Xtreme can go either way for me. San Diego/Philly/Xtreme are tough to place. You also pretty much wat an even number in each era. Jillian & Ibis are more JEK era in my mind even though they debuted prior to FM. Jodi & Kina are more difficult for me to place
Ughhhhhh why did Queen Brittini not wanna come back after Duel 2? The era she came in was absolute garbage though, maybe Fresh Meat 2/Cutthroat would've been good fits for her.
Jodi & Kina's Last Challenge was Bananas' first. Def Golden Era to me. Not even a question.
Ibis- did 2 challenges before any of JEK even debuted, and then was basically non-existent on the one she did after. Def Golden Era.
Jillian- valid argument for her to be JEK era. Only did 1 challenge prior to JEK, and 2 after where she did well.
On a different note, funny how the X-treme girls all did 3 challenges minus Angela.
Yeah. I'd put all the Xtreme girls in the golden era because that's when the all debuted.
Why did you guys wait until polls closed to say something? lol We could have had a discussion about this.I was looking past who debuted when and where for some and thought about impact, allies and rivalires that even crossed eras. Besides Robin who I still lump in JEK bc that's where alliagence was, the x-treme girls + Susie and Cara's debuts were overshadowed by other rookies/regulars/vets of the Golden era and they made a bigger name for themselves during G2 and on.
The period I'm trying to highlight conists of:- The non-Mean Girl cliques: X-treme, Austin-VR, Drama Mafia alliances (Robin, Jodi, Ibis, Kina, Diem, Tori, Johanna, Melinda, Rachel M.)- The rookie girls that rivaled those cliques (Jillian, Svetlana, Cara and Susie)- The girls that aligned with JEK as a group, duo or idv. (Kina, Jodi, Robin, Diem, Paula, Casey, Jenn, Janelle, Evelyn (The Island))- The girls that rivaled JEK as a group, duo or idv. (Evelyn, Susie, Cara, KellyAnne)
- Fresh Meat + JEK Dynasty (Diem, Paula, Jenn, Casey, Robin)- The RW/RR debuters between FM and FM2 (Austin, Key West, Denver, Viewers' Revenge, Hollywood, Sydney, Brooklyn (Sarah))
What do we call that period of the Challenge?
I think your split was fine...people will always complain
Essential Season(s): Extreme, Sexes, Sexes 2
Essential Season(s): Gauntlet 3, The Island, Ruins
Essential Season(s): Seasons (2012), Rivals II
Jemmye's a top 20 girl in this era--sigh--explaines why so many want old schoolers back
Ayanna being ahead of Holly S, Jamie & Kendal disappoints me
Jemmye's a top 20 girl in this era--sigh--explaines why so many want old schoolers backAyanna being ahead of Holly S, Jamie & Kendal disappoints me
No. That's just Nostalgia.
Ok bye I was not complaining, merely discussing. Funny how the same that complained about people complaining then complain when the list doesn't meet their requirements.
kvm1977 wrote:Jemmye's a top 20 girl in this era--sigh--explaines why so many want old schoolers backAyanna being ahead of Holly S, Jamie & Kendal disappoints meNo. That's just Nostalgia.
kvm1977 wrote:Jemmye's a top 20 girl in this era--sigh--explaines why so many want old schoolers backAyanna being ahead of Holly S, Jamie & Kendal disappoints me
Im good. Bri is coming at that number 1 spot, so the others should be worried
Unfortunately she wasn’t even included in the poll lmaooo.
Essential Season(s): Seasons
Essential Season(s): Gauntlet 3, Duel II, Cutthroat
Essential Season(s): Free Agents
The summaries are well done.
Question, I havent been following but is this list based purely off competition or a variety of characteristics?
Various characteristics described in OP.
@kvm thank you!
Essential Season(s): Sexes
Essential Season(s): Gauntlet 2, The Duel
Okay, let's just pretend that Season XXX is Marie Roda's second challenge -- no, let's be real, fans of the show genuinely like Marie but she definitely suffered from a Sophomore slump for someone that was in such high demand for a return. Stand Your Ground: Marie on Battle of the Seasons (2012) was so loud and abrasive as hell... but she was for a good reason, Marie took no shit from the players that were running the game. Too bad it was from guys like Frank, Zach and Knight and not guys like Bananas. Marie was the head bitch of her team of misfits St. Thomas. St. Thomas were the rookiest of rookies just based on being the more recent season and weren't apart of the big alliances. Yet it was Marie's social game that secured her team a few weeks of safety before it was their time to finally see an elimination. Once Trey and Laura were eliminated Marie and Robb managed to stick around longer than expected, she even notably pulled weight for the pair during an underwater mission.Plantgate: Most of all Marie left her mark the night of the huge house fight of the season (and maybe even of all New Age seasons). Marie saw two men teaming up on her friend Nany, so naturally she jumped into the fight to come to Nany’s rescue. That also meant Robb had to come in to make sure Marie doesn't go off the hinges and get them kicked off. Robb can thank Marie for giving him another invite back onto the challenge by the way. The night snowballed into Derek pushing Robb, then Marie pushing Derek down with Sam positioned behind him, falling into a plant. Marie didn't finish it there, she then verbally attacks Sam for no reason. Since that night we saw how many fucks Marie gives and how crazy she can get.After a hiatus Marie arrived on Invasion of the Champions with her bestie Latoya, both highly anticipated, but not in the best of shape. Marie found herself screwed in the first mission and eliminated after the first round against a new school rookie. We never got to see that aggressive, loudmouth badass we were so desperately asking to return to the show. But there's always a chance on Season 30...hopefully she doesn't let us down.
Essential Season(s): Seasons (2012)
Hey, at least your other girls are still in the running lol
That JEK list just shows how HORRIBLE that era was.
Brittini, Aviv & Ibis though >>>>>>>>
The JEK list has Jenn & Kimberly so it will be fine at the end.
Marie's about right. She wasn't making the top 10 with that limited of a resume. Potential only does so much. Hopefully she brings it on XXX
I know right? One of the worst periods in any reality show.
How are Brittany and Jenna ahead of Marie.
Jenna is.... Jenna. But who said that?