The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if Rivals2 teams were Bananas&CT and Frank&Wes(bots2 little fight)

I tkink Frank and Wes won. Bananas wasn't in shape that season.

What if during FA Cara never broke her hand? 

Laurel still won that elimination.

Cara Maria and CT would've won the challenge. Nany would've went in against Laurel. Nany would've been out. Then I guess Theresa vs. Laurel again. And I think that 1st place would've been a toss up with Cara and Laurel.

i don't know if cara would've won that challenge. To nany and Theresa's credit, they both beat cara across the shore the first time around before cara started to get burdened by her band with the dig

the free agents finale with Laurel theresa and cara would have been amazing. I honestly don't know who would have won and it would have been one of the closest we've seen in challenge history . I really do think that Laurel got lucky that none of the true threats made it to the end 

 

What if BOTS2 Eric&CM were eliminated first. Could Camila&Brandon made it to finale? Definitely beat Devyn&JD but....

What if Rivals2 teams were Bananas&CT and Frank&Wes(bots2 little fight)

I tkink Frank and Wes won. Bananas wasn't in shape that season.

Yeah Frank/Wes probably would have won and I think Bananas/Frank would have ended up hating each other.

What if BOTS2 Eric&CM were eliminated first. Could Camila&Brandon made it to finale? Definitely beat Devyn&JD but....

It would have been a toss up. They could have possibly taken JD/Devyns spot. They're only threat elimination wise was San Diego and Robb/Marie.

What if BOTS2 Eric&CM were eliminated first. Could Camila&Brandon made it to finale? Definitely beat Devyn&JD but....

Absolutely not. Fresh Meat would have been thrown in every time San Diego, New Orleans, and/or Cancun won, which was quite often.

What if BOTS2 Eric&CM were eliminated first. Could Camila&Brandon made it to finale? Definitely beat Devyn&JD but....

Absolutely not. Fresh Meat would have been thrown in every time San Diego, New Orleans, and/or Cancun won, which was quite often.


I think you are underrating this pair. Camila was one of the strongest girls and Brandon does not suck.
They would have beat Devyn&JD in Water Torture, Preston and McKenzie Balls Out, Laura&Trey in Knot so Fast. 2 wins for Brooklyn.
Beatinh Dustin&Trishelle and Robb&Marie are harder to beat not impossible.

Also two of them are way stronger team than Camila and Eric and who knows, maybe they could have won missions.

Brandon is so underrated

What if BOTS2 Eric&CM were eliminated first. Could Camila&Brandon made it to finale? Definitely beat Devyn&JD but....

Absolutely not. Fresh Meat would have been thrown in every time San Diego, New Orleans, and/or Cancun won, which was quite often.

I think you are underrating this pair. Camila was one of the strongest girls and Brandon does not suck. They would have beat Devyn&JD in Water Torture, Preston and McKenzie Balls Out, Laura&Trey in Knot so Fast. 2 wins for Brooklyn. Beatinh Dustin&Trishelle and Robb&Marie are harder to beat not impossible. Also two of them are way stronger team than Camila and Eric and who knows, maybe they could have won missions. Brandon is so underrated

I think they would have beat JD & Devyn, Preston & Mckenzie, and Trey & Laura. With the back to back Brooklyn wins, that would have put them at Episode 9. San Diego won and most likely would have thrown in Vegas still to go against last place St. Thomas, Robb & Marie beat Alton & Nany. Then in Episode 10, San Diego won again and they most likely would have thrown in Fresh Meat instead of St. Thomas at which point Dustin & Trishelle may or may not have beat Brandon & Camila. So let's say they do, that means in the last swimming challenge, it would have been San Diego, Brooklyn, Cancun, St. Thomas and Fresh Meat. No way Fresh Meat wins a swimming with Brandon. And if I remember correctly, Brooklyn came in 2nd to Vegas, so with Vegas not being there, Brooklyn would have won, and assuming Fresh Meat didn't come in last, Fresh Meat could have made it to the final challenge. So I apologize, there is a pretty good chance that they could have made it to the finals.

As far as Brandon goes, I don't think he sucks, but he is not that great. The only way I ever see Brandon getting to a final challenge is if they do another big team challenge with a weak cast. If its individual or pairs, he doesn't stand a chance. 

What if BOTS2 Eric&CM were eliminated first. Could Camila&Brandon made it to finale? Definitely beat Devyn&JD but....

Absolutely not. Fresh Meat would have been thrown in every time San Diego, New Orleans, and/or Cancun won, which was quite often.

