The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

14909 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

The Challenge Cutthroat 2

Team Beasts: Jenny West, Laurel Strucky, Tori Deal, Sylvia Elsrode, Nicole Zanatta, KC Clarke, CT, Ashley Cain, Fessy, Turbo, Kwasi and Derrick Kosinski 

Team Firecrackers: Hunter Barfield, Nelson Thomas, Giovanni Rivera, Ronnie, Lewis Good, Josh Martinez,  Abi Maria, Bria Hamilton, Liw Jawando, Anamelia Silva, Jemma Lucy and Megan McKenna 

Team Masterminds: Johnny Bananas, Weston Bergmann, Keith Klebacher, Paulie Calafiore, Caleb Reynolds, Devin Walker, Vanessa Russo, Kam Williams, Lois Hazel, Alex Ow, Kelley Wentworth and Ashley Mitchell 

Who the hell is Ronnie?

The Beasts win and it will be a blowout like The Ruins

I think Ronnie from Jersey Shore but that's just my guess

No it definitely won't be a blowout. Johnny and Wes together have a combined total of 86 challenge mission wins and there are veterans like Devin and Paulie who know how to manipulate games into their favour.  It's Ronnie from Jersey Shore.

No it definitely won't be a blowout. Johnny and Wes together have a combined total of 86 challenge mission wins and there are veterans like Devin and Paulie who know how to manipulate games into their favour.  It's Ronnie from Jersey Shore.

It would be a blowout

The Ruins (Fantasy Recasting)

I still want some events and storylines to occur, plus some of the bad players to go out early but I took a stab at this.

Pre-Season:

The Duel 2: Landon beats Brad in the final elimination, Landon wins the season, Evan joins the Challengers on The Ruins. Tonya skips The Ruins; we do not get the rape allegations/only lost is Tonya hitting Veronica

Champions:

Darrell Taylor

Derrick Kosinski

Johnny Devenanzio

Kenny Santucci

Nehemiah Clark – Replaces Evan

Syrus Yarbrough

Wes Bergmann

Evelyn Smith

Ibis Nieves

Johanna Botta

Katie Doyle

Coral Smith – Replaces Tonya

Susie Meister

Veronica Portillo

 

Challengers:

Brad Fiorenza

Dunbar Merrill

Evan Starkman* – Replaces Adam

Greg Halstead – Debuts & Replaces Nick

Cohutta Grindstaff

Dan Walsh – Replaces Chet

Danny Jamieson

Brittini Sherrod – Replaces Brianna

Diem Brown

KellyAnne Judd

Kimberly Alexander

Paula Meronek – Replaces Casey

Sarah Rice

Shauvon Torres

The Ruins (Fantasy Recasting)

I still want some events and storylines to occur, plus some of the bad players to go out early but I took a stab at this.

Pre-Season:

The Duel 2: Landon beats Brad in the final elimination, Landon wins the season, Evan joins the Challengers on The Ruins. Tonya skips The Ruins; we do not get the rape allegations/only lost is Tonya hitting Veronica

Champions:

Darrell Taylor

Derrick Kosinski

Johnny Devenanzio

Kenny Santucci

Nehemiah Clark – Replaces Evan

Syrus Yarbrough

Wes Bergmann

Evelyn Smith

Ibis Nieves

Johanna Botta

Katie Doyle

Coral Smith – Replaces Tonya

Susie Meister

Veronica Portillo

 

Challengers:

Brad Fiorenza

Dunbar Merrill

Evan Starkman* – Replaces Adam

Greg Halstead – Debuts & Replaces Nick

Cohutta Grindstaff

Dan Walsh – Replaces Chet

Danny Jamieson

Brittini Sherrod – Replaces Brianna

Diem Brown

KellyAnne Judd

Kimberly Alexander

Paula Meronek – Replaces Casey

Sarah Rice

Shauvon Torres

I like this.  Although I'd have Brittini replace Diem instead of Brianna  and maybe Aneesa replacing Shauvon--just my thoughts but I like yours

Cutthroat (Fantasy Recasting)

