Survivor: Generic Thread (No Spoilers)

6778 posts / 0 new
Last post
It was disapointing when Ozzy lost and he deserved it. It to an extent could be viewed as like this last season with Natalie winning.
[QUOTE=mr.unamazing;146928]It was disapointing when Ozzy lost and he deserved it. It to an extent could be viewed as like this last season with Natalie winning.[/QUOTE] I think that Yul and Ozzy were both deserving. Ozzy is the best physical player ever and Yul was the best strategist in that season!
[QUOTE=mr.unamazing;146928]It was disapointing when Ozzy lost and he deserved it. It to an extent could be viewed as like this last season with Natalie winning.[/QUOTE] No way! Not even close. I think that Yul and Ozzy were the best two in that season and both deserved to be there. Yul was the master strategist and best social player in the game; Ozzy was the best physical attribute and provider in the game. It definitely was a hard decision for them.
What locations does everyone like the best? I really love both Africa locations the most! Austalia, China, and Brazil too. It gets old always seeing the same tropical locations. They're beautiful locations but after a while Palau and Panama start to get annoying...
If I were on the jury I would careless how a person performed physically. It's all about how you played the game as a whole for me. Each season this is how I would have voted... 1) Rich 2) I think they played the same game so it would have been who I had more of a connection with. 3) Ethan 4) Neleh 5) Brian 6) Jenna 7) Sandra 8) Rob 9) Twilia 10) Katie 11) Danni 12) I don't even remember their game play, Danielle? Both are forgettable. 13) Ozzy 14) Dreamz 15) Courtney 16) Parvati 17) Sugar 18) Stephen 19) Natalie
I think Tom was the best at the challenges in Survivor History. And i say this because there were many Team Immunities and Rewards he won by himself for Koror. Statistically i guess some people were better than him, but i remember being amazed by Tom during the challenges when i watched Palau. Here is who i would have voted for each season: 1. Kelly 2. Colby 3. Kim J 4. Neleh 5. Brian 6. Jenna 7. Sandra 8. Amber 9. Twila 10. Tom 11. Steph 12. Danielle 13. Yul 14. Earl 15. Courtney 16. Eh I have no idea, i think they both sucked.. But if it were a final 3, i would have voted Cirie 17. Susie 18. JT 19. Natalie.
[QUOTE=asamber1;146947]I think Tom was the best at the challenges in Survivor History. And i say this because there were many Team Immunities and Rewards he won by himself for Koror. Statistically i guess some people were better than him, but i remember being amazed by Tom during the challenges when i watched Palau. Here is who i would have voted for each season: 1. Kelly 2. Colby 3. Kim J 4. Neleh 5. Brian 6. Jenna 7. Sandra 8. Amber 9. Twila 10. Tom 11. Steph 12. Danielle 13. Yul 14. Earl 15. Courtney 16. Eh I have no idea, i think they both sucked.. But if it were a final 3, i would have voted Cirie 17. Susie 18. JT 19. Natalie.[/QUOTE] Just curious...why would you have voted for Danielle or Susie, or Cirie over the other person available? I (personally, of course) thought Aras, Bob, and Parvati (or even Amanda) were better choices. I'm still wondering why Danielle was brought back for Heroes vs Villains.
I don't get the love for Cirie, I think she deserved to be invited back for Fans vs Favorites but not for All Stars 2. I don't even remember what season she was on, Panama? I liked her for the most part till she thought she was entitled to the money on Fans vs Favorites because she was poor....I think her poor atheletic performance and surviving skills are going to get her the early boot on AS2.
[QUOTE=Bolt8;146994]I don't get the love for Cirie, I think she deserved to be invited back for Fans vs Favorites but not for All Stars 2. I don't even remember what season she was on, Panama? I liked her for the most part till she thought she was entitled to the money on Fans vs Favorites because she was poor....I think her poor atheletic performance and surviving skills are going to get her the early boot on AS2.[/QUOTE] Cirie was the brains behind a lot of the things that happened in FvF. She was the one that came up with the idea to convince Erik to give immunity to Natalie. I didn't like her in the begining of FvF, but torwards the end I really liked her. I definetly don't think that she got enough credit for a lot of things that she did.
[QUOTE=molds13;146986]Just curious...why would you have voted for Danielle or Susie, or Cirie over the other person available? I (personally, of course) thought Aras, Bob, and Parvati (or even Amanda) were better choices. [B]I'm still wondering why Danielle was brought back for Heroes vs Villains[/B].[/QUOTE] I heard that Courtney from the EI season was asked, but declined. Danielle was the next best I guess...
[QUOTE=Lamb Chop!!!;147013]I heard that Courtney from the EI season was asked, but declined. Danielle was the next best I guess...[/QUOTE] Even just looking at the alternate choices though, I think that Natalie would have been a much better choice as a villain.
