The Challenge: Cast Member Rankings

854 posts / 0 new
Last post

Ayiiia making her comeback next season. Just wait. 

Ayiiia making her comeback next season. Just wait. 

*PinkRose dies waiting* jk

All I remember about JD being in drama is when Marie went on her rampage and called him a dolphin trainer like it was an insult.

 

I love Marie

All I remember about JD being in drama is when Marie went on her rampage and called him a dolphin trainer like it was an insult. I love Marie

God I love her. This list is gonna make me envy that a lot of these top castmembers didn't do challenges Sad

All I remember about JD being in drama is when Marie went on her rampage and called him a dolphin trainer like it was an insult. I love Marie

I love her too. I really wish she would return to our screens.

Ayiiia gonna come back & be everything Emilee was supposed to be.

Imagine if Ayiiia was on Free Agents instead of Emilee 

Ayiiia gonna come back & be everything Emilee was supposed to be.

Emilee was never anything even on her season , she was the sabrina of that season

Graphik wrote:

Ayiiia gonna come back & be everything Emilee was supposed to be.

Emilee was never anything even on her season , she was the sabrina of that season

I remember Emilee being about as crazy as Ayiiia on her season, who didn't she argue or have problems with? If anything, Jonna was the Sabrina (even though Jonna is 100 times better).

PinkRose wrote:

Graphik wrote:Ayiiia gonna come back & be everything Emilee was supposed to be.

Emilee was never anything even on her season , she was the sabrina of that season

I remember Emilee being about as crazy as Ayiiia on her season, who didn't she argue or have problems with? If anything, Jonna was the Sabrina (even though Jonna is 100 times better).

The Ayiiia storyline carried the first half of the season. 

Jonna/Jasmine/Pratt carried the second half of the season, that was the main storyline for the second half which got tiring.

Emilee was shown every now and then, yes she got in arguments but never really was part of the main storylines and she was far from a main character in my opinion she was a secondary character. The other 3 girls were way more relevant than her.

Jonna was a main character in terms of screen time that season with the girls not liking her, her being attention hungry when it came to guys, cheating , the love triangle and even the 3some with Ayiiia.

Graphik wrote:

PinkRose wrote:

Graphik wrote:Ayiiia gonna come back & be everything Emilee was supposed to be.

Emilee was never anything even on her season , she was the sabrina of that season

I remember Emilee being about as crazy as Ayiiia on her season, who didn't she argue or have problems with? If anything, Jonna was the Sabrina (even though Jonna is 100 times better).

The Ayiiia storyline carried the first half of the season. Jonna/Jasmine/Pratt carried the second half of the season, that was the main storyline for the second half which got tiring.Emilee was shown every now and then, yes she got in arguments but never really was part of the main storylines and she was far from a main character in my opinion she was a secondary character. The other 3 girls were way more relevant than her.Jonna was a main character in terms of screen time that season with the girls not liking her, her being attention hungry when it came to guys, cheating , the love triangle and even the 3some with Ayiiia.

But see that's the thing, Sabrina hasn't even done that lol she really can't be compared to the Cancun girls; all of them were dramatic.

Ayiiia & Emilee's hookup then big argument was a pretty big thing, then her thing with Jasmine where they were friends but then hated each other but were friends again, then her hating Bronne/Joey & didn't she have like a meltdown/walk-off at the reunion?

PinkRose wrote:

Graphik wrote:

PinkRose wrote:
Graphik wrote:Ayiiia gonna come back & be everything Emilee was supposed to be.

Emilee was never anything even on her season , she was the sabrina of that season

I remember Emilee being about as crazy as Ayiiia on her season, who didn't she argue or have problems with? If anything, Jonna was the Sabrina (even though Jonna is 100 times better).

The Ayiiia storyline carried the first half of the season. Jonna/Jasmine/Pratt carried the second half of the season, that was the main storyline for the second half which got tiring.Emilee was shown every now and then, yes she got in arguments but never really was part of the main storylines and she was far from a main character in my opinion she was a secondary character. The other 3 girls were way more relevant than her.Jonna was a main character in terms of screen time that season with the girls not liking her, her being attention hungry when it came to guys, cheating , the love triangle and even the 3some with Ayiiia.