Pre-season: Let Fresh Meat II play out the way it did tbh. Tonya returns since Fresh Meat

 

Men

Abram Boise

Brad Fiorenza

Brandon Nelson

Chet Cannon – Debuts*

Darrell Taylor – Replaces Eric

Derrick Kosinski

Dunbar Merrill

Mike Manning – Replaces Derek

Isaac Stout – Replaces Dan

JD Ordoñez

Johnny Devenanzio

Noor Jehangir – Replaces Vinny

Pete Connolly – Replaces Luke

Ty Ruff

Tyler Duckworth

 

Women

Ayiiia Elizarraras

Brianna Taylor – Debuts* & Replaces Melinda

Camila Nakagaw

Cara Maria Sorbello

Emily Schromm

Jenn Grijalva

Jonna Mannion – Debuts & Replaces Emilee

Laurel Stucky

Paula Meronek

Sarah Rice

Shauvon Torres

Theresa Gonzalez

Tonya Cooley – Replaces Katie

Tori Fiorenza

Trisha Cummings – Debuts & Replaces Mandi

 

The Ruins (Fantasy Recasting)

I still want some events and storylines to occur, plus some of the bad players to go out early but I took a stab at this.

Pre-Season:

The Duel 2: Landon beats Brad in the final elimination, Landon wins the season, Evan joins the Challengers on The Ruins. Tonya skips The Ruins; we do not get the rape allegations/only lost is Tonya hitting Veronica

Champions:

Darrell Taylor

Derrick Kosinski

Johnny Devenanzio

Kenny Santucci

Nehemiah Clark – Replaces Evan

Syrus Yarbrough

Wes Bergmann

Evelyn Smith

Ibis Nieves

Johanna Botta

Katie Doyle

Coral Smith – Replaces Tonya

Susie Meister

Veronica Portillo

 

Challengers:

Brad Fiorenza

Dunbar Merrill

Evan Starkman* – Replaces Adam

Greg Halstead – Debuts & Replaces Nick

Cohutta Grindstaff

Dan Walsh – Replaces Chet

Danny Jamieson

Brittini Sherrod – Replaces Brianna

Diem Brown

KellyAnne Judd

Kimberly Alexander

Paula Meronek – Replaces Casey

Sarah Rice

Shauvon Torres

I like this.  Although I'd have Brittini replace Diem instead of Brianna  and maybe Aneesa replacing Shauvon--just my thoughts but I like yours

Those work too. I think I'd still want to see Shavoun flop lol

The Ruins (Fantasy Recasting)

I still want some events and storylines to occur, plus some of the bad players to go out early but I took a stab at this.

Pre-Season:

The Duel 2: Landon beats Brad in the final elimination, Landon wins the season, Evan joins the Challengers on The Ruins. Tonya skips The Ruins; we do not get the rape allegations/only lost is Tonya hitting Veronica

Champions:

Darrell Taylor

Derrick Kosinski

Johnny Devenanzio

Kenny Santucci

Nehemiah Clark – Replaces Evan

Syrus Yarbrough

Wes Bergmann

Evelyn Smith

Ibis Nieves

Johanna Botta

Katie Doyle

Coral Smith – Replaces Tonya

Susie Meister

Veronica Portillo

 

Challengers:

Brad Fiorenza

Dunbar Merrill

Evan Starkman* – Replaces Adam

Greg Halstead – Debuts & Replaces Nick

Cohutta Grindstaff

Dan Walsh – Replaces Chet

Danny Jamieson

Brittini Sherrod – Replaces Brianna

Diem Brown

KellyAnne Judd

Kimberly Alexander

Paula Meronek – Replaces Casey

Sarah Rice

Shauvon Torres

I like this.  Although I'd have Brittini replace Diem instead of Brianna  and maybe Aneesa replacing Shauvon--just my thoughts but I like yours

Those work too. I think I'd still want to see Shavoun flop lol

lol okay i respect that

The Challenge XXX: Dirty 30 (Fantasy Recast)

Males

- Johnny Bananas

- Tony Raines

- Derrick Kosinski

- Darrell Taylor

- Cory Wharton

- Wes Bergmann (replaces CT)

- Nelson Thomas

- Hunter Barfield

- Giovanni Rivera (replaces Derrick H.)

