The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

16667 posts / 0 new
Last post

Laurel isn't genuinely psycho to me. Put her in the room with Big Ivori and let's see that same psychotic shit. 

Laurel isn't genuinely psycho to me. Put her in the room with Big Ivori and let's see that same psychotic shit. 

We don't disagree. Laurel knows who to get crazy with and when to keep it cute.

The Challenge: Skeletons

 

Format: A challenge vet paired with a rookie from their past

 

Teams:

  1. Amber Borzotra & Zach Rance (Big Brother 16) “Rivals” 
  2. Bayleigh Dayton & Brett Robinson (Big Brother 20) “Rivals”
  3. Camilla Pointdexter & Wes Bergmann (House of Villains 2) “Rivals”
  4. Courtney Stark & Johnny Middlebrooks (Love Island Games) “Exes”
  5. Da’Vonne Rogers & Jamar Lee (Ex on the Beach USA - Season 5) “Rivals”
  6. Faith Stowers & Jax Taylor (Vanderpump Rules) “Exes”
  7. Haleigh Broucher & Faysal Shafaat (Big Brother 20) “Exes”
  8. Jessica Nickson & Josh Martinez (Big Brother 19) “Rivals”
  9. Kenya Scott & Devin Walker (Ex on the Beach USA - Season 3) “Rivals”
  10. Mattie Lynn Breaux & Jeremiah Buoni (Floribama Shore) “Exes”
  11. Michele Fitzgerald & Wendell Holland (Survivor World) “Exes”
  12. Missy Byrd & Tommy Sheehan (Survivor: Island of the Idols) “Rivals”
  13. Nicole Ramos & Chad Johnson (Ex on the Beach USA - Season 2) “Exes”
  14. Nicole Zanatta & Jason Hill (Real World: Skeletons) “Rivals” 
  15. Nurys Mateo & Malcolm Drummer (Are You the One?: Season 6) “Exes”
  16. Taylor Hale & Monte Taylor (Big Brother 24) “Exes”
  17. Tyara Hooks & Theo King-Bradley (Real World: Bad Blood) "Exes"
  18. Violetta Milerman & Tony Raines (Real World: Skeletons) “Rivals”

The Challenge: Skeletons

 

Format: A challenge vet paired with a rookie from their past

 

Teams:

  1. Amber Borzotra & Zach Rance (Big Brother 16) “Rivals” 
  2. Bayleigh Dayton & Brett Robinson (Big Brother 20) “Rivals”
  3. Camilla Pointdexter & Wes Bergmann (House of Villains 2) “Rivals”
  4. Courtney Stark & Johnny Middlebrooks (Love Island Games) “Exes”
  5. Danielle Clarke & Mechie Harris (Ex on the Beach USA - Season 3 “Exes”
  6. Da’Vonne Rogers & Jamar Lee (Ex on the Beach USA - Season 5) “Rivals”
  7. Faith Stowers & Jax Taylor (Vanderpump Rules) “Exes”
  8. Haleigh Broucher & Faysal Shafaat (Big Brother 20) “Exes”
  9. Jessica Nickson & Josh Martinez (Big Brother 19) “Rivals”
  10. Kenya Scott & Devin Walker (Ex on the Beach USA - Season 3) “Rivals”
  11. Mattie Lynn Breaux & Jeremiah Buoni (Floribama Shore) “Exes”
  12. Michele Fitzgerald & Wendell Holland (Survivor World) “Exes”
  13. Missy Byrd & Tommy Sheehan (Survivor: Island of the Idols) “Rivals”
  14. Nicole Ramos & Chad Johnson (Ex on the Beach USA - Season 2) “Exes”
  15. Nicole Zanatta & Jason Hill (Real World: Skeletons) “Rivals” 
  16. Nurys Mateo & Malcolm Drummer (Are You the One?: Season 6) “Exes”
  17. Taylor Hale & Monte Taylor (Big Brother 24) “Exes”
  18. Violetta Milerman & Tony Raines (Real World: Skeletons) “Rivals”

