Survivor Fantasy casts

311 posts / 0 new
Last post

Survivor: Second Chance (recast)

 
Ta Keo
Heidi Hamels - Survivor: Amazon
Burton Roberts - Survivor: Pearl Islands
Cindy Hall - Survivor: Guatemala
Nick Stanbury - Survivor: Exile Island
Michelle Yi - Survivor: Fiji
Erinn Moss - Survivor: Tocantins
Brett Clouser - Survivor: Samoa
Chelsea Meissner - Survivor: One World
Eddie Fox - Survivor: Caramoan
Jon Misch - Survivor: San Juan del Sur
 
Bayon
Greg Buis - Survivor: Borneo
Neleh Dennis - Survivor: Marquesas
Silas Gaither - Survivor: Africa
Ian Rosenberger - Survior: Palau
Jenny Guzon-Bae - Survivor: Cook Islands
Natalie Bolton - Survivor: Micronesia
RC Saint-Amour - Survivor: Philippines
Hayden Moss - Survivor: Blood vs. Water
LJ McKanas - Survivor: Cagayan
Jenn Brown - Survivor: Worlds Apart

Heroes vs Villains 2

mediumpurple"> Villains

  • Natalie (Micronesia)
  • Ken (Gabon)
  • Alina (Nicaragua)
  • Todd (China)
  • Ashley (China)
  • Brandon (Guatemala)
  • Trish (Cagayan)
  • Judd (Guatemala)
  • J'Tia (Cagayan)
  • Shane (Exile)

Heroes

  • Savage (Pearl Islands, Cambodia)
  • Sherea (China)
  • Brian (Guatemala)
  • Crystal (Gabon)
  • Brice (Cagayan)
  • Cindy (Guatemala)
  • Yul (Cook Islands)
  • Eliza (Micronesia, Vanuatu)
  • Benry (Nicaragua)
  • Jane (Nicaragua)

It's only with people which seasons I have seen, so don't be mad lol, I know it's poor pool cast members.

Survivor Indonesia: Third Chance
Birok Tribe:
Rob Cesternino (Amazon)
Randy Bailey (Gabon)
Phillip Sheppard (Redemption Island)
Bobby Jon Drinkard (Palau)
Malcolm Freberg (Philippines)
Shii Ann Huang (Thailand)
Kat Eddorson (One World)
Eliza Orlins (Vanuatu)
Andrea Boehlke (Redemption Island)
Laura Morrett (Samoa)
 
Mopozap Tribe:
Tom Buchanan (Africa)
Yau-man Chan (Fiji)
Michael Skupin (Austrailian Outback)
Erik Reichenbach (Micronesia)
Russell Swan (Samoa)
Jenna Lewis (Borneo)
Courtney Yates (China)
Ami Cusack (Vanuatu)
Francesca Hogi (Redemption Island)
Monica Culpepper (One World)
 
merged tribe
 
I didn't want to include anyone from Cambodia yet. I did a simulation using the Caramoan format and the final 3 were Jenna, Francescsa, and Erik with Jenna winning and Erik getting second lol.

Hayden doesn't qualify for Second Chance. Since he was on Big Brother, CBS considers his next Survivor appearance his third.

YASS at Kat and Andrea melm!!!!

Here is the placements of my third chance cast.

Bye at Kat leaving first... Someone should do a Bran Steele (BB or Survivor) with Vevmo players!

Survivor: Winners vs Losers

20 castaways, 10 winners, 10 people booted first or second, 2 tribes, 1 Sole Survivor.

Juara (winners)

  • Danni
  • Bob
  • Vecepia
  • Yul
  • Natalie (SJDS)
  • Todd
  • Kim
  • Fabio
  • Sophie
  • Tony

Bodho (losers) 

  • Garett
  • Jolanda
  • Vince
  • Michelle
  • Zane
  • Mary
  • Matt
  • Ashley 
  • Shannon
  • Semhar

 

Survivor Suriname
Second Chance 2
Lawa Tribe
Hayden
Shane
Greg
Eddie
Ken
Taj
Jefra
Stephanie
Baylor
Natalie b

Galibi Tribe
Jon
Brad
LJ
Carter
Jim
Crystal
Chelsea
Theresa
Jenn
Morgan

Second Chances 2

Tribe #1:

Teresa Cooper (Australian Outback)

Greg Buis (Borneo)

Carolyn Rivera (Worlds Apart)

Rodney Lavoie, Jr. (Worlds Apart)

Neleh Dennis (Marquesas)

Reed Kelly (San Juan del Sur)

Trish Hegarty (Cagayan)

Marty Piombo (Nicaragua)

RC Saint-Amour (Philippines)

Jason Siska (Micronesia)

Tribe #2:

Michelle Yi (Fiji)

John Carroll (Marquesas)

Natalie Bolton (Micronesia)

Shane Powers (Exile Island)

Tracy Hughes-Wolf (Micronesia)

Dreamz Herd (Fiji)

Erinn Lobdell (Tocantins)

Erik Cardona (Samoa)

Jane Bright (Nicaragua)

Ace Gordon (Gabon)

Bye at Kat leaving first... Someone should do a Bran Steele (BB or Survivor) with Vevmo players!

