The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

ya but my point is.... does production actually care? they made cara do the wall with broken hand ( more or less the knew jordan was doing the wall as well) i dont think they would care to much to alter their plans to make the elimination more fair,

 

again what happened , happened. which is why it is a what if Smile

What I meant is that if CT would have beat Bananas in the last elimination, who would have won the final, CT or Johnny R.?
Well if we base it off of Rivals final, then Johnny R. Smile I feel like devyn was the defining factor in that final (who dealt w her, was the most patient, ect) anyways. Reilly got her on the hardest leg (climbing up that mountain), but had Banana's gotten her, it could've been a whole different ball game

 

Which makes Zach even a bigger idiot since he had Devyn, at the easiest leg. He definietly could have made the time gap smaller if not, won had he not thrown a ***** fit with Laurel. But shit happens, right?

What if I saved money on my car insurance?

lol @richjoe92

 

What if a Road Rules team did appear on Battle of the Seasons?  imo they would have whooped all their butts Wink

What if Trishelle didn't quit Rivals 2?  I think her and Sarah would have gotten a shot at first.

What if Sarah G lost her first Gauntlet (glad she didn't)...I think the outcome for the girls on the first Gauntlet could have been a lot different. 

What if Evelyn took Johnny's key on The Island and permanently eliminated him from the game?

What if diem didn't get sick on BOTE2 and she and ct could have finished the competition?

What if diem didn't get sick on BOTE2 and she and ct could have finished the competition?

They would have won.

I agree and maybe things wouldn't have been so ugly between everyone else. 

I agree and maybe things wouldn't have been so ugly between everyone else. 

I think you're right. Diem was a peacemaker. She showed that again when she was there for Avery.

What if diem didn't get sick on BOTE2 and she and ct could have finished the competition?

They would have won.

I'm trying to be real sensitive about this but I don't believe CT & Diem would have won...I don't think Diem could have done the food--CT handled all of it for her on the first Exes.  There's no way she knocks back 4 of those drinks--no way.  She'd have been in the same spot as Jay IMO.  There was more swimming and biking on this one--not Diem's strength either.  Who knows who else would have been in the final against them but I doubt Jay/Jenna make it if they stay and I highly doubt CT/Diem would have won.  This just wasn't a final that catered to Diem's strengths...which is long distance running

I agree and maybe things wouldn't have been so ugly between everyone else. 

What if diem didn't get sick on BOTE2 and she and ct could have finished the competition?

They would have won.

And the season wouldn't be nearly as good as it was.

What if the Free Agents last draw put 

Zach vs Bananas

and 

Devyn vs Theresa

 

and the final was Laurel/Nany/Theresa and CT/Bananas/Johnny R.

 

Who wins 1st, 2nd, and 3rd?

lol @richjoe92

 

What if a Road Rules team did appear on Battle of the Seasons?  imo they would have whooped all their butts Wink

What if Trishelle didn't quit Rivals 2?  I think her and Sarah would have gotten a shot at first.

What if Sarah G lost her first Gauntlet (glad she didn't)...I think the outcome for the girls on the first Gauntlet could have been a lot different. 


Trashelle sucks, no way they would have won.

I'm trying to be real sensitive about this but I don't believe CT & Diem would have won...I don't think Diem could have done the food--CT handled all of it for her on the first Exes.  There's no way she knocks back 4 of those drinks--no way.  She'd have been in the same spot as Jay IMO.  There was more swimming and biking on this one--not Diem's strength either.  Who knows who else would have been in the final against them but I doubt Jay/Jenna make it if they stay and I highly doubt CT/Diem would have won.  This just wasn't a final that catered to Diem's strengths...which is long distance running


CT ate the food because she doesn't eat meat. She might have still ate that fish ****. I agree tho this final wasn't nearly enough running for girls like Diem & Paula.

What if Bananas would've pushed Wes instead of Ev when he was yelling on The Ruins Episode 2?

