The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

15070 posts / 0 new
Last post

Y'all really want that steaming pile of garbage Gio? lol

The Challenge: Showdown

Location: Kalafati, Mykonos, Greece

7 Teams each from different shows join to find out which show is the best.


Team Survivor

Jay Starrett (Survivor: Millennials vs Gen X)

Turbo Camkiran (Survivor Turkey Dirol

Michele Fitzgerald (Survivor: Kaoh Rong)

Natalie Anderson (Survivor: San Juan del Sur)


Team Love Island

Theo Campbell (Love Island UK 3)

Tre Forte (Love Island US 2)

Georgia Harrison (Love Island UK 3)

Justine Ndiba (Love Island US 2)


Team Big Brother

Faysal Shafaat (Big Brother 20)

Paulie Calafiore (Big Brother 18)

Amber Borzata (Big Brother 16)

Da’vonne Rogers (Big Brother 17)


Team Circle

Ed Eason (The Circle)

Joey Sasso (The Circle)

Miranda Bissonnette (The Circle)

Sammie Cimarelli (The Circle)


Team Ex on the Beach

Marlon Williams (The Real World: Portland)

Rogan O’Connor (Ex on the Beach UK 2)

Angela Babicz (Bad Girls Club 15)

Naomi Hedman (Ex on the Beach UK 4)


Team Beach Club

Brent Marks (Lohan’s Beach Club)

Kyle Marve (Lohan’s Beach Club)

Jonitta Wallace (Lohan’s Beach Club)

Kailah Casillas (The Real World: Go Big or Go Home)


Team Are You The One?

Justin Palm (Are You the One? Season 8 )

Nelson Thomas (Are You the One? Season 3)

Amanda Garcia (Are You the One? Season 3)

Kam Williams (Are You the One? Season 5)


TJ says some corny thing about needing more OG’s and outcomes these 2 Teams


Team Real World

Cory Wharton (The Real World: Ex-Plosion)

Tony Raines (The Real World: Skeletons)

KellyAnne Judd (The Real World: Sydney)

Nany Gonzalez (The Real World: Las Vegas 2011)


Team Road Rules

Darrell Taylor (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)

Shane Landrum (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)

Kendal Sheppard (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)

Rachel Robinson (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)

Ex on the Beach Season 5 Fantasy Cast


Cuban Doll (Rapper)

Jania Meshell (Social Media Influencer)
Fessy Shafaat (Big Brother)
Zach Rance - Big Brother 16


Tadoe - Cuban's Ex

Dejounte Murray - Jania's Ex
Harry Jowsey - Francesca's Ex
Shamoy Persad - Maria's Ex
Haley Cureton - Francesca's Ex
Maria Elizondo - Kwasi's Ex

Haleigh Broucher - Fessy's Ex

Ashley Mitchell - Fessy's Ex


Midseason Addition:

Jazmyn Wallace - BGC: Twisted Sisters

I don't think Zach and Jozea dated but its MTV so theu would make a fake storyline. Lol Lets add Frankie.

The Challenge: The Intrusion

Defenders: Jordan, Marlon, Johnny, Hunter, Devin, Darrell, Nelson, Nehemiah, Laurel, Cara, Kam, Ashley, Kailah, Cooke, Marie, Tori

Intruders: Turbo, Fessy, Paulie, Jay, Caleb (LI), Rogan, Josh, Josiah(EOTBUK), Kaycee, Natalie A., Justine, Bayleigh, Da'Vonne, Melissa, Dominika (EOTBUK), Big T

OG Seasons 2

Coral, Tina, Julie, Veronica, Rachel, Ibis, Kelley (New Orleans), Susie, Cara Z, Irulan, 

Shane, Steven (Las Vegas), Landon, Danny (New Orleans), Jamie Murray, Timmy, Dan (RR), MJ, Tyler, Abe. 

