While we're on the FvF topic, here's my recast of the dreadful Caramoan Favs Tribe:
Erik Reichenbach-was tempted to go with Kenny instead since Erik did nothing, but he was a good casting choice, just didn't end up doing anything
Stephen Fishbach-replacing Brandon
John Cochran
Troyzan Robertson-replacing Phillip
Malcolm Freberg
Natalie Bolton-replacing Corinne, who I liked on the cast but doesn't fit as much as Natalie
Brenda Lowe
Holly Hoffman-replacing Dawn
Chelsea Meissner-replacing Andrea, who I liked on the cast but didn't really fit the theme
Sabrina Thompson-replacing Francesca
Marty, Kenny, Andrea & Corinne as alternates
Assuming Matt Elrod & Taj would both decline
You still kept Cochran? Cancel it! Lol
Second in fan fave voting In SP after Ozzy. He was one of the few people who fit the theme(especially considering Malcolm hadn't even been on tv yet), and his return was inevitable. At least this way he doesn't come in with all his friends
Location: Africa (Like season 3 of the us verison)
24 Castaways 50 days
America Tribe (Red):
Parvati Shallow
Cirie Fields
Abi-Maria Gomes
Natalie Anderson
Amber Mariano
Aubry Bracco
Malcolm Freberg
Jeremy Collins
Ethan Zohn
Yul Kwon
Tyson Apostol
Joe Anglim
Australia Tribe (Blue):
Shonee Fairfax
Brooke Jowett
Janine Allis
Tessa O’Halloran
Michelle Dougan
Kristie Bennett
Nick Iadanza
Locky Gilbert
David Genat
Benji Wilson
Harry Hills
Samuel Hinton
Love it, I really hope this happens eventually. Apparently it was considered for S5 before they decided on all stars. Here's mine:
Aus
David Genat
Luke Toki
Benji Wilson
Harry Hills
Shaun Hamson
Jericho Malabonga
Sarah Tilleke
Janine Allis
Tessa O'Halloran
Kristie Bennett
Brooke Jowett
Shonee Fairfax
America
Spencer Bledsoe
Malcolm Freberg
Joe Anglim
Tony Vlachos
Chris Underwood
Wendell Holland
Natalie Anderson
Michele Fitzgerald
Kelleg Wentworth
Kim Spradlin
Michaela Bradshaw
Kass McQuellen
Im assuming anyone who's a lock for a US returnee season, especially second chance 2 would probably not be on so I left people like Dom, Chrissy, Christian etc off
Natalie Tenerelli (Survivor: Redemption Island 2nd runner-up)
Missy Payne (Survivor: San Juan Del Sur 2nd runner-up)
Noura Salman (Survivor: Island of the idols 2nd runner-up)
Dreamz Herd (Survivor: Fiji runner-up)
Chase Rice (Survivor: Nicaragua runner-up)
Mike Holloway (Survivor: Worlds Apart winner)
Domenick Abbate (Survivor: Ghost Island runner-up)
Gavin Whitson (Survivor: Edge of extinction runner-up)
Alternates: Carolyn Rivera (Worlds Apart runner-up) or Bi Nguyen (David vs Goliath medevac) ///// Ryan Ulrich (HvsHvsH runner-up) or Tommy Sheehan (Island of the idols winner)
Natalie Tenerelli (Survivor: Redemption Island 2nd runner-up)
Missy Payne (Survivor: San Juan Del Sur 2nd runner-up)
Noura Salman (Survivor: Island of the idols 2nd runner-up)
Dreamz Herd (Survivor: Fiji runner-up)
Chase Rice (Survivor: Nicaragua runner-up)
Mike Holloway (Survivor: Worlds Apart winner)
Domenick Abbate (Survivor: Ghost Island runner-up)
Gavin Whitson (Survivor: Edge of extinction runner-up)
Alternates: Carolyn Rivera (Worlds Apart runner-up) or Bi Nguyen (David vs Goliath medevac) ///// Ryan Ulrich (HvsHvsH runner-up) or Tommy Sheehan (Island of the idols winner)
I ran this in brainsteel... and stopped when Earl and Dreamz were the first two boots... .. not here for it.
Location: Africa (Like season 3 of the us verison)
24 Castaways 50 days
America Tribe (Red):
Parvati Shallow
Cirie Fields
Abi-Maria Gomes
Natalie Anderson
Amber Mariano
Aubry Bracco
Malcolm Freberg
Jeremy Collins
Ethan Zohn
Yul Kwon
Tyson Apostol
Joe Anglim
Australia Tribe (Blue):
Shonee Fairfax
Brooke Jowett
Janine Allis
Tessa O’Halloran
Michelle Dougan
Kristie Bennett
Nick Iadanza
Locky Gilbert
David Genat
Benji Wilson
Harry Hills
Samuel Hinton
Love it, I really hope this happens eventually. Apparently it was considered for S5 before they decided on all stars. Here's mine:
Aus
David Genat
Luke Toki
Benji Wilson
Harry Hills
Shaun Hamson
Jericho Malabonga
Sarah Tilleke
Janine Allis
Tessa O'Halloran
Kristie Bennett
Brooke Jowett
Shonee Fairfax
America
Spencer Bledsoe
Malcolm Freberg
Joe Anglim
Tony Vlachos
Chris Underwood
Wendell Holland
Natalie Anderson
Michele Fitzgerald
Kelleg Wentworth
Kim Spradlin
Michaela Bradshaw
Kass McQuellen
Im assuming anyone who's a lock for a US returnee season, especially second chance 2 would probably not be on so I left people like Dom, Chrissy, Christian etc off
Location: Africa (Like season 3 of the us verison)
24 Castaways 50 days
America Tribe (Red):
Parvati Shallow
Cirie Fields
Abi-Maria Gomes
Natalie Anderson
Amber Mariano
Aubry Bracco
Malcolm Freberg
Jeremy Collins
Ethan Zohn
Yul Kwon
Tyson Apostol
Joe Anglim
Australia Tribe (Blue):
Shonee Fairfax
Brooke Jowett
Janine Allis
Tessa O’Halloran
Michelle Dougan
Kristie Bennett
Nick Iadanza
Locky Gilbert
David Genat
Benji Wilson
Harry Hills
Samuel Hinton
Love it, I really hope this happens eventually. Apparently it was considered for S5 before they decided on all stars. Here's mine:
Aus
David Genat
Luke Toki
Benji Wilson
Harry Hills
Shaun Hamson
Jericho Malabonga
Sarah Tilleke
Janine Allis
Tessa O'Halloran
Kristie Bennett
Brooke Jowett
Shonee Fairfax
America
Spencer Bledsoe
Malcolm Freberg
Joe Anglim
Tony Vlachos
Chris Underwood
Wendell Holland
Natalie Anderson
Michele Fitzgerald
Kelleg Wentworth
Kim Spradlin
Michaela Bradshaw
Kass McQuellen
Im assuming anyone who's a lock for a US returnee season, especially second chance 2 would probably not be on so I left people like Dom, Chrissy, Christian etc off
Yours is better lol. And when was it considered?
Not too sure, I read on a spoiler site it was considered before they chose to do all stars. It may have not gone very far though, I imagine it's much cheaper to have all Australians and no legal issues to worry about either
They really need to bring back Earl! I just recently did a Fiji rewatch and his gameplay was phenomenal.
Id like Earl to comeback but sadly I think his last shot was WAW.
Agreed, I don't think any winners will return between 40 and 50(any returnee season will be SC2, Unfinished business, non winner captains or FvF3 IMO) and he's not a big enough name to be in season 50, which will likely be legends
I like it, there's a couple people who I doubt would return like Woo and Tommy, possibly Kyle and I don't see Joe & Wardog on the same cast(Both Tony clones) but it's solid
I like it, there's a couple people who I doubt would return like Woo and Tommy, possibly Kyle and I don't see Joe & Wardog on the same cast(Both Tony clones) but it's solid
I kind of regret not adding Denise since I put Abi on the cast.
Maybe Swap Densie and Lauren and have Lauren be on my Second Chances 2 cast.
Next returee season I think Dom, Chrissy, Angelina, Christian & Devens are all locks if they accept the call, Gabby, Janet, Davie & Lauren O have good shots(they need a young attractive girl like Lauren and she's well liked), Chris should be back next time winners are eligible. Jay, Devon, Dean & Chris Noble will probably be fighting for 2 spots. I hope Lauren B, Kellee & Victoria will be on but there's a ton of girls, especially from IOI and I'm concerned Noura, Karishma and/or Elaine may take their spots, and who knows if they want Kellee or if she'd accept. Wardog, Ali & Jamal are other newer players I'd like to see but may not make it
For second chances 2 they should cast the poll loser (whoever accepts) and from there have the public chose from recent seasons to be added to the cast. Wish US can take notes and copy the AUS Survivor format.
From The Challenge who would you think would have a good crossover?
Boys- Tony Raines, Johnny Bananas, Derrick K, Darrell Taylor, Frank Sweeny, Cory Warton, Hunter Barfield, Wes Bergmann, and Brad Fiorenza
Girls- Cara Maria Sorbello, Amanda Garcia, Ashley Mitchell, Marie Roda, Laurel Stucky, Tori Deal, Kam Williams, Kailah Casillas, Veronica Portillo, Sylvia Elsrode and Kellyanne Judd.
From The Challenge who would you think would have a good crossover?
Boys- Tony Raines, Johnny Bananas, Derrick K, Darrell Taylor, Frank Sweeny, Cory Warton, Hunter Barfield, Wes Bergmann, and Brad Fiorenza
Girls- Cara Maria Sorbello, Amanda Garcia, Ashley Mitchell, Marie Roda, Laurel Stucky, Tori Deal, Kam Williams, Kailah Casillas, Veronica Portillo, Sylvia Elsrode and Kellyanne Judd.
I don't remember many of the older challengers.
Kam and cara cant swim so they'd be gone early lol
From The Challenge who would you think would have a good crossover?
Boys- Tony Raines, Johnny Bananas, Derrick K, Darrell Taylor, Frank Sweeny, Cory Warton, Hunter Barfield, Wes Bergmann, and Brad Fiorenza
Girls- Cara Maria Sorbello, Amanda Garcia, Ashley Mitchell, Marie Roda, Laurel Stucky, Tori Deal, Kam Williams, Kailah Casillas, Veronica Portillo, Sylvia Elsrode and Kellyanne Judd.
I don't remember many of the older challengers.
Kam and cara cant swim so they'd be gone early lol
True. But knowing Cara she will create another Cara Cult and get far.
From The Challenge who would you think would have a good crossover?
Boys- Tony Raines, Johnny Bananas, Derrick K, Darrell Taylor, Frank Sweeny, Cory Warton, Hunter Barfield, Wes Bergmann, and Brad Fiorenza
Girls- Cara Maria Sorbello, Amanda Garcia, Ashley Mitchell, Marie Roda, Laurel Stucky, Tori Deal, Kam Williams, Kailah Casillas, Veronica Portillo, Sylvia Elsrode and Kellyanne Judd.
I don't remember many of the older challengers.
Kam and cara cant swim so they'd be gone early lol
True. But knowing Cara she will create another Cara Cult and get far.
Cara would be a massive goat, nobody would ever vote for her to win
From The Challenge who would you think would have a good crossover?
Boys- Tony Raines, Johnny Bananas, Derrick K, Darrell Taylor, Frank Sweeny, Cory Warton, Hunter Barfield, Wes Bergmann, and Brad Fiorenza
Girls- Cara Maria Sorbello, Amanda Garcia, Ashley Mitchell, Marie Roda, Laurel Stucky, Tori Deal, Kam Williams, Kailah Casillas, Veronica Portillo, Sylvia Elsrode and Kellyanne Judd.
I don't remember many of the older challengers.
Kam and cara cant swim so they'd be gone early lol
True. But knowing Cara she will create another Cara Cult and get far.
Cara would be a massive goat, nobody would ever vote for her to win
You forgot to say she'll get dragged by the jury for playing victim.
While we're on the FvF topic, here's my recast of the dreadful Caramoan Favs Tribe:
Marty, Kenny, Andrea & Corinne as alternates
Assuming Matt Elrod & Taj would both decline
Someone is looking to do a brainsteele game later on
People really want quiters Ian and Rafe back... hate to see it. Least you could throw legendary villains Dreamz and Judd in their place.
You still kept Cochran? Cancel it! Lol
Second in fan fave voting In SP after Ozzy. He was one of the few people who fit the theme(especially considering Malcolm hadn't even been on tv yet), and his return was inevitable. At least this way he doesn't come in with all his friends
Survivor: Inferno (Mix of favorite players and players I believe deserve a second shot)
Koror:
Brenda Lowe
Ciera Eastin
Hayden Moss
Kim Spradlin
Natalie Anderson
Ozzy Lusth
Parvati Shallow
Rodney Lavoie
Russell Hantz
Tony Vlachos
Dangrayne:
Amanda Kimmel
Andrea Boehlke
Cirie Fields
Joe Anglim
Jon Misch
Kelley Wentworth
Malcolm Freberg
Rob Mariano
Sandra Diaz-Twine
Yul Kwon
Episode 1:
Immunity: Koror
Voted out: Boston Rob (8-0) after a revote. Original vote was (5-5)
Episode 2:
Immunity: Koror
Voted out: Joe (8-1)
Episode 3:
Immunity: Koror
Voted out: Malcolm (5-2-1)
Episode 4:
Immunity: Koror
Voted out: Kim (Medievac)
Episode 5: Tribe Swap
Exiled: Cirie
Vuku:
Brenda
Ciera
Hayden
Rodney
Yul
Jabeni:
Ozzy
Parvati
Russell
Sandra
Tony
Tiva:
Amanda
Andrea
Jon
Kelley
Natalie
Immunity: Vuku and Jabeni
Voted out: Natalie (4-1)
Episode 6:
Immunity: Jabeni and Tiva
Voted out: Rodney (3-2)
Episode 7:
Immunity: Vuku and Tiva
Voted out: Sandra (4-1)
Episode 8: Merge
Amanda
Andrea
Brenda
Ciera
Cirie
Hayden
Jon
Kelley
Ozzy
Parvati
Russell
Tony
Yul
Immunity: Hayden
Voted out: Jon (7-4-2) *Russell nullified 7 votes with idol*
Episode 9:
Immunity: Amanda
Voted out: Hayden (9-3)
Episode 10:
Immunity: Parvati
Voted out: Andrea (6-3-2)
Episode 11 Part 1:
Immunity: Ciera
Voted out: Brenda (4-3-3)
Episode 11 Part 2:
Immunity: Amanda
Voted out: Tony (5-2-2)
Episode 12:
Immunity: Russell
Voted out: Kelley Wentworth (5-3) *Ciera nullifed the 3 votes with idol*
Episode 13:
Immunity: Yul
Voted out: Russell (5-2)
Finale Part 1:
Immunity: Amanda
Voted out: Yul (Rocks Drawn), Orignal Vote was (3-3) then revote (2-2) between Parvati and Ciera
Finale Part 2:
Immunity: Parvati
Voted out: Amanda (2-1) on revote, original vote was (2-2-1)
Finale Part 3:
Immunity: Parvati
She Grants Immunity to: Ozzy
Winner of Fire Making: Ciera
Voted out: Cirie
Reunion:
Winner: Parvati (6-2-2)
Voted for Parvati: Amanda,Cirie,Hayden,Jon,Kelley,Yul
Voted for Ozzy: Tony and Andrea
Voted for Ciera: Russell and Brenda
Fan Favorite: Ozzy
Anyone removing Phillip from FvF2 is wrong. Just make him the first boot after overplaying.
