The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

All Stars 5 Re-Cast

.

[Same pairs]

- Fessy & Amber

- Shane & Da’Vonne

- Frank & Sam

- Adam & Steve

.

[Different Pairs]

- Dario & Nany (argued on Bloodlines)

- Corey & Melissa (argued on BFANC)

- Nicole & Sylvia (argued on Invasion)

- Jonna & Kellyanne (argued on World Championship)

- Devin & Turbo (argued on Ride or Dies)

- Beth & Nehemiah/MJ (Beth & Nehemiah are exes/rivals from Duel 1; Beth & MJ dislike each other from AS3)

- Ashley K & CJ (hooked up on Battle of the Seasons 2)

- Ashley M & Jay M (enemies from RW Ex-Plosion)

- Aneesa & Laterrian ("exes" from All Stars 1)

- Veronica & Chadwick (rivals from Battle of the Seasons 1)

.

[Teams I wish they cast]

- Marlon & Jemmye ("exes" from Rivals 2 & Ex on the Peak)

- Susie & Johnny (rivals from The Ruins & her podcast)

- Alton & Irulan (exes from RW Las Vegas & Gauntlet 1)

- Wes & Louise Hazel (rivals from Champs vs Stars 2)

Recasting All Stars 5 as Same-Sex Pairs (Trying to be realistic)

Men:

1. Adam & Steve (All Stars feud)
2. Brad & MJ (All Stars feud)
3. Cory & Darrell (D30/DA feud)
4. Derrick & Nehemiah (All Stars feud)
5. Devin & Josh (SLA/DA feud)
6. Dustin & Frank (BOTS feud)
7. Latterian & Mark (All Stars feud)
8. Wes & yes (All Stars feud)

Women:

1. Averey & Nia (RW feud)
2. Ayanna & Janelle (All Stars feud)
3. Beth & Jonna (All Stars feud)
4. Cara Maria & Nicole (Invasion/Vendettas/All Stars feud)
5. Katie & Veronica (Inferno feud)
6. Kailah & Melissa (Final Reckoning feud)
7. KellyAnne & Sylvia (All Stars feud)
8. Nany & Theresa (BOTE2/DA feud)

Rivals 4

 

Rules: Just like the first 2 Rivals seasons the eliminations would alternate between guy and girl days. The team of of the designated sex for that days elimination is safe. The winning team whose sex is not designated for the Jungle is awarded a cash prize and a sabotage they can use on a team in the next challenge. The team of the designated sex for that days elimination that finishes last is automatically sent to the Jungle. The winning team that is safe from elimination will then nominate 2 teams to possibly face elimination. After that the rest of the house will have to vote between the 2 teams to send into elimination. The team with the most votes then goes in aganist the losing team. In the event of a tie the winning team that is safe will choose who goes in. This will go on until there are 3 teams left of each sex and those teams will compete in the final. It wouldbe 13 challenges with the first 12 alternating between guy and girl days. The 13th challenge would be a double elimination. After that is the final. Also no stealing money twist as I feel that is stupid.

 

I prefer last place team always goes in automatically because this prevents terrible layup teams from making it far. You have to perform to stay safe as well. House voting part can cause drama as it can be boring where only the winning team has any say on who goes into elimination. I like watching the cast scramble and strategize on who to vote for. If the winning team was smart they will put two teams who are in the same alliance up for nominations so this can cause riffs in alliances.

 

Teams:

I tried making the cast as diverse and realistic as possible. Also included team colors for fun with a randomizer. I also went with a big cast as you can see.

