The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

15226 posts / 0 new
Last post

Duel 3 or other name (Individual) 

Girls, Jenny, Kam, Cara, Ashley M, Tori, Theresa, Aneesa, Natalie A, Louise, Justine (Love Island), Kailah, and Amber B. 

Boys, Turbo, Paulie, Joss, Rogan, Nelson, Hunter, Darrell, Derrick, Fessy, Brett (BB), Caleb (Love Island), and Brad.

The problem im not knowing all of these reality tv shows, is not been able to follow your fantasy casts. It's sad that some lists just contains names for me now. 

If Rivals was used instead of Guantlet 3

Who wins?

Coral/Trishelle.   Shane/Darrell

Veronica/Emily.   Adam/Abram

Tina/Mary Beth.    Davis/Stephen

Kina/Angel.            Alton/Theo

Trisha/Parisa.          Johnny/Tyler

Robin/Aneesa.         Ct/Wes

Beth/Svetlana.          Nehimiah/Danny

Jenn/Rachel.             Puck/David

 

If Rivals was used instead of Guantlet 3

Who wins?

Coral/Trishelle.   Shane/Darrell

Veronica/Emily.   Adam/Abram

Tina/Mary Beth.    Davis/Stephen

Kina/Angel.            Alton/Theo

Trisha/Parisa.          Johnny/Tyler

Robin/Aneesa.         Ct/Wes

Beth/Svetlana.          Nehimiah/Danny

Jenn/Rachel.             Puck/David

I'd have used Veronica/Katie, Coral/Julie, Tina/Beth, Tonya/Susie, Evelyn/Aneesa, Kina/Cara & Jenn/Rachel M--the female rivalries were so awesome back in the day that there's countless options.

But I'll play

Women:  1.  Veronica/Emily   2.  Coral/Trishelle  3.  Beth/Svetlana (if they don't quit)

Men:   1.  CT/Wes  2.  Shane/Darrell  3.  Alton/Theo

Coral/Julie would have been an epic team as well!

The Duel 3: (Results were simulated so if they come out crazy dont blame me lol)

 

Men:

Bananas

CT

Wes

Jordan

Fessy

Darrell

Leroy

Zach

Josh

Paulie

 

Girls:

Amanda

Aneesa

Ashley

Averey

Davonne

Jenna

Kailah

Kam

Nany

Theresa

 

 

Episode 1:

Winners: Kailah and CT

Not Picked: Wes

Chosen: Paulie

Eliminated: Paulie

 

Episode 2:

Winners: Leroy and Davonne

Not Picked: Jenna

Chosen: Kailah

Eliminated: Jenna

 

Episode 3:

Winners: Theresa and Fessy

Not Picked: Wes

Chosen: Bananas

Eliminated: Bananas

 

Episode 4:

Winners: Fessy and Davonne

Not Picked: Kam

Chosen: Ashley

Eliminated: Ashley

 

Episode 5:

Winners: Nany and Leroy

Not Picked: Darrell

Chosen: Jordan

Eliminated: Darrell

 

Episode 6:

Winners: Leroy and Aneesa

Not Picked: Nany

Chosen: Kam

Eliminated: Nany

 

Episode 7:

Winners: Davonne and Leroy

Not Picked: Wes

Chosen: Fessy

Eliminated: Wes

 

Episode 8:

Winners: Jordan and Kam

Not Picked: Davonne

Chosen: Amanda

Eliminated: Amanda

 

Episode 9: 

Winners: Averey and Jordan

Not Picked: Zach 

Chosen: CT

Eliminated: CT

 

Episode 10:

Winners: Jordan and Kailah

Not Picked: Kam

Chosen: Davonne

Eliminated: Davonne

 

Episode 11:

Winners: Aneesa and Josh

Not Picked: Leroy

Chosen: Jordan

Eliminated: Leroy

 

Episode 12:

Winners: Jordan and Kailah

Not Picked: Kam

Chosen: Aneesa

Eliminated: Aneesa

 

