It's every pair for themselves. 10 missions/eliminations, 5 pairs in the final. Two day final, day one last two teams will be purged. Day two a third place, second place, and winning team will be crowned. Rules similar to Fresh Meat, winning pair of the mission nominates one pair. The rest of the house has a public vote, individually, to pick the second pair. **** private voting (this ain't double agents). Eliminations won't be like Fresh Meat though and would instead be more like the ones from Exes/Rivals 3
Anyone feel free to do the imaginary challenge and elimination order lolz
I like it a lot. I feel really bad for Jenn and would prefer a different Boston girl (Elka or Genesis) but i think it's pretty realistic and fully on board though I'd rather see FM2 exiles than Exes/Rivals 3 eliminations but that's just personal opinion. I'd be happy with either as long as long as we don't get eliminations like Alton/Aneesa beat Syrus/Beth when really it was Alton vs. Syrus
I agree! I wouldn't be opposed to the exiles either
And I agree about the Boston girls. Idk which one would be most realistic to return but I only chose Montana because I'd love to see her rivalry with Beth again lol
i thought about picking Davis over Tyrie, but I've just always found his ol' plain little *** to be so boring. At least Tyrie is kinda funny at times
I would LOVE to see those new school / old school pairs. I literally laughed out loud when imagining some of the duos, like Beth and Nelson, Trishelle and Tony, Jodi and Josh, and Tina and Kyle
Would also love to see Tina, Rachel, Veronica, Beth all back on a season together
Alternate (Ruthie Alcaide/Jonna Mannion--reach--I wish Julie had friends)
Men
Alton Williams/Landon Lueck
Wes Bergmann/Nehemiah Clark
Darrell Taylor/Shane Landrum
Derrick Kosinski/Eric Banks
Mark Long/Eric Nies
Dan Setzler/Yes Duffy
Cohutta Grindstaff/Isaac Stout
John Devenanzio/Leroy Garrett (sadly realistic)
Alternate (Abram Boise/Dan Walsh)
Opposite
Dan Setzler/Holly Shand
Yes Duffy/Veronica Portillo
Darrell Taylor/Kendal Sheppard
Mark Long/Rachel Robinson
Shane Landrum/Genesis Moss
Syrus Yarbrough/Beth Stolarczyk
Alton Williams/Sarah Rice
Abram Boise/Coral Smith
Teck Holmes/Ruthie Alcaide
Derrick Kosinski/Jenn Grijalva
Dunbar Flinn/Kimberly Alexander (I just want Kim on)
Timmy Beggy/Susie Meister
Wes Bergmann/Evelyn Smith
Ryan Kehoe/Paula Meronek
Theo Von/Chanda Sneed
David Burns/Julie Stoffer
Alternate (Pete Connolly/Jillian Zoboroski and John Devenanzio/Casey Cooper)
So many of your pairs dont make sense....especially Rachel & Britni, Theo & Chanda, David & Julie
What? Rachel/Brittini (not Britni) were best friends on The Duel 2 whileTheo and Chanda were friends after Fresh Meat. David and Julie were friends for years but admittedly that's a bit of a reach. I'm dumbfounded you think Rachel/Brittini doesn't make sense. Veronica will be with Tina not Rachel. Or she'd be with Jemmye.
It's also why I made it clear "Allies" as potential instead of Best Friends. Allies gives people far more options.
I decided to do a recasting of a season. I think it's fun sometimes to think of a cast that could have been at that time. I decided to recast The Gauntlet 3. I only used people who were eligible for casting at that time which was pretty much anything up to The Real World: Denver, all of Road Rules, and Fresh Meat 1. I removed people who I felt brought really nothing to the table and to try and balance out the teams better. It was hard because there really wasn't any great rookie guys at that time of filming. I tried to be somewhat realistic as well.