I would watch this for Missy/Tommy, Nicole/Chad, Mattie/Jerimiah, & Nicole/Jason

Amazing idea but team 5 is definitely not needed. I don't even remember Danielle from that szn

Would love to see a Kailah/Dione team. And if Jamar makes it on... Minh-Ly better be on ASAP

I'd be rooting for Bayleigh/Brett HARD

The Challenge USA III: Battle of the Seasons

 

2 Teams with players partnered with someone from their season

 

Each week 1 pair will be nominated by the winner of the previous elimination as Team Captain’s. The winning teams captains are safe, while the losing pair goes into the draw. The losing team then must vote in another pair from their team into the draw. The winning captains then nominate one pair from their team to complete the draw. 3 cards: 1 will be safe while the other 2 face off in the arena

 

Halfway through the teams dissolve where it becomes a pairs game. Each daily there will be a winner and loser. The winners will vote another team into the draw and the house will vote in the other team.

Team Survivor

Chris & Lauren (Edge of Extinction)

Cody & Cassidy (43)

Dean & Missy (Island of the Idols)

Jay & Michaela (Millennials vs Gen X)

Kaleb & Dee (45)

Sam & Tiyanna (47)

Tevin & Venus (46)

Xander & Liana (41)

 

Team Big Brother

Faysal & Bayleigh (20)

Jared & Blue (25)

Joseph & Taylor (24)

Josh & Christmas (19)

Kyland & Alyssa (23)

Paulie & Da’Vonne (18)

Tucker & Makensy (26)

Zach & Amber (16)

 

I tried not to use players that will be on Survivor 50 to make it realistic (mainly Q)

> I tried not to use players that will be on Survivor 50 to make it realistic (mainly Q)

Is the cast leaked yet?!

The challenge Total Chaos

Random cast, pairs, and location

Location Samoa

Noor & Kelly Anne

CT & Coral

Chet & Amanda

Jay g & Lolo

Raphy & Jenny

Robb & Melissa 

Shane & Svetlana

Big easy & Tina

Frank & Kam

Swaggy c & Faith

Theo b & Nia

Faysal & Ruthie

Hunter & Katelynn

Thomas & Sylvia

Syrus & Nicole z

Chuck & Devyn

Is there a theme to that or just teams I'm confused

Is there a theme to that or just teams I'm confused

Nope just went on brantsteele and hit random cast from the challenge. Didn't put too much thought into it just thought some of these pairs they gave me were funny.

Chet & Amanda especially is such a funny pair because you just know she'd hate that man lol

The Challenge: The Island 2

Location: Papua New Guinea

Format: The winner of the daily challenge nominates 3 men and 3 women to compete in the face-off, the players vote for which nominees will compete in the face-off, the winner of the face-off chooses who stays in the game between the two people who lost.

Cast:

Males:

Fessy Shafaat

Josh Martinez

Johnny Middlebrooks

Cole Medders

Chris Underwood

Devin Walker

Cory Wharton

Frank Sweeney 

Shane Landrum

Corey Lay

Ryan Kehoe

Tony Raines

Q Burdette

Jonathan Young

Paulie Calafiore

Females:

Cara Maria Sorbello

Amber Borzotra

Da'Vonne Rogers

Michaela Bradshaw

Ashley Mitchell

Kayleigh Morris

Sophia Pasquis

Tina Barta

Berna Canbeldek

Moriah Andrychowski

Carley Johnson

Zara Zoffany

Chelsie Baham

Dee Valladares

Kenzie Petty

 

The Challenge: Battle of the Shows

 

Team Challenge:

Bananas (RW: Key West)

Cory (RW: Explosion)

Devin (AYTO? 3)

Frank (RW: San Diego 2011)

Shane (RR: Campus Crawl)