I did both. Dscott won both... I rage quit Brantsteele after that. LMAO

Second Chances 2Tribe #1:Teresa Cooper (Australian Outback)Greg Buis (Borneo)Carolyn Rivera (Worlds Apart)Rodney Lavoie, Jr. (Worlds Apart)Neleh Dennis (Marquesas)Reed Kelly (San Juan del Sur)Trish Hegarty (Cagayan)Marty Piombo (Nicaragua)RC Saint-Amour (Philippines)Jason Siska (Micronesia)Tribe #2:Michelle Yi (Fiji)John Carroll (Marquesas)Natalie Bolton (Micronesia)Shane Powers (Exile Island)Tracy Hughes-Wolf (Micronesia)Dreamz Herd (Fiji)Erinn Lobdell (Tocantins)Erik Cardona (Samoa)Jane Bright (Nicaragua)Ace Gordon (Gabon)

Dreamz and Rodney? Seriously?

Andre wrote:

Second Chances 2Tribe #1:Teresa Cooper (Australian Outback)Greg Buis (Borneo)Carolyn Rivera (Worlds Apart)Rodney Lavoie, Jr. (Worlds Apart)Neleh Dennis (Marquesas)Reed Kelly (San Juan del Sur)Trish Hegarty (Cagayan)Marty Piombo (Nicaragua)RC Saint-Amour (Philippines)Jason Siska (Micronesia)Tribe #2:Michelle Yi (Fiji)John Carroll (Marquesas)Natalie Bolton (Micronesia)Shane Powers (Exile Island)Tracy Hughes-Wolf (Micronesia)Dreamz Herd (Fiji)Erinn Lobdell (Tocantins)Erik Cardona (Samoa)Jane Bright (Nicaragua)Ace Gordon (Gabon)

Dreamz and Rodney? Seriously?

Rodney is slightly a random pick but I think Dreamz is an interesting character that could use redemption after screwing Yau-Man.

Second Chance 2 (only with females, because I couldn't choose only 10 lol)

Where was revote for winner and J'tia voted for Erinn.

I'd watch the **** out of that season. I live for Erinn.

Still salty Twila was cut from Heroes vs Villains. Vanuatu is such an underrated season. And that vertical maze immunity challenge was everything.

Still salty Twila was cut from Heroes vs Villains. Vanuatu is such an underrated season. And that vertical maze immunity challenge was everything.

I was TeamEliza for Vanuatu but I would love to see Twila back. I wish she was on the second chance ballot.

I also wanted to see Twila back. Never got why she didn't return.

Twila, Twila...  I don't understand why Ghandia and Caryn didn't return. 

Twila, Twila...  I don't understand why Ghandia and Caryn didn't return. 

Cuz Caryn Sucks..hehe.

 

OMG

Sandy won a Fan Favorite

Julie won 5 immunities!!

 

Survivor Tonga: Winners vs. Runner Ups vs. Jury vs. Pre-Jury

Winners Tribe:

Tony Vlachos (Cagayan)

Natalie Anderson (San Juan del Sur)

Kim Spradlin (One World)

Mike Holloway (Worlds Apart)

Sophie Clarke (South Pacific)

Runner ups Tribe:

Carolyn Rivera (Worlds Apart)

Sabrina Thompson (One World)

Chase Rice (Nicaragua)

Missy Payne (San Juan del Sur)

Albert Destrade (South Pacific)

Jury Tribe:

Hayden Moss (BloodvsWater)

Holly Hoffman (Nicaragua)

RC Saint-Amour (Philippines)

Marty Piombo (Nicaragua)

Neal Gottlieb (Kaoh Rong)

Pre-Jury Tribe:

Alexis Maxwell (Cagayan)

Caleb Reynolds (Kaoh Rong)

Brad Culpepper (BloodvsWater)

Stephanie Valencia (Redemption Island)

Joaquin Souberbielle (Worlds Apart)

 

 

YES AT ALEXIS WINNING. ❤️

Survivor Tonga: Second Chance (Pre-merge Edition)

Tofua

Cliff Robinson(Cagayan)

Max Dawson(Worlds Apart)

Matt Bischoff(Caramoan)

Stephanie Johnson(Ghost Island)

Marissa Peterson(Blood vs Water)

Stephanie Valencia(Redemption Island)

Kao

Garrett Adelstein(Cagayan)

Jacob Derwin(Ghost Island)

John Cody(Blood vs Water)

Christine Shields-Markoski(South Pacific)

Laura Alexander(Caramoan)

Alexandria "Ali"Elliott(Heroes vs Healers vs Hustlers

Ata

Bradley Kleihege(Ghost Island)

Joaquin Souberbielle(Worlds Apart)