The Challenge: The Ruins 2

The Ruins meets Cutthroat with the groups consisting of Champions, Winners and Finalists


  • Derrick Kosinski (Road Rules: X-Treme)  
  • Frank Sweeney (Real World: San Diego) 
  • Rogan O'Connor (Ex on the Beach) 
  • Turbo (Survivor: Turkey) 
  • Wes Bergmann (Real World: Austin)
  • Ashley Mitchell (Real World: X-Plosion)
  • Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)
  • Jenny West (Survival of the Fittest)
  • Rachel Robinson (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) 
  • Veronica Portillo (Road Rules: Semester at Sea)



  • Asaf Goran (Big Brother VIP) 
  • Chris James (Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands)
  • Cody Califiore (Big Brother 22)
  • Devin Walker (Are You The One: Second Chances)
  • Tony Raines (Champs vs. Stars 3)
  • Justine Nbida (Love Island US)
  • Kaycee Clark (Big Brother 20)
  • Liv Leilani (Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands)
  • Natalie Anderson (Survivor: San Juan del Sur)
  • Paras Atashnak (Big Brother Canada 7)




  • Caspar Smart (Champs Vs. Stars)
  • Fessy Shaffat (Big Brother 20)
  • Marlon Williams (Real World: Portland) 
  • Paulie Califiore (Big Brother 18)
  • Theo Campbell (Love Island 3) 
  • Kam Williams (Are You The One 5)
  • Louise Hazel (Champs Vs. Pros) 
  • Marie Roda (Real World: St. Thomas) 
  • Nany Gonzales (Real World: Las Vegas)
  • Tina Barta (Road Rules: South Pacific)

The Challenge: Black Excellence

Location: Mpumalanga, South Africa


My yearly Black Excellence cast in honor of Black History Month.


Alton Williams (The Real World: Las Vegas)

Ashley Cain (Ex on the Beach UK 2)

Basit Shittu (Are You the One? Season 8 )

Brandon Nelson (The Challenge: Fresh Meat II)

Chris James (Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands)

Cory Wharton (The Real World: Ex-Plosion)

Darrell Taylor (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)

Kwasi (Are You the One? Season 6)

Leroy Garrett (The Real World: Las Vegas 2011)

Marlon Williams (The Real World: Portland)

Michael Griffith (Ex on the Beach UK 5)

Nehemiah Clark (The Real World: Austin)

Nelson Thomas (Are You the One? Season 3)

Theo Campbell (Love Island UK 3)

Tre Forte (Love Island US 2)


Amber Borzata (Big Brother 16)

Aneesa Ferriera (The Real World: Chicago)

Bayleigh Dayton (Big Brother 20)

CeeJai Jenkins (The Real World: Go Big or Go Home)

Coral Smith (The Real World: Back to New York)

Tula “Big T Fazakerley (Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands)

Da’vonne Rogers (Big Brother 17)

Danielle Lickey (Big Brother: Over the Top)

Faith Stowers (Vanderpump Rules)

Jonitta Wallace (Lohan’s Beach Club)

Justine Ndiba (Love Island US 2)

Kam Williams (Are You the One? Season 5)

Olivia “Liv” Leilani (Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands)

Nia Moore (The Real World: Portland)

Seven Craft (Bad Girls Club 17)


The Challenge 37: Proving Ground

A Challenge format where teams are formed based on how many seasons the members have competed in.


Billy Reilich (Ex on the Beach 3), Brett Robinson (BB20), Justin Palm (AYTO8)

Kaela Grant (BBCan6), Lauren O’Connell (Survivor EoE), Sammie Cimarelli (The Circle US)

1 Previous Season

Sean Lineker, Asaf Goren, Ashley Cain

Natalie Anderson, Bayleigh Dayton, Heather Cooke

2 Previous Seasons

Fessy Shafaat, CJ Koegel, Jay Starrett

Georgia Harrison, Natalie “Ninja” Duran, Louise Hazel

3 Previous Seasons

Nicole Zanatta, Natalie Negrotti, Tula “Big T” Fazakerley

Rogan O’Connor, Frank Sweeney, Paulie Calafiore

4 or 5 Previous Seasons

Cohutta Grindstaff, Hunter Barfield, Devin Walker

Kam Williams, Kellyanne Judd, Kailah Casillas

6+ Previous Seasons

Laurel Stucky, Ashley Mitchell, Nany Gonzalez

Abram Boise, Nelson Thomas, Tony Raines


Explanations for choices are here: