The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

Jonna wasn't the weak link. Zach shit the bed all season long, he didn't compete well and he was a horrible partner.. Ashley/Zach would have done better soley because Zach wouldn't have disrespected Ashley the way he did Jonna or at least not to her face. The one time he tried to be a **** to her on Seasons, she immeditaely went off on him and he shutup. It sucks Jonna wasn't that way but he took away all her confidence : (

Team Jonna<3

What if there was no EX-ile on BTOE2? The house wouldn't have ganged up on Wes/Theresa (Leroy was on their side).

Jay/Jenna finish last on "Wrecking Ball," and gotten crushed by whoever would've been voted in.

And Wes/Theresa would've won the final. 

I completely agree. Wes/Theresa were a much better team than Jordan/Sarah. It would've been a close race between those teams though. Wes/Theresa would've won the final with Jordan/Sarah getting second and Leroy/Nia getting third. 

Zach & Ashley probably would have won. 8 can't see them doing bad in anything. I Gotchu Babe: Possible Win. Rounding The Bases: probably out 2nd Base On Again, Off Again: Possible Win. The Brush Off: Possible Win Open Arms: Possible Win. Don't Forget About Me: Possible Win. Are You The One: Possible Win. Speed Dating: Possible Win. Wrecking Ball: Possible Win. Don't Let Go: Possible Win. I really can't see them struggling with anything physically their biggest problem would be communication, even though they seemed fine on BOTS.

i dont know if they were going to do "bad" in anyting but im not sure where peope are getting this idea that ashley K is some beast when she had a david and goliath STRUGGLE with jasmine in the oil pit and a whole bunch of other performances that werent even displayed because of the way her season was edited. i listened to a lot of interviews after seasons and i didnt hear a single person say that ashley K was going to be a big star...all the spotlight was on nany. the only thing people acknowledged about ashley K was that she was a cardio bunny and could run long distances. people think shes awesome athlete now because she does crossfit to get a beverly hills basic becky ***** body?

i got you babe: no way shes dragging zach across the wire. she was the reason her team didnt finish top 2 in the first climbing mission on seasons anyways even though she only had to carry her body weight. nany was on the team that performed superior to san diego BTW

rounding the bases: this was zachs fault, ashleys presence has no bearing

on and off again: there is zero evidence that shes a better swimmer than sarah or even theresa

brush off: maybe

open arms: the winning of this would be based on zach so why would ashley's mere presence change the outcome? she probably isnt a better swimmer than sarah or even theresa

dont forget about me: this requires brain power, someting ashley k is completely depleted of

are you the one: no way. if the question doesnt pertain to MAC make up, tampons, instagram, stupid cliche quotes, and nordstrom clothes that make her *** look "phat" then shes getting it wrong. you really think she knows where the taj mahal is when she thought there were 30 continents on BOTS?

speed dating: maybe

wrecking ball: doesnt matter since this one was rigged

dont let go: no. she wasnt a good climber on seasons and i dont see her doing pull ups now

she would have been eaten alive by nia in the elimination rounds too. i see her as a jenna type and i dont see her outperforming nany or avery. the challenge is set up where its all or nothing, youre either the best, in which case you get the decision making for the day or the worst, in which case youre sent into elmination round. everything between is all the same. second is the same as second to last i the grand scheme of politics. is ashley better than jonna? i dont know, but that doesnt matter because zach/jonan were never even close to winning a challenge anyways. the question is whether or not she was better than theresa/sarah, in other words, good enough to solidify the top spot for decision making. IMO? not even close

StuffAndThings
Anonymous's picture

 beverly hills basic becky ***** body

What if there was no EX-ile on BTOE2? The house wouldn't have ganged up on Wes/Theresa (Leroy was on their side).

Jay/Jenna finish last on "Wrecking Ball," and gotten crushed by whoever would've been voted in.

And Wes/Theresa would've won the final. 

I completely agree. Wes/Theresa were a much better team than Jordan/Sarah. It would've been a close race between those teams though. Wes/Theresa would've won the final with Jordan/Sarah getting second and Leroy/Nia getting third. 

Wes/Theresa were definitely the best team and would have beat Sarah/Jordan. I actually felt really bad for them when they got eliminated.

Jonna wasn't the weak link. Zach shit the bed all season long, he didn't compete well and he was a horrible partner.. Ashley/Zach would have done better soley because Zach wouldn't have disrespected Ashley the way he did Jonna or at least not to her face. The one time he tried to be a **** to her on Seasons, she immeditaely went off on him and he shutup. It sucks Jonna wasn't that way but he took away all her confidence : (

Team Jonna<3

He didn't compete well??? he single handedly won them a challenge due to his large size, he carried Jonna on his back when she was too weak to swim, he saved her dumb *** before she almost injured herself on that truck challenge, he gained 11 balls (and yes he was the reason why they didn't win but still that's impressive), he was the only one to answer a Trivia question correct, etc

Neither one of them were the weak link tbh. they were both a good team, abou top six or five athletically. and they both had their screw ups.