Yeah! I thought Natalie was totally overlooked on her season. She was a major reason as to why the person who won did win. As she got him to give up his necklace. Though it isn't certain if he would have continued winning, it did look that way.
I would like to have seen Natalie (FvF) on All Stars. She was a dirty player towards the end and kind of a *****. I could be wrong but if I can't even remember Danielle on her season I don't see her bringing too much to the table. Corrine would have been a good choice also.
The best choice, in my opinion, would have been Twila, to bring diversity to the female villains. Natalie was invisible for the first ten episodes, and only emerged toward the end. The only purpose she would serve on HVV would have been an easy alliance for casting's favorite girl Parv. Corinne is a wannabe Jerri and totally artificial. Twila's authentic, not afraid to make moves, and gets into conflicts. She has a personality that is unique that Parvati, Jerri, Sandra and Courtney don't already bring to the table. Lynne Spillman has stated in the past that they cast people for sex, humor and conflict, and I think they way over-emphasize the "sex" aspect at the expense of conflict.
Natalie was invisible for the majority of the season, and I'm not really that big of a fan of her but I do think she would have brought some good entertainment to this season and would have been a lot more bold. I agree with you on Corrine, she was fake I retract what I said on her. Twilia would have added alot to the show, I would have liked to seen her over Sandra.
I am still wondering why James was brought back, because last time he was on an all star season he was pretty much just background?
James is a strong competitor but not a great game player. Amanda was boring on China and just annoying on FvF I don't get why she was brought back either I would have much rather seen Tina someone from an earlier season like Kim P or Gretchen. Oh and are Ozzy & Amanda still together?
I have to say, whether people think Natalie deserved to win or not, she is one of the sweetest people ever. She takes time on facebook to respond to most of the people who address her. A few days ago, I sent her a message on FB chat and she sent me an inbox message saying she was sorry that her chat wasn't working but thanked me and hoped I had a merry Christmas. And last night we talked on FB chat for a few minutes. She has even sent messages to people who have left her nasty wall posts saying she is sorry they didn't think she deserved it, but that she hopes they have a good holiday. Russell deserved to win, but after seeing all his crying and how gracious and classy Natalie has been, I am growing more glad that she was the victor. SU has said on sucks that her facebook is a fake, but given that her profile picture was added July 27, and that her boyfriend's facebook has pictures of her from January 2009, when nobody knew who she was, it seems totally authentic to me.
[QUOTE=Bolt8;147053]James is a strong competitor but not a great game player. Amanda was boring on China and just annoying on FvF I don't get why she was brought back either I would have much rather seen Tina someone from an earlier season like Kim P or Gretchen. Oh and are Ozzy & Amanda still together?[/QUOTE] I'm a bit irritated that they brought back people for a third time in general. I've seen enough of Rupert, Stephenie, James, etc. I do have to say that I'm extremely glad they got China Courtney on this season. She declined Fans VS Favorites and that's the only reason Amanda got put on that season...
I don't mind people being brought back for a third time, just as long as they deserve it. Parvati & Rob I think totally deserved to be asked back a third time. Amanda & Cirie are two examples that shouldnt have been asked back for a third time in my opinion.
[QUOTE=Bolt8;147149]I don't mind people being brought back for a third time, just as long as they deserve it. Parvati & Rob I think totally deserved to be asked back a third time. Amanda & Cirie are two examples that shouldnt have been asked back for a third time in my opinion.[/QUOTE] I think that Parvati, Cirie, Jerry, Colby, Stephanie, and Rob are vey deserving of a third time. Amanda might be too if she didn't give up at both final tribal councils that she was in. I can understand her being an alternate but not at the top of the list. Rupert was good in PI but got on my last nerve in AS. I see why James is on, but I don't really think that he is a true all star. I would have much rather seen someone like Penner, Ozzy, or Cesternino take his and Ruperts spots.
Why do you think Cirie is deserving of a 3rd time?
[QUOTE=Bolt8;147160]Why do you think Cirie is deserving of a 3rd time?[/QUOTE] She played a really good game on FvF. She played more under the radar so a lot of the credit went to Parv. She was the mastermind behind the whole blindside of Erik
Part of me wishes they had passed on threepeaters all together.... Jerri - lost interest in AS1 after she got revenge on Colby & Tina, though I do love her and am glad she is in this season Colby - had no interest in AS1 Rupert, James - have no concept of how to play Cirie, Amanda, James - played the exact same game twice and got nearly the same result twice
[QUOTE=salt&vinegar;147159][B]Rupert was good in PI but got on my last nerve in AS.[/B] [/QUOTE] I watched Pearl Islands a little while ago and it reminded me why I am not a fan of Rupert. The rarrrr yells, the cockiness, the "I can't believe this" when he was voted off, just the way he talked...was annoying to me. I really hope he won't be like that this time around.

Pages