The Challenge: What Could Have Been (SPOILERS)

403 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

Maybe they are spliting up the trilogy and finishing it up later?

Or maybe they realized only a handful of UK cast members have delivered and have moved on to US newbies.. 

either way I'm happy to see more Real World and Road Rules and not less likely the last two seasons. 

Svetlana leaving at the airport is a damn travesty 

Imagine if we had gotten Melissa AND Coral on Inferno 2...

Imagine if we had gotten Melissa AND Coral on Inferno 2...

would have been epic, though I wonder how long Melissa would have lasted. The girls were iconic that season, it would have been epic if they'd just added those two to the cast and too other dudes to even it out. I always wondered if Beth would have made the final had she not quit.

Will this be updated for Total Madness?

I didn't really keep up with the casting too much for Total Madness.

This is what I have, so please let me know if there's any changes or additions:

Contacted by production: Amber AYTO8, Angela BGC, Davonne BB, Esther WOTW2, Georgia WOTW1, Jenna AYTO8, Morgan WOTW1, Nicole WOTW2, Ninja WOTW1, Zahida WOTW1

Declined/dropped: Bria AYTO7 declined, Cara Maria initially accepted but dropped out when Paulie was dropped even though she was offered a bigger paycheck (replaced by Jenna), Kayleigh declined to focus on her business

Contacted by production: Brett Robinson BB, Hunter AYTO, Sam Bird Love Island, Rykard Jenkins Love Island, Theo WOTW1, Zach RW

Declined/dropped: Billy Reilich and Paulie were dropped, Sean Lineker accepted but was not used

 

What about for WOTW2?

I didn't really keep up with the casting too much for Total Madness.

This is what I have, so please let me know if there's any changes or additions:

Contacted by production: Amber AYTO8, Angela BGC, Davonne BB, Esther WOTW2, Georgia WOTW1, Jenna AYTO8, Morgan WOTW1, Nicole WOTW2, Ninja WOTW1, Zahida WOTW1

Declined/dropped: Bria AYTO7 declined, Cara Maria initially accepted but dropped out when Paulie was dropped even though she was offered a bigger paycheck (replaced by Jenna), Kayleigh declined to focus on her business

Contacted by production: Brett Robinson BB, Hunter AYTO, Sam Bird Love Island, Rykard Jenkins Love Island, Theo WOTW1, Zach RW

Declined/dropped: Billy Reilich and Paulie were dropped, Sean Lineker accepted but was not used

 

Pink said that JP, Morgan, and Natalie Negrotti got dropped from the cast. Also I heard that Billy got dropped for Jay and Tony got a call but declined.

What about for WOTW2?

Same situation, didn't really keep an eye on the casting too much. This is what I have for that season.

War of the Worlds II – The original theme of this Challenge was going to be old vs. new; Tori Hall, Brad Fiorenza, and Kendal Sheppard accepted but were dropped when the theme changed, while Alton Williams was initially contacted as well. Among veterans, Shaleen Sutherland was contacted, while for the British rookies, many Love Island people were contacted, such as Georgia Steel.

 

What about for WOTW2?

Same situation, didn't really keep an eye on the casting too much. This is what I have for that season.

War of the Worlds II – The original theme of this Challenge was going to be old vs. new; Tori Hall, Brad Fiorenza, and Kendal Sheppard accepted but were dropped when the theme changed, while Alton Williams was initially contacted as well. Among veterans, Shaleen Sutherland was contacted, while for the British rookies, many Love Island people were contacted, such as Georgia Steel.

Thank you!!

The fact that we could of had Christina & Julie from BGC9 on Vendettas Sad

 

What about for WOTW2?

Same situation, didn't really keep an eye on the casting too much. This is what I have for that season.