Episode 13:

Winners: Kam and Josh

Not Picked: Zach

Chosen: Fessy

Eliminated: Zach

 

Episode 14:

Winners: Josh and Averey

Not Picked: Kailah

Chosen: Kam

Eliminated: Kailah

 

Episode 15:

Winners: Josh and Averey

Duel Matchups: Jordan vs Fessy, Kam vs Theresa

Eliminated: Fessy and Kam

 

Episode 16:

Winners: Josh and Averey

2nd Place: Jordan and Theresa

 

The Challenge: Battle of the Shows 

Credit to TeamLandon

Alternates in parenthesis. Similar format to Battle of the Seasons. Feel like teams are pretty evenly matched and I think if they tried this could actually be done. With all these new shows coming in I feel like it makes sense to try and market a season as "which show is the best" 

UK - Rogan, Kyle, Liv, Big T (Jenny/Joss)

AYTO - Kam, Tori, Nelson, Hunter (Amber M/Asaf)

BB - Fessy, Paulie, Amber B., Da'Vonne (Josh/Kaycee)

Survivor - Jay, Wendell, Natalie, Michelle (Idk Survivor) 

TRW - Wes, CT, Nany, Aneesa (Bananas/Averey)

TRW (New School) Cory, Tony, Ashley, Kailah (Thomas/Jenna)

Road Rules- Darrell, Shane, Rachel, Veronica (Derrick/Kendall)

Hybrid Team of Rookies: 4 new people from 4 different shows not already listed. 

Battle of the Exes 3:

Chad Johnson / Nicole Ramos 

CT / Mandi Moyer 

Nelson Thomas/ Angela Babicz

Jordan Weisley / Tori Deal 

Malcolm Drummer / Nurys Mateo

Theo Campbell / Kam Williams

Joss Mooney / Amanda Garcia

Cohutta Grindstaff / Nany Gonzalez 

Callum Izzard / Georgia Steele 

Leroy Garret / Jemmye Carrol 

Brad Fiorenza / Tori Hall 

Kyle Christie / Cara Maria Sorbello 

Paulie Calafiore / Lexi Marsella

How do you think this cast would play out!  

my top 3: Ct/Mandi, Jordan/Tori, Theo/Kam

 

 

 

Recasting Double Agents Rookies

Liv and Mechie can stay 

  • (Jon Moody(Southern Charm/Instead of Joseph)
  • Kenya Scott(AYTO7/EOTB3/ instead of Amber M)
  • Carlos Garcia(Paradise Hotel/Instead of Lio)
  • Tatum(Tempation Island/Instead of Lolo)
  • Callum Izard (Ibiza Weekender/Instead of Nam)
  • Kemi Faknule(BB21/Instead of Amber)
  • Kaz Crossley(Love Island UK/Instead of Gabby)
  • Morgan Lolar(Temptation Island/instead of Natalie)

All young and They would definitely deliver Dirol

Recasting Double Agents Rookies

Liv and Mechie can stay 

  • (Jon Moody(Southern Charm/Instead of Joseph)
  • Kenya Scott(AYTO7/EOTB3/ instead of Amber M)
  • Carlos Garcia(Paradise Hotel/Instead of Lio)
  • Tatum(Tempation Island/Instead of Lolo)
  • Callum Izard (Ibiza Weekender/Instead of Nam)
  • Danielle Lickey(BBOTT/Instead of Amber)
  • Kaz Crossley(Love Island UK/Instead of Gabby)
  • Morgan Lolar(Temptation Island/instead of Natalie)

All young and They would definitely deliver

I think I've made the worst season 

final reckoning 2, but with red skulls 

Bananas & Wes, Fessy & Kyle, Devin & Josh,

Brad & Britni, Zach & ninja, Jordan & Tori, Tyler & Christmas, Jozea & Kailah, David & Nicole (big brother) Rogan & Jennifer, Gus & Mattie, CT & Kaycee