But see that's the thing, Sabrina hasn't even done that lol she really can't be compared to the Cancun girls; all of them were dramatic.Ayiiia & Emilee's hookup then big argument was a pretty big thing, then her thing with Jasmine where they were friends but then hated each other but were friends again, then her hating Bronne/Joey & didn't she have like a meltdown/walk-off at the reunion?

Ayiiia/Emilee hookup and fight was on episode 2 then never mentioned again, it wasnt that big. Her hookup with Jonna and the aftermath was more interesting. Compared to the other 3 girls she was boring in my opinion.

I guess! You are right about Sabrinanot even bein an Emilee.

Arielle? Bronne? Zzzz

I honestly have a feeling like Nia will be #1

I see the top 10 being a combination of  Knight, Jemmye, Dustin, Ryan L., maybe Frank? Idk who else, maybe Nany

EDIT - oh and Nia too

What season are they? Brooklyn to present? 

What season are they? Brooklyn to present? 

Yes!

If it is I see knight, Jemmye, Jenny, Madison, Marie, Dustin in top 10

25. Cory (Ex-Plosion)

Cory was an interesting case because he's not that different from a lot of other guys cast on this show, in that he's an attractive, cocky, kind of ******* guy. But, beyond that, Cory was incredibly charming. You couldn't help but kind of like him even when he did things that ****ed you off, like getting angry at Jenny for talking to other guys at the bar even though he was talking to other girls and they weren't in a relationship. Cory and Jenny had a complicated relationship. They started the season by having "bear sex" in the confessional on like night 2, and then went through a phase where they didn't want to be together but didn't want each other with anybody else, and then Brian came. Cory's relationship with Brian was even more complicated because they started as enemies and then became bros (or frenemies, idk) and it was actually kind of funny watching them as bros, even though you know both of them were just doing it to **** off Jenny. Of course, this eventually lead to Cory and Brian have an all-out brawl in the van and back at the house, which Cory "won" for lack of a better word. He also had sex with his ex-gf who got pregnant but it was with someone else which he did NOT like. I don't know, Cory ****ed me off a lot but at the end of the day, I found him entertaining and mostly level-headed in comparison to some other people. But man, he was dumb.

 

24. Brian (Ex-Plosion)

Where there is Cory, there is Brian. In terms of entertainment, I think Brian takes the cake even if he came off as kind of a slouch during some of those physical fights compared to Cory (and Arielle, let's be real). The thing about Brian is that everything he did and said on the show should have made him incredibly unlikable, and yet he was easily the most likable guy that season. I was rooting for Brian in his arguments with Cory because man, I felt bad for the guy. Something about him was kind of tragic, like he SO desperately wanted approval (from Jenny and the guys) but he just couldn't get it. There was nothing sadder than when the guys kept taking pics without Brian. And watching him struggle through his relationship with Jenny was hard to watch, because you could see him self-destructing. He would make out with girls at the bar to purposely **** of Jenny, but then still want to get back with her, then beg for her approval then tell her to **** himself. It was like watching a bomb getting ready to explode, which it finally did in the finale. Also, he said the weirdest shit. Like, are you smart? Are you dumb? I can't tell!! Honestly, I hope Jenny and Brian are happy together and with their child because I wasn't 100% sure they would good for each other based on what happened on the show.

 

23. Adam (Las Vegas 2)

What a ******* shithead, this kid. Possibly the most immature cast member in a pool of incredibly immature people. He just didn't get it. He was so self-destructive, and not just that. He left a path of destruction everywhere he went, smacking painting off walls, knocking over plants, punching walls, etc. This kid was so bad he was literally kicked out of his hotel and BANNED for life. And possibly got MTV banned from there? I don't know. He also got kicked out of their regular club, like dude chill your shit. And that's not even getting into his treatment of Nany. He basically told her the entire time she had a BF that they're gonna bang and then when she breaks up with her BF, they finally get together and of course he continues punching walls and shit because why not. He talked about being a teen drug dealer like it was something to be proud of while like half this cast had parents with drug problems. Kid sucked. Plus, even made Leroy ****ed off! Leroy! That guy loves everybody.