 

 

Cara Maria Sorbello/Tori Deal- Red

Laurel Stucky/Michele Fitzgerald- Blue

Nurys Mateo/Olivia Kaiser- Light Blue

Nany González/Theresa Gonzalez- Black

KellyAnne Judd/Jonna Mannion- Green

Kailah Casillas/Melissa Reeves- Purple

Kaycee Clark/Bayleigh Dayton- Navy

Jenna Compono/Amanda Garcia- Yellow

Kiki Morris/Emily Seebohm- Orange

Ashley Mitchell/Da'Vonne Rogers- Grey

 

Yes Duffy/Wes Bergmann- Black

Kyland Young/Asaf Goren- Grey

Turbo Çamkıran/Jordan Wiseley- Green

Jay Starrett/Horacio Gutiérrez- Orange

Paulie Calafiore/Kyle Christie- Blue

Johnny Devenanzio/Shane Landrum- Yellow

Tony Raines/Cory Wharton- Navy

Derrick Kosinski/Nehemiah Clark- Purple

CT Tamburello/Fessy Shafaat- Red

Adam Larson/Steve Meinke- Light blue

 

Any thoughts? Who would be in the finals? Who would win?

 

Also side note, I feel like this should have been the rules for Rivals 3 where the winning team selects two teams and instead of the stupid skull twist, the rest of the house has to vote between the 2 teams.

The Challenge: Battle for Redemption 

Girls:

1. Analyse Talavera (Big Brother 21) - Didn’t get to compete in her elimination on Ride or Dies 

2. Angela Babicz (BGC: Twisted Sisters) - Eliminated on Final Reckoning because Faith broke her nail 

3. Ashley Mitchell (RW: Explosion) - Disqualified on Spies, Lies & Allies with no explanation 

4. Brianna Taylor (RW: Hollywood) - Eliminated early on The Ruins & never got a second chance 

5. CeeJai Jenkins (RW: GBOGH) - Sent home on her season of Real World

6. Dee Nguyen (Geordie Shore) - Fired from MTV & edited out of Total Madness after insensitive tweets during the height of the BLM movement 

7. Esther Agunbiade (BB Naija) - Eliminated before the team portion of Spies, Lies & Allies

8. Faith Stowers (Vanderpump Rules) - Quit War of the Worlds 2

9. Lauren Coogan (Love Island 2) - Unfairly disqualified on Spies, Lies & Allies with no explanation

10. Mackenzie Dipman (Love Island 2) - Walked on Love Island Season 4

11. Mattie Lynn Breaux (Party Down South) - Personal redemption after multiple DUI’s and tweets using the N-Word 

12. Natalie Anderson (The Amazing Race 29) - Medically disqualified on Double Agents

13. Tamara Alfaro (Ride or Dies) - Early exit on Ride or Dies

14. Tyara Hooks (RW: Bad Blood) - Quit on her season of Real World 

15. Zahida Allen (EOTB UK) - Quit War of the Worlds 2 

Guys: 

1. Bruno Bettencourt (RW: Skeletons) - First boot on Invasion 

2. Bryton Constantin (Squid Games) - Early boot on Squid Games & Perfect Match plus personal redemption after homophobic tweets 

3. Carrington Rodriguez (Love Island 2) - Dumped early on Love Island Games

4. Cohutta Grindstaff (RW: Sydney) - Disqualified on All Stars 2 with no chance to compete 

5. Coye Simmons (Love Island 6) - Dumped first on his season of Love Island 

6. Derrick Henry (AYTO?: Season 5) - Exited early on both of his Challenge seasons

7. Dustin Zito (RW: Las Vegas 2) - Eliminated early on his last two Challenge seasons

8. Eddie Williams (AYTO?: Season 5) - Disqualified on Vendettas with no explanation 

9. Hunter Barfield (AYTO?: Season 3) - Eliminated in the War of the Worlds final

10. Jay Starrett (Survivor 33) - Eliminated in the Battle for a New Champion final

11. Johnny Middlebrooks (Love Island 2) - Eliminated early on Ride or Dies 

12. Rogan O’Connor (EOTB UK) - Eliminated in Total Madness plus personal redemption after racist tweets 

13. Theo King Bradley (RW: Bad Blood) - Quit on Invasion 

14. Thomas Buell (RW: Ex-Plosion) - Quit on Rivals 3

15. Tony Raines (RW: Skeletons) - Quit on All Stars 4

The Challenge: All Stars 5 Recast

Teams:

1. Alton Williams & Irulan Wilson (RW: Las Vegas) - Exes 
2. Amanda Garcia & Faysal Shafaat (Spies, Lies & Allies) - Exes 
3. Amber Borzotra & Jeremiah White (Love Island 2) - Exes
4. Ashley Mitchell & Mattie Lynn Breaux (Total Madness) - Rivals 
5. Bruno Bettencourt & Sylvia Elsrode (RW: Skeletons) - Rivals 
6. Coral Smith & Evelyn Smith (The Gauntlet 3) - Rivals
7. Da’Vonne Rogers & Shane Landrum (Final Reckoning) - Rivals 
8. Frank Sweeney & Nany Gonzalez (Battle of the Seasons 2012) - Rivals
9. Hunter Barfield & Kailah Casillas (Dirty 30) - Rivals 
10. Jay Mitchell & Zach Nichols (Battle of the Exes 2) - Rivals 
11. Jay Starrett & Rogan O’Connor (Total Madness) - Rivals
12. Marie Roda & Sam McGinn (Battle of the Seasons 2012) - Rivals 
13. Melissa Reeves & Ravyn Rochelle (Battle for a New Champion) - Rivals

The Challenge: All Stars 5 Recast

Teams:

1. Alton Williams & Irulan Wilson (RW: Las Vegas) - Exes 
2. Amanda Garcia & Faysal Shafaat (Spies, Lies & Allies) - Exes 
3. Amber Borzotra & Jeremiah White (Love Island 2) - Exes
4. Ashley Mitchell & Simone Kelly (Rivals 3) - Rivals 
5. Bruno Bettencourt & Sylvia Elsrode (RW: Skeletons) - Rivals 
6. Coral Smith & Evelyn Smith (The Gauntlet 3) - Rivals
7. Da’Vonne Rogers & Shane Landrum (Final Reckoning) - Rivals 
8. Frank Sweeney & Nany Gonzalez (Battle of the Seasons 2012) - Rivals
9. Hunter Barfield & Kailah Casillas (Dirty 30) - Rivals 
10. Jay Mitchell & Zach Nichols (Battle of the Exes 2) - Rivals 
11. Jay Starrett & Rogan O’Connor (Total Madness) - Rivals
12. Marie Roda & Sam McGinn (Battle of the Seasons 2012) - Rivals 
13. Melissa Reeves & Ravyn Rochelle (Battle for a New Champion) - Rivals

Coral & Evelyn would be a good team.  They would balance each other out if they could get along

The Challenge 41: Battleground

 

Team Real World:

Frank (RW: San Diego 2)

Cory (RW: Explosion)

Theo (RW: Bad Blood)

Nia (RW: Portland)

Ashley (RW: Explosion)

Kailah (RW: Go Big or Go Home)

 

Team Are You The One?:

Devin (Season 3)

Hunter (Season 3)

Brendan (Season 9)

Amanda (Season 3)

Kam  (Season 5)

Nurys (Season 6)

 

Team Big Brother:

Zach (BB 16)

Paulie (BB 18)

Kyland (BB 23)

Amber (BB 16)

Da’Vonne (BB 17)

Alyssa (BB 23)

 

Team Survivor:

Jay (Millennials vs Gen X)

Wendell (Ghost Island)

Chris (Edge of Extinction)

Michaela (Millennials vs Gen X)

Michele (Kaoh Rong)

Dee (45)

 

Team Love Island:

Johnny (Season 2)

Carrington (Season 2)

Cinco (Season 3)

Justine (Season 2)

Olivia (Season 3)

Imani (Season 5)

The Challenge: Battle for Redemption 

Girls:

1. Analyse Talavera (Big Brother 21) - Didn’t get to compete in her elimination on Ride or Dies 

2. Angela Babicz (BGC: Twisted Sisters) - Eliminated on Final Reckoning because Faith broke her nail 

3. Ashley Mitchell (RW: Explosion) - Disqualified on Spies, Lies & Allies with no explanation 

4. Brianna Taylor (RW: Hollywood) - Eliminated early on The Ruins & never got a second chance 

5. CeeJai Jenkins (RW: GBOGH) - Sent home on her season of Real World

6. Dee Nguyen (Geordie Shore) - Fired from MTV & edited out of Total Madness after insensitive tweets during the height of the BLM movement 

7. Esther Agunbiade (BB Naija) - Eliminated before the team portion of Spies, Lies & Allies

8. Faith Stowers (Vanderpump Rules) - Quit War of the Worlds 2

9. Lauren Coogan (Love Island 2) - Unfairly disqualified on Spies, Lies & Allies with no explanation

10. Mackenzie Dipman (Love Island 2) - Walked on Love Island Season 4

11. Mattie Lynn Breaux (Party Down South) - Personal redemption after multiple DUI’s and tweets using the N-Word 

12. Natalie Anderson (The Amazing Race 29) - Medically disqualified on Double Agents

13. Tamara Alfaro (Ride or Dies) - Early exit on Ride or Dies

14. Tyara Hooks (RW: Bad Blood) - Quit on her season of Real World 

15. Zahida Allen (EOTB UK) - Quit War of the Worlds 2 

Guys: 

1. Bruno Bettencourt (RW: Skeletons) - First boot on Invasion 

2. Bryton Constantin (Squid Games) - Early boot on Squid Games & Perfect Match plus personal redemption after homophobic tweets 

3. Carrington Rodriguez (Love Island 2) - Dumped early on Love Island Games

4. Cohutta Grindstaff (RW: Sydney) - Disqualified on All Stars 2 with no chance to compete 

5. Coye Simmons (Love Island 6) - Dumped first on his season of Love Island 

6. Derrick Henry (AYTO?: Season 5) - Exited early on both of his Challenge seasons

7. Dustin Zito (RW: Las Vegas 2) - Eliminated early on his last two Challenge seasons

8. Eddie Williams (AYTO?: Season 5) - Disqualified on Vendettas with no explanation 

9. Hunter Barfield (AYTO?: Season 3) - Eliminated in the War of the Worlds final

10. Jay Starrett (Survivor 33) - Eliminated in the Battle for a New Champion final

11. Johnny Middlebrooks (Love Island 2) - Eliminated early on Ride or Dies 

12. Rogan O’Connor (EOTB UK) - Eliminated in Total Madness plus personal redemption after racist tweets 

13. Theo King Bradley (RW: Bad Blood) - Quit on Invasion 

14. Thomas Buell (RW: Ex-Plosion) - Quit on Rivals 3

15. Tony Raines (RW: Skeletons) - Quit on All Stars 4

yes!

THE CHALLENGE: ALL STARS 6

Team format. Champions vs Veterans vs Rookies (Stats previous to *** / S40, so no spoilers, dont worry )

CHAMPIONS

CONTENDERS

ROOKIES (Two or less seasons)

ALTERNATES:  Tyler Duckworth & Jodi Weatherton //////////// Tyri Ballard-Brown & Sylvia Elsrode /////////// Brandon Swift & Emilee Fitzpatrick

Season 41, The Challenge Gauntlet 4: Rookies vs Vets.

Vets

Adam

CT

Dario

Darrell

Derek

Kefla

Shane

Theo C

Turbo

Zach

Amanda

Ashley M

Jonna

Laurel

Marie

Michele

Michaela

Nia

Nurys

Tina

Rookies

Bryton SG1

Carrington LI2

Connor LI6

George LI6

Jesse SG1

Johnny LI2

Kaleb S45

Kordell LI6

Rob LI6

Q S46

Dee S45

Destiny LI6

Holly THTH2

Jada SG1

JaNa LI6

Kishori AR36

Lauren LI2

Liv LI6

Serena LI6

Sydney S41

I'm interested in how this season would play out.... post results please 

Season 41, The Challenge Gauntlet 4: Rookies vs Vets.

Vets

Adam

CT

Dario

Darrell

Derek

Kefla

Shane

Theo C

Turbo

Zach

Amanda

Ashley M

Jonna

Laurel

Marie

Michele

Michaela

Nia

Nurys

Tina

Rookies

Bryton SG1

Johnny LI2

Kaleb S45

Q S46

Dee S45

Sydney S41

I deleted the people I don't know. 