War of the Worlds II – The original theme of this Challenge was going to be old vs. new; Tori Hall, Brad Fiorenza, and Kendal Sheppard accepted but were dropped when the theme changed, while Alton Williams was initially contacted as well. Among veterans, Shaleen Sutherland was contacted, while for the British rookies, many Love Island people were contacted, such as Georgia Steel.

They DROPPED Tori, Brad and Kendal? Straight clownery.

 

 

What about for WOTW2?

Same situation, didn't really keep an eye on the casting too much. This is what I have for that season.

War of the Worlds II – The original theme of this Challenge was going to be old vs. new; Tori Hall, Brad Fiorenza, and Kendal Sheppard accepted but were dropped when the theme changed, while Alton Williams was initially contacted as well. Among veterans, Shaleen Sutherland was contacted, while for the British rookies, many Love Island people were contacted, such as Georgia Steel.

They DROPPED Tori, Brad and Kendal? Straight clownery.

I mean, who would you swap out of the US Team for these? would gladly have left Faith at home to get Tori, but it makes no sense to cast her without Brad. and could they even film a season together considering their kids at home? I guess Romber did it

 

 

 

What about for WOTW2?

Same situation, didn't really keep an eye on the casting too much. This is what I have for that season.

War of the Worlds II – The original theme of this Challenge was going to be old vs. new; Tori Hall, Brad Fiorenza, and Kendal Sheppard accepted but were dropped when the theme changed, while Alton Williams was initially contacted as well. Among veterans, Shaleen Sutherland was contacted, while for the British rookies, many Love Island people were contacted, such as Georgia Steel.

They DROPPED Tori, Brad and Kendal? Straight clownery.

I mean, who would you swap out of the US Team for these? would gladly have left Faith at home to get Tori, but it makes no sense to cast her without Brad. and could they even film a season together considering their kids at home? I guess Romber did it

You do know that they've been divorced for many years and that Tori's the one keeping the kids, right?

I know they're divorced, yes. but I don't see Brad and Tori both agreeing to film a season when they'd need to find someone to mind their kids for up to 7 weeks AND if they'd need to be in the same damn house again.

I know they're divorced, yes. but I don't see Brad and Tori both agreeing to film a season when they'd need to find someone to mind their kids for up to 7 weeks AND if they'd need to be in the same damn house again.

I get what you're saying now. But based on their recent interactions with each other, one of them would've probably dropped if they knew they were both going to be on.

Ugh, I need Kendal and Shalegend Sutherland to show up.

I'll update the first post in the thread with some of what Youssarian said, likewise that I haven't paid as much attention the past few seasons and definitely havent been on here nearly as much as I used to (been so busy finishing up school and with work)

Devin and Kailah were alternates for war of the world 2.

Diandra was alternate for 2 seasons in a row but I cant remember which ones. I think one was Final Reckoning.

Devin and Kailah were alternates for war of the world 2.

Diandra was alternate for 2 seasons in a row but I cant remember which ones. I think one was Final Reckoning.

Thanks Pink! I would guess the other is War of the Worlds because I know she at least accepted that one. I actually liked Didi a lot (but never watched her Ex on the Beach season); I wish she made it on.

 

Devin and Kailah were alternates for war of the world 2.

Diandra was alternate for 2 seasons in a row but I cant remember which ones. I think one was Final Reckoning.

Thanks Pink! I would guess the other is War of the Worlds because I know she at least accepted that one. I actually liked Didi a lot (but never watched her Ex on the Beach season); I wish she made it on.

thanks to both of you! Just updated the first post

 

What about for WOTW2?

Same situation, didn't really keep an eye on the casting too much. This is what I have for that season.

War of the Worlds II – The original theme of this Challenge was going to be old vs. new; Tori Hall, Brad Fiorenza, and Kendal Sheppard accepted but were dropped when the theme changed, while Alton Williams was initially contacted as well. Among veterans, Shaleen Sutherland was contacted, while for the British rookies, many Love Island people were contacted, such as Georgia Steel.

this kills my soul every time I hear it....wish they would have replaced others to bring them in. Brad has history with a lot of them, Tori as his ex would have interesting there and Kendal is a good friends with her. Tori has done seasons with Laurel, Wes, Johnny, Cara Maria, etc - would have been a great time to bring them back 

 

 

What about for WOTW2?