I think you are underrating this pair. Camila was one of the strongest girls and Brandon does not suck. They would have beat Devyn&JD in Water Torture, Preston and McKenzie Balls Out, Laura&Trey in Knot so Fast. 2 wins for Brooklyn. Beatinh Dustin&Trishelle and Robb&Marie are harder to beat not impossible. Also two of them are way stronger team than Camila and Eric and who knows, maybe they could have won missions. Brandon is so underrated

I think they would have beat JD & Devyn, Preston & Mckenzie, and Trey & Laura. With the back to back Brooklyn wins, that would have put them at Episode 9. San Diego won and most likely would have thrown in Vegas still to go against last place St. Thomas, Robb & Marie beat Alton & Nany. Then in Episode 10, San Diego won again and they most likely would have thrown in Fresh Meat instead of St. Thomas at which point Dustin & Trishelle may or may not have beat Brandon & Camila. So let's say they do, that means in the last swimming challenge, it would have been San Diego, Brooklyn, Cancun, St. Thomas and Fresh Meat. No way Fresh Meat wins a swimming with Brandon. And if I remember correctly, Brooklyn came in 2nd to Vegas, so with Vegas not being there, Brooklyn would have won, and assuming Fresh Meat didn't come in last, Fresh Meat could have made it to the final challenge. So I apologize, there is a pretty good chance that they could have made it to the finals.

As far as Brandon goes, I don't think he sucks, but he is not that great. The only way I ever see Brandon getting to a final challenge is if they do another big team challenge with a weak cast. If its individual or pairs, he doesn't stand a chance. 

Agreed with all of this, I remember Kenny saying that Brandon could be a great competitor if he goes there for the game and not the party.

 

What if Frank never got sick on Free Agents?

I bet he could have won none of the missions were something he couldn't handle.

Plus one of the main reasons Frank quit challenges was because he wasn't as sick as they said. In an interview he said that he already passes the contagious stage and wasn't a threat anymore. He thinks they kicked him off because he was "sick" and wasn't giving them drama. So if he isn't removed we may still be seeing Frank on our screens. Which is missed.

What if Frank never got sick on Free Agents? I bet he could have won none of the missions were something he couldn't handle. Plus one of the main reasons Frank quit challenges was because he wasn't as sick as they said. In an interview he said that he already passes the contagious stage and wasn't a threat anymore. He thinks they kicked him off because he was "sick" and wasn't giving them drama. So if he isn't removed we may still be seeing Frank on our screens. Which is missed.

I think he would have lost at some point. 

What if Frank never got sick on Free Agents? I bet he could have won none of the missions were something he couldn't handle. Plus one of the main reasons Frank quit challenges was because he wasn't as sick as they said. In an interview he said that he already passes the contagious stage and wasn't a threat anymore. He thinks they kicked him off because he was "sick" and wasn't giving them drama. So if he isn't removed we may still be seeing Frank on our screens. Which is missed.

I think he would have lost at some point. 

Probably toward the end when it was just the top guys left. He would have had to face Leroy, Zach , Ct or Bananas eventually and probably would have lost. 

What if Rivals2 teams were Bananas&CT and Frank&Wes(bots2 little fight)

I think Frank & Wes would see alot of eliminations, or maybe they would win alot of daily challenges. I don't remember alot of the dailies from that season.

What if Wes had Theresa as his original partner on the first Battle of the Exes instead of Mandi? I think they would've made it really far. 

StuffAndThings
Anonymous's picture

Nope.

 

Delete.

What if Wes had Theresa as his original partner on the first Battle of the Exes instead of Mandi? I think they would've made it really far. 

i think they couldve done some serious damage. wes lost their elimination round but it was mandi who sucked in the challenges and ultimately prevented them from winning. theresa/wes might have been able to come through in both challenges

also i think bananas/camila both had ties to theresa at the time from cutthroat and rivals and i dont think they wouldve turned on her like that. the theresa/bananas alliance didnt come through on exes 2 because theresa made her decision to discard that alliance in the beginning and that was only evident because of 1) winning the first challenge, which gave her the opportunity to show her colors and 2) nany

what if kenny and johanna had been on exes 2?

What if BOTS2 Eric&CM were eliminated first. Could Camila&Brandon made it to finale? Definitely beat Devyn&JD but....

Absolutely not. Fresh Meat would have been thrown in every time San Diego, New Orleans, and/or Cancun won, which was quite often.

