The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

Frank is better than Dustin and Nia is better than Nany.

I think Zach&Aneesa is weak pair and I just can not see them making into finale. Only thing they are good is physical.

What if The Ruins was Free Agents instead? That would've been a much better challenge format because the cast was a great mix of old school and new school competitors. 

I wish Ruthie would come back.  I read in a comment to one of her Youtube videos that she doesn't get "second calls" anymore (not sure what that means, if someone could elaborate?)

Didnt she have a twin?  I want them on Bloodlines!! #dreaming

But yes, a Ruthie/Rachel showdown would've been a lot better than seeing Rachel dominate two competitors that you knew she could take...

Production calls people to see if they're available and these are known as first calls. If production wants to cast them for sure on the challenge, they call them again and let them know they're going to be on next season. Ruthie stopped getting second calls after Duel II )= 

I remember Ruthie had a twin, seeing them together on Bloodlines would be everything!!!!

She was hands down the best girl on Battle of the Sexes. Her outperforming all the guys in the Maximum Velocity mission is one of my favorite moments in Challenge history! Even though she got eliminated early on The Duel II, she still impressed me. Ruthie beating Brittini and Tori in her heat was really impressive because those girls are twice the size of her. I want Ruthie to come back so bad. She deserves to win. A Free Agents/Duel format would be perfect for her. 

Sad thing is she is still very much interested smh Ruthie was one of the premier RWers in that age & now she can't even get a second call...

Exactly. Ruthie is one of the most memorable cast members from the golden era. TJ even stated on The Gauntlet 2 pre special how Ruthie has always been a fan favorite since her debut. It's really sad knowing Ruthie was an alternate for Free Agents and they cast girls like Emilee, Jasmine and Jessica over her SMH Ruthie would've been Laurel's biggest competition. Wish we got to see her on that challenge. 

I like Ruthie but Laurel would've killed her js

I like Ruthie but Laurel would've killed her js

Probably but Ruthie would've been great competition for her in a final. I think she could've gave Laurel a run for her money. 

I like Ruthie but Laurel would've killed her js

Probably but Ruthie would've been great competition for her in a final. I think she could've gave Laurel a run for her money. 

Final wise yeah for sure! But Ruthies politicking isn't the best and she would've most likely went in and mostikely go home since the elimination rounds catered to bigger girls 

jordan and nia probably would have went after the top teams and end up getting eliminated early

I have no Idea why but I laughed so hard at this post.

***** same

Frank is better than Dustin and Nia is better than Nany.

I think Zach&Aneesa is weak pair and I just can not see them making into finale. Only thing they are good is physical.


Zach did very well on free agents regardless of how disgusting he is.
He performed well in pretty much every mission.

What if the pairs for auto body rally during free agents were the pairs for the whole game? Who makes the final? Bananas & Jonna Brandon & LaToya Cohutta & Laurel CT & Emilee Dustin & Nany Frank & Nia Isaac & Devyn Johnny & Cara Maria Jordan & Jasmine Leroy & Jessica Preston & Camila Swift & Theresa Zach & Aneesa

the third spot would be a toss up between Frank & Nia, and Cohutta & Laurel. 

Dustin and Nany would make the final instead of Frank and Nia imo.


Cohutta & Laurel would over both of them IMO.

What if the pairs for auto body rally during free agents were the pairs for the whole game? Who makes the final? Bananas & Jonna Brandon & LaToya Cohutta & Laurel CT & Emilee Dustin & Nany Frank & Nia Isaac & Devyn Johnny & Cara Maria Jordan & Jasmine Leroy & Jessica Preston & Camila Swift & Theresa Zach & Aneesa

That is tough and if the same things happened still (Frank getting sick, Cara Maria getting injured, etc), I would say Cohutta & Laurel, Bananas & Jonna, and Dustin & Nany.

What if Tina and CT never showed up on Cutthroat? Who would win in that "Back Up Off Me" Elimination.. Tyler vs Bananas and Tori vs Theresa?

What if Tina and CT never showed up on Cutthroat? Who would win in that "Back Up Off Me" Elimination..  Tyler  vs Bananas and Tori vs  Theresa  ?

What if Tina and CT never showed up on Cutthroat? Who would win in that "Back Up Off Me" Elimination..  Tyler  vs Bananas and Tori vs  Theresa  ?

What if the pairs for auto body rally during free agents were the pairs for the whole game? Who makes the final? Bananas & Jonna Brandon & LaToya Cohutta & Laurel CT & Emilee Dustin & Nany Frank & Nia Isaac & Devyn Johnny & Cara Maria Jordan & Jasmine Leroy & Jessica Preston & Camila Swift & Theresa Zach & Aneesa

That is tough and if the same things happened still (Frank getting sick, Cara Maria getting injured, etc), I would say Cohutta & Laurel, Bananas & Jonna, and Dustin & Nany.

I think Zach/Aneesa would have made the final just based on no one being able to beat them in an elimination. The only girl that could beat her is Laurel but Cohutta can't beat Zach in any of those Free Agents eliminations. I would say 

1) Bananas/Jonna she's a good runner and there was no lifting involved 

2) Cohutta/Laurel not far behind them

3) Zach/Aneesa both tanking at the end 

Jonna's first win would have been awesome.

What if Tina and CT never showed up on Cutthroat? Who would win in that "Back Up Off Me" Elimination..  Tyler  vs Bananas and Tori vs  Theresa  ?

What if the pairs for auto body rally during free agents were the pairs for the whole game? Who makes the final? Bananas & Jonna Brandon & LaToya Cohutta & Laurel CT & Emilee Dustin & Nany Frank & Nia Isaac & Devyn Johnny & Cara Maria Jordan & Jasmine Leroy & Jessica Preston & Camila Swift & Theresa Zach & Aneesa

That is tough and if the same things happened still (Frank getting sick, Cara Maria getting injured, etc), I would say Cohutta & Laurel, Bananas & Jonna, and Dustin & Nany.

I think Zach/Aneesa would have made the final just based on no one being able to beat them in an elimination. The only girl that could beat her is Laurel but Cohutta can't beat Zach in any of those Free Agents eliminations. I would say 

1) Bananas/Jonna she's a good runner and there was no lifting involved 

2) Cohutta/Laurel not far behind them

3) Zach/Aneesa both tanking at the end 

Jonna's first win would have been awesome.

Bananas and Jonna would not make the final because I don't think Jonna could beat most girls in those elimination rounds.

(I'm including Cara cause she wouldn't have fractured her wrist in this format) 

1.)Johnny & Cara Maria

2.)Cohutta & Laurel

3.)Zach & Aneesa

What if the pairs for auto body rally during free agents were the pairs for the whole game? Who makes the final? Bananas & Jonna Brandon & LaToya Cohutta & Laurel CT & Emilee Dustin & Nany Frank & Nia Isaac & Devyn Johnny & Cara Maria Jordan & Jasmine Leroy & Jessica Preston & Camila Swift & Theresa Zach & Aneesa

That is tough and if the same things happened still (Frank getting sick, Cara Maria getting injured, etc), I would say Cohutta & Laurel, Bananas & Jonna, and Dustin & Nany.

I think Zach/Aneesa would have made the final just based on no one being able to beat them in an elimination. The only girl that could beat her is Laurel but Cohutta can't beat Zach in any of those Free Agents eliminations. I would say 

1) Bananas/Jonna she's a good runner and there was no lifting involved 

2) Cohutta/Laurel not far behind them

3) Zach/Aneesa both tanking at the end 

Jonna's first win would have been awesome.

Bananas and Jonna would not make the final because I don't think Jonna could beat most girls in those elimination rounds.

(I'm including Cara cause she wouldn't have fractured her wrist in this format) 

1.)Johnny & Cara Maria

2.)Cohutta & Laurel

3.)Zach & Aneesa

I guess that makes sense but in that case I think Cohutta and Laurel would have won. Cohutta = Johnny and Laurel >  Cara Maria. But I wouldn't be surprised if your scenario happened. 

Cohutta = Johnny? No way

I love my baby Cohutta but pls

What if Leroy was given Jemmye as an Ex instead of Theresa. Would Jemmye Beat Nany X Battle

What if Leroy was given Jemmye as an Ex instead of Theresa. Would Jemmye Beat Nany X Battle

no way. nany would have beat jemmye for sure

What if Leroy was given Jemmye as an Ex instead of Theresa. Would Jemmye Beat Nany X Battle

No shot in ****.

What if Leroy was given Jemmye as an Ex instead of Theresa. Would Jemmye Beat Nany X Battle

Love Jemmye but she was in the worst shape on Exes 2. Nany would have beat her so easily lol

Cohutta = Johnny? No way

I love my baby Cohutta but pls


He out performed Johnny r in almost every mission.

I would take Cohutta on my team over Johnny R. But that's just me.

I would take Cohutta on my team over Johnny R. But that's just me.

Same. Johnny R's decent, but I feel that Cohutta is more consistent in the daily missions, and crafty too. His main downfall is weight, but overall he's pretty underrated IMO. I really want to see him in a final.

I would take Cohutta on my team over Johnny R. But that's just me.

Same. Johnny R's decent, but I feel that Cohutta is more consistent in the daily missions, and crafty too. His main downfall is weight, but overall he's pretty underrated IMO. I really want to see him in a final.

The only thing is Johnny R really surprised me in the final with his endurance. Idk how Cohutta's endurance is but I think he would do well.

I would take Cohutta on my team over Johnny R. But that's just me.

Eh that is a tough one. They are both smaller guys but perform really well in the missions. 

 

What if Susie was on The Duel 2?

 

What if Susie was on The Duel 2?


She would've finally been eliminated. The Duel format is awful for her gameplay.

 

What if Susie was on The Duel 2?

She would've finally been eliminated. The Duel format is awful for her gameplay.

Eh she would have made it far based on politics but they are definitely people on the cast that could have taken her out.

Pages