Wes (RW: Austin)

Amanda (AYTO? 3)

Ashley (RW: Explosion)

Kam (AYTO? 5)

Nurys (AYTO? 6)

Ravyn (TC: Ride or Dies)

Tori (AYTO? 4)

 

Team Big Brother:

Cam (Big Brother 26)

Faysal (Big Brother 20)

Josh (Big Brother 19)

Kyland (Big Brother 23)

Paulie (Big Brother 18)

Tucker (Big Brother 26)

Alyssa (Big Brother 23)

Angela (Big Brother 20)

Chelsie (Big Brother 26)

Da’Vonne (Big Brother 17)

Kaycee (Big Brother 20)

Makensy (Big Brother 26)

 

Team Survivor:

Chris (Survivor: Edge of Extinction)

Danny (Survivor 41)

Jay (Survivor: Millennials vs Gen X)

Q (Survivor 46)

TK (Survivor 47)

Tyson (Survivor: Tocantins)

Cassidy (Survivor 43)

Dee (Survivor 45)

Michaela (Survivor: Millennials vs Gen X)

Michele (Survivor: Kaoh Rong)

Tiffany (Survivor 46)

Venus (Survivor 46)

Rivals II (recast as CoEd pairs)

 

Abram & Laurel

Bananas & KellyAnne

CJ & Ayiiia

CT & Aneesa

Dustin & Trishelle

Frank & Nany

Johnny & Jessica

Jordan & Nia

Leroy & Cooke

Swift & LaToya

Trey & Marie

Ty & Camila

Wes & Cara Maria

Zach & Sam

*** those are some great pairs! I would rock with Abe/Laurel, Jordan/Laurel, Trey/Marie, and Frank/Nany in 2014 so hard

The Challenge: The Showdown 

Team Big Brother:

Da'Vonne Rogers (Season 17)

Faysal Shafaat (Season 20)

Josh Martinez (Season 19)

Makensy Jo Manbeck (Season 26)

 

Team Love Island: 

Jeff Christian Jr (Season 4)

Johnny Middlebrooks (Season 2)

Justine Nbida (Season 2)

Olivia Kaiser (Season 1)

 

Team Ex on the Beach: 

Alain Lorenzo (Season 5)

Angela Babicz (Season 1 & 2)

Faith Stowers (Season 1)

Mechie Harris (Season 3)

 

Team Are You the One?: 

Hunter Barfield (Season 3)

Kam Williams (Season 5)

Leo Svete (Season 9)

Nurys Mateo (Season 6)

 

Team Survivor: 

Danny McCray (Season 41)

Jay Starrett (Season 33)

Michaela Bradshaw (Season 33)

Tiffany Nicole Ervin (Season 46)

 

Team Amazing Race: 

Anna Leigh Wilson (Season 35)

Dusty Harris (Season 33)

Luis Colon (Season 34)

Natalie Anderson (Season 21)

 

Team Golden Era: 

Beth Stolarczyk (Season 2)

CT Tamburello (Season Eight)

Darrell Taylor (Season 7)

Rachel Robinson (Season 6)

 

Team JEK Era:

Johnny Bananas (Season 13)

KellyAnne Judd (Season 16)

Nehemiah Clark (Season 13)

Sarah Rice (Season 17)

 

Team Invasion Era:  

Ashley Mitchell (Season 28)

Kailah Casillas (Season 29)

Cory Wharton (Season 27)

Tony Raines (Season 27)

 

Team Internationals: 

Berna Canbeldek (Turkey)

Kelechi **** (UK)

Esther Agunbiade (Nigeria)

Turbo Camkiran (Turkey)

Drama that happened in my simulation was:

Kendal vs Frank, Michaela vs Marie, Jonna vs Nurys, Ashley vs Dee, Frank vs Bananas, Shane vs Bananas, Kyland vs a lot of people. I guessed Kendal & Dee would hook up as well as Keenan & Nia, and Marie & Josh (don't ask me why I could see it but I could when I was high)

What simulator or simulation did you use?