The Challenge: All Stars 5 Recast

Teams:

1. Alton Williams & Irulan Wilson (RW: Las Vegas) - Exes 
2. Amanda Garcia & Faysal Shafaat (Spies, Lies & Allies) - Exes 
3. Amber Borzotra & Jeremiah White (Love Island 2) - Exes
4. Ashley Mitchell & Mattie Lynn Breaux (Total Madness) - Rivals 
5. Bruno Bettencourt & Sylvia Elsrode (RW: Skeletons) - Rivals 
6. Coral Smith & Evelyn Smith (The Gauntlet 3) - Rivals
7. Da’Vonne Rogers & Shane Landrum (Final Reckoning) - Rivals 
8. Frank Sweeney & Nany Gonzalez (Battle of the Seasons 2012) - Rivals
9. Hunter Barfield & Kailah Casillas (Dirty 30) - Rivals 
10. Jay Mitchell & Zach Nichols (Battle of the Exes 2) - Rivals 
11. Jay Starrett & Rogan O’Connor (Total Madness) - Rivals
12. Flower Pot & Sam McGinn (Battle of the Seasons 2012) - Rivals 
13. Melissa Reeves & Ravyn Rochelle (Battle for a New Champion) - Rivals

Fixed it

The Challenge: USA (Rebooted)

Rookies from American-based shows and Challengers with two or fewer appearances under their belt (minus one, but he made sense for the cast)

Johnny Middlebrooks (Love Island USA 2)

Bryton Constain (Squid Games: The Challenge)

Lorenzo Nobillio (Squid Games: The Challenge)

Jared Fields (Big Brother 25)

Jeff Christian Jr. (Love Island USA 4)

Timmy Pandolfi (Love Island USA 4)

Ray Gnatt (Love Island USA)

Chase Demoor (Too Hot to Handle 1)

Kelechi "Kelz" **** (Too Hot to Handle)

Cinco Holland Jr. (Love Island US 3)

Jay Starrett (Survivor: MvGx)

Hisam Goueli (Big Brother 25)

Kaleb Gebrewold (Survivor 45)

Ryan Medrano (Survivor 43)

Dusty Harris (The Amazing Race 33)

Robert "Rob" Rausch (Love Island USA 5 AND 6) 

Kendall Washington (Love Island USA 6)

Monte Taylor (Big Brother 24)

Justine Nbida (Love Island USA 2)

Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor: MvG)

Taylor Hale (Big Brother 24)

Imani Wheeler (Love Island USA 5)

Zeta Morrison (Love Islanda USA 6)

America Lopez (Big Brother 25)

Blue Kim (Big Brother 25)

Tiffany Mitchell (Big Brother 24)

Trina Njoroge (Love Islanda USA 3)

Michaela Pratt (Survivor: MvGx)

Melinda Melrose (Too Hot to Handle)

Cassidy Clarke (Survivor 43) 

Chanelle Howell (Survivor 42)

Esther Agunbiade (Big Brother Nigeria 4)

Dee Valladares (Survivor 45)

JaNa Craig (Love Island USA 6)

Ravyn Rochelle (The Challenge: Ride or Dies)

Serena Page (Love Island USA 6)

Cringe Kendall and Blue lol? No.

Love the idea & love the cast!

 

The Challenge: All Stars 5 Recast

Teams:

1. Alton Williams & Irulan Wilson (RW: Las Vegas) - Exes 
2. Amanda Garcia & Faysal Shafaat (Spies, Lies & Allies) - Exes 
3. Amber Borzotra & Jeremiah White (Love Island 2) - Exes
4. Ashley Mitchell & Mattie Lynn Breaux (Total Madness) - Rivals 
5. Bruno Bettencourt & Sylvia Elsrode (RW: Skeletons) - Rivals 
6. Coral Smith & Evelyn Smith (The Gauntlet 3) - Rivals
7. Da’Vonne Rogers & Shane Landrum (Final Reckoning) - Rivals 
8. Frank Sweeney & Nany Gonzalez (Battle of the Seasons 2012) - Rivals
9. Hunter Barfield & Kailah Casillas (Dirty 30) - Rivals 
10. Jay Mitchell & Zach Nichols (Battle of the Exes 2) - Rivals 
11. Jay Starrett & Rogan O’Connor (Total Madness) - Rivals
12. Flower Pot & Sam McGinn (Battle of the Seasons 2012) - Rivals 
13. Melissa Reeves & Ravyn Rochelle (Battle for a New Champion) - Rivals

