordan would have said Wes. Jordan said he wanted nia in the final because she wouldn't be able to last. Jordan also said he didn't want to see Wes and Theresa in there. I'm not sure if this is true, but I read somewhere here he was asking for Wes.

Jonna wasn't the weak link. Zach shit the bed all season long, he didn't compete well and he was a horrible partner.. Ashley/Zach would have done better soley because Zach wouldn't have disrespected Ashley the way he did Jonna or at least not to her face. The one time he tried to be a **** to her on Seasons, she immeditaely went off on him and he shutup. It sucks Jonna wasn't that way but he took away all her confidence : (

Team Jonna<3

Pages