I think you are underrating this pair. Camila was one of the strongest girls and Brandon does not suck. They would have beat Devyn&JD in Water Torture, Preston and McKenzie Balls Out, Laura&Trey in Knot so Fast. 2 wins for Brooklyn. Beatinh Dustin&Trishelle and Robb&Marie are harder to beat not impossible. Also two of them are way stronger team than Camila and Eric and who knows, maybe they could have won missions. Brandon is so underrated

I think they would have beat JD & Devyn, Preston & Mckenzie, and Trey & Laura. With the back to back Brooklyn wins, that would have put them at Episode 9. San Diego won and most likely would have thrown in Vegas still to go against last place St. Thomas, Robb & Marie beat Alton & Nany. Then in Episode 10, San Diego won again and they most likely would have thrown in Fresh Meat instead of St. Thomas at which point Dustin & Trishelle may or may not have beat Brandon & Camila. So let's say they do, that means in the last swimming challenge, it would have been San Diego, Brooklyn, Cancun, St. Thomas and Fresh Meat. No way Fresh Meat wins a swimming with Brandon. And if I remember correctly, Brooklyn came in 2nd to Vegas, so with Vegas not being there, Brooklyn would have won, and assuming Fresh Meat didn't come in last, Fresh Meat could have made it to the final challenge. So I apologize, there is a pretty good chance that they could have made it to the finals.

As far as Brandon goes, I don't think he sucks, but he is not that great. The only way I ever see Brandon getting to a final challenge is if they do another big team challenge with a weak cast. If its individual or pairs, he doesn't stand a chance. 

Agreed with all of this, I remember Kenny saying that Brandon could be a great competitor if he goes there for the game and not the party.

 

But wasn't the back to back win for Brooklyn because of the four working perfectly together in the hike trail with the puzzle, which they wouldn't have won if it was just Sarah and Chet, and the eating daily, which they wouldn't have won if it was just Sarah and Chet. So I think, had CM&Eric lost to Sarah and Chet and Brandon & Camila beat JD & Devyn, I think it would have been deterimental to both Brooklyn and Fresh Meat in the long run. 

What if Wes had Theresa as his original partner on the first Battle of the Exes instead of Mandi? I think they would've made it really far. 

IDK depends on when/if they go into elimination against who...

Leroy and Naomi still would have beaten Wes and Theresa in that elimination round

Leroy and Naomi still would have beaten Wes and Theresa in that elimination round

Stop Theresa and Wes wouldn't of even been in that elimination round 

Leroy and Naomi still would have beaten Wes and Theresa in that elimination round

Stop Theresa and Wes wouldn't of even been in that elimination round 

i don't remember but weren't Wes and Mandy voted in? So there's a chance they would have been in that elimination.  Bananas and Camilla would have kept throwing Wes in. 

Leroy and Naomi still would have beaten Wes and Theresa in that elimination round

Stop Theresa and Wes wouldn't of even been in that elimination round 

i don't remember but weren't Wes and Mandy voted in? So there's a chance they would have been in that elimination.  Bananas and Camilla would have kept throwing Wes in. 

Yea Wes ****** lots of people off so they were throwing them in each time. they lost to Leroy and Naomi

What if Rivals2 was with Alton with CJ(altho he had fights with Zach and Frank too)

Also BOTS2, Dustin&Trishelle vs Marie&Robb in Hall Brawl?

What if Rivals2 was with Alton with CJ(altho he had fights with Zach and Frank too) Also BOTS2, Dustin&Trishelle vs Marie&Robb in Hall Brawl?

Marie would've destroyed Trashelle but Dustin would've beat Robb so it would go down to a sudden death match. 

What if in the exes 2 pairs would be:

Nia and Jordan

Leroy and Theresa

Wes and KellyAnne

(rest same, no Sarah)

 

What if in the exes 2 pairs would be:

Nia and Jordan

Leroy and Theresa

Wes and KellyAnne

(rest same, no Sarah)

 

I don't think Jordan and Nia would've been good partners for each other. Nia wouldn't have tolerated him being an ******* and he would've laid into her a lot over her performance (which, as much as people want to praise the elimination rounds, she was only good in day challenges twice). Leroy was good for her because he was lowkey and let her do her thing and her being bad at swimming wasn't an issue for him since he was worse. She and Jordan would've had a problem. 

Jordan/Nia would have been a toxic pairing... lol 

Sarah was probably the only person who knew how to handle Jordan and Leroy was probably the only person who knew how to handle Nia.

A Jordan/Nia pairing would've been everything lol which is why I want a Seasons 3 Portland team of Johnny/Jordan/Averey/Nia. Imagine the drama that would go down. 

What if Season 27 gets killer ratings like 2 or 3 million viewers?

Pages