Kayleigh & natalie, Aneesa & Nany, Amber m & Liv

mercenaries Hunter & Juila, Leroy & Jemmye  

The Challenge: Free Agents 2
Women: Laurel, Natalie A., Kam, Kailah, Marie, Ashley, Cara, Melissa, Missy(Survivor), Big T., Liv, Amber B., Nurys, Dani L (BBOTT)

Men: Jordan, Darrell, Rogan, Marlon, Fessy, Paulie, Jay, Hunter, Nelson, Turbo, Zach (BB16), Mechie, Malcolm (AYTO), Caleb (LI)

Recasting The Ruins 

Male Champs: Darrell, Wes, Kenny, Evan, John, Abe and Nehemiah 

Female Champs: Veronica, Johanna, Susie, Evelyn, Tori H, Rachel and Kendal 

Male Challengers: CT, Brad, Cohutta, Dunbar, Ace, Shane and Danny 

Female Challengers: Diem, Aneesa, Britni, Paula, KellyAnne, Svetlana and Sarah 

there's no need for Messy Missy from Survivor. she used someone's discomfort with unwanted touching as a tool in the game. that's not cute.

let's cast Cydney or Michaela instead, thx.

there's no need for Messy Missy from Survivor. she used someone's discomfort with unwanted touching as a tool in the game. that's not cute.

let's cast Cydney or Michaela instead, thx.

So many white men and women are given 5 or 6 chances, I think Missy deserves another shot.. Cydney and Michaela I don't think they want to come on anymore.. I'd like to see them though.

They will never cast Cydney she's so out spoken and strong. Plus I feel like shes better then the Challenge same with Michaela. Also Natalie is too.

Recasting The Ruins 

Male Champs: Darrell, Wes, Kenny, Evan, John, Abe and Nehemiah 

Female Champs: Veronica, Johanna, Susie, Evelyn, Tori H, Rachel and Kendal 

Male Challengers: CT, Brad, Cohutta, Dunbar, Ace, Shane and Danny 

Female Challengers: Diem, Aneesa, Britni, Paula, KellyAnne, Svetlana and Sarah 

Not bad...I always wanted it to have been

Evan Kenny John Wes Darrell Landon Frank R Susie Cara Z Evelyn Veronica Johanna Jillian and Ibis

CT Brad Dunbar Ace Chet Cohutta Tyler KellyAnne Aneesa Jenn Paula Sarah Kimberly Brianna and Brittini

Ideally 16 vs 16 instead of 14 vs 14 with Syrus Katie Derek M and Beth

Recasting The Ruins 

Male Champs: Darrell, Wes, Kenny, Evan, John, Abe and Nehemiah 

Female Champs: Veronica, Johanna, Susie, Evelyn, Tori H, Rachel and Kendal 

Male Challengers: CT, Brad, Cohutta, Dunbar, Ace, Shane and Danny 

Female Challengers: Diem, Aneesa, Britni, Paula, KellyAnne, Svetlana and Sarah 

Not bad...I always wanted it to have been

Evan Kenny John Wes Darrell Landon Frank R Susie Cara Z Evelyn Veronica Johanna Jillian and Ibis

CT Brad Dunbar Ace Chet Cohutta Tyler KellyAnne Aneesa Jenn Paula Sarah Kimberly Brianna and Brittini

Ideally 16 vs 16 instead of 14 vs 14 with Syrus Katie Derek M and Beth

Why are y'all still casting JEK together? That's what ruined the first one lol

Recasting The Ruins 

Male Champs: Darrell, Wes, Kenny, Evan, John, Abe and Nehemiah 

Female Champs: Veronica, Johanna, Susie, Evelyn, Tori H, Rachel and Kendal 

Male Challengers: CT, Brad, Cohutta, Dunbar, Ace, Shane and Danny 

Female Challengers: Diem, Aneesa, Britni, Paula, KellyAnne, Svetlana and Sarah 

Not bad...I always wanted it to have been

Evan Kenny John Wes Darrell Landon Frank R Susie Cara Z Evelyn Veronica Johanna Jillian and Ibis