Veterans:
Adam King- The Real World: Paris
Chris "CT" Tamburello- The Real World: Paris
Brad Fiorenza- The Real World: San Diego
Wes Bergmann- The Real World: Austin
Johnny Devenanzio- The Real World: Key West
Eric Banks- Fresh Meat
Evan Starkman- Fresh Meat
Kenny Santucci- Fresh Meat
Beth Stolarczyk- The Real World: Los Angeles
Aneesa Ferreira- The Real World: Chicago
Coral Smith- The Real World: Back to New York
Katie Doyle- Road Rules: The Quest
Trishelle Cannatella- The Real World: Las Vegas
Robin Hibbard- The Real World: San Diego
Diem Brown- Fresh Meat
Evelyn Smith- Fresh Meat
Rookies:
Frank Roessler- The Real World: Las Vegas
MJ Garrett- The Real World: Philadelphia
Nehemiah Clark- The Real World: Austin
Tyler Duckworth- The Real World: Key West
Johnnie McBride- Fresh Meat
Davis Mallory- The Real World: Denver
Dan Walsh- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' Revenge
Derek McCray- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' Revenge
Jamie Chung- The Real World: San Diego
Jillian Zoboroski- Road Rules: X-Treme
Johanna Botta- The Real World: Austin
Svetlana Shusterman- The Real World: Key West
Janelle Casanave- The Real World: Key West
Jenn Grijalva- The Real World: Denver
Angel Turlington- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' Revenge
Tori Hall- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' Revenge
People I removed from the original cast for the vets were Danny Jamieson, Paula Meronek, and Casey Cooper. They were replaced with Wes Bergmann, Aneesa Ferreira, and Trishelle Cannatella. The 3 I removed just didn't bring anything. Danny was annoying, Casey was useless and a terrible choice for a vet, and Paula was invisible pretty much the entire time until she went into the gauntlet. Wes would have brought more of a dynamic to the team with his relationships with them from The Duel as well as his relationship with Johanna. Trishelle being on a season with Coral again would have been great and back with Katie too. Aneesa always brought drama at that point in her career and I also wanted to weaken the vets just a little. I'm sure all 3 of these people were asked since they were just on shows right before filming and declined but it was definitely possible.
For the rookies I removed from the original cast were Rachel Moyal, Melinda Stolp, Brooke LaBarbera, Ryan Kehoe, Zach Mann, Tyrie Ballard, and Alex Smith. With this group I just didn't care for them on the cast. Rachel was useless and I am shocked people tried to act like she was one of the stronger girls on the team. Melinda's relationship with Danny was just toxic and not entertaining. Also she was apparently a replacement for Svetlana dropping out so she wasn't even supposed to be there. Brooke was terrible. Ryan was a random choice and nothing special. Zach was boring. Tyrie quit and didn't bring anything. Lastly Alex seemed promising from his Real World portrayal but we didn't get any of that. To replace them all I put in MJ Garrett, Johnnie McBride, Davis Mallory, Dan Walsh, Jamie Chung, Svetlana Shusterman, and Jenn Grijalva. MJ was obvious since he ended up being a replacement. Johnnie was funny on Fresh Meat 2 and brings some muscle. Davis just came off Inferno 3 and would be interesting to see him with CT being there. Dan just came off Road Rules and would bring some better strength to the team and entertainment. Jamie I loved and she is a previous winner. Svetlana dropping out right at the airport was still such a travesty so I put her back on. and Jenn just came off Inferno 3 with a storyline so would have liked to see her back.
I decided to do a recasting of a season. I think it's fun sometimes to think of a cast that could have been at that time. I decided to recast The Gauntlet 3. I only used people who were eligible for casting at that time which was pretty much anything up to The Real World: Denver, all of Road Rules, and Fresh Meat 1. I removed people who I felt brought really nothing to the table and to try and balance out the teams better. It was hard because there really wasn't any great rookie guys at that time of filming. I tried to be somewhat realistic as well.
Veterans:Adam King- The Real World: ParisChris "CT" Tamburello- The Real World: ParisBrad Fiorenza- The Real World: San DiegoWes Bergmann- The Real World: AustinJohnny Devenanzio- The Real World: Key WestEric Banks- Fresh MeatEvan Starkman- Fresh MeatKenny Santucci- Fresh MeatBeth Stolarczyk- The Real World: Los AngelesAneesa Ferreira- The Real World: ChicagoCoral Smith- The Real World: Back to New YorkKatie Doyle- Road Rules: The QuestTrishelle Cannatella- The Real World: Las VegasRobin Hibbard- The Real World: San DiegoDiem Brown- Fresh MeatEvelyn Smith- Fresh Meat
Rookies:Frank Roessler- The Real World: Las VegasMJ Garrett- The Real World: PhiladelphiaNehemiah Clark- The Real World: AustinTyler Duckworth- The Real World: Key WestJohnnie McBride- Fresh MeatDavis Mallory- The Real World: DenverDan Walsh- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' RevengeDerek McCray- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' RevengeJamie Chung- The Real World: San DiegoJillian Zoboroski- Road Rules: X-TremeJohanna Botta- The Real World: AustinSvetlana Shusterman- The Real World: Key WestJanelle Casanave- The Real World: Key WestJenn Grijalva- The Real World: DenverAngel Turlington- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' RevengeTori Hall- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' Revenge
People I removed from the original cast for the vets were Danny Jamieson, Paula Meronek, and Casey Cooper. They were replaced with Wes Bergmann, Aneesa Ferreira, and Trishelle Cannatella. The 3 I removed just didn't bring anything. Danny was annoying, Casey was useless and a terrible choice for a vet, and Paula was invisible pretty much the entire time until she went into the gauntlet. Wes would have brought more of a dynamic to the team with his relationships with them from The Duel as well as his relationship with Johanna. Trishelle being on a season with Coral again would have been great and back with Katie too. Aneesa always brought drama at that point in her career and I also wanted to weaken the vets just a little. I'm sure all 3 of these people were asked since they were just on shows right before filming and declined but it was definitely possible.