What if there was no EX-ile on BTOE2? The house wouldn't have ganged up on Wes/Theresa (Leroy was on their side).

Jay/Jenna finish last on "Wrecking Ball," and gotten crushed by whoever would've been voted in.

And Wes/Theresa would've won the final. 

I completely agree. Wes/Theresa were a much better team than Jordan/Sarah. It would've been a close race between those teams though. Wes/Theresa would've won the final with Jordan/Sarah getting second and Leroy/Nia getting third. 

Wes/Theresa were definitely the best team and would have beat Sarah/Jordan. I actually felt really bad for them when they got eliminated.

Honestly I think it could have gone either way. In a final Jordan is better than Wes and Theresa is better than Sarah. 

Wes is hit or miss with endurance so you never know.

What if there was no EX-ile on BTOE2? The house wouldn't have ganged up on Wes/Theresa (Leroy was on their side).

Jay/Jenna finish last on "Wrecking Ball," and gotten crushed by whoever would've been voted in.

And Wes/Theresa would've won the final. 

I completely agree. Wes/Theresa were a much better team than Jordan/Sarah. It would've been a close race between those teams though. Wes/Theresa would've won the final with Jordan/Sarah getting second and Leroy/Nia getting third. 

Wes/Theresa were definitely the best team and would have beat Sarah/Jordan. I actually felt really bad for them when they got eliminated.

Honestly I think it could have gone either way. In a final Jordan is better than Wes and Theresa is better than Sarah. 

I don't know I think Sarah/Jordan had it so easy in the finals so I think Wes/Theresa would have won. Jordan absolutely killed it though but I think they would have been more nervous going against them and Theresa would have competed better with Wes than Leroy instead of freaking out a lot at the beginning.

What if Nia got Balls in or Oppenheimer eliminations aganist Cara Maria in FA? 

What if Nia got Balls in or Oppenheimer eliminations aganist Cara Maria in FA? 

 

She wins Balls in 100% money on her, idk about pppenhemier tho is Nia quick on her feet? Couldnt really tell from her elimination agaisnt theresa because of the camera angles.

Instead of Fresh Meat 1, it was Rivals.   The original cast members with their rivals.  (some may be a stretch)  I couldn't think of a rival for Wes or Johanna, so let's pretend the fresh meat were originally on a season together.  Eliminations alternate between guys and girls.  Four teams in the end.

Coral & Julie 

Tonya & Beth

Melinda & Rachel

Katie & Veronica

Tina & MaryBeth

Aviv & Chanda

Danny & Nehemiah

Theo & Alton

Darrell & Abe

Shane & Steven

Derrick & Adam

Kenny &  Ryan

 

Instead of Fresh Meat 1, it was Rivals.   The original cast members with their rivals.  (some may be a stretch)  I couldn't think of a rival for Wes or Johanna, so let's pretend the fresh meat were originally on a season together.  Eliminations alternate between guys and girls.  Four teams in the end.

Coral & Julie 

Tonya & Beth

Melinda & Rachel

Katie & Veronica

Tina & MaryBeth

Aviv & Chanda

Danny & Nehemiah

Theo & Alton

Darrell & Abe

Shane & Steven

Derrick & Adam

Kenny &  Ryan

 

How come Aviv and Chanda got chosen over every other Fresh Meat castmember? Lol

Theo and Alton is a ridiculously unfair team. The only team close to them would be Adam and Derrick and both of them are at a disadvantage due to size.

The female teams are pathetic. Tonya and Beth would win, the only other decent team would be Coral and Julie. 

darrell and abram would be able to compete with theo and alton.  out of the girls i think aviv and chanda could win. chanda's only fault was the puzzle, something aviv can do.  

What if Evelyn & Luke beat Landon & Carley, considering it came down to time.

That leaves Evelyn & Luke, Jillian & Pete, Kenny & Laurel, Ryan & Theresa, and Jenn & Noor in the obstacle challenge. I'm pretty sure Ryan & Theresa and Jenn & Noor would get last place, with Ryan & Theresa getting eliminated.

FINAL:
1st: Kenny & Laurel
2nd: Evelyn & Luke
3rd: Jillian & Pete
4th: Jenn & Noor

What if the Rivals II were Duel III? (Naomi still quits, but no one replace her.) Final:

Male:

Frank, CT, Marlon or Leroy

Female:

Emily, Cooke,  Aneesa or Theresa (maybe even Nany)

Emily will be like Jodi/Rachel- win most of the missions, and no one call her for the duel,  won the whole thing.  Cooke- just like Britt- won once maybe two, duel maybe two times, and get second in final. For guys I'm not so sure with the winner.

I feel like Cooke would be always last pick. Duel was lot of politics too. I can see Diem doing really well also. Probably always partnered with CT and everybody loves her.

Also, I can see Camilla in finale before Aneesa/Theresa/Nany.

I think finale would be epic. CT vs Frank(experience vs endurance) and Emily vs Cooke. I actually think Cooke could win over Emily. Yeah, Emily is stronger but not that smart and finale usually do not require strenght that much.

