The Challenge: Unpopular Opinions

10051 posts / 0 new
Last post

Honestly: the Rookies girls rankings in my opinion went like this.....

Tori

Jillian

Janelle

Johanna

Melinda

Rachel

Angel

Brooke

Honestly: the Rookies girls rankings in my opinion went like this.....

Tori

Jillian

Janelle

Johanna

Melinda

Rachel

Angel

Brooke

Put Tori 3rd and switch around Rachel and Angel and that's my ranking 

anon3895345345345
Anonymous's picture

Honestly: the Rookies girls rankings in my opinion went like this.....

Tori

Jillian

Janelle

Johanna

Melinda

Rachel

Angel

Brooke

I still think it's pathetic how Rachel basically skated by without seeing a single elimination round on The Gauntlet 3. She was TERRIBLE. Her elimination on The Inferno 3 was hilarious. "I can't believe a chubby civilian just beat me." **** lol 

Honestly: the Rookies girls rankings in my opinion went like this.....

Tori

Jillian

Janelle

Johanna

Melinda

Rachel

Angel

Brooke

I still think it's pathetic how Rachel basically skated by without seeing a single elimination round on The Gauntlet 3. She was TERRIBLE. Her elimination on The Inferno 3 was hilarious. "I can't believe a chubby civilian just beat me." **** lol 

That is one of my top 10 fav moments of all time.

I think Angel was stronger than people thought, she didn't get to show much but she impressed me against Jillian. I'm a person who believes Jillian is overrated though.

Janelle disappointed me on the Gauntlet 3. She should've easily been the best girl there and she barely tried in her Gauntlet. I'll give Jillian credit that she is quicker than Janelle but still, I was a little disappointed.

I think Angel was stronger than people thought, she didn't get to show much but she impressed me against Jillian. I'm a person who believes Jillian is overrated though.

Janelle disappointed me on the Gauntlet 3. She should've easily been the best girl there and she barely tried in her Gauntlet. I'll give Jillian credit that she is quicker than Janelle but still, I was a little disappointed.

Angel impressed me too. I wouldn't mind seeing her back.

anon3895345345345
Anonymous's picture

I think Angel was stronger than people thought, she didn't get to show much but she impressed me against Jillian. I'm a person who believes Jillian is overrated though.

Janelle disappointed me on the Gauntlet 3. She should've easily been the best girl there and she barely tried in her Gauntlet. I'll give Jillian credit that she is quicker than Janelle but still, I was a little disappointed.

Angel impressed me too. I wouldn't mind seeing her back.

I will always remember her calling Kina a transvestite ****

Angel was amazing on road rules. Hated Kina.

janelle wasnt aggressive enough and she also had a shitty plan. she shoudlve threw her on the floor but she was overly obsessed with going after the ball. beth was the ONLY one who knew how to play that game. she laid coral out and THEN went after the ball. even kina was able to man handle jillian...janelle said "im flat out stronger" but she didnt even use that strength

i guess it doesnt help when you have TJ pressuring you to contstantly "go after the ball" in the background

In what world is Melinda NOT wallpaper? Nice to look at though.

The only moment I can think of with her is when she hilariously & delusionally considered herself one of the top two girls on the G3 Rookie team **** she did the best thing she could ever do by dropping Danny though.

Well in her defense she was probably third because the rookie girls were awful.
What about Janelle? Melinda was fourth.

Janelle was so underrated on challenges. She's one of the few female rookies to win on their debut season. There was a reason why the Vets picked her to go into the Gauntlet on Gauntlet 3. She was more of a threat than Tori, Johanna, Rachel, and Brooke (who IMO was the weakest girl of the bunch). Those girls picked Jillian because they knew she and Janelle were the top 2 strongest girls that season and they were threatened. I still hate that the Rookie (Females only) won. Frank deserved it though.

fixed it for you.

Didn't Jillian go just as much as Frank did? What makes him more deserving? Just asking because I haven't rewatched G3 and I might be wrong here but I thought Jillian more than deserved the prize money.

On the reunion, they were talking about how Jill, Nehemiah and Johanna were SLEEPING on the beach, while Frank was digging in the sand the entire time. That, to me, showed why Frank deserved it more than anyone on his team

I think Angel was stronger than people thought, she didn't get to show much but she impressed me against Jillian. I'm a person who believes Jillian is overrated though.

Janelle disappointed me on the Gauntlet 3. She should've easily been the best girl there and she barely tried in her Gauntlet. I'll give Jillian credit that she is quicker than Janelle but still, I was a little disappointed.

Angel impressed me too. I wouldn't mind seeing her back.

I will always remember her calling Kina a transvestite ****

"Because you're a strong girl, Kina! You're friggen strong!"

Yeah.. Good save, Angel.

Angel really could've been a bright spot in that garbage era (along with Ivory but that's besides the point). I wonder if she decided to stop doing them herself or did they never ask her again...