For the rookies I removed from the original cast were Rachel Moyal, Melinda Stolp, Brooke LaBarbera, Ryan Kehoe, Zach Mann, Tyrie Ballard, and Alex Smith. With this group I just didn't care for them on the cast. Rachel was useless and I am shocked people tried to act like she was one of the stronger girls on the team. Melinda's relationship with Danny was just toxic and not entertaining. Also she was apparently a replacement for Svetlana dropping out so she wasn't even supposed to be there. Brooke was terrible. Ryan was a random choice and nothing special. Zach was boring. Tyrie quit and didn't bring anything. Lastly Alex seemed promising from his Real World portrayal but we didn't get any of that. To replace them all I put in MJ Garrett, Johnnie McBride, Davis Mallory, Dan Walsh, Jamie Chung, Svetlana Shusterman, and Jenn Grijalva. MJ was obvious since he ended up being a replacement. Johnnie was funny on Fresh Meat 2 and brings some muscle. Davis just came off Inferno 3 and would be interesting to see him with CT being there. Dan just came off Road Rules and would bring some better strength to the team and entertainment. Jamie I loved and she is a previous winner. Svetlana dropping out right at the airport was still such a travesty so I put her back on. and Jenn just came off Inferno 3 with a storyline so would have liked to see her back.
Thoughts?
Not bad at all. The only "problem" I see is that Danny was pretty much a lock at that time. He was someone they wanted to make the face of the show.
I think Ryan was better casting than Davis and I feel like Jamie Chung had already started her acting career then so not convinced she's realistic but I like the casting changes.
The Challenge 38: Old School vs New School (Cutoff is Free Agents)
Old School: Darrell, Nehemiah, Wes, Johnny, Jordan, Marlon, Brad, Frank, Laurel, Cara, Nany, Theresa, Nia, Trishelle, Rachel, Ashley K.
New School: Paulie, Turbo, Hunter, Tony, Fessy, Cory, Jedson(BBCAN9), Adam(BBCAN7), Ashley, Nicole, Michaela, Natalie A., Bayleigh, Kaycee, Melissa, Jenn(RWBB), Cydney
the only "old schoolers" on your list is Darrell, Rachel, Brad, Trishelle, Nehemiah, Wes, & Bananas the rest are kinda "middle school" competitors lol
Of course but that doesn't really matter to them, it's just a catchy name... just like Leroy and Mike were rivals or Wes and Theresa were Exes.. and with All Stars, makes no sense of adding any of those people on the main cast as most of them wouldn't want to do it anyway.
I decided to do a recasting of a season. I think it's fun sometimes to think of a cast that could have been at that time. I decided to recast The Gauntlet 3. I only used people who were eligible for casting at that time which was pretty much anything up to The Real World: Denver, all of Road Rules, and Fresh Meat 1. I removed people who I felt brought really nothing to the table and to try and balance out the teams better. It was hard because there really wasn't any great rookie guys at that time of filming. I tried to be somewhat realistic as well.
Veterans:Adam King- The Real World: ParisChris "CT" Tamburello- The Real World: ParisBrad Fiorenza- The Real World: San DiegoWes Bergmann- The Real World: AustinJohnny Devenanzio- The Real World: Key WestEric Banks- Fresh MeatEvan Starkman- Fresh MeatKenny Santucci- Fresh MeatBeth Stolarczyk- The Real World: Los AngelesAneesa Ferreira- The Real World: ChicagoCoral Smith- The Real World: Back to New YorkKatie Doyle- Road Rules: The QuestTrishelle Cannatella- The Real World: Las VegasRobin Hibbard- The Real World: San DiegoDiem Brown- Fresh MeatEvelyn Smith- Fresh Meat
Rookies:Frank Roessler- The Real World: Las VegasMJ Garrett- The Real World: PhiladelphiaNehemiah Clark- The Real World: AustinTyler Duckworth- The Real World: Key WestJohnnie McBride- Fresh MeatDavis Mallory- The Real World: DenverDan Walsh- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' RevengeDerek McCray- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' RevengeJamie Chung- The Real World: San DiegoJillian Zoboroski- Road Rules: X-TremeJohanna Botta- The Real World: AustinSvetlana Shusterman- The Real World: Key WestJanelle Casanave- The Real World: Key WestJenn Grijalva- The Real World: DenverAngel Turlington- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' RevengeTori Hall- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' Revenge
People I removed from the original cast for the vets were Danny Jamieson, Paula Meronek, and Casey Cooper. They were replaced with Wes Bergmann, Aneesa Ferreira, and Trishelle Cannatella. The 3 I removed just didn't bring anything. Danny was annoying, Casey was useless and a terrible choice for a vet, and Paula was invisible pretty much the entire time until she went into the gauntlet. Wes would have brought more of a dynamic to the team with his relationships with them from The Duel as well as his relationship with Johanna. Trishelle being on a season with Coral again would have been great and back with Katie too. Aneesa always brought drama at that point in her career and I also wanted to weaken the vets just a little. I'm sure all 3 of these people were asked since they were just on shows right before filming and declined but it was definitely possible.
