The Challenge: What Ifs

2445 posts / 0 new
Last post
[QUOTE=kvm1977;419694]Depends who you're bumping off the rookies team...Alton was never going to call out Landon or MJ...maybe if Derrick replaced MJ or Jamie but I think Alton would have called him out before Jamie, Landon or MJ. Remember Kina called out Jillian though the guys wanted her to go against Ibis. I don't think those 3 girls could have saved Derrick.[/QUOTE] I agree. Even though the girls could have tried to influence Alton, the Rookies on G2 played the game so as to let their team captain choose who they wanted to go against. Alton always did what was best for the team, and I definitely think he would've called out Derrick before Landon and Jamie. MJ might be debatable, but I think he would save MJ over Derrick.
[QUOTE=Youssarian;419705]I agree. Even though the girls could have tried to influence Alton, the Rookies on G2 played the game so as to let their team captain choose who they wanted to go against. Alton always did what was best for the team, and I definitely think he would've called out Derrick before Landon and Jamie. MJ might be debatable, but I think he would save MJ over Derrick.[/QUOTE] Kina would have also been more concerned about Randy than Derrick
[QUOTE=kvm1977;419711]Kina would have also been more concerned about Randy than Derrick[/QUOTE] Hahaha I totally forgot about Randy. Actually, I think a choice between Randy or Derrick might've gone either way for Alton... but in that case, Kina would definitely have campaigned for Randy to stay.
[QUOTE=Youssarian;419713]Hahaha I totally forgot about Randy. Actually, I think a choice between Randy or Derrick might've gone either way for Alton... but in that case, Kina would definitely have campaigned for Randy to stay.[/QUOTE] Randy was very forgettable. I think Alton would have gone after Derrick first just because Derrick was smaller.
What if trashelle quit the same time Naomi did and they paired up Cooke & Sarah?
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;419747]What if trashelle quit the same time Naomi did and they paired up Cooke & Sarah?[/QUOTE] Cooke & Sarah finish second
[QUOTE=toenails;419581]If Derrick had never done Battle of the Sexes 2 ([COLOR=#ff0000]in which he lasted like 2 episodes[/COLOR]), he would have been on the Rookies team for The Gauntlet 2 with all of his fellow X-Treme castmates. Kina would have probably convinced Alton to never call out Derrick, and Derrick probably would have won that Challenge.[/QUOTE] He actually lasted 5 episodes
Here is a what if that has probably been asked before. What would the final teams have looked like on The Ruins if Shauvon, Tonya, Brad, and Darrell had not left due to injuries or disqualifications?
What if Trishelle quit Rivals II before Naomi left, allowing Sarah to get Cara Maria as a replacement partner instead of Cooke? How far could they have ultimately gotten? Would this team have done as well as the Cooke/CM team did?
[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;419855]What if Trishelle quit Rivals II before Naomi left, allowing Sarah to get Cara Maria as a replacement partner instead of Cooke? How far could they have ultimately gotten? Would this team have done as well as the Cooke/CM team did?[/QUOTE] Probably would have had the same result. Cara Maria & Sarah would have still came runner up to Emily & Paula in the final challenge. Plus I thought it would be more fitting to have Cara Maria as a replacement for Sarah because you could articulate it better since they have somewhat of a rivalry from Cutthroat. Then they could have tried to get Heather as Cooke's replacement. So what if that happened? Cara Maria replaced Trishelle as Sarah's partner and Heather replaced Naomi as Cooke's partner. How would that have changed things?
What if the black team took Johnny's advice and sent Dustin balls in to face frank
If Naomi hadn't left early on Rivals II then I think the final 3 teams would have been Emily/Paula, Camila/Jemmye, and Aneesa/Diem or Jonna/Nany.
[QUOTE=El Scorcho;422313]If Naomi hadn't left early on Rivals II then I think the final 3 teams would have been Emily/Paula, Camila/Jemmye, and Aneesa/Diem or Jonna/Nany.[/QUOTE] Aneesa/Diem probably.
What if Sarah was on Free Agents? I believe she would have done very well in this format not having to constantly worry about a weak partner or team. She probably would have been a lock for the final and would've had a decent chance at winning. I think it goes without saying Laurel would've been her toughest competition as far as winning it all is concerned.
I think she could win because puzzles might screw laurel up
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;422504]I think she could win because puzzles might screw laurel up[/QUOTE] Sarah's not flawless at puzzles though... see Rivals. I think she definitely would've made the competition more interesting than someone like, say, Emilee.
[QUOTE=Youssarian;422509]Sarah's not flawless at puzzles though... see Rivals. I think she definitely would've made the competition more interesting than someone like, say, Emilee.[/QUOTE] She's still better then Laurel in puzzles
[QUOTE=Youssarian;422509]Sarah's not flawless at puzzles though... see Rivals. I think she definitely would've made the competition more interesting than someone like, say, Emilee.[/QUOTE] I'd still rather have seen Emilee than Sarah for the umpteenth time.
I'd rather see Emilee than Jazmin, Jemmye or Aneesa.
[QUOTE=dylan76;422515]I'd still rather have seen Emilee than Sarah for the umpteenth time.[/QUOTE] I agree. I love Sarah, but she definitely needed a break. Now that she's had one it will be great to see her again.
[QUOTE=dylan76;422515]I'd still rather have seen Emilee than Sarah for the umpteenth time.[/QUOTE] Why, Emilee sucks Sarah is [B]MUCH[/B] better then Emilee will ever be
[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;422517]I agree. I love Sarah, but she definitely needed a break. Now that she's had one it will be great to see her again.[/QUOTE] She should have took rivals 2 off instead IMO
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;422519]She should have took rivals 2 off instead IMO[/QUOTE] There's some truth to that.
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;422518]Why, Emilee sucks Sarah is [B]MUCH[/B] better then Emilee will ever be[/QUOTE] Sarah is annoying. I'll take the far hotter Emilee over her any day.
[QUOTE=JayTee;422516]I'd rather see Emilee than Jazmin, Jemmye or Aneesa.[/QUOTE] Out of curiosity, why? Is it simply because of her looks? No harm in that, but you've stressed in the past your vast preference towards stronger competitors and, well, Emilee is not the epitome of great competitor.
[QUOTE=dylan76;422522]Sarah is annoying. I'll take the far hotter Emilee over her any day.[/QUOTE] IMO Sarah is hotter, I never got why people think Emilee is so attractive
I don't see why everyone says Sarah is good at puzzles? She did poorly on the Ruins final puzzle Susie and EVAN beat her, on Cutthroat Abram won Gas Problems for the team and she didn't make it to the puzzle phase of the final, she did poorly on the simple puzzle in her elimination on rivals losing to Jonna and Jasmine, she lost her exile on fresh meat and Vinny finished the first puzzle, she struggled a bit on the 2nd one, 3rd she did pretty good, BOTE she didn't have to do any puzzles, In BOTS2 she did pretty good on puzzles as her team won Logged out and her and Chet beat Cara and Brandon in Knot So Fast, however neither of those 2 are rocket scientists, and then she didn't do any puzzles on Rivals 2. I don't see what all the hype is about she lost 3 times in puzzle heavy eliminations/finals and won twice.
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;422534]IMO Sarah is hotter, I never got why people think Emilee is so attractive[/QUOTE] In my opinion Emilee is cute, but nothing special. I can't believe how changed Sarah is, she looked completely different on the Ruins.
I still don't get the big fuss over Emilee. Not ugly, but stunning or anything.
well, lets get this one out of the way, what if the final elimination on free agents was physical, something similar to X-Battle, or the elevator, or push me or some combination elimination like Ascender or Spot On?

Pages