Jordan Wiseley 

- Bruno Bettencourt (replaces Dario)

- Ammo Hall

- Shane Landrum (replaces Shane)

- Thomas Buell (replaces Leroy)

- Devin Walker

Females

- Cara Maria Sorbello

- Laurel Stucky (replaces Veronica)

- Sylvia Elsrode (replaces Jenna)

- Jemmye Carroll

- LaToya Jackson

- Marie Roda

- Amanda Garcia

- Ashley Mitchell

- Kailah Casillas

- Alicia Wright (replaces Britni)

- Tori Deal

- Briana LaCuesta (replaces Nicole)

- Beth Stolarczyk (replaces Aneesa)

- Nany Gonzalez (replaces Simone)

- KellyAnne Judd (replaces Camila)

The Challenge: Invasion (Fantasy Recast)

Underdogs

- Bruno

- Kailah

- Dylan (replaces Theo)

- Katrina (replaces Anika)

- Hunter

- Sylvia

- Nelson

- Nicole

- Amanda

- Shane

- Ashley

- Tony

- Marie

- Thomas (replaces Dario)

- Averey (replaces Jenna)

- Cory

- Nia (replaces LaToya)

- Dione (replaces Anthony)

 

Champions

- Darrell

- Laurel

- Frank (replaces Zach)

- Cara Maria

- Derrick (replaces CT)

- Veronica (replaces Ashley K)

- Bananas

- Camila

The Challenge: Free Agents II 

Men

Leroy Garrett (Real World Las Vegas 2011) 

Zach Nichols (Real World San Diego 2011) 

Marlon Williams (Real World Portland) 

Cory Wharton (Real World Ex-Plosion) 

Nelson Thomas (Are You The One? 3) 

Kwasi Opoku (Are You The One? 7) 

Billy Reilich (Ex on The Beach 3) 

Joao Paulo "JP" Andrade (Ex on The Beach Brazil) 

Caleb Reynolds (Big Brother 16, Survivor: Kaoh Rong & Survivor: Game Changers) 

Faysal Shafaat (Big Brother 20) 

Cole Medders (Suvivor: Heroes v.s. Healers v.s. Hustlers) 

Turabi "Turbo" Camkiran (Survivor Turkey) 

Theo Campbell (Love Island UK 3) 

Ched Uzor (Love Island UK 6)  

David McIntosh (Celebrity Big Brother UK, Bromans, Famously Single, Gladiators, Celebrity Ex on The Beach UK)  

Warren Phillips (Survival of The Fittest) 

James Jean-Louis (The Titan Games)  

Carlos Garcia (Paradise Hotel) 

Kelechi "Kelz" **** (Too Hot To Handle) 

Jeremiah Buoni (Floribama Shore)

 

Women 

Jemmye Carroll (Real World: New Orleans 2011) 

Nany Gonzalez (Real World: Las Vegas 2011) 

Heather Cooke (Real World: Las Vegas 2011) 

Ashley Mitchell (Real World: Ex-Plosion)

Nicole Zanatta (Real World: Skeletons) 

CeeJai Jenkins (Real World: Go Big or Go Home) 

Katrina Stack (Real World Seattle: Bad Blood) 

Laurel Stucky (Fresh Meat 2) 

Lolo Jones (The Challenge: Champs v.s. Pros & Celebrity Big Brother US 2) 

Louise Hazel (The Challenge: Champs v.s. Pros & Champs v.s. Stars 2) 

Tori Deal (Are You The One? 4) 

Kam Williams (Are You The One? 5) 

Diandra Delgado (Are You The One? 6) 

Bria Hamilton (Are You The One? 7) 

Analyse Talavera (Big Brother 21) 

Natalie Anderson (Survivor: San Juan Del Sur & Winners At War) 

Cydney Gillion (Survivor: Kaoh Rong)

Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor: Millennials v.s. Gen-X & Game Changers) 

Jenny West (Survival of The Fittest) 

Mattie Lynn Breaux (Party Down South & Floribama Shore) 

Casting would never make this good of a cast.

Casting would never make this good of a cast.

Folks are satisfied with any piece of trash MTV throws out there so they don't feel the need to smmfh

The Challenge: Free Agents II 

Men

Leroy Garrett (Real World Las Vegas 2011) 

Zach Nichols (Real World San Diego 2011) 

Marlon Williams (Real World Portland) 

Cory Wharton (Real World Ex-Plosion) 

Nelson Thomas (Are You The One? 3) 

Kwasi Opoku (Are You The One? 7) 

Billy Reilich (Ex on The Beach 3) 

Joao Paulo "JP" Andrade (Ex on The Beach Brazil) 

Caleb Reynolds (Big Brother 16, Survivor: Kaoh Rong & Survivor: Game Changers) 

Faysal Shafaat (Big Brother 20) 

Cole Medders (Suvivor: Heroes v.s. Healers v.s. Hustlers) 

Turabi "Turbo" Camkiran (Survivor Turkey) 

Theo Campbell (Love Island UK 3) 

Ched Uzor (Love Island UK 6)  

David McIntosh (Celebrity Big Brother UK, Bromans, Famously Single, Gladiators, Celebrity Ex on The Beach UK)  

Warren Phillips (Survival of The Fittest) 

James Jean-Louis (The Titan Games)  

Carlos Garcia (Paradise Hotel) 

Kelechi "Kelz" **** (Too Hot To Handle) 

Jeremiah Buoni (Floribama Shore)

 

Women 

Jemmye Carroll (Real World: New Orleans 2011) 

Nany Gonzalez (Real World: Las Vegas 2011) 

Heather Cooke (Real World: Las Vegas 2011) 

Ashley Mitchell (Real World: Ex-Plosion)

Nicole Zanatta (Real World: Skeletons) 

CeeJai Jenkins (Real World: Go Big or Go Home) 

Katrina Stack (Real World Seattle: Bad Blood) 

Laurel Stucky (Fresh Meat 2) 

Lolo Jones (The Challenge: Champs v.s. Pros & Celebrity Big Brother US 2) 

Louise Hazel (The Challenge: Champs v.s. Pros & Champs v.s. Stars 2) 

Tori Deal (Are You The One? 4) 

Kam Williams (Are You The One? 5) 

Diandra Delgado (Are You The One? 6) 

Bria Hamilton (Are You The One? 7) 

Analyse Talavera (Big Brother 21) 

Natalie Anderson (Survivor: San Juan Del Sur & Winners At War) 

Cydney Gillion (Survivor: Kaoh Rong)

Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor: Millennials v.s. Gen-X & Game Changers) 

Jenny West (Survival of The Fittest) 

Mattie Lynn Breaux (Party Down South & Floribama Shore) 

We don't often agree but this has my full support. I'd bump Zach for someone else but I'd kind of like to see him on this because I think he'd leave early. Well done. 

Final 5 predictions for each gender anyone? Smile

Final 5 predictions for each gender anyone?

Theo (if healthy), Faysal, David M, Cole and Turbo....if Theo is hinder I'd throw in Leroy

Lolo, Louise, Jenny, Laurel and Cooke (though I wouldn't be shocked if Tori and/or Nany were in the F5 and left next)

Final 5 predictions for each gender anyone?

Its hard especially for the girls because there are so many strong competitors 

 

Final 5 predictions for each gender anyone?

Theo (if healthy), Faysal, David M, Cole and Turbo....if Theo is hinder I'd throw in Leroy

Lolo, Louise, Jenny, Laurel and Cooke (though I wouldn't be shocked if Tori and/or Nany were in the F5 and left next)

I don't think it's really that cut & dry for either side. There's some very MONSTROUS rookies on the men's side & the women's side is full of Alphas who would have no fear targeting girls like Laurel & Jenny.

Final 5 predictions for each gender anyone?

Theo (if healthy), Faysal, David M, Cole and Turbo....if Theo is hinder I'd throw in Leroy

Lolo, Louise, Jenny, Laurel and Cooke (though I wouldn't be shocked if Tori and/or Nany were in the F5 and left next)

I don't think it's really that cut & dry for either side. There's some very MONSTROUS rookies on the men's side & the women's side is full of Alphas who would have no fear targeting girls like Laurel & Jenny.

Oh I agree...I love your cast.  A lot would depend on matchups.

The Challenge: Invasion of the Vets

22 new school Challengers (rookies & non winners) compete in a concept similar to Invasion of Champions except with super vets coming in. Eliminations are old school vs new school. Vets enter the game when the newbies get down to 16.

 

New school Challengers:

Amanda 

Ceejai

Kailah

Sylvia

Katrina 

Kam

Michaela

Angela

Kenya

Bria

Da’Vonne

Cory

Nelson

Tony

Theo

Jay

Kwasi

Kareem

Fessy

Paulie

Bear

Kyle

 

 

 

 Vets: 

Laurel

Coral 

Evelyn

Tina

Veronica

Theresa

Jenn G.

KellyAnne

Darrell

Shane

Dustin

CT

Abram

Leroy

Frank

Wes

The Challenge : Battle of the Zodiac

Teams of 4 people with same zodiac signs just for fun. Similar set up as Battle of the Seasons. Going off birthdays I found on google.

Team Aries

Devin Walker (AYTO?: 3)

Sam Bird (Love Island UK: 4)

Laurel Stucky (Freah Meat 2)

Britni Thornton (AYTO?: 3)

Team Taurus

Leroy Garrett (RW: Las Vegas)

Frank Sweeney (RW: San Diego)

Da'vonne Rogers (BB:17)

Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)

Team Gemini

Jay Starrett (Survivor: Millenials be Gen X)

Tony Raines (RW: Skeletons)

Bayleigh Dayton (BB: 20)

Kayleigh Morris (ExOTB UK 2)

Team Cancer

Theo Campbell (LI UK: 3)

Turabi Camkiran (Survivor Turkey: Dirol

Ibis Nieves (RR: X-treme)

LaToya Jackson (RW: St. Thomas)

Team Leo

Derrick Kosinski (RR: X-treme)

Zach Nichols (RW: San Diego)

Marie Roda (RW: St. Thomas)

Ashley Mitchell (RW: Ex-plosion)

Team Virgo

Cole Medders (Survivor : Heroes vs Healers vs Hustlers)

Jordan Wiseley (RW: Portland)

Avonlea Elkins (The Bachelor: 24) (I have no idea who she is I just needed someone other than Camila lmao)

Aneesa Ferreira (RW: Chicago)

Team Libra

Fasal "Fessy" Shafaat (BB: 20)

Ashley Cain (ExOTB UK: 1)

Amanda Garcia (AYTO?: 3)

Kenya Scott (AYTO?: 7)

Team Scorpio  So many other options - Brad, Nehemiah, Darrell

Nelson Thomas (AYTO?: 3)

Paulie Calafiore (BB:18)

Kam Williams (AYTO?: 5)

Kailah Casillas (RW: Go Big or Go Home)

Team Sagittarius

Wes Bergmann (RW: Austin)

Brandon Nelson (Freah Meat 2)

Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor: Millenials vs Gen X)

Sylvia Elsrode (RW: Skeletons)

Team Capricorn

Stephen Bear (Shipwrecked: The Island)

Robb Schreiber (RW: St. Thomas)

Averey Tressler (RW: Portland)

Tula "Big T" Fazakerley (Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands)

Team Aquarius

Tyler Crispen (BB: 20)

Abram Boise (RR: South Pacific)

Nany Gonzalez (RW: Las Vegas)

Haleigh Broucher (BB: 20)

Team Pisces

Cory Wharton (RW: Ex-plosion)

Jeremiah Buoni (Floribama Shore)

Faith Stowers (Vanderpump Rules)

Tori Deal (AYTO?: 4)

Nany is SUCH an Aquarius.

I'd be ready to stan Team Libra though

She really is lol but yes same team libra and also Gemini for me even though I'm a Pisces

The Challennge Dirty II

Amber Borzotra

Amber Martinez

Aneesa Ferreira 

Ashley Mitchell

Blonde Bitch

Kaycee Clark

Malkamitu Williams

Natalie Anderson

Nicole Zanatta

Noemi Gonzalez

Olivia Jawando

Theresa Jones

Tula Fazakerley

Victoria Dehel

Christopher Tamburello

Cory WHarton

Darrell Taylor

Devin Walker

Faysal Shafaat

Joseph Allen

Josh Martinez

Justin Starrett

Kyle Christie

Lionel Rush

Meechie Harris

Nam Vo Nelson Thomas

Weston Bergmann

"I....been here this long....been through this much....It's gotta be....worth....something" <#

#FightForHumanity   

The Challenge : Battle of the Zodiac

Teams of 4 people with same zodiac signs just for fun. Similar set up as Battle of the Seasons. Going off birthdays I found on google.

Team Aries

Devin Walker (AYTO?: 3)

Sam Bird (Love Island UK: 4)

Laurel Stucky (Freah Meat 2)

Britni Thornton (AYTO?: 3)

Team Taurus

Leroy Garrett (RW: Las Vegas)

Frank Sweeney (RW: San Diego)

Da'vonne Rogers (BB:17)

Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)

Team Gemini

Jay Starrett (Survivor: Millenials be Gen X)

Tony Raines (RW: Skeletons)

Bayleigh Dayton (BB: 20)

Kayleigh Morris (ExOTB UK 2)

Team Cancer

Theo Campbell (LI UK: 3)

Turabi Camkiran (Survivor Turkey:

Ibis Nieves (RR: X-treme)

LaToya Jackson (RW: St. Thomas)

Team Leo

Derrick Kosinski (RR: X-treme)

Zach Nichols (RW: San Diego)

Marie Roda (RW: St. Thomas)

Ashley Mitchell (RW: Ex-plosion)

Team Virgo

Cole Medders (Survivor : Heroes vs Healers vs Hustlers)

Jordan Wiseley (RW: Portland)

Avonlea Elkins (The Bachelor: 24) (I have no idea who she is I just needed someone other than Camila lmao)

Aneesa Ferreira (RW: Chicago)

Team Libra

Fasal "Fessy" Shafaat (BB: 20)

Ashley Cain (ExOTB UK: 1)

Amanda Garcia (AYTO?: 3)

Kenya Scott (AYTO?: 7)

Team Scorpio  So many other options - Brad, Nehemiah, Darrell

Nelson Thomas (AYTO?: 3)

Paulie Calafiore (BB:18)

Kam Williams (AYTO?: 5)

Kailah Casillas (RW: Go Big or Go Home)

Team Sagittarius

Wes Bergmann (RW: Austin)

Brandon Nelson (Freah Meat 2)

Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor: Millenials vs Gen X)

Sylvia Elsrode (RW: Skeletons)

Team Capricorn

Stephen Bear (Shipwrecked: The Island)

Robb Schreiber (RW: St. Thomas)

Averey Tressler (RW: Portland)

Tula "Big T" Fazakerley (Shipwrecked: Battle of the Islands)

Team Aquarius

Tyler Crispen (BB: 20)

Abram Boise (RR: South Pacific)

Nany Gonzalez (RW: Las Vegas)

Haleigh Broucher (BB: 20)

Team Pisces

Cory Wharton (RW: Ex-plosion)

Jeremiah Buoni (Floribama Shore)

Faith Stowers (Vanderpump Rules)

Tori Deal (AYTO?: 4)

I just wanted to make a Rivals 4 or Vendettas 2 cast with the rules of Rivals 1. 7 teams of girls 7 teams of guys: 

Cory W and Tony R

Josh and Swaggy

Rogan and Jay

Fessy and Bret (bb 20)

Darrell and Brad

Tre and Caleb ( Love Island US)

Bear and Mike (Rookie, Kailahs Ex)

Nany and Bayleigh 

Melissa and Kailah 

Amanda and Cara

Aneesa and Veronica

Dayvone and Vanessa (big brother)

Angela Babics and Hanan (Bad girls club)

Suzi and Derynn (Double shot of love) 

 

 

Pages