For the rookies I removed from the original cast were Rachel Moyal, Melinda Stolp, Brooke LaBarbera, Ryan Kehoe, Zach Mann, Tyrie Ballard, and Alex Smith. With this group I just didn't care for them on the cast. Rachel was useless and I am shocked people tried to act like she was one of the stronger girls on the team. Melinda's relationship with Danny was just toxic and not entertaining. Also she was apparently a replacement for Svetlana dropping out so she wasn't even supposed to be there. Brooke was terrible. Ryan was a random choice and nothing special. Zach was boring. Tyrie quit and didn't bring anything. Lastly Alex seemed promising from his Real World portrayal but we didn't get any of that. To replace them all I put in MJ Garrett, Johnnie McBride, Davis Mallory, Dan Walsh, Jamie Chung, Svetlana Shusterman, and Jenn Grijalva. MJ was obvious since he ended up being a replacement. Johnnie was funny on Fresh Meat 2 and brings some muscle. Davis just came off Inferno 3 and would be interesting to see him with CT being there. Dan just came off Road Rules and would bring some better strength to the team and entertainment. Jamie I loved and she is a previous winner. Svetlana dropping out right at the airport was still such a travesty so I put her back on. and Jenn just came off Inferno 3 with a storyline so would have liked to see her back.
Thoughts?
Not bad at all. The only "problem" I see is that Danny was pretty much a lock at that time. He was someone they wanted to make the face of the show.
I think Ryan was better casting than Davis and I feel like Jamie Chung had already started her acting career then so not convinced she's realistic but I like the casting changes.
The only problem I see is KVM trying to dictate someone else's FANTASY cast
New School: Paulie, Turbo, Hunter, Tony, Fessy, Cory, Jedson(BBCAN9), Adam(BBCAN7), Ashley, Nicole, Michaela, Natalie A., Bayleigh, Kaycee, Melissa, Jenn(RWBB), Cydney
I actually like this cast and see it as realistic outside of Rachel! people are tripping if they think we'd get ACTUAL old school competitors on a full season when they decided to call the spin-off All Stars and harp on about how these people are the "best of the best" and then cast Jisela, Jonna, and Big Easy.
I agree! I wouldn't be opposed to the exiles either
And I agree about the Boston girls. Idk which one would be most realistic to return but I only chose Montana because I'd love to see her rivalry with Beth again lol
i thought about picking Davis over Tyrie, but I've just always found his ol' plain little *** to be so boring. At least Tyrie is kinda funny at times
Yeah, Tyrie > Davis--Denver just doesn't any good male options IMO
The Challenge: Worlds Collide
Beth and Nelson
Trishelle and Tony
Jodi and Josh
Veronica and Jay
Rachel and Fessy
Tina and Kyle
Katie and Cory
Kam and Abram
Nany and Landon
Jenna and Shane
Ashley and Brad
Sylvia and Alton
Amanda and Ace
Episode 1:
Winners: Jenna and Shane
Last: Beth and Nelson
Voted in: Jodi and Josh
Eliminated: Beth and Nelson
Episode 2:
Winners: Kam and Abram
Last: Jodi and Josh
Voted in: Trishelle and Tony
Eliminated: Jodi and Josh
Episode 3:
Winners: Jenna and Shane
Last: Kam and Abram
Voted in: Trishelle and Tony
Eliminated: Kam and Abram
Episode 4:
Winners: Rachel and Fessy
Last: Veronica and Jay
Voted in: Sylvia and Alton
Eliminated: Veronica and Jay
Episode 5:
Winners: Trishelle and Tony
Last: Tina and Kyle
Voted in: Rachel and Fessy
Eliminated: Tina and Kyle
Episode 6:
Winners: Ashley and Brad
Last: Jenna and Shane
Voted in: Rachel and Fessy
Eliminated: Jenna and Shane
Episode 7:
Winners: Trishelle and Tony
Last: Katie and Cory
Voted in: Rachel and Fessy
Eliminated: Katie and Cory
Episode 8:
Winners: Rachel and Fessy
Last: Amanda and Ace
Voted in: Sylvia and Alton
Eliminated: Amanda and Ace
Episode 9:
Winners: Sylvia and Alton
Last: Rachel and Fessy
Voted in: Nany and Landon