What if Bananas would've pushed Wes instead of Ev when he was yelling on The Ruins Episode 2?

Evelyn deserved it. plus he gave her a soft push, not this 'life-changing' push Jason apparently gave Nicole.


What if DummyBear didn't quit the eliminaiton on Rivals 2. how far do ya think him and Tyrie would have gone?


What if DummyBear didn't quit the eliminaiton on Rivals 2. how far do ya think him and Tyrie would have gone?

To the next elimination


What if DummyBear didn't quit the eliminaiton on Rivals 2. how far do ya think him and Tyrie would have gone?

To the next elimination

prove it.

how on earth is that possible lol!  they would of probably lost sooner rather than later tbh

What if the Free Agents last draw put 

Zach vs Bananas

and 

Devyn vs Theresa

 

and the final was Laurel/Nany/Theresa and CT/Bananas/Johnny R.

 

Who wins 1st, 2nd, and 3rd?

1st - CT and Laurel

2nd - Bananas and Theresa

3rd - Johnny and Nany

What if Evelyn took Johnny's key on The Island and permanently eliminated him from the game?

Johnny isn't on the champions team for Ruins, and has 2 less championships.  Same results as "What if Abe didn't ask to be kicked off?"


Also, the winners of the Island is most likely Kenny, Derrick, Paula, and Dunbar.

 

What if the Free Agents last draw put 

Zach vs Bananas

and 

Devyn vs Theresa

 

and the final was Laurel/Nany/Theresa and CT/Bananas/Johnny R.

 

Who wins 1st, 2nd, and 3rd?

1st - CT and Laurel

2nd - Bananas and Theresa

3rd - Johnny and Nany

it would have been really close but I think Bananas would have still won. He was out to redeem himself from Rivals 2 and looked to be in great shape. Nany still would have taken second. Especially because Theresa had a hurt ankle during the show. Theresa also needed a break when climbing on the mountain on Exes 2 while I don't remember Nany taking breaks. Either way if Theresa was healthy it would be a close race for second. 

Theresa also needed a break when climbing on the mountain on Exes 2 while I don't remember Nany taking breaks. Either way if Theresa was healthy it would be a close race for second. 

Nana took a break during her tarantula freakout.

What if the Free Agents last draw put 

Zach vs Bananas

and 

Devyn vs Theresa

 

and the final was Laurel/Nany/Theresa and CT/Bananas/Johnny R.

 

Who wins 1st, 2nd, and 3rd?

1st - CT and Laurel

2nd - Bananas and Theresa

3rd - Johnny and Nany

it would have been really close but I think Bananas would have still won. He was out to redeem himself from Rivals 2 and looked to be in great shape. Nany still would have taken second. Especially because Theresa had a hurt ankle during the show. Theresa also needed a break when climbing on the mountain on Exes 2 while I don't remember Nany taking breaks. Either way if Theresa was healthy it would be a close race for second. 


Nany took a meltdown break lol

Theresa also needed a break when climbing on the mountain on Exes 2 while I don't remember Nany taking breaks. Either way if Theresa was healthy it would be a close race for second. 

Nana took a break during her tarantula freakout.

All of 5 seconds when she screamed lol Theresa literally sat down cause she was tired. 


What if DummyBear didn't quit the eliminaiton on Rivals 2. how far do ya think him and Tyrie would have gone?

They both suck lol so episode 3

lol @richjoe92

 

What if a Road Rules team did appear on Battle of the Seasons?  imo they would have whooped all their butts Wink

What if Trishelle didn't quit Rivals 2?  I think her and Sarah would have gotten a shot at first.

What if Sarah G lost her first Gauntlet (glad she didn't)...I think the outcome for the girls on the first Gauntlet could have been a lot different. 

Trashelle sucks, no way they would have won.

disgree, she was strong imo in Seasons 2...she may have sucked back in the day, but she came back a good competitor imo, her and sarah would have went far.

Pages