What if the Rivals II were Duel III? (Naomi still quits, but no one replace her.) Final:

Male:

Frank, CT, Marlon or Leroy

Female:

Emily, Cooke,  Aneesa or Theresa (maybe even Nany)

Emily will be like Jodi/Rachel- win most of the missions, and no one call her for the duel,  won the whole thing.  Cooke- just like Britt- won once maybe two, duel maybe two times, and get second in final. For guys I'm not so sure with the winner.

I would put Wes in over Marlon. If the final was still the same I would say honestly Frank would maybe have a good shot of winning because Bananas was holding him back. 

What if during FA Cara never broke her hand? 

or What if Theresa beat Nany in the puzzle challenge and made the final instead... 

I honestly think Theresa would have beat Laurel because her endurance is better then Nany's so she would not have stopped on the bike to throw a fit and I also think she would have kept running down the mountain. 

What if during FA Cara never broke her hand? 

Laurel still won that elimination.

What if during FA Cara never broke her hand? 

Laurel still won that elimination.

I agree but I think it would've been a great battle. Cara Maria was at a huge disadvantage going in that elimination. 

What if during FA Cara never broke her hand? 

Laurel still won that elimination.

I agree but I think it would've been a great battle. Cara Maria was at a huge disadvantage going in that elimination. 

I fell it'll be like Frank/Dustin elimination.

What if during FA Cara never broke her hand? 

Laurel still won that elimination.

Cara Maria and CT would've won the challenge. Nany would've went in against Laurel. Nany would've been out. Then I guess Theresa vs. Laurel again. And I think that 1st place would've been a toss up with Cara and Laurel.

What if during FA Cara never broke her hand? 

Laurel still won that elimination.

Cara Maria and CT would've won the challenge. Nany would've went in against Laurel. Nany would've been out. Then I guess Theresa vs. Laurel again. And I think that 1st place would've been a toss up with Cara and Laurel.

I honestly don't think anyone would have beaten Laurel in the final whether it was Theresa, Cara or Nany. 

What if during FA Cara never broke her hand? 

Laurel still won that elimination.

Cara Maria and CT would've won the challenge. Nany would've went in against Laurel. Nany would've been out. Then I guess Theresa vs. Laurel again. And I think that 1st place would've been a toss up with Cara and Laurel.

I honestly don't think anyone would have beaten Laurel in the final whether it was Theresa, Cara or Nany. 

I think Cara had the biggest shot though. She was crazy fit that season. It would've been interesting to see an even closer race considering Nany was 9 min away

What if during FA Cara never broke her hand? 

Laurel still won that elimination.

Cara Maria and CT would've won the challenge. Nany would've went in against Laurel. Nany would've been out. Then I guess Theresa vs. Laurel again. And I think that 1st place would've been a toss up with Cara and Laurel.

I honestly don't think anyone would have beaten Laurel in the final whether it was Theresa, Cara or Nany. 

I think Cara had the biggest shot though. She was crazy fit that season. It would've been interesting to see an even closer race considering Nany was 9 min away

The thing is Nany getting off her bike to throw the fit was maybe 2 min (Just made up a time maybe it was less) so that would be 7 min and Bananas said in a podcast or something that when they were on the mountain after they passed Zach & Laurel Nany basically gave up because she thought she would win so she just walked like the whole thing. Even down the mountain she refused to run. 

What if during FA Cara never broke her hand? 

Laurel still won that elimination.

Cara Maria and CT would've won the challenge. Nany would've went in against Laurel. Nany would've been out. Then I guess Theresa vs. Laurel again. And I think that 1st place would've been a toss up with Cara and Laurel.

I honestly don't think anyone would have beaten Laurel in the final whether it was Theresa, Cara or Nany. 

I think Cara had the biggest shot though. She was crazy fit that season. It would've been interesting to see an even closer race considering Nany was 9 min away

The thing is Nany getting off her bike to throw the fit was maybe 2 min (Just made up a time maybe it was less) so that would be 7 min and Bananas said in a podcast or something that when they were on the mountain after they passed Zach & Laurel Nany basically gave up because she thought she would win so she just walked like the whole thing. Even down the mountain she refused to run. 

Zach slowed laurel down she would have finished quicker.

What if Zach beasted the final on FA. He would have had the best partners:
Devyn in Kayak (the easiest)
Nany for the run
Laurel for the climb

What if the Rivals II were Duel III? (Naomi still quits, but no one replace her.) Final:

Male:

Frank, CT, Marlon or Leroy

Female:

Emily, Cooke,  Aneesa or Theresa (maybe even Nany)

Emily will be like Jodi/Rachel- win most of the missions, and no one call her for the duel,  won the whole thing.  Cooke- just like Britt- won once maybe two, duel maybe two times, and get second in final. For guys I'm not so sure with the winner.

I would put Wes in over Marlon. If the final was still the same I would say honestly Frank would maybe have a good shot of winning because Bananas was holding him back. 

wow that's actually hard to determine especially since we don't know what type of eliminations. i predict Frank, Johnny Bananas, and CT.

What if Rivals2 teams were Bananas&CT and Frank&Wes(bots2 little fight)

Pages