Most Satisfying/Dissapointing Challenge Winners

287 posts / 0 new
Last post

Yeah but it was against brooke and angel.. Her only good win was against janelle

and tori beat Melinda. is Melinda better than Janelle?

None of the Austin cast, besides Wes, is that better than anyone else. Don't get me wrong, Danny and Melinda are gorgeous and try their ***** off, but they come up short and aren't all that good. Johanna can be beaten, Rachel and Lacey can be beaten,  although it might be hard to eliminate Nehemiah. He's a beast.

On the case between Tori and Jillian, Jillian is better. I don't see how that's a discussion that needs to be had.

I think Tori is a better competitor than Jillian, but I would still pick Jillian to be on my team hands down because I can't stand the *****. 

Yeah but it was against brooke and angel.. Her only good win was against janelle

and tori beat Melinda. is Melinda better than Janelle?

None of the Austin cast, besides Wes, is that better than anyone else. Don't get me wrong, Danny and Melinda are gorgeous and try their ***** off, but they come up short and aren't all that good. Johanna can be beaten, Rachel and Lacey can be beaten,  although it might be hard to eliminate Nehemiah. He's a beast.

On the case between Tori and Jillian, Jillian is better. I don't see how that's a discussion that needs to be had.

lol Nehemiah and the word beast don't belong in the same sentence, but everything else I agree with you. 

Maybe it's the way he's built.. I dunno.

Maybe it's the way he's built.. I dunno.

He is a good competitor and it's pretty big, but I consider "beasts" people like Landon and CT, and to an extent Bananas, Darrell, etc. 

Never got why people liked to act like Nehemiah is some scrub

Yeah but it was against brooke and angel.. Her only good win was against janelle

and tori beat Melinda. is Melinda better than Janelle?

None of the Austin cast, besides Wes, is that better than anyone else. Don't get me wrong, Danny and Melinda are gorgeous and try their ***** off, but they come up short and aren't all that good. Johanna can be beaten, Rachel and Lacey can be beaten,  although it might be hard to eliminate Nehemiah. He's a beast.

On the case between Tori and Jillian, Jillian is better. I don't see how that's a discussion that needs to be had.


Well you're the one who continued it lol.

Another satisfying win was when Laurel won free agents. Goodness knows she deserves it.

Yeah but it was against brooke and angel.. Her only good win was against janelle

and tori beat Melinda. is Melinda better than Janelle?

None of the Austin cast, besides Wes, is that better than anyone else. Don't get me wrong, Danny and Melinda are gorgeous and try their ***** off, but they come up short and aren't all that good. Johanna can be beaten, Rachel and Lacey can be beaten,  although it might be hard to eliminate Nehemiah. He's a beast.

On the case between Tori and Jillian, Jillian is better. I don't see how that's a discussion that needs to be had.

Well you're the one who continued it lol.

More like ended it, try again.

Another satisfying win was when Laurel won free agents. Goodness knows she deserves it.

No she didn't.

Laurel was the only girl besides cara who deserved to win. Nany didn't do anything that season then had a meltdown in the final. And Devyn everyone knew would be last in a final

Most satisfying for me will always be: 

1. Sarah in the Gauntlet

2. Katie in the Inferno

3. Landon and Carley in Fresh Meat 2

4. Paula and Evelyn in Rivals (not a HUGE fan of Paula, but to see them do it together made me very happy, especially with how they fought hardcore on the Island reunion).

 

I try not to dwell on the negative (with disappointing wins), so just naming off positive ones.

Laurel was the only girl besides cara who deserved to win. Nany didn't do anything that season then had a meltdown in the final. And Devyn everyone knew would be last in a final

Just because you don't win an elimination round doesn't mean you don't deserve it. Nany was on the winning team most of the time, was one of the only girls to hold the bar besides Laurel in that one challenge (Don't know the name of it), and competed/won a challenge with a concussion... 

It annoys me when people think people don't deserve it just because they didn't see an elimination. If they competed well and won most of the challenges then no shit they won't see an elimination. Nany deserved that final.

