The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if Season 27 gets killer ratings like 2 or 3 million viewers?

Thatd be perfecttt

What if Season 27 gets killer ratings like 2 or 3 million viewers?

The plan to kill the show will have failed and to rectify it Season 28 will be Rivals 3

What if Rivals2 was with Alton with CJ(altho he had fights with Zach and Frank too) Also BOTS2, Dustin&Trishelle vs Marie&Robb in Hall Brawl?

Marie would've destroyed Trashelle but Dustin would've beat Robb so it would go down to a sudden death match. 


Robb now would crush Dustin. But skinny Robb probably would have lost

I think Robb could have given Dustin a run for his money

I think Robb could have given Dustin a run for his money

Yeah I personally think Robb would've beaten him

jordan and nia probably would have went after the top teams and end up getting eliminated early

jordan and nia probably would have went after the top teams and end up getting eliminated early

I have no Idea why but I laughed so hard at this post.

I had a random dream on this so I want to ask it.

What if, after Spring Break Challenge instead of putting Camila on Cutthroat they put her on The Real World first? How would you have reacted to this?

 

I had a random dream on this so I want to ask it.

What if, after Spring Break Challenge instead of putting Camila on Cutthroat they put her on The Real World first? How would you have reacted to this?

 

That would be a terrible move..but the right one. She would be a real castmember and have a right to be on the challenges then.

Well if you think about it, if she were to get cast for a Real World season first, she would most likely be on San Diego season. Which means her first challenge would be Seasons, Rivals 2, or Free Agents. Maybe even not be on any challenges since we only see like 2-4 people from every newer RW season

Well if you think about it, if she were to get cast for a Real World season first, she would most likely be on San Diego season. Which means her first challenge would be Seasons, Rivals 2, or Free Agents. Maybe even not be on any challenges since we only see like 2-4 people from every newer RW season

That would be a good thing.

 

Well if you think about it, if she were to get cast for a Real World season first, she would most likely be on San Diego season. Which means her first challenge would be Seasons, Rivals 2, or Free Agents. Maybe even not be on any challenges since we only see like 2-4 people from every newer RW season

That would be a good thing.

 

You wouldn't be the only one that would like that. 

A seasons team of frank, zach, Ashley and Camilla would be too stacked.

StuffAndThings
Anonymous's picture

A seasons team of frank, zach, Ashley and Camilla would be too stacked.

Ugh...just reading that makes me want to throw up.

I would have probably enjoyed and watch the San Diego 2 season

A seasons team of frank, zach, Ashley and Camilla would be too stacked.

Ugh...just reading that makes me want to throw up.

Frank Zach Marie Camila Wink

A seasons team of frank, zach, Ashley and Camilla would be too stacked.

But entertaining 

What if Ruthie didn't get eliminated on The Duel II? It sucks how most of the challenges after Ruthie's elimination were individual and involved heights. I think Ruthie would've excelled in those missions and would've made the finals. It'd be a super close final between Rachel and Ruthie. Seeing Ruthie win her first challenge would've been great. I think she's really underrated. Even Rachel admitted that Ruthie was her biggest competition in the game. 

I wish Ruthie would come back.  I read in a comment to one of her Youtube videos that she doesn't get "second calls" anymore (not sure what that means, if someone could elaborate?)

Didnt she have a twin?  I want them on Bloodlines!! #dreaming

But yes, a Ruthie/Rachel showdown would've been a lot better than seeing Rachel dominate two competitors that you knew she could take...

I wish Ruthie would come back.  I read in a comment to one of her Youtube videos that she doesn't get "second calls" anymore (not sure what that means, if someone could elaborate?)

Didnt she have a twin?  I want them on Bloodlines!! #dreaming

But yes, a Ruthie/Rachel showdown would've been a lot better than seeing Rachel dominate two competitors that you knew she could take...

Production calls people to see if they're available and these are known as first calls. If production wants to cast them for sure on the challenge, they call them again and let them know they're going to be on next season. Ruthie stopped getting second calls after Duel II )= 

I remember Ruthie had a twin, seeing them together on Bloodlines would be everything!!!!

She was hands down the best girl on Battle of the Sexes. Her outperforming all the guys in the Maximum Velocity mission is one of my favorite moments in Challenge history! Even though she got eliminated early on The Duel II, she still impressed me. Ruthie beating Brittini and Tori in her heat was really impressive because those girls are twice the size of her. I want Ruthie to come back so bad. She deserves to win. A Free Agents/Duel format would be perfect for her. 

I agree.  In all my "fantasy cast" lists I always pencil her in.  I think Battle of the Sexes 2 was sort've weird for her.  She could've easily taken Arissa's spot in the final 3 but there were a lot of politics in that season that turned me off.

Id take her ANY DAY over ANY of these new girls..

I wish Ruthie would come back.  I read in a comment to one of her Youtube videos that she doesn't get "second calls" anymore (not sure what that means, if someone could elaborate?)