The Challenge: Survival Games

Cory (RW: Explosion)

Derek (RW: Cancun)

Devin (AYTO? 3)

Frank (RW: San Diego 2011)

Jared (Big Brother 25)

Jay (Survivor)

Johnny (Love Island USA 2)

Josh (Big Brother 19)

Miguel (Love Island USA 6)

Kyland (Big Brother 23)

Paulie (Big Brother 18)

Rob (Love Island USA 6)

Tony (RW: Skeletons)

Tucker (Big Brother 26)

 

Alyssa (Big Brother 23)

Amanda (AYTO? 3)

Ashley (RW: Ex-Plosion)

Blue (Big Brother 25)

Cassidy (Survivor 43)

Dee (Survivor 45)

Jonna (RW: Cancun) 

Justine (Love Island USA 2)

Leah (Love Island USA 6)

Michele (Survivor: Kaoh Rong)

Nurys (AYTO? 6)

Olivia (Love Island USA 3)

Ravyn (The Challenge: Ride or Dies)

Venus (Survivor 46)

Format Overview

  • Players: 28 contestants (14 men, 14 women).
  • Daily Challenge: Varies each round-individual, pair, or team-based.
  • Team Challenges: Before starting, teams elect one male and one female to represent them.
  • Winners: Immunity and nomination power for the round.
  • Losers: The last-place male and female (or pair/representatives) are sent directly into the Draw.
  • Nominations: Daily winners nominate 2 men and 2 women for potential elimination.
  • The Draw: Players in the Draw randomly select tokens.
  • Safe Token: 1 man and 1 woman draw this token and avoid elimination.
  • Remaining players are sent into elimination.
  • Elimination: 1 man and 1 woman are eliminated per round 
  • Here is my cast for USA3: Survivor vs Big Brother:

    Survivor

    1. Cole S35
    2. Michael S36
    3. Wendell S36
    4. Alec S37
    5. Dean S39
    6. Kaleb S45
    7. Q S45
    8. Sam S47
    9. Rome S47
    10. Cydney S32
    11. Michaela S33
    12. Angelina S37
    13. Parvati S13
    14. Sydney S41
    15. Dee  S45
    16. Venus S46
    17. Tiffany S46
    18. Genevieve S47

    Big Brother

    1. Cody BB16
    2. Devin BB16
    3. Cody BB19
    4. Brett BB20
    5. Monte BB24
    6. Joseph BB24
    7. Tucker BB26
    8. Cedric BB26
    9. Matt BB26
    10. Rachel BB12
    11. Davonne BB17
    12. Haleigh BB20
    13. Janelle BB6
    14. Alyssa BB23
    15. Taylor BB24
    16. Reilly BB25
    17. Kiersten BB25
    18. Chelsie BB26

    Here is my cast for USA3: Survivor vs Big Brother:

    Survivor

    1. Cole S35
    2. Michael S36
    3. Alec S37
    4. Dean S39
    5. Kaleb S45
    6. Q S45
    7. Sam S47
    8. Michaela S33
    9. Angelina S37
    10. Sydney S41
    11. Dee  S45
    12. Venus S46
    13. Tiffany S46
    14. Genevieve S47

    Big Brother

    1. Devin BB16
    2. Brett BB20
    3. Monte BB24
    4. Joseph BB24
    5. Tucker BB26
    6. Cedric BB26
    7. Matt BB26
    8. Rachel BB12
    9. Haleigh BB20
    10. Janelle BB6
    11. Alyssa BB23
    12. Reilly BB25
    13. Kiersten BB25
    14. Chelsie BB26

    36 is way too much for a USA. Cutting Rome because he spoiled 47 so **** him, Wendell, Parvati, Cydney, Taylor, Janelle and both Codys will never come, and Davonne is apparently done.