Fixed it

LMAO

Cringe Kendall and Blue lol? No.

Kendall is manipulative, and Blue has an ex and a rival in the cast.

I don't like everyone on this list, but most are here because of prior relationships.

The Challenge: Battle of the Legends

 

Blue:

Emily

Jonna

Jenna

Laurel

Rachel

Brad

Jordan

Alton

Zach

Derrick

 

Red:

Nany

Amanda

Veronica

Theresa

Sylvia

Abram

Frank

Cory

Darrell

Landon

 

Green:

Aneesa

Tori D

Kam

Tina

Cara Maria

Shane

Mark 

CT

Wes

Tony

 

Yellow:

Susie

Kellyanne

Sarah

Jodi

Ashley

Bananas

Leroy

Hunter

Kyle

Nelson

 

Episode 1:

Winners: Red

Saved: Blue

Voted in Green: Tina and Mark

Voted in Yellow: Susie and Hunter

Eliminated: Susie and Hunter

 

Episode 2:

Winners: Blue

Saved: Red

Voted in Green: Tina and Mark

Voted in Yellow: Jodi and Kyle

Eliminated: Tina and Kyle

 

Episode 3:

Winners: Blue

Saved: Red

Voted in Green: Kam and Tony

Voted in Yellow: Jodi and Nelson

Eliminated: Kam and Nelson

 

Episode 4:

Winners: Green

Saved: Blue

Voted in Red: Sylvia and Landon

Voted in Yellow: Jodi and Leroy

Eliminated: Sylvia and Landon

 

New Teams:

Jodi and Cara Maria

Jenna and Amanda

Sarah and Ashley

Rachel and Nany

Veronica and Emily

Jonna and Aneesa

Laurel and Kellyanne

Tori D and Theresa

 

Darrell and Bananas

Jordan and Leroy

Alton and Frank

Brad and CT

Wes and Shane

Derrick and Tony

Abram and Zach

Mark and Cory

 

Episode 5:

Winners: Jonna and Aneesa/ Brad and CT

Last: Veronica and Emily/ Abram and Zach

Voted in: Jenna and Amanda/ Alton and Frank

Eliminated: Jenna and Amanda/ Alton and Frank

 

Episode 6:

Winners: Sarah and Ashley/ Jordan and Leroy

Last: Tori D and Theresa/ Derrick and Tony

Voted in: Jodi and Cara Maria/ Abram and Zach

Eliminated: Tori D and Theresa/ Derrick and Tony

 

Episode 7:

Winners: Sarah and Ashley/ Wes and Shane

Last: Jonna and Aneesa/ Jordan and Leroy

Voted in: Jodi and Cara Maria/ Abram and Zach

Eliminated: Jonna and Aneesa/ Jordan and Leroy

 

Individual Stage

Jodi

Sarah

Rachel

Veronica

Laurel

Cara Maria

Ashley

Nany

Emily

Kellyanne

 

Darrell

Brad

Wes

Abram

Mark

Bananas

CT

Shane

Zach

Cory

 

Episode 8:

Winners: Laurel and CT

Last: Veronica and Shane

Selected: Emily and Zach

Eliminated: Veronica and Shane

 

Episode 9:

Winners: Laurel and Bananas

Last: Nany and Cory

Selected: Jodi and Mark

Eliminated: Nany and Mark

 

Episode 10:

Winners: Sarah and Wes

Last: Kellyanne and Cory

Selected: Emily and Brad

Eliminated: Kellyanne and Cory

 

New Teams:

Cara Maria and CT

Jodi and Wes

Emily and Abram

Rachel and Zach

Sarah and Darrell

Ashley and Brad

Laurel and Bananas

 

Episode 11:

Winners: Jodi and Wes

Last: Sarah and Darrell

Voted in: Emily and Abram

Eliminated: Emily and Abram

 

Episode 12:

Winners: Sarah and Darrell

Last: Jodi and Wes

Voted in: Laurel and Bananas

Eliminated: Jodi and Wes

 

Episode 13:

Winners: Rachel and Zach

Last: Ashley and Brad

Voted in: Cara Maria and CT

Eliminated: Ashley and Brad

 

Episode 14: Individual Final

4th: Sarah and Zach

3rd: Cara Maria and CT

2nd: Laurel and Darrell

1st: Rachel and Bananas

The Challenge: Final Reckoning 2 (Randomized Teams)

Laurel and Kyle

Emily and Ashley

Bananas and Devin

Shane and Darrell

Amanda and Paulie

Jenna and Cara Maria

Wes and Jonna

Marie and CT

Fessy and Veronica

Rachel and Kam

Cory and Nany

Tina and Sylvia

Kailah and Cohutta

Zach and Brad

 

Episode 1:

Winners: Fessy and Veronica

2 Last Place Teams Going to Redemption: Amanda and Paulie/ Tina and Sylvia

Sent to Redemption: Emily and Ashley

 

Episode 2:

Winners: Marie and CT

Voted in: Laurel and Kyle

Chosen: Kailah and Cohutta

Sent to Redemption: Laurel and Kyle

 

Episode 3: REDEMPTION

Double Cross: Laurel and Kyle

Chosen: Emily and Ashley

Eliminated: Amanda and Paulie/ Tina and Sylvia

Winners: Laurel and Kyle

Back to Redemption: Emily and Ashley

 

Episode 4:

Purged to Redemption: Jenna and Cara Maria

 

Episode 5:

Winners: Rachel and Kam

Voted in: Laurel and Kyle

Chosen: Fessy and Veronica

Sent to Redemption: Fessy and Veronica

 

Episode 6:

Winners: Wes and Jonna

Voted in: Laurel and Kyle

Mercenaries: Kellyanne and Jordan

Sent to Redemption: Kellyanne and Jordan

 

Episode 7:

Winners: Bananas and Devin

Voted in: Laurel and Kyle

Chosen: Kailah and Cohutta

Sent to Redemption: Laurel and Kyle

 

Episode 8: Redemption

Double Cross: Jenna and Cara Maria

Chosen: Emily and Ashley

Eliminated: Fessy and Veronica/ Kellyanne and Jordan/ Laurel and Kyle

Winners: Emily and Ashley

Sent back to Redemption: Jenna and Cara Maria

 

Episode 9:

Purged and Sent to Redemption: Cory and Nany

 

Episode 10:

Winners: Zach and Brad

Voted in: Emily and Ashley

Chosen: Rachel and Kam

Sent to Redemption: Rachel and Kam

 

Episode 11:

Winners: Bananas and Devin

Voted in: Emily and Ashley

Chosen: Kailah and Cohutta

Mercenaries: Tony and Leroy

Sent to Redemption: Emily and Ashley/ Kailah and Cohutta

 

Episode 12:

Winners: Wes and Jonna

Voted in: Tony and Leroy

Chosen: Shane and Darrell

Sent to Redemption: Shane and Darrell

 

Episode 13: Redemption

Double Cross: Rachel and Kam/ Emily and Ashley

Chosen: Shane and Darrell/ Jenna and Cara Maria

Eliminated: Nany and Cory/ Kailah and Cohutta

Winners: Rachel and Kam/ Emily and Ashley

Sent back to Redemption: Shane and Darrell/ Jenna and Cara Maria

 

Episode 14:

Winners: Bananas and Devin

Voted in: Emily and Ashley

Chosen: Rachel and Kam

Sent to Redemption: Emily and Ashley

 

Episode 15:

Purged and Sent to Redemption: Marie and CT

 