Didnt she have a twin?  I want them on Bloodlines!! #dreaming

But yes, a Ruthie/Rachel showdown would've been a lot better than seeing Rachel dominate two competitors that you knew she could take...

Production calls people to see if they're available and these are known as first calls. If production wants to cast them for sure on the challenge, they call them again and let them know they're going to be on next season. Ruthie stopped getting second calls after Duel II )= 

I remember Ruthie had a twin, seeing them together on Bloodlines would be everything!!!!

She was hands down the best girl on Battle of the Sexes. Her outperforming all the guys in the Maximum Velocity mission is one of my favorite moments in Challenge history! Even though she got eliminated early on The Duel II, she still impressed me. Ruthie beating Brittini and Tori in her heat was really impressive because those girls are twice the size of her. I want Ruthie to come back so bad. She deserves to win. A Free Agents/Duel format would be perfect for her. 

Sad thing is she is still very much interested smh Ruthie was one of the premier RWers in that age & now she can't even get a second call...

I wish Ruthie would come back.  I read in a comment to one of her Youtube videos that she doesn't get "second calls" anymore (not sure what that means, if someone could elaborate?)

Didnt she have a twin?  I want them on Bloodlines!! #dreaming

But yes, a Ruthie/Rachel showdown would've been a lot better than seeing Rachel dominate two competitors that you knew she could take...

Production calls people to see if they're available and these are known as first calls. If production wants to cast them for sure on the challenge, they call them again and let them know they're going to be on next season. Ruthie stopped getting second calls after Duel II )= 

I remember Ruthie had a twin, seeing them together on Bloodlines would be everything!!!!

She was hands down the best girl on Battle of the Sexes. Her outperforming all the guys in the Maximum Velocity mission is one of my favorite moments in Challenge history! Even though she got eliminated early on The Duel II, she still impressed me. Ruthie beating Brittini and Tori in her heat was really impressive because those girls are twice the size of her. I want Ruthie to come back so bad. She deserves to win. A Free Agents/Duel format would be perfect for her. 

Sad thing is she is still very much interested smh Ruthie was one of the premier RWers in that age & now she can't even get a second call...

Yeah. She was a big name just going by how she was and what she dealt with on her RW season. Ruthie is really one of the few old-schoolers I would love to see return. It's a shame they don't ask her anymore because she really should get another shot.

i wish ruthie got the aneesa treatment.  getting calls back despite being an old school cast member

I think Robb could have given Dustin a run for his money

i think at that time it would have gone 2/3 but still with Dustin winning.

What if the pairs for auto body rally during free agents were the pairs for the whole game?
Who makes the final?
Bananas & Jonna
Brandon & LaToya
Cohutta & Laurel
CT & Emilee
Dustin & Nany
Frank & Nia
Isaac & Devyn
Johnny & Cara Maria
Jordan & Jasmine
Leroy & Jessica
Preston & Camila
Swift & Theresa
Zach & Aneesa

What if the pairs for auto body rally during free agents were the pairs for the whole game? Who makes the final? Bananas & Jonna Brandon & LaToya Cohutta & Laurel CT & Emilee Dustin & Nany Frank & Nia Isaac & Devyn Johnny & Cara Maria Jordan & Jasmine Leroy & Jessica Preston & Camila Swift & Theresa Zach & Aneesa

the third spot would be a toss up between Frank & Nia, and Cohutta & Laurel. 

What if the pairs for auto body rally during free agents were the pairs for the whole game? Who makes the final? Bananas & Jonna Brandon & LaToya Cohutta & Laurel CT & Emilee Dustin & Nany Frank & Nia Isaac & Devyn Johnny & Cara Maria Jordan & Jasmine Leroy & Jessica Preston & Camila Swift & Theresa Zach & Aneesa

the third spot would be a toss up between Frank & Nia, and Cohutta & Laurel. 

Dustin and Nany would make the final instead of Frank and Nia imo.

What if the pairs for auto body rally during free agents were the pairs for the whole game? Who makes the final? Bananas & Jonna Brandon & LaToya Cohutta & Laurel CT & Emilee Dustin & Nany Frank & Nia Isaac & Devyn Johnny & Cara Maria Jordan & Jasmine Leroy & Jessica Preston & Camila Swift & Theresa Zach & Aneesa

the third spot would be a toss up between Frank & Nia, and Cohutta & Laurel. 

Dustin and Nany would make the final instead of Frank and Nia imo.

 

Dustin is average. He'll mess up in a challenge, and send them both home. 

What if the pairs for auto body rally during free agents were the pairs for the whole game? Who makes the final? Bananas & Jonna Brandon & LaToya Cohutta & Laurel CT & Emilee Dustin & Nany Frank & Nia Isaac & Devyn Johnny & Cara Maria Jordan & Jasmine Leroy & Jessica Preston & Camila Swift & Theresa Zach & Aneesa

the third spot would be a toss up between Frank & Nia, and Cohutta & Laurel. 

Dustin and Nany would make the final instead of Frank and Nia imo.

 

Dustin is average. He'll mess up in a challenge, and send them both home. 

Nia is pretty average too.

Pages