Eliminated: Nany and Landon
Episode 10:
Winners: Rachel and Fessy
Last: Trishelle and Tony
Voted in: Sylvia and Alton
Eliminated: Trishelle and Tony
Episode 11:
3rd: Sylvia and Alton
Episode 12:
2nd: Rachel and Fessy
1st: Ashley and Brad
The Challenge All Stars 2
Rules: Winning team safe, last goes in, winning team of opposite *** votes other team in
Aneesa and Jonna
Katie and Coral
Arissa and Cooke
Jasmine and Irulan
Trishelle and Elka
Sophia and Casey
Jemmye and Ruthie
Isaac and Ryan
Landon and Ace
Danny J and Alton
MJ and Nehemiah
Brad and Cohutta
Darrell and Yes
Abram and Mark
Episode 1:
Winners: Trishelle and Elka/ Brad and Cohutta
Last: Jasmine and Irulan
Voted in: Arissa and Cooke
Eliminated: Jasmine and Irulan
Episode 2:
Winners: Brad and Cohutta/ Aneesa and Jonna
Last: Isaac and Ryan
Voted in: Landon and Ace
Eliminated: Isaac and Ryan
Episode 3:
Winners: Trishelle and Elka/ Abram and Mark
Last: Sophia and Casey
Voted in: Arissa and Cooke
Eliminated: Sophia and Casey
Episode 4:
Winners: Abram and Mark/ Aneesa and Jonna
Last: Danny and Alton
Voted in: Landon and Ace
Eliminated: Landon and Ace
Episode 5:
Winners: Aneesa and Jonna/ Darrell and Yes
Last: Arissa and Cooke
Voted in: Trishelle and Elka
Eliminated: Arissa and Cooke
Episode 6:
Winners: Abram and Mark/ Trishelle and Elka
Last: MJ and Nehemiah
Voted in: Brad and Cohutta
Eliminated: Brad and Cohutta
Episode 7:
Winners: Trishelle and Elka/ Abram and Mark
Last: Jemmye and Ruthie
Voted in: Aneesa and Jonna
Eliminated: Jemmye and Ruthie
Episode 8:
Winners: Darrell and Yes/ Aneesa and Jonna
Last: Danny and Alton
Voted in: Abram and Mark
Eliminated: Danny and Alton
Episode 9:
Start of Final
Episode 10:
3rd: Katie and Coral/ MJ and Nehemiah
2nd: Aneesa and Jonna/ Abram and Mark
1st: Trishelle and Elka/ Darrell and Yes
Re: The Challenge: Worlds Collide
I would LOVE to see those new school / old school pairs. I literally laughed out loud when imagining some of the duos, like Beth and Nelson, Trishelle and Tony, Jodi and Josh, and Tina and Kyle
Would also love to see Tina, Rachel, Veronica, Beth all back on a season together
The Challenge: All Stars 2
Females
Arissa Hill
Coral Smith
Svetlana Shusterman
Rachel Robinson
Casey Cooper
Evelyn Smith
KellyAnne Judd
Kendal Sheppard
Tina Barta
Cara Zavaleta
Julie Stoffer
Jenn Grijavla
Mandi Moyer
Paula Meronek
Males
Landon Lueck
Alton Williams ll
Darrell Taylor
Theo Von
Abram Boise
Brad Fiorenza
CJ Koegel
Cohutta Grindstaff
Eric Nies
Laterrian Wallance
Yes Duffy
Leroy Garrett
Frank Roessler
Shane Landrum
The Challenge: Carnage
—
Females:
Amanda Garcia - AYTO?: Season 3
Angela Babicz - BGC: Twisted Sisters
Berna Canbeldek - Survivor Turkey
Bettina Buchanan - Paradise Hotel NO
Coral Smith - RW: Back 2 New York
Da’Vonne Rogers - Big Brother 17
Faith Stowers - Vanderpump Rules
Haley Cureton - Too Hot to Handle
Jisela Delgado - RR: The Quest
Kendal Sheppard - RR: Campus Crawl
Khat Bell - The Circle US
Mercy Eke - Big Brother NG
Michaela Bradshaw - Survivor: MvGX
Olivia Jawando - Shipwrecked UK
Pareploy Saeaia - Real World: Bangkok
Priscilla Anyabu - Love Island UK
Shaughna Phillips - Love Island UK
Sylvia Elsrode - RW: Skeletons
AAE32BF4-55EA-4C94-9D3C-4773E680A52D.jpeg
Males:
Alton Williams - RW: Las Vegas ‘02
Amin Elkach - Love Island DE
Brad Fiorenza - RW: San Diego ‘04
Emanuel Neagu - Survivor Romania
Fessy Shafaat - Big Brother 20
Javen Butler - Temptation Island S1
Jeremiah White - Love Island US
JP Andrade - Ex on the Beach BR
Kareem Peterson - Ex on the Beach US
Laterrian Wallace - RR: MVT
Mechie Harris - Ex on the Beach US
Nelson Thomas - AYTO?: Season 3
Pumped Gabo - Warsaw Shore
Renan Hellemans - Ex on the Beach DD
Rob Bentele - Survivor South Africa
Theo Campbell - Love Island UK
Tre Forte - Love Island US
Turbo Camkiran - Survivor Turkey
Tychon Carter - Big Brother CAN
BB5AF4F5-F509-45D2-9198-A1341874911B.jpeg
The Chocolate is strong with this one!