    And at 28, this is still an S-Tier cast. Bravo.

    36 isn't too much. Two people leave a week for 13 episodes. That's minus 26 and a 10 person team final. Can probably do a bigger final of 12 people and do a two part premiere with no elimination the first episode. Film it in 4 weeks and all those people will say yes.

    Here is my cast for USA3: Survivor vs Big Brother:

    Survivor

    1. Cole S35
    2. Michael S36
    3. Wendell S36
    4. Alec S37
    5. Dean S39
    6. Kaleb S45
    7. Q S45
    8. Sam S47
    9. Rome S47
    10. Cydney S32
    11. Michaela S33
    12. Angelina S37
    13. Parvati S13
    14. Sydney S41
    15. Dee  S45
    16. Venus S46
    17. Tiffany S46
    18. Genevieve S47

    Big Brother

    1. Cody BB16
    2. Devin BB16
    3. Cody BB19
    4. Brett BB20
    5. Monte BB24
    6. Joseph BB24
    7. Tucker BB26
    8. Cedric BB26
    9. Matt BB26
    10. Rachel BB12
    11. Davonne BB17
    12. Haleigh BB20
    13. Janelle BB6
    14. Alyssa BB23
    15. Taylor BB24
    16. Reilly BB25
    17. Kiersten BB25
    18. Chelsie BB26

    Ooooo, that sounds terrible- 

    Ooooo, that sounds terrible- 

    Thank you for validating my cast and proving it was great.

    Rivals II (recast as CoEd pairs)

     

    Abram & Laurel

    Bananas & KellyAnne

    CJ & Ayiiia

    CT & Aneesa

    Dustin & Trishelle

    Frank & Nany

    Johnny & Jessica

    Jordan & Nia

    Leroy & Cooke

    Swift & LaToya

    Trey & Marie

    Ty & Camila

    Wes & Cara Maria

    Zach & Sam

    Love this cast.....id swap out Darrell for Bananas.

     

    Here is my cast for USA3: Survivor vs Big Brother:

    Survivor

    1. Cole S35
    2. Michael S36
    3. Alec S37
    4. Dean S39
    5. Kaleb S45
    6. Q S45
    7. Sam S47
    8. Michaela S33
    9. Angelina S37
    10. Sydney S41
    11. Dee  S45
    12. Venus S46
    13. Tiffany S46
    14. Genevieve S47

    Big Brother

    1. Devin BB16
    2. Brett BB20
    3. Monte BB24
    4. Joseph BB24
    5. Tucker BB26
    6. Cedric BB26
    7. Matt BB26
    8. Rachel BB12
    9. Haleigh BB20
    10. Janelle BB6
    11. Alyssa BB23
    12. Reilly BB25
    13. Kiersten BB25
    14. Chelsie BB26

    36 is way too much for a USA. Cutting Rome because he spoiled 47 so **** him, Wendell, Parvati, Cydney, Taylor, Janelle and both Codys will never come, and Davonne is apparently done.

    And at 28, this is still an S-Tier cast. Bravo.

    Both Battle of the Sexes were 36 people and they were epic.

    36 isn't too much. Two people leave a week for 13 episodes. That's minus 26 and a 10 person team final. Can probably do a bigger final of 12 people and do a two part premiere with no elimination the first episode. Film it in 4 weeks and all those people will say yes.

    36 is way too much for a 12-14 episode spinoff. Most people will be invisible for half the season. I think 34-36 is the sweet spot for an 18,19 episode season and 26-28 for 12-14 episodes.

    I disagree, especially with 90 minute episodes. The more the merrier. Sexes 1 & 2 were amazing with 36 people and only 30 min episodes.

    I disagree, especially with 90 minute episodes. The more the merrier. Sexes 1 & 2 were amazing with 36 people and only 30 min episodes.

    USA 1 and 2 were only 42 minute episodes though...

    Pages