One More Survivor 40 Fanfic (Using David vs Goliath Format and tribe names)
David:
Ben
Nick
Tony
Tyson
Yul
Danni
Michele
Natalie
Parvati
Sarah
Goliath:
Adam
Ethan
Jeremy
Boston Rob
Wendell
Amber
Denise
Kim
Sandra
Sophie
Episode 1:
Immunity: Goliath
Voted out: Yul (7-3)
Episode 2:
Immunity: David
Voted out: Jeremy (6-4)
Episode 3:
Immunity: Goliath
Voted out: Nick (7-2)
Episode 4:
Immunity: Goliath
Voted out: Sarah (7-1)
Episode 5: Tribe Swap
Exiled: Sandra
Vuku:
Tony
Amber
Denise
Parvati
Sophie
Jabeni:
Adam
Ben
Wendell
Kim
Natalie
Tiva:
Ethan
Boston Rob
Tyson
Danni
Michele
Immunity: Jabeni and Vuku
Voted out: Michele (3-1-1)
Episode 6:
Immunity: Jabeni and Tiva
Voted out: Tony (3-1-1)
Episode 7:
Immunity: Jabeni and Tiva
Voted out: Denise (3-1)
Episode 8: Merge
Adam
Ben
Ethan
Boston Rob
Tyson
Wendell
Amber
Danni
Kim
Natalie
Parvati
Sandra
Sophie
Immunity: Adam
Voted out: Boston Rob (7-4-2)
Episode 9:
Immunity: Natalie
Voted out: Adam (6-4 revote, original vote was 5-5-2)
Episode 10:
Immunity: Sandra
Voted out: Sophie (5-3-3)
Episode 11 Part 1:
Immunity: Tyson
Voted out: Sandra (6-3-1)
Episode 11 Part 2:
Immunity: Ben
Voted out: Danni (5-3-1)
Episode 12:
Immunity: Natalie
Voted out: Amber (4-3-1)
Episode 13:
Immunity: Natalie
Voted out: Tyson (3-2-2)
Finale Part 1:
Immunity: Parvati
Voted out: Natalie (3-3) *Ben used idol to nullify 3 votes against him*
Finale Part 2:
Immunity: Ben
Voted out: Parvati (3-2)
Finale Part 3:
Immunity: Ben
Gives immunity to: Kim
Winner of Firemaking: Ethan
Voted out: Wendell
Reunion:
Winner: Kim- 5 votes (Votes From: Adam,Natalie,Sandra,Sophie,Wendell)
2nd: Ethan- 3 votes (Votes From: Danni,Boston Rob,Tyson)
3rd: Ben- 2 votes (Votes From: Amber and Parvati)
Fan Favorite: Kim
Survivor America vs Australia
Location: Africa (Like season 3 of the us verison)
24 Castaways 50 days
America Tribe (Red):
Parvati Shallow
Cirie Fields
Abi-Maria Gomes
Natalie Anderson
Amber Mariano
Aubry Bracco
Malcolm Freberg
Jeremy Collins
Ethan Zohn
Yul Kwon
Tyson Apostol
Joe Anglim
Australia Tribe (Blue):
Shonee Fairfax
Brooke Jowett
Janine Allis
Tessa O’Halloran
Michelle Dougan
Kristie Bennett
Nick Iadanza
Locky Gilbert
David Genat
Benji Wilson
Harry Hills
Samuel Hinton
Love it, I really hope this happens eventually. Apparently it was considered for S5 before they decided on all stars. Here's mine:
Aus
America
Im assuming anyone who's a lock for a US returnee season, especially second chance 2 would probably not be on so I left people like Dom, Chrissy, Christian etc off
SURVIVOR: BREATHING FIRE.
(Returring contestants whose fire never went)
Location: Indonesia.
Format: two teams, switch at 15, merge at 11.
TEAM 1
TRIBE 2
Alternates: Carolyn Rivera (Worlds Apart runner-up) or Bi Nguyen (David vs Goliath medevac) ///// Ryan Ulrich (HvsHvsH runner-up) or Tommy Sheehan (Island of the idols winner)
I ran this in brainsteel... and stopped when Earl and Dreamz were the first two boots... .. not here for it.
Yours is better lol. And when was it considered?