CT Brad Dunbar Ace Chet Cohutta Tyler KellyAnne Aneesa Jenn Paula Sarah Kimberly Brianna and Brittini

Ideally 16 vs 16 instead of 14 vs 14 with Syrus Katie Derek M and Beth

Why are y'all still casting JEK together? That's what ruined the first one lol

Kenny and Evan were big names during this time period but John could stay home lol not to mention Kenny/Wes/Johanna storyline so you need Kenny 

What would have been your ideal format for Rivals 3 considering the cast we got? Ive looked it over and maybe they could have done vets v rookies 

Recasting The Ruins 

Male Champs: Darrell, Wes, Kenny, Evan, John, Abe and Nehemiah 

Female Champs: Veronica, Johanna, Susie, Evelyn, Tori H, Rachel and Kendal 

Male Challengers: CT, Brad, Cohutta, Dunbar, Ace, Shane and Danny 

Female Challengers: Diem, Aneesa, Britni, Paula, KellyAnne, Svetlana and Sarah 

Not bad...I always wanted it to have been

Evan Kenny John Wes Darrell Landon Frank R Susie Cara Z Evelyn Veronica Johanna Jillian and Ibis

CT Brad Dunbar Ace Chet Cohutta Tyler KellyAnne Aneesa Jenn Paula Sarah Kimberly Brianna and Brittini

Ideally 16 vs 16 instead of 14 vs 14 with Syrus Katie Derek M and Beth

Why are y'all still casting JEK together? That's what ruined the first one lol

Because let's be real, it was going to happen. Those 3 only did 3 challenges together and this was only the second. And they still cared way more about Derrick than John. 

And what ruined the first one was Casey throwing missions

What would have been your ideal format for Rivals 3 considering the cast we got? Ive looked it over and maybe they could have done vets v rookies 

AYTO vs Real World vs Other

AYTO

Dario, Brandon, Nate, Devin, Nelson

Christina, Briana, Simone, Cheyenne, Amanda

RW

Ashley, Kellyanne, Averey, Sarah, Jenna, Nany, Jessica

Cory, Tony, Reilly, Bananas, Leroy, Thomas, Wes

Other

Nicole R, Camila

Jamie, Vince

..

obviously we'd need to cut some RWers for Bloodlines / Road Rules / Fresh Meats but it could work out. and then hopefully we'd get better AYTO alumni like Layton and Shanley than Nate and Christina

Next should be EXES too many good possibilities to pass up

Cely/Johnny   Alicia/ Cory    Caro/Ray    Fessy/Haleigh  

Angela/Nelson    Kailah/Bear   Tori/Jordan    Marie/Devin  

 

What would have been your ideal format for Rivals 3 considering the cast we got? Ive looked it over and maybe they could have done vets v rookies 

AYTO vs Real World vs Other

AYTO

Dario, Brandon, Nate, Devin, Nelson

Christina, Briana, Simone, Cheyenne, Amanda

RW

Ashley, Kellyanne, Averey, Sarah, Jenna, Nany, Jessica

Cory, Tony, Reilly, Bananas, Leroy, Thomas, Wes

Other

Nicole R, Camila

Jamie, Vince

..

obviously we'd need to cut some RWers for Bloodlines / Road Rules / Fresh Meats but it could work out. and then hopefully we'd get better AYTO alumni like Layton and Shanley than Nate and Christina

Could just do RW v Others because there would be 14 on each side 

The Challenge: The Last Flame

 

Jenna and Joss

Tori D and Cory

Susie and Hunter

Ashley M and Zach

Nany and Brad

Aneesa and Shane

Kailah and Leroy

Sarah and Nelson

Tori H and Wes

Jonna and Jordan

Theresa and Rogan

Kam and Bananas

Veronica and Dustin

 

 

Episode 1:

Winners: Tori H and Wes

Last: Aneesa and Shane

Voted in: Jonna and Jordan

Eliminated: Aneesa and Shane

 