Angel really could've been a bright spot in that garbage era (along with Ivory but that's besides the point). I wonder if she decided to stop doing them herself or did they never ask her again...

I think she stopped. I remember reading that she herself stated that she was done for some reason.

Ivory would've been a great addition to the challenges. I wish they would've brought her on.

Rachel and Johanna were the only ones who didnt deserve it IMO.

Rachel and Johanna were the only ones who didnt deserve it IMO.

Jill, Nehemiah, Frank & Tori (to a lesser degree) did earn it--I agree.

Johanna kind of ran it politically so I'm not even that upset with her winning

Rachel on the other hand was useless

Rachel and Johanna were the only ones who didnt deserve it IMO.

Jill, Nehemiah, Frank & Tori (to a lesser degree) did earn it--I agree.

Johanna kind of ran it politically so I'm not even that upset with her winning

Rachel on the other hand was useless

That's pretty much how I feel.

In what world is Melinda NOT wallpaper? Nice to look at though.

The only moment I can think of with her is when she hilariously & delusionally considered herself one of the top two girls on the G3 Rookie team **** she did the best thing she could ever do by dropping Danny though.

Well in her defense she was probably third because the rookie girls were awful.
What about Janelle? Melinda was fourth.

Janelle was so underrated on challenges. She's one of the few female rookies to win on their debut season. There was a reason why the Vets picked her to go into the Gauntlet on Gauntlet 3. She was more of a threat than Tori, Johanna, Rachel, and Brooke (who IMO was the weakest girl of the bunch). Those girls picked Jillian because they knew she and Janelle were the top 2 strongest girls that season and they were threatened. I still hate that the Rookie (Females only) won. Frank deserved it though.

fixed it for you.

Rachel sucked. She's probably the worst female champion IMO ever. 

In what world is Melinda NOT wallpaper? Nice to look at though.

The only moment I can think of with her is when she hilariously & delusionally considered herself one of the top two girls on the G3 Rookie team **** she did the best thing she could ever do by dropping Danny though.

Well in her defense she was probably third because the rookie girls were awful.
What about Janelle? Melinda was fourth.

Janelle was so underrated on challenges. She's one of the few female rookies to win on their debut season. There was a reason why the Vets picked her to go into the Gauntlet on Gauntlet 3. She was more of a threat than Tori, Johanna, Rachel, and Brooke (who IMO was the weakest girl of the bunch). Those girls picked Jillian because they knew she and Janelle were the top 2 strongest girls that season and they were threatened. I still hate that the Rookie (Females only) won. Frank deserved it though.

fixed it for you.

Rachel sucked. She's probably the worst female champion IMO ever. 

oh you were talking specifially about champions lol.

I hate Angel so much, though her feud with Kina was hilarious. 

anon3895345345345
Anonymous's picture

I kind of want to see Anastasia come back lol didn't she say in her last Rivals II interview that she was going to train harder and come back bulkier?

I Understand Why Anastasia is hesitant because all of the CT & Diem fans tortured her after Rivals 2, but I feel if she came back she could leave a different impression.

anon3895345345345
Anonymous's picture

I Understand Why Anastasia is hesitant because all of the CT & Diem fans tortured her after Rivals 2, but I feel if she came back she could leave a different impression.

Reality TV fans are psycho. Anastasia was likable on RW: Portland and was seen as the voice of reason at times. It sucks how she got a bad edit on her first challenge. 

Edit: SOME reality tv fans take these shows way too seriously. What is the point of bashing someone on all of their social media accounts? Some people comment on Nany's page that she's a ****. If people don't like her, they should get off her page **** 

I Understand Why Anastasia is hesitant because all of the CT & Diem fans tortured her after Rivals 2, but I feel if she came back she could leave a different impression.

Reality TV fans are psycho. Anastasia was likable on RW: Portland and was seen as the voice of reason at times. It sucks how she got a bad edit on her first challenge. 

Edit: SOME reality tv fans take these shows way too seriously. What is the point of bashing someone on all of their social media accounts? Some people comment on Nany's page that she's a ****. If people don't like her, they should get off her page **** 

This isn't a negative about Diem but SOME of her fan base was the worst.  We saw that with Davis recently and countless other situations.  Ana was a "victim" of that as well.  Coming between CT/Diem was not tolerated by many fans even though they weren't together.

I don't want to see Ana again because she has zero athleticism but that's it

I don't think she will be back after her elimination round and the fact tj stated that's what happens when you don't eat and smoke all the time 

Anastasia sucks, She's the weakest person from Portland And I wouldn't be surprised if jasmine beat her in something physical

I want to see Joi's fine *** on my screen once again. 

I don't mind Anastasia so I if she return I'd be find with it.

Does Ana still keep in contact with any of the Portand cast? It's funny how all the Portand girls seem to get along great now but she's left out of the loop. She was the median between Nia & Averey & made it a point to exclude Jessica.

Pages