I also don't see how Cara deserved anything on Free Agents, even when pulling my dislike of her out of the equation. Yeah luck wasn't on her side but she really on beat one decent competitor in Nia. Latoya, who I like a lot, is a below average athlete and Jessica's performance on that season is HEAVILY inflated by virtue of being on good teams the majority of the time. Cara also wasn't particularly great on any of the day challenges aside from the sausage party one and the rope one. She wasn't bad but it's not like she was getting robbed by having to go into the draw. 

Another satisfying win was when Laurel won free agents. Goodness knows she deserves it.

No she didn't.


DA let me keep my own opinion.

Laurel was the only girl besides cara who deserved to win. Nany didn't do anything that season then had a meltdown in the final. And Devyn everyone knew would be last in a final

Just because you don't win an elimination round doesn't mean you don't deserve it. Nany was on the winning team most of the time, was one of the only girls to hold the bar besides Laurel in that one challenge (Don't know the name of it), and competed/won a challenge with a concussion... 

It annoys me when people think people don't deserve it just because they didn't see an elimination. If they competed well and won most of the challenges then no shit they won't see an elimination. Nany deserved that final.

I agree. Nany definetly deserved it.

Yeah but it was against brooke and angel.. Her only good win was against janelle

and tori beat Melinda. is Melinda better than Janelle?

None of the Austin cast, besides Wes, is that better than anyone else. Don't get me wrong, Danny and Melinda are gorgeous and try their ***** off, but they come up short and aren't all that good. Johanna can be beaten, Rachel and Lacey can be beaten,  although it might be hard to eliminate Nehemiah. He's a beast.

On the case between Tori and Jillian, Jillian is better. I don't see how that's a discussion that needs to be had.

Well you're the one who continued it lol.

More like ended it, try again.


Well you still continued it whenu could have left it alone.

Another win i loved is the Ruins. Team JEK showed why they are a force to be reckoned with. It woukd have been even more satisfying if Darrell had won with them.

Disappointing:

1. Battle of the Exes/The Ruins/The Island/Free Agents - Johnny's wins: It was just terrible to watch Bananas and Camila win. While I like Camila a whole lot, Bananas is practically handed wins half the time with great partners or on a team with his friends. On the Island, I was upset when Abram decided he had to go home, which would have been Johnny if Abram stayed. It was practically handed to him, but not intentional on Abram's part. The Ruins was terrible because Evan, Bananas and Kenny were there, and their sheep, Derrick, too. We all know saw it coming anyway. Honestly, Johnny R. would have been a whole lot better when it comes to Free Agents. Rivals might have been the only season he deserved, though I welcome anyone to disagree with me.

2. Battle of the Seasons: I have mixed feelings about this format. I think they picked shitty people for some of the teams. To be exact, New Orleans was terrible; I would have preferred Ryan L. over Preston or Knight anyday, and would have preferred Sahar over Jemmye. I could probably go on about it, but the final outcome of it was ******. San Diego had more heart in three out of four of their members, but it was just terrible to see Frank win in general. I'm not a huge Zach fan, but I don't mind him. I would have preferred any other team in that finale to win, so watching that team of bullies make it to the end and win was gut wrenching.

Cutthroat: Format was amazing, but I absolutely despise Brad, Tori, and Dunbar. The three of them did nothing, Tori especially as she cries for the second/third time about whether she should go home or try in an elimination. All in all, that entire team did not deserve their win after what they did to Camila and Brandon.

Satisfying:

Outcome of Rivals II - I was ever so thankful that Wes and CT beat out Frank and Johnny. Frank is the most annoying person ever with his self important attitude. It would have been terrible to watch him win, only to have his ego grow past this world and the next over. Johnny even said he didn't try though, so it's whatever with him there.

 

 

 

 

 


I LOVED WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT BRAD, TORI, AND DUNBAR. Smile

Laurel was the only girl besides cara who deserved to win. Nany didn't do anything that season then had a meltdown in the final. And Devyn everyone knew would be last in a final

Just because you don't win an elimination round doesn't mean you don't deserve it. Nany was on the winning team most of the time, was one of the only girls to hold the bar besides Laurel in that one challenge (Don't know the name of it), and competed/won a challenge with a concussion... 

It annoys me when people think people don't deserve it just because they didn't see an elimination. If they competed well and won most of the challenges then no shit they won't see an elimination. Nany deserved that final.