Episode 2:

Winners: Theresa and Rogan

Last: Susie and Hunter

Voted in: Veronica and Dustin

Eliminated: Veronica and Dustin

Episode 3:

Winners: Tori H and Wes

Last: Kailah and Leroy

Voted in: Jonna and Jordan

Eliminated: Jonna and Jordan

 

Episode 4:

Winners: Jenna and Joss

Last: Susie and Hunter

Voted in: Sarah and Nelson

Eliminated: Susie and Hunter

 

Episode 5:

Winners: Tori H and Wes

Last: Kam and Bananas

Voted in: Ashley and Zach

Eliminated: Kam and Bananas

 

Episode 6:

Winners: Sarah and Nelson

Last: Jenna and Joss

Voted in: Nany and Brad

Eliminated: Nany and Brad

 

Episode 7: 

Winners: Tori H and Wes

Last: Jenna and Joss

Voted in: Ashley and Zach

Eliminated: Ashley and Zach

 

Episode 8:

Winners: Theresa and Rogan

Last: Tori H and Wes

Voted in: Kailah and Leroy

Eliminated: Tori H and Wes

 

Episode 9:

Winners: Theresa and Rogan

Last: Sarah and Nelson

Voted in: Kailah and Leroy

Eliminated: Kailah and Leroy

 

Episode 10:

Winners: Theresa and Rogan

Last: Tori D and Cory

Voted in: Sarah and Nelson

Eliminated: Tori D and Cory

 

Episode 11:

3rd: Jenna and Joss

 

Episode 12:

2nd: Sarah and Nelson

1st: Theresa and Rogan

The Challenge: 37 WOTW 3

MTV Personalities: Marlon, Darrell, Nelson, Devin, Hunter, Jordan, Johnny, Mechie, Laurel, Kam, Cara, Ashley, Kailah, Nicole, Marie, Nurys (EOTB, AYTO)

Outsiders: Turbo, Rogan, Paulie, Fessy, Lio, Nam, Mark, Caleb(LI), Melissa, Natalie A., Liv, Jenny, Amber, Big T., Figgy, Michaela

The Challenge: Gauntlet 4 - tried to give this cast an BOTS/Invasion-esque feel with a lot of fresh faces and not too many of the regulars (other than a few that i feel still have new stories when theyre on or ones that are my faves)

Veterans (2 or more chahellenges)

Girls: Marie, Kailah, Big T, Sylvia, Kayleigh, Kam, Nany, Ashley M

Guys: Darrell, Jay, Nelson, Paulie, Hunter, Tony, Frank S, Dustin

Rookies (1 or none prior challenges)

Girls: Amber M, Liv, Angela B, Violetta, Natalie (Survivor), Elena (BB/EOTB), Kenya (AYTO), Michele Fitzgerald

Guys: Max (AYTO), Mark (BB), Mechie, Chuck (AYTO), Anthony B (AYTO), Bruno, Billy Reilich, Corey Brooks

The Ruins 2 

Champs - CT, Brad, Derrick, Darrell, Jordan, Rogan, Turbo, Jenny, Amber, Laurel, Veronica, Cara, Ashley M, and Sarah. ALT = Zach/Hunter Susie/Rachel

Challengers - Paulie, Fessy, Leeroy, Nelson, Theo, Cory, Joss, Rookie Guy, Tori, Nany, Kam, Theresa, Kaycee, Rookie Girl ALT = Ash Cain/Josh KellyAnne/Mattie

The Ruins 2 

Male champs: Wes, Darrell, Landon, Abe, Jordan, Turbo, CT, and Brad 

Female champs: Sarah, Cara, Ashley M, Veronica, Laurel, Kendall, Tori H, and Jenny 

Male challengers: Fessy, Nelson, Paulie, Theo, Jay, Kyle, Cory and Joss 

Female challengers: Kam, Tori, Day, Natalie Anderson, Kailah, Nany, Sylvia, and Cooke