Not too sure, I read on a spoiler site it was considered before they chose to do all stars. It may have not gone very far though, I imagine it's much cheaper to have all Australians and no legal issues to worry about either
All Stars 2(1 time players only)
They really need to bring back Earl! I just recently did a Fiji rewatch and his gameplay was phenomenal.
Id like Earl to comeback but sadly I think his last shot was WAW.
Survivor Heroes Vs Villains 2
Location: Guatemala
Heroes Tribe:
Carolyn Rivera
Cydney Gillon
Devon Pinto
Janet Carbin
Jeremy Collins
Lauren O'Connell
Michele Fitzgerald
Tommy Sheehan
Woo Hwang
Yul Kwon
Villains Tribe:
Abi-Maria Gomes
Chrissy Hofbeck
Corinne Kaplan
Dan DaSilva
Dean Kowalski
Joe Mena
Kim Spradlin
Kyle Jason
Michaela Bradshaw
Tony Vlachos
What do you guys think?
Agreed, I don't think any winners will return between 40 and 50(any returnee season will be SC2, Unfinished business, non winner captains or FvF3 IMO) and he's not a big enough name to be in season 50, which will likely be legends
I like it, there's a couple people who I doubt would return like Woo and Tommy, possibly Kyle and I don't see Joe & Wardog on the same cast(Both Tony clones) but it's solid
I kind of regret not adding Denise since I put Abi on the cast.
Maybe Swap Densie and Lauren and have Lauren be on my Second Chances 2 cast.
Next returee season I think Dom, Chrissy, Angelina, Christian & Devens are all locks if they accept the call, Gabby, Janet, Davie & Lauren O have good shots(they need a young attractive girl like Lauren and she's well liked), Chris should be back next time winners are eligible. Jay, Devon, Dean & Chris Noble will probably be fighting for 2 spots. I hope Lauren B, Kellee & Victoria will be on but there's a ton of girls, especially from IOI and I'm concerned Noura, Karishma and/or Elaine may take their spots, and who knows if they want Kellee or if she'd accept. Wardog, Ali & Jamal are other newer players I'd like to see but may not make it
Big Brother vs Survivor
Location: Cambodia
Big Brother Tribe (Blue)
Cody Nickson
Da'Vonne Rogers
Derrick Levasseur
Janelle Pierzina
Keesha Smith
Kemi Fakunle
Matt Hoffman
Paul Abrahamian
Rachel Reilly
Zach Rance
Survivor Tribe (Green)
Alexandrea Elliot
Chris Underwood
Chrissy Hofbeck
Davie Rickenbacker
Dean Kowalski
Devon Pinto
Hannah Shapiro
Kellyn Bechtold
Lauren O'Connell
Terry Deitz
Survivor second chance 2
Female cast
Lauren O. 38
Elaine 39
Chrissy 35
Hannah 33
Cydney 32
Carolyn 30
Jaclyn 29
Gabby 37
sabrina 24
Lauren 39
MALES
Rick Devens 38
Christian 37
Davie 37
Domenick 36
Michael Y 36
Rodney 30
Hayden 27
Dean 39
Gavin 38
Pete Y 25
For second chances 2 they should cast the poll loser (whoever accepts) and from there have the public chose from recent seasons to be added to the cast. Wish US can take notes and copy the AUS Survivor format.
From The Challenge who would you think would have a good crossover?
Boys- Tony Raines, Johnny Bananas, Derrick K, Darrell Taylor, Frank Sweeny, Cory Warton, Hunter Barfield, Wes Bergmann, and Brad Fiorenza
Girls- Cara Maria Sorbello, Amanda Garcia, Ashley Mitchell, Marie Roda, Laurel Stucky, Tori Deal, Kam Williams, Kailah Casillas, Veronica Portillo, Sylvia Elsrode and Kellyanne Judd.
I don't remember many of the older challengers.
Kam and cara cant swim so they'd be gone early lol
True. But knowing Cara she will create another Cara Cult and get far.
Cara would be a massive goat, nobody would ever vote for her to win
You forgot to say she'll get dragged by the jury for playing victim.
Pages