The Challenge: Unpopular Opinions

10051 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

 

I do think the males that were simply awful weren't often invited back--production seemed to care more about competition with the men.

That said, I'd take Danny Jamieson as a partner over Tyrie--and I'd probably take both over Isaac.

 

if basing it one or two challenge appearances, Danny Dias, Nick Brown, Jacquese, Nate (AYTO), Brandon (AYTO), Alex from Denver, Nate from San Diego. That's off the top of my head.  

easy will always get criticized for gassing out in the final. But I never felt he was a horrible competitor actually. 

Oh my god. Nate from San Diego on Exes gave one of if not the worst daily mission performances I've ever seen. It was pitiful to watch. 

 

 

Battle of the Seasons and Final Reckoning are top tier seasons.  

The early seasons BOT Seasons-Gauntlet 2 era are way better than the current seasons.  

Seasons 2 is complete trash--there's no competitors on that season.   Again, people just like it because of who wasn't there.

XXX >>>>> Vendettas/FR

No competitors on a season that featured Wes, Zach, Frank, Alton, Cara Maria, Camila, CJ, Dustin, and Jonna?  Ok whatever. I love that season. 

Camila/Cara had no chance because of Easy.  Wes had no chance because of Lacey (God Love her for trying).  Dustin sucks as you saw in every other season he did.  Alton quit.   You like it because it wasn't run by the people the typically run it--not because it was good--ratings sucked for many reasons and it causes John to be on for almost a decade straight.

Don't tell me why I like something. Who are you to tell me why I liked a season? I've watched the season several times and I've enjoyed it every rewatch.  I don't watch seasons that I dislike over and over again.  I have never watched ******* seasons like Fresh Meat more than once.  I like messy drama seasons and BOT Seasons had that.  True the people that are normally in control werent that season and it was a breath of fresh air.  But that's not the only reason I looked it.  I liked the fights, missions, cast dynamics and it ushered in a new era of Challengers that was badly needed. Something this show doesn't know how to do anymore.  and this season is not responsible for giving us John for the next decade. That right there is castings decision. 

Yes that season is why we had John every season after that.  It's a known fact.

And I said what I said

 

 

 

I do think the males that were simply awful weren't often invited back--production seemed to care more about competition with the men.

That said, I'd take Danny Jamieson as a partner over Tyrie--and I'd probably take both over Isaac.

 

if basing it one or two challenge appearances, Danny Dias, Nick Brown, Jacquese, Nate (AYTO), Brandon (AYTO), Alex from Denver, Nate from San Diego. That's off the top of my head.  

easy will always get criticized for gassing out in the final. But I never felt he was a horrible competitor actually. 

Oh my god. Nate from San Diego on Exes gave one of if not the worst daily mission performances I've ever seen. It was pitiful to watch. 

It's still funny he's the only one that fell

 

 

Danny doesn't deserve to be in the worst males in challenge history conversation as he is probably one of the unluckiest people in challenge history. 

Assuming you mean Jamieson not Dias I agree lol.  Danny Dias (RIP) easily wins worst male competitor. Nick Brown is in that discussion.  Tyrie is. Hell Isaac should be but people like him for some reason. 

I personally think Tyrie was on the wrong seasons. He should've did cutthroat, duel 2, and free agents imo. He was never winning with Davis, Jasmine, or Dunbar. Inferno 3 he lost to Alton who's a beast, quit one of the gauntlets (I forgot which one), and the Island you can't really tell who was really good. 

Why should have done The Duel 2? That season was run by 5 people and Tyrie would not have been in that alliance. He probably still would have gone home 5th at the best.

 

 

 

Battle of the Seasons and Final Reckoning are top tier seasons.  

The early seasons BOT Seasons-Gauntlet 2 era are way better than the current seasons.  

Seasons 2 is complete trash--there's no competitors on that season.   Again, people just like it because of who wasn't there.

XXX >>>>> Vendettas/FR

No competitors on a season that featured Wes, Zach, Frank, Alton, Cara Maria, Camila, CJ, Dustin, and Jonna?  Ok whatever. I love that season. 

Camila/Cara had no chance because of Easy.  Wes had no chance because of Lacey (God Love her for trying).  Dustin sucks as you saw in every other season he did.  Alton quit.   You like it because it wasn't run by the people the typically run it--not because it was good--ratings sucked for many reasons and it causes John to be on for almost a decade straight.

Don't tell me why I like something. Who are you to tell me why I liked a season? I've watched the season several times and I've enjoyed it every rewatch.  I don't watch seasons that I dislike over and over again.  I have never watched ******* seasons like Fresh Meat more than once.  I like messy drama seasons and BOT Seasons had that.  True the people that are normally in control werent that season and it was a breath of fresh air.  But that's not the only reason I looked it.  I liked the fights, missions, cast dynamics and it ushered in a new era of Challengers that was badly needed. Something this show doesn't know how to do anymore.  and this season is not responsible for giving us John for the next decade. That right there is castings decision. 

Yes that season is why we had John every season after that.  It's a known fact.

And I said what I said

Oh you said what you said?  Child please how the hell are you going to tell me why I like a season?  Move around. 

 

 

Nate from AYTO has to be up there with worst male challengers too. I don't think he would have improved much either cause he's such a crybaby. Vinny Foti was another guy who performed bad despite having the size on paper. 