The Challenge: The Ruins 2

 

Challengers:

Kam

Theresa

Tori D

Nany

Jenna

Kailah

Aneesa

Cory

Nelson

Leroy

Devin

Fessy

Kyle

Paulie

 

 

Champions:

Laurel

Cara Maria

Ashley M

Ashley K

Tori H

Jenny

Veronica

Bananas

Wes

Jordan

Zach

CT

Hunter

Brad

 

 

Episode 1: When THERES will, THERES A way

Nominees Challengers: Kam, Tori D, Aneesa, Fessy, Paulie, Nelson

Nominees Champions: Laurel, Tori H, Veronica, Wes, Hunter, Brad

Winners: Challengers

Matchups: Kam vs Tori H, Nelson vs Brad

Eliminated: Tori H and Nelson

 

Episode 2: Jenny From The Block

Nominees Challengers: Theresa, Jenna, Kailah, Cory, Devin, Leroy

Nominees Champions: Ashley M, Ashley K, Jenny, CT, Bananas, Zach

Winners: Challengers

Matchups: Theresa vs Ashley K, Devin vs Bananas

Eliminated: Ashley K and Devin

 

Episode 3: The Great White Hunter

Nominees Challengers: Nany, Tori D, Aneesa, Kyle, Fessy, Paulie

Nominees Champions: Cara Maria, Veronica, Laurel, Jordan, Wes, Hunter

Winners: Challengers

Matchups: Nany vs Veronica, Kyle vs Jordan

Eliminated: Veronica and Jordan

 

Episode 4: Who Wants To Be A Multi-Millionaire

Nominees Challengers: Jenna, Kailah, Aneesa, Cory, Leroy, Paulie

Nominees Champions: Cara Maria, Ashley M, Jenny, Zach, CT, Bananas

Winners: Champions

Matchups: Jenny vs Kailah, Zach vs Paulie

Eliminated: Kailah and Paulie

 

Episode 5: Messy Fessy

Nominees Challengers: Jenna, Aneesa, Tori D, Cory, Leroy, Fessy

Nominees Champions: Laurel, Ashley M, Cara Maria, Hunter, CT, Bananas

Winners: Champions

Matchups: Laurel vs Aneesa, Hunter vs Fessy

Eliminated: Aneesa and Hunter

 

Episode 6: Kam With The Plan

Nominees Challengers: Kam, Tori D, Jenna, Cory, Leroy, Kyle

Nominees Champions: Cara Maria, Ashley M, Jenny, Wes, Zach, Brad

Winners: Champions

Matchups: Jenny vs Jenna, Wes vs Kyle

Eliminated: Jenna and Wes

 

Episode 7: LEE-d The Way

Nominees Challengers: Tori D, Nany, Theresa, Cory, Leroy, Fessy

Nominees Champions: Laurel, Cara Maria, Ashley M, Bananas, CT, Brad

Winners: Champions

Matchups: Laurel vs Theresa, Brad vs Fessy

Eliminated: Theresa and Brad

 

Episode 8: This S#!+ is B-A-N-A-N-A-S

Nominees Challengers: Kam, Tori D, Nany, Cory, Leroy, Kyle

Nominees Champions: Cara Maria, Ashley M, Jenny, Bananas, Zach, CT

Winners: Champions

Matchup: Jenny vs Nany, Zach vs Cory

Eliminated: Nany and Cory

 

Episode 9: Burned To ASHes

Nominees Challengers: Kam, Tori D, Leroy, Fessy, Kyle

Nominees Champions: Laurel, Cara Maria, Ashley M, Bananas, Zach, CT

Winners: Challengers

Matchups: Tori D vs Ashley M, Fessy vs Bananas

Eliminated: Ashley M and Bananas

 

Episode 10: The Real Champions

Winners: Champions (Laurel, Cara Maria, Jenny, Zach, CT)

2nd: Challengers: (Kam, Tori D, Leroy, Fessy, Kyle)

Pages