The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

14891 posts / 0 new
Last post

^ I was just working on a cast similar to this actually lol but not champs vs challenges

I get the logic after reading the post. if shift Hunter and Joss though that makes more sense, no one views Joss as a champ and plus that's disrespectful to Hunter. 

 

I think they're saying Sylvia and Joss beat Ashley/Hunter but I'm confused so...

^ I was just working on a cast similar to this actually lol but not champs vs challenges

I get the logic after reading the post. if shift Hunter and Joss though that makes more sense, no one views Joss as a champ and plus that's disrespectful to Hunter. 

actually since I relegated Sylvia to an alternate, I guess I don't need to die on this Sylvia/Joss hill. could easily swap Hunter and Joss, which might actually make the politics more interesting, because they each would be incentivized to Turncoat to the other team to be with their best friends.

thanks for the tip!

but if we swap Hunter and Joss - then I just want to cut Joss and have Ash Cain or Sean Lineker instead.

but if we swap Hunter and Joss - then I just want to cut Joss and have Ash Cain or Sean Lineker instead.

lol that works too

Laurel and Kailah coming for the win! With Kam/Theresa in a close second

Faith a...Challenge Champion 

The Challenge: Eskimo Siblings

I copied the concept from chefsaucy, and I think the dynamic of these teams would cause tons of mess.

Girl teams:

Amanda & Tori (Mike C.)

Ashley M. & Angela (Nelson)

Laurel & Melissa (Nicole Z.)

Nany & Bayleigh (Kaycee)

Kailah & Aneesa (Cory)

Kam & Da’Vonne (Theo)

Cara Maria & Faith (Kyle)

Nia & Sarah Rice (Jordan)

 

Boy teams:

Marlon & Hunter (Nany)

Jordan & Bear (Laurel)

Ashley C. & Joss (Kayleigh)

Jay & Rogan (Dee)

Leroy & Theo (Kam)

Nelson & Bananas (Angela & Kayleigh)

Kyle & Paulie (Cara Maria)

Zach & Cory (Jenna)

The Challenge: Total Agents (Total Madness + Free Agents = Total Agents)

32 Challengers will compete in the most twisted season ever in order to win their share of 1 million dollars (1 man and 1 woman will each win 500,000 dollars). The first 6 daily challenges will have only one male and one female winner and will result in an elimination in which one man and one woman will be sent home in an elimination round each week.

The first twist is that only 24 players (12 males and 12 females) out of 32 will be allowed to participate in an elimination round to earn a "red skull", and no player will participate in an elimination round more than once.  The winners of the daily challenges will be allowed to either volunteer into elimination or chose someone to earn red skull who has NOT already earned one (a female will choose a female and a male will choose a male). The other opponent will be chosen in the "The Draw" where each loser without a red skull will either flip over a "kill card", which has a RED skeleton symbol, or a blank card. If a player flips over a kill card, the player will face the player of the respective gender to earn their red skull.

The second twist is that after 6 males and 6 females have earned their red skulls. The remaining 4 males and 4 females will participate in a "Bloodbath" (same format as the one in Invasion of The Champions) where 2 males and 2 females will earn red skulls. The 8 players without red skulls will be told by TJ to come with him right after the 6th elimination (thinking they're leaving the game), and at the location of the bloodbath TJ will tell them only half of them will leave the game. The 12 players with red skulls will not see the bloodbath as they are given the day off while having no clue it is taking place. 

The third twist is that the 12 players with red skulls will be brought to location for their 7th daily challenge where they will be surprised that the 4 winners of the bloodbath are still in the game. TJ will then explain that the game has been reset, and the rules will change to the "Free Agents" format with 2 exceptions: there will still be only one male and one female of each daily challenge (no teams/pairs) and there will be female days and male days. On female days, the female daily challenge winner will earn safety from elimination, but will have to choose a female to go in elimination while the male winner will win $5,000 (and vice versa for male days). Only 4 males and 4 females will compete in the final challenge. There will be 16 episodes (14 elimination episodes + Bloodbath + Final) with no TBC episodes.

Cast:

Laurel Stucky (Fresh Meat II)

Jenny West (Survival of the Fittest)

Kam Williams (Are You the One? 5)

Ashley Mitchell (Real World: Ex-plosion)

Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat II)

Big T (Shipwrecked)

Nany Gonzalez (Real World: Las Vegas)

Da'vonne Rogers (Big Brother 17)

Natalie Negrotti (Big Brother 18)

Amanda Garcia (Are You the One? 3)

Evelyn Smith (Fresh Meat)

KellyAnne Judd (Real World Sydney)

Heather Cooke (Real World Las Vegas)

Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor)

Michelle Fitzgerald (Survivor)

Kyra Green (Love Island)

 

Darrell Taylor (Road Rules Campus Crawl)

Brad Fiorenza (Real World San Diego)

Jay Starrett (Survivor)

Fessy Shafaat (Big Brother 20)

Cory Wharton (Real World Explosion)

Nelson Thomas (Are You the One? 3)

Sean Lineker (Shipwrecked)

Turbo Camkiran (Survivor Turkey)

Theo Campbell (Love Island UK)

Frank Sweeney (Real World San Diego)

Wes Bergmann (Real World Austin)

Paulie Calafiore (Big Brother 18)

Leroy Garrett (Real World Las Vegas)

Cheyenne Parker (Ex on the Beach 2)

Michael Yerger (Survivor)

Cashel Barnett (Love Island)

 

 

^Dope!

^Dope!

Thanks!

The Challenge 36: Anarchy

3 teams of 12 competitors from different eras of The Challenge.

Royals (Seasons 1-12):

Darrell Taylor

Shane Landrum

Wes Bergmann

Brad Fiorenza

Landon Lueck

Alton Williams

Coral Smith

Aneesa Ferriera

Rachel Robinson

Susie Meister

Evelyn Smith

 

Regals (Seasons 13-24):

Leroy Garrett

Dustin Zito

Frank Sweeney

Marlon Williams

Johnny Bananas (duh theyre gonna autocast him)

CJ Koegel

Nany Gonzales

Laurel Stucky

Cara Maria Sorbello

Theresa Gonzales

Sarah Rice

Heather Cooke

 

Rebels (Seasons 25-35):

Nelson Thomas

Turbo Camikaran

Tony Raines

Cory Wharton

Stephen Bear

Ashley Cain

Ashley Mitchell

Da’Vonne Rogers

Kam Williams

Tori Deal

Sylvia Elsrode

Bayleigh Dayton

oops, also add Veronica to the Royals team

Inferno (2021): Villians vs Heroes

Some sort of mix between The Ruins & Inferno 2 format with a relic.

 

Villains

Carlos Garcia (Paradise Hotel 3)

Jordan W.

Michael Griffiths (Love Island UK 5)

Nelson T.

Paulie C.

Rogan O.

Stephen Bear

Wes B.

Amanda G.

Angela B.

Ashley M.

Francesca Farago (Too Hot To Handle)

Georgia Steel (Love Island UK 4)

Kailah C.

Laurel S.

Veronica P.

 

Heroes

Anthony Douglas (Big Brother Canada 7)

CT

Hunter B.

Jay S.

Leroy G.

Sam Bird (Love Island UK 4)

Theo C.

Turbo C.

Big T

Cara Maria

Georgia H.

Haleigh Broucher (Big Brother US 20)

Kam W.

Nany G.

Natalie N.

Sammie Cimarelli (The Circle)

love the effort but Cara a hero? after her huge villain edit on WotW2? should swap her with Georgia Steele

love the effort but Cara a hero? after her huge villain edit on WotW2? should swap her with Georgia Steele

Was thinking the same thing about Nelson actually. He just got this huge heroic sacrificial edit on TM, it'd be hard to forget that despite his past disputes. 

Cara Susie Alton John Brad Robin etc were all good guys...it can be any criteria 

love the effort but Cara a hero? after her huge villain edit on WotW2? should swap her with Georgia Steele

Contrast to Wes and Laurel and given her past of overcoming bullying/underdog edit I think producers would consider her still to be a hero and then on the flip side completely wash away all of CT's past. As far as Steele just going off of Love Island backlash. 

Nelson could **** that redemption arc all up in one episode but I get ya lol. It's just not enough to call him a hero. Hunter can get a pass because of the contrast to Ashley since he was "screwed" and got payback on WOTW.

Cara Susie Alton John Brad Robin etc were all good guys...it can be any criteria 

Exactly lol let's be honest here it's hard when everyone but wallpaper characters with no camera time have all done some questionable stuff. You have to look at it in a versus ___ lens at that point.

The Challenge: Battle of the Series

It will run similar to Seasons 2, 8 teams of 4 from different reality shows

 

Team Real World:

Cory Wharton (RW: Explosion)

Kailah Casillas (RW: Go Big)

Aneesa Ferreira (RW: Chicago)

Cohutta Grindstaff (RW: Sydney)

 

Team Road Rules:

Veronica Portillo (RR: SAS)

Darrell Taylor (RR: Campus Crawl)

Abram Boise (RR: South Pacific)

Kendal Sheppard (RR: Campus Crawl)

 

Team Fresh Meat:

Aviv Melmed (Fresh Meat)

Noor Jehangir (Fresh Meat II)

Mitch Reid (Bloodlines)

Louise Hazel (Champs vs. Pros)

 

Team AYTO:

Amanda Garcia (AYTO3)

Kam Williams (AYTO5)

Asaf Goren (AYTO4)

Nate Siebenmark (AYTO2)

 

Team Big Brother:

Da'Vonne Rogers (BB17)

Bayleigh Dayton (BB20)

Josh Martinez (BB19)

Fessy Shafaat (BB20)

 

Team Survivor:

Jay Starett (Survivor: MvGX)

Michele Fitzgerald (Survivor: Kaoh Rong)

Wendall Holland (Survivor: Ghost Island)

Abi-Maria Gomes (Survivor: Philippines)

 

Team EOTB UK:

Zahida Allen (EOTB UK 6)

Joss Mooney (EOTB UK 1)

Ashley Cain (EOTB UK 1)

Melissa Reeves (EOTB UK 2)

 

Team Big Brother International:

Stephen Bear (CBBUK 18)

Cami-Li (CBBUK 15)

Sindy Nguyen (BB CAN 3)

Demetres Giannitsos (BB CAN 5)

wow a bunch of nobodies on the cast. Zahida, Josh, Nate, Aviv, Aneesa, Kendall?

I sleep

The Challenge: Love and War

 

I had this idea for a challenge awhile ago but also saw someone on YouTube have a similar idea and made a cast for them. This is my cast below. It’s a team of 10 pairs of current lovers still in their relationship vs 10 pairs of exes.

 

Lovers:

Cara Maria Sorbello and Paulie Calafiore

Kam Williams and Leroy Garrett

Morgan Willett and Johnny Devenanzio

Bayleigh Dayton and Swaggy Williams

Haleigh Broucher and Fessy Shafaat

Taylor Selfridge and Cory Wharton

Kailah Casillas and Sam Bird

Tori Deal and Jordan Wiseley

Jenna Compono and Zach Nichols

Sierra Anglim and Joe Anglim (Survivor)

 

Exes

Kellyanne Judd and Wes Bergman

Nany Gonzalez and Hunter Barfield

Dee Nguyen and Rogan O’Connor

Angela Babicz and Nelson Thomas

Georgia Harrison and Stephen Bear

Mattie Lynn Breaux and Jeremiah Buoni

Britni Thornton and Brad Fiorenza

Amanda Garcia and Joss Mooney

Ashley Mitchell and Jamie Banks

Michelle Fitzgerald and Wendell Holland (Survivor)

 

I am disregarding any of the controversies going on right now since that would literally make the cast much hard to put together. This challenge would start off in two teams of 10 pairs (20 players on each team). At all times you are tied to your ex or lover so if they go home, so do you. Eliminations are pair vs pair. I didn’t go with any same sex couples so we can keep the teams with the same amount of guys and girls when it starts. I tried to put a good mix of vets, people we haven’t seen in the last 3 challenges, and rookies. Also wanted to keep a good cast dynamic that would cause drama and alliances. I went with some realism on the cast but at the same time threw people in that I think would make it interesting so I’m aware some of the players are probably retired and def not coming back.

 

 

The Rules: 

 

Phase 1:

I decided to bring back an old format but also change it a little. We are bringing back “The Scoreboard” and “Team Bank Accounts.” The first half of this challenge will have these players competing in two teams, Lovers (Red) vs Exes (Blue). The teams will compete in a daily challenge where the winning team banks $20k which is divided up to the pairs on the team into each of their bank accounts. At the same time the types of challenges they compete in will also have each of the pairs scored based on how they did/what place they came in. After the challenge the scores will be added up and the top 3 pairs for each team will form the inner circle. Each inner circle will have to vote in one of their own pairs to go into elimination. The losing team will have to vote first which gives the winning team some type of advantage in when they vote since they know who will be going in first before they vote (gotta give the winning team something for winning besides just money). Once each pair from the teams has been selected they will face off in elimination called The Scorned (working title) with the losing pair going home. The winning pair will bank any money from the losing pair (similar to The Ruins). The winning pair will also bank the points from losing pairs score board. The scoreboard is consecutive so any points you have will keep carrying over to the next challenges. Once about 10-11 pairs are left in the game, phase 2 begins.

 

Phase 2:

At phase two the teams disband and now the pairs fight on their own. This is NOT like War of the Worlds where they disband the pairs and compete as individuals. They will still compete as pairs but on their own, not on their original teams. The rules will be similar to before. The pairs will compete in challenges and score points based on how they do. The pairs that get 1st, 2nd and 3rd in the mission will also win some amount of money for the pairs bank account (Ex: 1st gets $7500, 2nd gets $3000, 3rd gets $1000, not sure of the exact amounts). The pairs scores will then be calculated based on how they performed in the mission and top 3 highest scoring pairs will form the inner circle and be safe from elimination. This part was tricky because what if the pair that gets first place in that days challenge doesn't make into the top 3 somehow? Like the team with the lowest score gets first in the mission but the points they get don’t put them in the top 3. Well what we will do is the pair that gets 1st place in the challenge will automatically be in the inner circle along with the top two scoring pairs on the scoreboard. The pair with the lowest score on the scoreboard will automatically be sent into elimination. The inner circle will then vote in another pair from the remaining pairs to vs the lowest scoring pair. The two pairs will face off with the losing team being eliminated. Once again the pair that wins the elimination will get any money in the losing pairs bank account and any points they have acquired. When it gets to a smaller amount of pairs left, like 4-6 teams left, it would probably change the inner circle from 3 teams to 2 teams.

 

The final:

The final challenge would be with either 3-4 teams left. I think there should be some type of advantage given to each team based on how many points they have when the final starts but this is just an idea and fantasy challenge cast. The pair that gets 1st place wins $500k for their bank account and the remaining pairs only win whatever was in the bank accounts. 

 

Any thoughts? 

I thought this would be an interesting challenge and seeing how an older aspect of the game is treated with this new generation. Will the inner circles in the beginning throw in the weak pairs on their teams or try to get rid of the other high scoring pairs to avoid losing their spots in the inner circle like in Battle of the Sexes 1? With pairs who win elimination getting the points of the losing team, how will that affect the inner circles decisions since that may bump them out? 

 

 

 

Haleigh & Fessy broke up. Also, 40 people is a LOT for a cast.

The cast is extremely similar to this, outside of Amanda, who is never coming back: https://medium.com/@NovaRogue/the-potential-for-a-battle-of-the-exes-3-is-massive-7e9974e5fa0d?source=---------7------------------

Haleigh & Fessy broke up. Also, 40 people is a LOT for a cast.

The cast is extremely similar to this, outside of Amanda, who is never coming back: https://medium.com/@NovaRogue/the-potential-for-a-battle-of-the-exes-3-is-massive-7e9974e5fa0d?source=---------7------------------

 

Honesty I didn't even see that. I only saw a YouTube video about it with a very different cast but no concept or rules. I didn't know about Haleigh and Fessy breaking up. I just remember hearing about them dating all the time. I don't watch Big Brother so just went off what I have heard recently from watching the challenge. Now the people chosen are going to be similar to others list because those are the big names. I used other people such as the survivor people who aren't on that list. Are both lists similar? Yes because those are our options to choose from. Are both lists the same exact? Not at all. 

 

Also I was more focused on what the challenge was, not who is on it. So even though their are similarities to the cast (because most lists are 100% going to choose most of the same people) I was more focused on the concept of the challenge and rules which are no where to be found on the link sent. 

 

Also battle of the sexes and the first battle of the seasons had cast of 36 so 4 more isn't going to kill anyone and it's one guy and one girl eliminated after each challenge. Could even throw in a purge at the beginning for each team if people are that concerned about the amount. And that link literally lists about 28-30 options for different teams. You can't list every single big couple for a fantasy challenge and then make a complaint if someone has similarities lol.

go awff sis

The Challenge Cutthroat 2

Team Beasts: Jenny West, Laurel Strucky, Tori Deal, Sylvia Elsrode, Nicole Zanatta, KC Clarke, CT, Ashley Cain, Fessy, Turbo, Kwasi and Derrick Kosinski 

Team Firecrackers: Hunter Barfield, Nelson Thomas, Giovanni Rivera, Ronnie, Lewis Good, Josh Martinez,  Abi Maria, Bria Hamilton, Liv Jawando, Anamelia Silva, Jemma Lucy and Megan McKenna 

Team Masterminds: Johnny Bananas, Weston Bergmann, Keith Klebacher, Paulie Calafiore, Caleb Reynolds, Devin Walker, Vanessa Russo, Kam Williams, Lois Hazel, Alex Ow, Kelley Wentworth and Ashley Mitchell 

Lol @ Bananas being a mastermind

Missing Raven from BB19 on Masterminds.

Alex Ow a mastermind, lmao. And how is BEAST mode cowboy, the boy that got send home prejury twice in Survivor a Mastermind??

And the teams are sooo unbalanced. There's no chance fot Team Firecracker to win ANYTHING

Alex had an alliance with Paul that noone knew about and she made power moves like when she evicted Jessica. Caleb exited on kaoh rong for medical reasons and on game changers because the tribe swap caused him to be at a numerical disadvantage and the former nuku members  saw him as a bigger threat than Hali Ford. Don't forget that he lasted 90 days in big brother 16 only receiving 1 vote against him the entire time. And the firecrackers team can win challenges because Nelson and Hunter are very strong and Josh is a good swimmer. Lewis Good has a lot of boxing experience so his endurance is good. Anamelia on Big Brother UK lasted about 10 hrs in an endurance competition. 

The Challenge Cutthroat 2

Team Beasts: Jenny West, Laurel Strucky, Tori Deal, Sylvia Elsrode, Nicole Zanatta, KC Clarke, CT, Ashley Cain, Fessy, Turbo, Kwasi and Derrick Kosinski 

Team Firecrackers: Hunter Barfield, Nelson Thomas, Giovanni Rivera, Ronnie, Lewis Good, Josh Martinez,  Abi Maria, Bria Hamilton, Liw Jawando, Anamelia Silva, Jemma Lucy and Megan McKenna 

Team Masterminds: Johnny Bananas, Weston Bergmann, Keith Klebacher, Paulie Calafiore, Caleb Reynolds, Devin Walker, Vanessa Russo, Kam Williams, Lois Hazel, Alex Ow, Kelley Wentworth and Ashley Mitchell 

Who the hell is Ronnie?

The Beasts win and it will be a blowout like The Ruins

Pages