Vinny is a good add.   Why don't I recall a Nate from AYTO?  lol

Rivals 3 - the season you didn't watch. He didn't want to jump out the helicopter, he and Christina were considered the layup team, and he was willing to work with John and his cousin that season to go to the final so he could finish 3rd place. Actually stated it too.

Thanks--I did attempt to watch it this summer and made it through 5 episodes--completely forgot he existed.   Gotta love when people are okay playing for 3rd smh

Pov: Jenn her last 3 seasons.

PREACH

I don't hate nany & kaycee together 

 

 

 

 

I do think the males that were simply awful weren't often invited back--production seemed to care more about competition with the men.

That said, I'd take Danny Jamieson as a partner over Tyrie--and I'd probably take both over Isaac.

 

if basing it one or two challenge appearances, Danny Dias, Nick Brown, Jacquese, Nate (AYTO), Brandon (AYTO), Alex from Denver, Nate from San Diego. That's off the top of my head.  

easy will always get criticized for gassing out in the final. But I never felt he was a horrible competitor actually. 

Oh my god. Nate from San Diego on Exes gave one of if not the worst daily mission performances I've ever seen. It was pitiful to watch. 

It's still funny he's the only one that fell

you know it's a terrible challenge performance when even Tyrie and Jasmine who are criticized as the worst competitors made it across no problem. I felt really bad for Priscilla although she did worse than Nate in the elimination. 

I don't hate nany & kaycee together 

 

Welcome to the club lol i think they're adorable.

I'm young and I really dgaf,  would love tiktokers on the challenge 

Jonna is unlikable

Jonna is unlikable

lol are you trolling? I thought you stanned her lol

JEK was never actually an alliance.  It was DEK and they tolerated John

JEK was never actually an alliance.  It was DEK and they tolerated John

ik wat u tryna say but they were an alliance.. derrick was definitely  valued more than johnny tho

Nia shouldnt have ever been banned, it shoulda been jordan for always antagonizing her

JEK was never actually an alliance.  It was DEK and they tolerated John

on rivals 1 were they an alliance? 

I'm young and I really dgaf,  would love tiktokers on the challenge 

don't ever say this again

JEK was never actually an alliance.  It was DEK and they tolerated John

on rivals 1 were they an alliance? 

My default because John & Kenny needed another guy/guy team.   Evan couldn't have cared less about John on any season.  People act as though John/Evan/Kenny ran things together for years when John never ran anything until they were gone.  Exes was really the first time John had control and that was with Mark & Diem.  On The Island Kenny pretty much controlled everyone and everything.  It's actually sick how much power Kenny had

tik tokers wouldnt be too bad on the show seeing how bad the ratings are doing this season.

tik tokers wouldnt be too bad on the show seeing how bad the ratings are doing this season.

Really?  If you think Josh is annoying imagine tik tokers

tik tokers wouldnt be too bad on the show seeing how bad the ratings are doing this season.

I doubt ratings would increase much at all tbh.

tik tokers wouldnt be too bad on the show seeing how bad the ratings are doing this season.

rating will decline even more, most Tik Tokers have Chile fans who probably don't know what The Challenge even is, they would probably get bored

 

 

 

Danny doesn't deserve to be in the worst males in challenge history conversation as he is probably one of the unluckiest people in challenge history. 

Assuming you mean Jamieson not Dias I agree lol.  Danny Dias (RIP) easily wins worst male competitor. Nick Brown is in that discussion.  Tyrie is. Hell Isaac should be but people like him for some reason. 

I personally think Tyrie was on the wrong seasons. He should've did cutthroat, duel 2, and free agents imo. He was never winning with Davis, Jasmine, or Dunbar. Inferno 3 he lost to Alton who's a beast, quit one of the gauntlets (I forgot which one), and the Island you can't really tell who was really good. 

Why should have done The Duel 2? That season was run by 5 people and Tyrie would not have been in that alliance. He probably still would have gone home 5th at the best.

When I say seasons Tyrie should've done I mean seasons he had a chance in winning some eliminations in. I doubt Tyrie ever wins, nor even make the final, but I could realistically see him winning eliminations on Duel 2, Cutthroat, and Free Agents 

JEK was never actually an alliance.  It was DEK and they tolerated John

I always sensed tension between Evan and Johnny, probably because of Gauntlet 3.

I'll say this: Bananas benefited GREATLY from Evan and Kenny's ban because I think the show would have much preferred Kenny as their male face over him.

Bananas has the best male butt on the challenge.

 

JEK was never actually an alliance.  It was DEK and they tolerated John

I always sensed tension between Evan and Johnny, probably because of Gauntlet 3.

I'll say this: Bananas benefited GREATLY from Evan and Kenny's ban because I think the show would have much preferred Kenny as their male face over him.

True, of the three of them Kenny was probably the most charismatic, and was probably the most well rounded of the three

Yeah I'm not sure how I'd perceive the show now but catching up on it in my early teens it seemed like Kenny/Evan duo + Derrick. I never even included Bananas nor did I ever pay attention to who he was until the island I think. But he was always the least important to me.

Literally Kenny would have cut John in a heartbeat for Derrick.  He also would have cut John for Darrell on The Ruins.

Evan was the most well rounded of the 3 imo. Kenny cant win Duel 2 the way Evan did, 

 

I'm young and I really dgaf,  would love tiktokers on the challenge 

don't ever say this again

idk what u were expecting on the unpopular opinions thread hon

tiktokers would serve

Pages