Best Friends Season
If same *** pairs:
Female
Male
If mixed *** pairs:
Yes and Veronica
Paula and Bananas or Paula and Ryan
Gillian and Kenny
Laurel and Jordan
Coral and Evan
Kendal and Darrell OR Kendal and Shane
Tori and Devin
Wes and Evelyn OR Wes and Melinda
Ashley and Nelson
Melissa and Kyle
Georgia and Theo
Cara and CT
Rachel and Mark
Jodi and Derrick
Beth and Syrus
Sarah and Tyler
Julie and Jon
My thought for Best Friends/Allies(OG)
Women
Susie Meister/Cara Zavaleta
Coral Smith/Elka Walker
Kendal Sheppard/Tori Hall (they'll go in a lot)
Brittini Sherrod/Rachel Robinson
Veronica Portillo/Tina Barta
Jemmye Carroll/Beth Stolarczyk
Christena Pyle/Mallory Snyder
Rachel Braband/Sarah Greyson
Alternate (Ruthie Alcaide/Jonna Mannion--reach--I wish Julie had friends)
Men
Alton Williams/Landon Lueck
Wes Bergmann/Nehemiah Clark
Darrell Taylor/Shane Landrum
Derrick Kosinski/Eric Banks
Mark Long/Eric Nies
Dan Setzler/Yes Duffy
Cohutta Grindstaff/Isaac Stout
John Devenanzio/Leroy Garrett (sadly realistic)
Alternate (Abram Boise/Dan Walsh)
Opposite
Dan Setzler/Holly Shand
Yes Duffy/Veronica Portillo
Darrell Taylor/Kendal Sheppard
Mark Long/Rachel Robinson
Shane Landrum/Genesis Moss
Syrus Yarbrough/Beth Stolarczyk
Alton Williams/Sarah Rice
Abram Boise/Coral Smith
Teck Holmes/Ruthie Alcaide
Derrick Kosinski/Jenn Grijalva
Dunbar Flinn/Kimberly Alexander (I just want Kim on)
Timmy Beggy/Susie Meister
Wes Bergmann/Evelyn Smith
Ryan Kehoe/Paula Meronek
Theo Von/Chanda Sneed
David Burns/Julie Stoffer
Alternate (Pete Connolly/Jillian Zoboroski and John Devenanzio/Casey Cooper)
The Challenge All Stars II: Real World vs Road Rules.
Real World
Road Rules
So many of your pairs dont make sense....especially Rachel & Britni, Theo & Chanda, David & Julie
What? Rachel/Brittini (not Britni) were best friends on The Duel 2 whileTheo and Chanda were friends after Fresh Meat. David and Julie were friends for years but admittedly that's a bit of a reach. I'm dumbfounded you think Rachel/Brittini doesn't make sense. Veronica will be with Tina not Rachel. Or she'd be with Jemmye.
It's also why I made it clear "Allies" as potential instead of Best Friends. Allies gives people far more options.
Julie and Ellen were good friends it seems, and Beth has also been an ally of hers (both outcasts)
The Challenge All Stars 2
Team Real World:
Eric Nies: RW New York
Tyrie Ballard: RW Denver
Brad Fiorenza: RW San Diego
Nehemiah Clark: RW Austin
Teck Holmes: RW Hawaii
Steven Hill: RW Las Vegas
Coral Smith: RW Back to New York
Irulan Wilson: RW Las Vegas
Beth Stolarczyk: RW Los Angeles
Trishelle Cannatella: RW Las Vegas
Jasmine Fougere: RW Cancun
Svetlana Shusterman: RW Key West
Team Road Rules:
Laterrian Wallace: RR Maximum Velocity Tou
Adam Larson: RR The Quest
Abram Boise: RR South Pacific
Darrell Taylor: RR Campus Crawl
Dan Setzler: RR Northern Trail
Chadwick Pelletier: RR Down Under
Jodi Weatherton: RR X-treme
Tina Barta: RR South Pacific
Veronica Portillo: RR Semester at Sea
Kendal Sheppard: RR Campus Crawl
Gladys Sanabria: RR Latin America
Tara McDaniel: RR Northern Trail
I decided to do a recasting of a season. I think it's fun sometimes to think of a cast that could have been at that time. I decided to recast The Gauntlet 3. I only used people who were eligible for casting at that time which was pretty much anything up to The Real World: Denver, all of Road Rules, and Fresh Meat 1. I removed people who I felt brought really nothing to the table and to try and balance out the teams better. It was hard because there really wasn't any great rookie guys at that time of filming. I tried to be somewhat realistic as well.