It's not because she didn't win a elimination ,she only won tbone because Jessica kept screwing up and Laurel had to go at Devyns speed. Nany didn't deserve to win because she had a meltdown and wanted to quit, plus it was only close in the final because Zach slowed Laurel down a lot

Laurel was the only girl besides cara who deserved to win. Nany didn't do anything that season then had a meltdown in the final. And Devyn everyone knew would be last in a final

Just because you don't win an elimination round doesn't mean you don't deserve it. Nany was on the winning team most of the time, was one of the only girls to hold the bar besides Laurel in that one challenge (Don't know the name of it), and competed/won a challenge with a concussion... 

It annoys me when people think people don't deserve it just because they didn't see an elimination. If they competed well and won most of the challenges then no shit they won't see an elimination. Nany deserved that final.

It's not because she didn't win a elimination ,she only won tbone because Jessica kept screwing up and Laurel had to go at Devyns speed. Nany didn't deserve to win because she had a meltdown and wanted to quit, plus it was only close in the final because Zach slowed Laurel down a lot

She had a small meltdown. I've seen several people over the years do it. It was her first final and she didn't quit so it really wasn't that big of a deal.

JamieFire
Anonymous's picture

Laurel was the only girl besides cara who deserved to win. Nany didn't do anything that season then had a meltdown in the final. And Devyn everyone knew would be last in a final

Just because you don't win an elimination round doesn't mean you don't deserve it. Nany was on the winning team most of the time, was one of the only girls to hold the bar besides Laurel in that one challenge (Don't know the name of it), and competed/won a challenge with a concussion... 

It annoys me when people think people don't deserve it just because they didn't see an elimination. If they competed well and won most of the challenges then no shit they won't see an elimination. Nany deserved that final.

It's not because she didn't win a elimination ,she only won tbone because Jessica kept screwing up and Laurel had to go at Devyns speed. Nany didn't deserve to win because she had a meltdown and wanted to quit, plus it was only close in the final because Zach slowed Laurel down a lot

She had a small meltdown. I've seen several people over the years do it. It was her first final and she didn't quit so it really wasn't that big of a deal.

^^^^^^^^ THANK YOU!!!
fk the Nany haters!! That's my baby! #TeamDominican. Biggrin

Nany is so overrated... ughh. It actually makes me dislike her.

JamieFire
Anonymous's picture

Nany is so overrated... ughh. It actually makes me dislike her.

**** I really don't think she's that good of a competitor at all! :X I have just always liked her since LV2. #softspot

Most The Challenge winners in general have villain qualities. That's the one thing about this show that stand apart from other competition shows, they don't try to potray the winner as a nice lovable character to the audience and most of the time when I watch i'm annoyed with the outcome.

She also won the puzzle challenge with Johnny. I understand that Zach slowed Laurel down and I wasn't too impressed with Nany until the second day where she stayed with Laurel the whole time going up the mountain. I really didn't think she could keep up with Laurel at all. And I don't understand why everyone always brings up her meltdown and wanting to quit. It was her first final and she had a 30 second meltdown and got right back on the bike. 

She also won the puzzle challenge with Johnny. I understand that Zach slowed Laurel down and I wasn't too impressed with Nany until the second day where she stayed with Laurel the whole time going up the mountain. I really didn't think she could keep up with Laurel at all. And I don't understand why everyone always brings up her meltdown and wanting to quit. It was her first final and she had a 30 second meltdown and got right back on the bike. 


It was for about half a hour, she left the bike for that long.

She also won the puzzle challenge with Johnny. I understand that Zach slowed Laurel down and I wasn't too impressed with Nany until the second day where she stayed with Laurel the whole time going up the mountain. I really didn't think she could keep up with Laurel at all. And I don't understand why everyone always brings up her meltdown and wanting to quit. It was her first final and she had a 30 second meltdown and got right back on the bike. 

Exactly, Zach had a meltdown the entire final... Her meltdown wasn't a big deal.. She was exhausted but I don't think she ever was going to actually quit.

No way it was for that long if so she would have been much farther behind Laurel.

JamieFire
Anonymous's picture

Lol I think the fact that Nany was even able to keep up with Laurel during the mountain climb speaks a lot about her as a competitor. She really impressed me!

Pages