 

22. Jenny (Ex-Plosion)

Well I talked about the Brian/Cory/Jenny saga in the last two write-ups but here's the final piece. The thing about Jenny that was interesting is that she was just a really, weird, goofy human being. Like, she was so strange! I remember her macking on that dude outside the bar and just like casually dancing on the streets and shit. She was so strange and said the weirdest shit that in those ways she and Brian were perfect together, but man other than that I don't know. Their relationship was flawed while in the house to say the least. It was clear that they were "passionate" or whatever in that when they loved each other, they really loved each other, but when they hated each other they REALLY hated each other. They had that weird diary that they wrote in together? Was that a therapy thing? I honestly forget. I liked Jenny, I think she was entertaining but I will admit something about her came off as very try-hard, especially in the beginning of the season. I think she eventually just let herself be herself but she started off as really aware of the cameras.

 

21. Zach (San Diego 2)

Man, Zach was such a ***** during his season. Believe it or not, the season started with Nate being the homophobe and Zach being pretty level-headed in comparison. Well, that didn't last long because while Nate and Frank became close, Zach and Frank got increasingly worse with one another. If Zach wasn't so clearly narrow-minded, I would have felt worse for him because truly Frank was an insufferable, drama queeny little *****. But the fact is that there wasn't much sympathy to be had for Zach. I mean, he told Sam he would beat the gay out of her with a ping pong paddle. He spent his whole season tied to Ashley, a walking black hole of personality.  The thing is that Zach didn't allow himself to enjoy himself at all when in the house. He and Ashley purposely distanced themselves from the rest of the cast for seemingly no reason at all. I think Zach could've been a way more interesting cast member if he wasn't tethered to Ashley and quite frankly if he was on a season with more interesting people. But he didn't allow himself to have any fun. But still, this season is pretty much defined by the Zach/Frank rivalry.

Top 20 remaining:

Brooklyn: Chet, Katelynn, Ryan

Cancun: Ayiiia, Joey

DC: Ashley, Mike

New Orleans: Jemmye, Knight, Preston, Ryan

Las Vegas: Dustin, Leroy, Mike, Nany

San Diego: Frank

St. Thomas: Marie

Portland: Jordan, Nia

Ex-Plosion: N/A

Skeletons: Madison

Chet, Katelynn, Ryan C, Preston, Mike M, and Mike R next?

Where can I watch Inferno 3 and Gauntlet 3? I will pay. I live in the US.

I have never like zach, he was just fake on the real world, he tried really hard to be someone he wasnt just to be cast and then do the challenges, his true personality came later on the shows.

Leroy, both Mikes, Preston, and Chet should be next. 

Queen Jenny definitely should've been higher than Mike (DC), Chet, and Zach IMO

Out of the top 20 remaining Ryan, Joey, Ashley L, Mike (DC), Ryan L, and Madison haven't been on a challenge. ROOBBED OF LEGENDS

Out of the top 20 remaining Ryan, Joey, Ashley L, Mike (DC), Ryan L, and Madison haven't been on a challenge. ROOBBED OF LEGENDS

Production wants Madison so hopefully for 29.

gamer73 wrote:

Out of the top 20 remaining Ryan, Joey, Ashley L, Mike (DC), Ryan L, and Madison haven't been on a challenge. ROOBBED OF LEGENDS

Production wants Madison so hopefully for 29.

If I was production I would throw huge money Madison's way

PinkRose wrote:

gamer73 wrote:Out of the top 20 remaining Ryan, Joey, Ashley L, Mike (DC), Ryan L, and Madison haven't been on a challenge. ROOBBED OF LEGENDS

Production wants Madison so hopefully for 29.

If I was production I would throw huge money Madison's way

I would too.

Pretty sure Madison will be on the next from what I heard. Her and Tony would be top priority. Also was told no matter how boring Trey was on the 2 challenges he's done, they would want him on too if Madison and Tony were there. 

Pages