The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

16728 posts / 0 new
Last post

I need help with something, who are the most forgettable cast members from era 1 of the challenge? 

Noah - Real World vs Road Rules - Champ

Rebecca - Extreme Challenge - Champ

Josh - Battle of the Seasons

 Chris - Battle of the Seasons

Mike J - Battle of the Seasons

Jake - Battle of the Sexes

Dave G - The Guantlet- Champ

Steve - The Gauntlet ( better showing on All Stars)

Mallory - The Inferno

Jeremy - The Inferno

Randy - Battle of the Sexes 2

Chris - Battle of the Sexes 2

Shawn - Battle of the Sexes 2

Nick - Battle of the Sexes 2

Jaques - Battle of the Sexes 2

Shavonda - Inferno 2

Karamo - Inferno 2

imagine finally getting an Exes 3 and losing Tordan in the first episode LOOLLLL

Karamo's fight with CT is somewhat memorable. Plus, he's still famous so I wouldn't put him on that list.

The Challenge: Battle of the Seasons

 

Asaf & Tori (AYTO? 4)

Austin & Dee (Survivor 45)

Chris & Lauren (Survivor: Edge of Extinction)

Cinco & Olivia (Love Island 3)

Cory & Ashley (RW: Explosion)

Darrell & Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl)

Derek & Jonna (RW: Cancun)

Devin & Amanda (AYTO? 3)

Faysal & Bayleigh (Big Brother 20)

Jay & Michaela (Survivor: Millennials vs Gen X)

Johnny & Justine (Love Island 2)

Kareem & Nurys (AYTO? 6)

Keenan & Imani (AYTO? 5)

Kyland & Alyssa (Big Brother 23)

Leroy & Nany (RW: Las Vegas 2)

Marlon & Nia (RW: Portland)

Tony & Nicole (RW: Skeletons)

Tucker & Makensy (Big Brother 26)

Yes & Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea)

The Challenge: Battle of the Seasons

 

Asaf & Tori (AYTO? 4)

Austin & Dee (Survivor 45)

Chris & Lauren (Survivor: Edge of Extinction)

Cinco & Olivia (Love Island 3)

Cory & Ashley (RW: Explosion)

Darrell & Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl)

Derek & Jonna (RW: Cancun)

Devin & Amanda (AYTO? 3)

Faysal & Bayleigh (Big Brother 20)

Jay & Michaela (Survivor: Millennials vs Gen X)

Johnny & Justine (Love Island 2)

Kareem & Nurys (AYTO? 6)

Keenan & Imani (AYTO? 5)

Kyland & Alyssa (Big Brother 23)

Leroy & Nany (RW: Las Vegas 2)

Marlon & Nia (RW: Portland)

Tony & Nicole (RW: Skeletons)

Tucker & Makensy (Big Brother 26)

Yes & Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea)

keenan and Imani love island 5.

nice cast, but I would like to see ayto5 represented by Eddie/derrick & Kam/tyranny

Battle of the forgotten 

Location Suriname 

Eras themed 

Era 1

Matt, ,Nick, Sean, Noah,Jacquese

Shavonda, Mallory, Lori, Rebecca, Rachel b

Era 2

JD, Noor, Jeff, Jesse, Zach m

Chanda, Sandy, Linnette, Angel, Rachel m

Era 3

Swift, Anthony c, Anthony b, Bruno, Stephen 

Emily r, Hailey, Priscilla, Laura, Jill

Era 4

Sean L, Joseph, Victor, Alan, Kim

Liv, Shaleen, Julia, Analyse, Nicole b

Battle of the forgotten 

Location Suriname 

Eras themed 

Era 1

Matt, ,Nick, Sean, Noah,Jacquese

Shavonda, Mallory, Cameron, Rebecca, Montana

Era 2

JD, Noor, Jeff, Jesse, Zach m

Chanda, Sandy, Linnette, Angel, Rachel m

Era 3

Swift, Anthony c, Anthony b, Bruno, Stephen 

Emily r, Hailey, Priscilla, Laura, Jill

Era 4

Sean L, Joseph, Victor, Alan, Kim

Liv, Shaleen, Julia, Analyse, Nicole b

I'm sold if you bump Montana for Rachel Braband and Cameran for Lori Trespicio--Montana and Cam did multiple challenges and Cam got bigger things happening. I'd also like Carley in there.

Battle of the forgotten 

Location Suriname 

Eras themed 

Era 1

Matt, ,Nick, Sean, Noah,Jacquese

Shavonda, Mallory, Cameron, Rebecca, Montana

Era 2

JD, Noor, Jeff, Jesse, Zach m

Chanda, Sandy, Linnette, Angel, Rachel m

Era 3

Swift, Anthony c, Anthony b, Bruno, Stephen 

Emily r, Hailey, Priscilla, Laura, Jill

Era 4

Sean L, Joseph, Victor, Alan, Kim

Liv, Shaleen, Julia, Analyse, Nicole b

I'm sold if you bump Montana for Rachel Braband and Cameran for Lori Trespicio--Montana and Cam did multiple challenges and Cam got bigger things happening. I'd also like Carley in there.

I got lazy when it came to Era 1 tbh and kinda gave up lol. I'll add them

Battle of the forgotten 

Location Suriname 

Eras themed 

Era 1

Matt, ,Nick, Sean, Noah,Jacquese

Shavonda, Mallory, Cameron, Rebecca, Montana

Era 2

JD, Noor, Jeff, Jesse, Zach m

Chanda, Sandy, Linnette, Angel, Rachel m

Era 3

Swift, Anthony c, Anthony b, Bruno, Stephen 

Emily r, Hailey, Priscilla, Laura, Jill

Era 4

Sean L, Joseph, Victor, Alan, Kim

Liv, Shaleen, Julia, Analyse, Nicole b

I'm sold if you bump Montana for Rachel Braband and Cameran for Lori Trespicio--Montana and Cam did multiple challenges and Cam got bigger things happening. I'd also like Carley in there.

I got lazy when it came to Era 1 tbh and kinda gave up lol. I'll add them

Era 1 has a ton of one hit women I love...Rachel Braband Lori Trespicio Mallory Snyder Irulan Wilson Christena Pyle for starters...so many great options but I'd struggle with 3 & 4 so I get it

Hate her or love her Ellen was the best one hit wonder of the series, followed somewhat closely by Belou~*

Those Era 2 women are actually solid. (Minus Rachel M)

Hate her or love her Ellen was the best one hit wonder of the series, followed somewhat closely by Belou~*

It matters is you love or hate them.  Ellen was always a victim--in no way would I have wanted to see her again

Those Era 2 women are actually solid. (Minus Rachel M)

Yeah--Carley or Sydney would be a good replacement

 

Hate her or love her Ellen was the best one hit wonder of the series, followed somewhat closely by Belou~*

It matters is you love or hate them.  Ellen was always a victim--in no way would I have wanted to see her again

Your opinion on this holds little weight to me. We only agree on Christena Pyle and Irulan. Rachel and Mallory would've been cute for just 1 more season maybe. Lori should've been brought back for all stars.

Hate her or love her Ellen was the best one hit wonder of the series, followed somewhat closely by Belou~*

It matters is you love or hate them.  Ellen was always a victim--in no way would I have wanted to see her again

Your opinion on this holds little weight to me. We only agree on Christena Pyle and Irulan. Rachel and Mallory would've been cute for just 1 more season maybe. Lori should've been brought back for all stars.

Just like your opinion means nothing to me.   Mallory, Lori and Rachel B are all better and more realistic than Ellen.   Ellen is basically a female Josh.

 

Hate her or love her Ellen was the best one hit wonder of the series, followed somewhat closely by Belou~*

It matters is you love or hate them.  Ellen was always a victim--in no way would I have wanted to see her again

Your opinion on this holds little weight to me. We only agree on Christena Pyle and Irulan. Rachel and Mallory would've been cute for just 1 more season maybe. Lori should've been brought back for all stars.

Just like your opinion means nothing to me.   Mallory, Lori and Rachel B are all better and more realistic than Ellen.   Ellen is basically a female Josh.

I'm glad it means nothing to you because I could wipe my áss with yours. How are Mallory and Rachel B more realistic when they never appeared on anything after their one season? Ellen at least did the casting special for the gauntlet 1 or inferno 1 with Dan Renzi (can't remember which season she hosted that for, but she did do that). Also, she was a hell of a much better competitor than Josh will ever be. She easily could've been a multi-season champ unlike any of the dolls you mentioned with the exception of maybe Mallory. Lori could've probably won a season too. Rachel B not as likely, but if Katie and Sarah Greyson could win a season, I guess anything is possible. Don't kid yourself though, your picks are still rather delusional.

Those Era 2 women are actually solid. (Minus Rachel M)

Originally rachels spot was for ayiiia but I wanted a more forgettable person and while she didn't do anything on the show, Ayiiia is someone people actually want on the show lol.

 

 

 

Hate her or love her Ellen was the best one hit wonder of the series, followed somewhat closely by Belou~*

It matters is you love or hate them.  Ellen was always a victim--in no way would I have wanted to see her again

Your opinion on this holds little weight to me. We only agree on Christena Pyle and Irulan. Rachel and Mallory would've been cute for just 1 more season maybe. Lori should've been brought back for all stars.

Just like your opinion means nothing to me.   Mallory, Lori and Rachel B are all better and more realistic than Ellen.   Ellen is basically a female Josh.

I'm glad it means nothing to you because I could wipe my áss with yours. How are Mallory and Rachel B more realistic when they never appeared on anything after their one season? Ellen at least did the casting special for the gauntlet 1 or inferno 1 with Dan Renzi (can't remember which season she hosted that for, but she did do that). Also, she was a hell of a much better competitor than Josh will ever be. She easily could've been a multi-season champ unlike any of the dolls you mentioned with the exception of maybe Mallory. Lori could've probably won a season too. Rachel B not as likely, but if Katie and Sarah Greyson could win a season, I guess anything is possible. Don't kid yourself though, your picks are still rather delusional.

She did the casting special for Battle of the Sexes 2.      Anyone who compares Ellen to Josh should be banned hahah

 

 

 

Hate her or love her Ellen was the best one hit wonder of the series, followed somewhat closely by Belou~*

It matters is you love or hate them.  Ellen was always a victim--in no way would I have wanted to see her again

Your opinion on this holds little weight to me. We only agree on Christena Pyle and Irulan. Rachel and Mallory would've been cute for just 1 more season maybe. Lori should've been brought back for all stars.

Just like your opinion means nothing to me.   Mallory, Lori and Rachel B are all better and more realistic than Ellen.   Ellen is basically a female Josh.

I'm glad it means nothing to you because I could wipe my áss with yours. How are Mallory and Rachel B more realistic when they never appeared on anything after their one season? Ellen at least did the casting special for the gauntlet 1 or inferno 1 with Dan Renzi (can't remember which season she hosted that for, but she did do that). Also, she was a hell of a much better competitor than Josh will ever be. She easily could've been a multi-season champ unlike any of the dolls you mentioned with the exception of maybe Mallory. Lori could've probably won a season too. Rachel B not as likely, but if Katie and Sarah Greyson could win a season, I guess anything is possible. Don't kid yourself though, your picks are still rather delusional.

So you aren't aware of Ellen's life

 

 

 

 

Hate her or love her Ellen was the best one hit wonder of the series, followed somewhat closely by Belou~*

It matters is you love or hate them.  Ellen was always a victim--in no way would I have wanted to see her again

Your opinion on this holds little weight to me. We only agree on Christena Pyle and Irulan. Rachel and Mallory would've been cute for just 1 more season maybe. Lori should've been brought back for all stars.

Just like your opinion means nothing to me.   Mallory, Lori and Rachel B are all better and more realistic than Ellen.   Ellen is basically a female Josh.

I'm glad it means nothing to you because I could wipe my áss with yours. How are Mallory and Rachel B more realistic when they never appeared on anything after their one season? Ellen at least did the casting special for the gauntlet 1 or inferno 1 with Dan Renzi (can't remember which season she hosted that for, but she did do that). Also, she was a hell of a much better competitor than Josh will ever be. She easily could've been a multi-season champ unlike any of the dolls you mentioned with the exception of maybe Mallory. Lori could've probably won a season too. Rachel B not as likely, but if Katie and Sarah Greyson could win a season, I guess anything is possible. Don't kid yourself though, your picks are still rather delusional.

So you aren't aware of Ellen's life

Why would I be? Idk anything about any of these people's lives 

I might do a season summary but honestly who knows who would win an elimination between some of these people lol

Hate her or love her Ellen was the best one hit wonder of the series, followed somewhat closely by Belou~*

It matters is you love or hate them.  Ellen was always a victim--in no way would I have wanted to see her again

Your opinion on this holds little weight to me. We only agree on Christena Pyle and Irulan. Rachel and Mallory would've been cute for just 1 more season maybe. Lori should've been brought back for all stars.

Just like your opinion means nothing to me.   Mallory, Lori and Rachel B are all better and more realistic than Ellen.   Ellen is basically a female Josh.

I'm glad it means nothing to you because I could wipe my áss with yours. How are Mallory and Rachel B more realistic when they never appeared on anything after their one season? Ellen at least did the casting special for the gauntlet 1 or inferno 1 with Dan Renzi (can't remember which season she hosted that for, but she did do that). Also, she was a hell of a much better competitor than Josh will ever be. She easily could've been a multi-season champ unlike any of the dolls you mentioned with the exception of maybe Mallory. Lori could've probably won a season too. Rachel B not as likely, but if Katie and Sarah Greyson could win a season, I guess anything is possible. Don't kid yourself though, your picks are still rather delusional.