Veterans:
Adam King- The Real World: Paris
Chris "CT" Tamburello- The Real World: Paris
Brad Fiorenza- The Real World: San Diego
Wes Bergmann- The Real World: Austin
Johnny Devenanzio- The Real World: Key West
Eric Banks- Fresh Meat
Evan Starkman- Fresh Meat
Kenny Santucci- Fresh Meat
Beth Stolarczyk- The Real World: Los Angeles
Aneesa Ferreira- The Real World: Chicago
Coral Smith- The Real World: Back to New York
Katie Doyle- Road Rules: The Quest
Trishelle Cannatella- The Real World: Las Vegas
Robin Hibbard- The Real World: San Diego
Diem Brown- Fresh Meat
Evelyn Smith- Fresh Meat
Rookies:
Frank Roessler- The Real World: Las Vegas
MJ Garrett- The Real World: Philadelphia
Nehemiah Clark- The Real World: Austin
Tyler Duckworth- The Real World: Key West
Johnnie McBride- Fresh Meat
Davis Mallory- The Real World: Denver
Dan Walsh- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' Revenge
Derek McCray- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' Revenge
Jamie Chung- The Real World: San Diego
Jillian Zoboroski- Road Rules: X-Treme
Johanna Botta- The Real World: Austin
Svetlana Shusterman- The Real World: Key West
Janelle Casanave- The Real World: Key West
Jenn Grijalva- The Real World: Denver
Angel Turlington- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' Revenge
Tori Hall- Road Rules 2007: Viewers' Revenge
People I removed from the original cast for the vets were Danny Jamieson, Paula Meronek, and Casey Cooper. They were replaced with Wes Bergmann, Aneesa Ferreira, and Trishelle Cannatella. The 3 I removed just didn't bring anything. Danny was annoying, Casey was useless and a terrible choice for a vet, and Paula was invisible pretty much the entire time until she went into the gauntlet. Wes would have brought more of a dynamic to the team with his relationships with them from The Duel as well as his relationship with Johanna. Trishelle being on a season with Coral again would have been great and back with Katie too. Aneesa always brought drama at that point in her career and I also wanted to weaken the vets just a little. I'm sure all 3 of these people were asked since they were just on shows right before filming and declined but it was definitely possible.
For the rookies I removed from the original cast were Rachel Moyal, Melinda Stolp, Brooke LaBarbera, Ryan Kehoe, Zach Mann, Tyrie Ballard, and Alex Smith. With this group I just didn't care for them on the cast. Rachel was useless and I am shocked people tried to act like she was one of the stronger girls on the team. Melinda's relationship with Danny was just toxic and not entertaining. Also she was apparently a replacement for Svetlana dropping out so she wasn't even supposed to be there. Brooke was terrible. Ryan was a random choice and nothing special. Zach was boring. Tyrie quit and didn't bring anything. Lastly Alex seemed promising from his Real World portrayal but we didn't get any of that. To replace them all I put in MJ Garrett, Johnnie McBride, Davis Mallory, Dan Walsh, Jamie Chung, Svetlana Shusterman, and Jenn Grijalva. MJ was obvious since he ended up being a replacement. Johnnie was funny on Fresh Meat 2 and brings some muscle. Davis just came off Inferno 3 and would be interesting to see him with CT being there. Dan just came off Road Rules and would bring some better strength to the team and entertainment. Jamie I loved and she is a previous winner. Svetlana dropping out right at the airport was still such a travesty so I put her back on. and Jenn just came off Inferno 3 with a storyline so would have liked to see her back.
Thoughts?