Episode 16: Redemption

Double Cross: Emily and Ashley

Chosen: Jenna and Cara Maria

Other Matchup: Shane and Darrell vs Marie and CT

Winners: Emily and Ashley/ Shane and Darrell

Eliminated: Jenna and Cara Maria/ Marie and CT

 

Episode 17:

Purged and Eliminated: Rachel and Kam

 

Episode 18:

Purged and Eliminated: Emily and Ashley

 

Episode 19:

Winners: Bananas and Devin

Voted in: Shane and Darrell

Chosen: Tony and Leroy

Eliminated: Shane and Darrell

 

Episode 20:

4th: Tony and Leroy

3rd: Bananas and Devin

2nd: Wes and Jonna

1st: Zach and Brad

Bring back Ashley Cain! He's always been a beast, but now physically and with his mindset I think he'd be amazing to watch, and I'd love to see him win

I tried creating a simple, cute 30 person cast that would guarantee toxicity and drama that's also realistic. (Only includes people who have been on a season since szn 30 and who isn't blacklisted.)

Women

Amanda

Ashley Mitchell

Da'vonne 

Cara Maria

Melissa

Kailah

Ravyn

Nurys

Laurel

Amber B

Nicole Z

Kam

Kayleigh

Marie

Tori

Men

Hunter

Tony

Cory

Zach

Brad

Bananas

Paulie

Shane

Turbo

Josh

Fessy

Kyland

Corey L

Chauncey 

Johnny M

Give or take a few names I feel like this is very doable and would naturally create entertainment

pass on Chauncey, dude is a zero

I was going to do a battle of the eras style format for the worst competitions but most of the truly horrible people are from eras 2 or 3 lol

I was going to do a battle of the eras style format for the worst competitions but most of the truly horrible people are from eras 2 or 3 lol

Devyn be winning.

I was going to do a battle of the eras style format for the worst competitions but most of the truly horrible people are from eras 2 or 3 lol

Devyn be winning.

It's the men I'm struggling with for casting lol. Like who are 5 horrible era 1 or 3 men?

I was going to do a battle of the eras style format for the worst competitions but most of the truly horrible people are from eras 2 or 3 lol

Devyn be winning.

It's the men I'm struggling with for casting lol. Like who are 5 horrible era 1 or 3 men?

Jon Brennan, Laterrian, David Burns, Stephen Williams, Jeremy, Karamo

Mike Ross, both Nate S's, Jay M, JJ, Swift, Stephen Buell, Shane R, Brandon T, Derrick H

See that's the problem most of the terrible era 3 guys just don't get another call lol 

The Challenge: Free Agents

Location: Medellin, Colombia

Host: Johnny Bananas

Contestants:

Carrington (Love Island USA 2)

Chase (Too Hot to Handle 2)

Corey (12 Dates of Christmas)

Cory (RW: Explosion)

Derek (RW: Cancun)

Devin (AYTO? 3)

Frank (RW: San Diego 2011)

Jared (Big Brother 25)

Jay (Survivor)

Johnny (Love Island USA 2)

Josh (Big Brother 19)

Kendall (Love Island USA 6)

Kyland (Big Brother 23)

Paulie (Big Brother 18)

Rob (Love Island USA 6)

Sami (Survivor 43)

Tony (RW: Skeletons)

Tucker (Big Brother 26)

 

Alyssa (Big Brother 23)

Amanda (AYTO? 3)

Ashley (RW: Ex-Plosion)

Blue (Big Brother 25)

Cassidy (Survivor 43)

Dee (Survivor 45)

Diandra (AYTO? 6)

Imani (Love Island USA 4)

Jonitta (Lohan’s Beach Club)

Justine (Love Island USA 2)

Kam (AYTO? 5)

Liv (Love Island USA 6)

Michaela (Survivor: Millennials vs Gen X)

Michele (Survivor: Kaoh Rong)

Nurys (AYTO? 6)

Olivia (Love Island USA 3)

Ravyn (The Challenge: Ride or Dies)

Venus (Survivor 46)