Same situation, didn't really keep an eye on the casting too much. This is what I have for that season.

War of the Worlds II – The original theme of this Challenge was going to be old vs. new; Tori Hall, Brad Fiorenza, and Kendal Sheppard accepted but were dropped when the theme changed, while Alton Williams was initially contacted as well. Among veterans, Shaleen Sutherland was contacted, while for the British rookies, many Love Island people were contacted, such as Georgia Steel.

this kills my soul every time I hear it....wish they would have replaced others to bring them in. Brad has history with a lot of them, Tori as his ex would have interesting there and Kendall is a good friends with her. Tori has done seasons with Laurel, Wes, Johnny, Cara Maria, etc - would have been a great time to bring them back 

Tori and Brad would never do a challenge together they have two little children. Sorry to break your heart that wasnt going to happen.

 

 

 

What about for WOTW2?

Same situation, didn't really keep an eye on the casting too much. This is what I have for that season.

War of the Worlds II – The original theme of this Challenge was going to be old vs. new; Tori Hall, Brad Fiorenza, and Kendal Sheppard accepted but were dropped when the theme changed, while Alton Williams was initially contacted as well. Among veterans, Shaleen Sutherland was contacted, while for the British rookies, many Love Island people were contacted, such as Georgia Steel.

this kills my soul every time I hear it....wish they would have replaced others to bring them in. Brad has history with a lot of them, Tori as his ex would have interesting there and Kendall is a good friends with her. Tori has done seasons with Laurel, Wes, Johnny, Cara Maria, etc - would have been a great time to bring them back 

Tori and Brad would never do a challenge together they have two little children. Sorry to break your heart that wasnt going to happen.

still would have been epic lol. But at least one of them, I think tori could have fit in enough, prob would have either been taken in by Cara Maria for a number right away or flocked to people she played with like Wes and Laurel.  Oh well we shall never know 

 

 

 

What about for WOTW2?

Same situation, didn't really keep an eye on the casting too much. This is what I have for that season.

War of the Worlds II – The original theme of this Challenge was going to be old vs. new; Tori Hall, Brad Fiorenza, and Kendal Sheppard accepted but were dropped when the theme changed, while Alton Williams was initially contacted as well. Among veterans, Shaleen Sutherland was contacted, while for the British rookies, many Love Island people were contacted, such as Georgia Steel.

this kills my soul every time I hear it....wish they would have replaced others to bring them in. Brad has history with a lot of them, Tori as his ex would have interesting there and Kendall is a good friends with her. Tori has done seasons with Laurel, Wes, Johnny, Cara Maria, etc - would have been a great time to bring them back 

Tori and Brad would never do a challenge together they have two little children. Sorry to break your heart that wasnt going to happen.

Thank God. That would've been a nightmare.

Why does production hate Avery so much?

Diandra would've been a better choice than one of the twins or Morgan easily on WOTW1

Gamer has said multiple times Michaela Bradshaw has been contacted ( I think for WOTW1 )

Gamer has said multiple times Michaela Bradshaw has been contacted ( I think for WOTW1 )

any idea if she declined or just wasn't used? II wouldn't be shocked if she declined WOTW so she wouldn't hurt her chances for being on Survivor 40 before it was all winners

Gamer has said multiple times Michaela Bradshaw has been contacted ( I think for WOTW1 )

Legend said on IG that she's pretty happy with her job & doesn't really see the point of leaving "stable" money for the chance to win money again (hinting that she was likely done with Survivor too) BUT this was right before all the Corona madness so it's very possible that things have changed since then.

I could see her being convinced with everything that's happened.

Pages