So you aren't aware of Ellen's life

Why would I be? Idk anything about any of these people's lives 

Because it's been discussed here many times--I don't follow any of them but when it's discussed here you should be aware given you live here

Battle of the forgotten 

Location Suriname 

Eras themed 

Era 1

Matt, ,Nick, Sean, Noah,Jacquese

Shavonda, Mallory, Lori, Rebecca, Rachel b

Era 2

JD, Noor, Jeff, Jesse, Zach m

Chanda, Sandy, Linnette, Angel, Rachel m

Era 3

Swift, Anthony c, Anthony b, Bruno, Stephen 

Emily r, Hailey, Priscilla, Laura, Jill

Era 4

Sean L, Joseph, Victor, Alan, Kim

Liv, Shaleen, Julia, Analyse, Nicole b

Nick Brown way too memorable to make this cast. I know that right.

Wrong nick, nick brown is Era 2. He's not here

 

Hate her or love her Ellen was the best one hit wonder of the series, followed somewhat closely by Belou~*

It matters is you love or hate them.  Ellen was always a victim--in no way would I have wanted to see her again

Your opinion on this holds little weight to me. We only agree on Christena Pyle and Irulan. Rachel and Mallory would've been cute for just 1 more season maybe. Lori should've been brought back for all stars.

Just like your opinion means nothing to me.   Mallory, Lori and Rachel B are all better and more realistic than Ellen.   Ellen is basically a female Josh.

I'm glad it means nothing to you because I could wipe my áss with yours. How are Mallory and Rachel B more realistic when they never appeared on anything after their one season? Ellen at least did the casting special for the gauntlet 1 or inferno 1 with Dan Renzi (can't remember which season she hosted that for, but she did do that). Also, she was a hell of a much better competitor than Josh will ever be. She easily could've been a multi-season champ unlike any of the dolls you mentioned with the exception of maybe Mallory. Lori could've probably won a season too. Rachel B not as likely, but if Katie and Sarah Greyson could win a season, I guess anything is possible. Don't kid yourself though, your picks are still rather delusional.

So you aren't aware of Ellen's life

Why would I be? Idk anything about any of these people's lives 

Because it's been discussed here many times--I don't follow any of them but when it's discussed here you should be aware given you live here

Oh please. You've been in the neighborhood like a decade longer than I have. We've all heard the domestic violence between you and your wife OldSchooler (rip).

My idea for the next 2 seasons by making this the Eras trilogy after season 40.

 

Season 41:  Dawn of a New Era

For this season I tried what they should have done on 39 by making a cast made up of contestants in their 20’s that could actually have a future on the show.

Each week players will compete to get into the Winners’ Circle, while the worst performers go into the draw. The Winners’ Circle will nominate 2 players for elimination.

 

Austin (Survivor 45)

Bryton (Squid Games: The Challenge)

Cam (Big Brother 26)

Carrington (Love Island USA 2)

Cedric (Big Brother 26)

Cinco (Love Island USA 3)

Ed (The Circle)

Horacio (Exalton)

Jared (Big Brother 25)

Johnny (Love Island USA 2)

Joseph (Big Brother 24)

Kassius (RW: Bad Blood)

Kenny (Love Island USA 6)

Kordell (Love Island USA 6)

Tevin (Survivor 46)

Yeremi (Amazing Race 35)

 

Alyssa (Big Brother 23)

Amber (AYTO? 8 )

America (Big Brother 25)

Blue (Big Brother 25)

Cassidy (Survivor 43)

Dee (Survivor 45)

Imani (Love Island USA 5)

JaNa (Love Island USA 6)

Jordie (RW: Bad Blood)

Kaylor (Love Island USA 6)

Makensy (Big Brother 26)

Moriah (The Challenge: Ride or Dies)

Nurys (AYTO? 6)

Ravyn (The Challenge: Ride or Dies)

Serena (Love Island USA 6)

Venus (Survivor 46)

 

To decide the format of the final TJ will spin a board and the format chosen was 2 teams of 4

Tevin over Q is a wild choice, Q must be in his 30s.

Half the men being black >>>>>>

Tevin over Q is a wild choice, Q must be in his 30s.

He was Sad I would hope Tevin could bring messy Frank/Shane energy 

Pages