The Challenge: Worlds Collide 2 (BotSeasons2 rules)
Blue:
Katie
Averey
Landon
Devin
Red:
Trishelle
Kailah
Bananas
Cory
Green:
Kendal
Amanda
Shane
Jordan
Orange:
Aneesa
Ashley M
Yes
Nelson
Purple:
Tina
Ashley K
Darrell
Fessy
Yellow:
Beth
Nany
CT
Kyle
Pink:
Veronica
Tori D
Brad
Hunter
Black:
Tori H
Jenna
Wes
Tony
Episode 1:
Winners: Black
Last: Blue
Voted in: Orange
Matchup: Averey and Landon vs Aneesa and Nelson
Eliminated: Averey and Landon
Episode 2:
Winners: Yellow
Last: Green
Voted in: Purple
Matchup: Kendal and Jordan vs Ashley K and Darrell
Eliminated: Ashley K and Darrell
Episode 3:
Winners: Black
Last: Blue
Voted in: Orange
Matchup: Katie and Devin vs Aneesa and Nelson
Eliminated: Aneesa and Nelson
Episode 4:
Winners: Yellow
Last: Blue
Voted in: Purple
Matchup: Katie and Devin vs Tina and Fessy
Eliminated: Katie and Devin
Episode 5:
Winners: Green
Last: Purple
Voted in: Yellow
Matchup: Tina and Fessy vs Nany and Kyle
Eliminated: Tina and Fessy
Episode 6:
Winners: Pink
Last: Green
Voted in: Red
Matchup: Kendal and Shane vs Trishelle and Bananas
Eliminated: Trishelle and Bananas
Episode 7:
Winners: Green
Last: Red
Voted in: Yellow
Matchup: Kailah and Cory vs Beth and CT
Eliminated: Kailah and Cory
Episode 8:
Winners: Pink
Last: Orange
Voted in: Yellow
Matchup: Ashley M and Yes vs Beth and CT
Eliminated: Ashley M and Yes
Episode 9:
Winners: Black
Last: Yellow
Voted in: Green
Matchup: Nany and Kyle vs Kendal and Jordan
Eliminated: Nany and Kyle
Episode 10:
Winners: Pink
Last: Yellow
Voted in: Green
Matchup: Beth and CT vs Amanda and Shane
Eliminated: Beth and CT
Episode 11:
Winners: Black
Last: Pink
Voted in: Green
Matchup: Veronica and Hunter vs Kendal and Shane
Eliminated: Veronica and Hunter
Episode 12:
3rd: Pink (Tori D and Brad)
2nd: Black (Tori H, Jenna, Wes, Tony)
1st: Green (Kendal, Amanda, Shane, Jordan)
Not bad at all. The only "problem" I see is that Danny was pretty much a lock at that time. He was someone they wanted to make the face of the show.
I think Ryan was better casting than Davis and I feel like Jamie Chung had already started her acting career then so not convinced she's realistic but I like the casting changes.
The Challenge 38: Old School vs New School (Cutoff is Free Agents)
Old School: Darrell, Nehemiah, Wes, Johnny, Jordan, Marlon, Brad, Frank, Laurel, Cara, Nany, Theresa, Nia, Trishelle, Rachel, Casey
New School: Paulie, Turbo, Hunter, Tony, Fessy, Cory, Jedson(BBCAN9), Adam(BBCAN7), Ashley, Nicole, Michaela, Natalie A., Bayleigh, Kaycee, Melissa, Jenn(RWBB), Cydney
^^You can tell this person started watching after Cutthroat if that is their "old school" fantasy cast lol.
First season was BOTSexes 2 actually... I was trying to be realistic.. and it's a stretch puting Rachel and Trishelle on there.
Honestly, you're probably right and, in fact, that might be optimistic about what Old School would look like
Pregnant, zero personality Ashley K is a realistic old school choice?
the only "old schoolers" on your list is Darrell, Rachel, Brad, Trishelle, Nehemiah, Wes, & Bananas the rest are kinda "middle school" competitors lol
I actually forgot she was pregnant.. but I just needed someone who'd be a first boot on that team lol
Of course but that doesn't really matter to them, it's just a catchy name... just like Leroy and Mike were rivals or Wes and Theresa were Exes.. and with All Stars, makes no sense of adding any of those people on the main cast as most of them wouldn't want to do it anyway.
The only problem I see is KVM trying to dictate someone else's FANTASY cast
The Challenge: Battle of the Namesakes
Team Johnny: Bananas/Reilly
Team Ash: Ashley M/Ashley K
Team Derrick: Derrick K/Derrick H
Team Natalie: Ninja/Natalie N
Team Cara: Cara Z/Cara Maria
Team Dan: Danny J/Dan Walsh
Team Jay: Jay Gotti/Jay Starret
Team Rachel: Rachel R/Rachel Austin
Team Tori: Tori H/Tori D
Team Amber: Amber M/Amber B
Team Frank: Frank S/Frank R
Team Sarah: Sarah R/Sarah G
Team Jamie: Jamie B/Jamie M
Devyn & Devin robbed !
I actually like this cast and see it as realistic outside of Rachel! people are tripping if they think we'd get ACTUAL old school competitors on a full season when they decided to call the spin-off All Stars and harp on about how these people are the "best of the best" and then cast Jisela, Jonna, and Big Easy.
Pages