Peter Baggenstos(Koah Rong)

Alexis Maxwell(Cagayan)

Mikayla Wingle(South Pacific)

Jessica "Figgy" Figueroa(Millennials vs Gen X)

Merge

Survivor 40: Winners at War (My own outcome with same cast but different tribes) (Going based on Game changers format because I loved it)

 

Mana Tribe:

Ben

Boston Rob

Tyson

Wendell

Yul

Denise

Michele

Natalie

Sarah

Sophie

 

Nuku Tribe:

Adam

Ethan

Jeremy

Nick

Tony

Amber

Danni

Kim

Parvati

Sandra

 

 

Episode 1:

*Amber finds legacy advantage*

Immunity: Mana

Voted out: Sandra (6-4)

 

Episode 2:

Immunity: Mana

Voted out: Amber (7-2)

*Gifts legacy advantage to Parvati*

 

Episode 3: (Tribe Swap)

Mana:

Ben

Jeremy

Tyson

Kim

Michele

Parvati

 

Nuku:

Ethan

Nick

Tony

Yul

Danni

Denise

 

Tavua:

Adam

Boston Rob

Wendell

Natalie

Sarah

Sophie

 

Immunity: Mana and Nuku

Voted out: Sarah (5-1)

 

Episode 4:

Immunity: Mana

Voted out: Ethan (6-3-2)

 

Episode 5:

Immunity: Tavua and Nuku

Jeremy uses idol on Kim, Tyson uses idol on himself

Voted out: Michele (4 votes) (Tyson nullified 2 votes with idol)

 

Episode 6: Tribe Swap

Exiled: Denise

 

Mana:

Adam

Ben

Jeremy

Yul

Kim

Natalie

Sophie

 

Nuku:

Nick

Boston Rob

Tony

Tyson

Wendell

Danni

Parvati

 

Immunity: Mana

Voted out: Parvati (Quit)

Gifts Legacy Advantage to Ben

 

Episode 7:

Immunity: Nuku

Voted out: Adam (4-3)

 

Episode 8: Merge

Ben

Jeremy

Nick

Boston Rob

Tony

Tyson

Wendell

Yul

Danni

Denise

Kim

Natalie

Sophie

 

 

Immunity: Tyson

Voted out:Denise (5-5-3) Danni nullifed 5 votes with idol

 

Episode 9:

Immunity: Kim

Voted out: Tyson (6-4-2)

 

Episode 10:

Immunity: Natalie

Voted out: Kim (7-4) Boston Rob nullified 7 votes with idol

 

Episode 11:

Immunity: Danni

Voted out: Tony (7-3)

 

Episode 12:

Immunity: Danni

Voted out: Wendell (8-1)

 

Episode 13:

Immunity: Jeremy

Voted out: Boston Rob (5-3)

 

Episode 14:

Immunity: Yul

Voted out: Jeremy (Rocks drawn) (original vote was 3-2-2) with Sophie nullifying 3 votes with idol and they went automatically to rocks since it was a tie with 2 votes between Danni and Natalie

 

Episode 15:

Immunity: Natalie

*Ben uses Legacy advantage*

Voted out: Yul (4-2) 

 

Episode 16:

Immunity: Nick

*Nick uses idol on Danni*

Voted out: Natalie (3-2) Danni nullified 2 votes

 

Episode 17:

Immunity: Ben

Voted out: Sophie (3-1)

 

Reunion:

Winner: Ben (6-2-2) (Votes from: Denise, Jeremy, Natalie, Sophie,Tony,Wendell)

Runner up: Danni (Votes from: Yul and Tyson)

Runner up: Nick (Votes from: Boston Rob and Kim)

 

Fan Favorite: Natalie

Also had one more fantasy cast that was a mix of survivor players and challenge players

 

Vanua Tribe:

Jeff Varner 

Joss Mooney

Kayleigh Morris

Kim Spradlin

Kyle Christie

Natalie Tenerelli

Nelson Thomas

Peih-Gee Law

Stephen Fishbach

Sylvia Elsrode

 

Takali Tribe:

Amanda Garcia

Derrick Henry

Jenna Compono

Jeremy Collins

Johnny Bananas

Kailah Casillas

Marie Roda

Melissa Reeves

Paulie Calafiore

Rob Mariano

 

Episode 1:

*Joss finds legacy advantage*

Immunity: Takali

Voted out: Kyle (6-4)

 

Episode 2:

Immunity: Vanua

Voted out: Bananas (7-3)

 

Episode 3:

Immunity: Takali

Voted out: Kim (4-3-2)

 

Episode 4:

Immunity: Vanua

Voted out: Marie (6-2-1) (Derrick nullified the 2 votes with his idol)

 

Episode 5: Tribe Swap

Vanua:

Joss

Melissa

Natalie

Nelson

Boston Rob

 

Takali:

Amanda

Varner

Kailah

Kayleigh

Fishbach

 

Ikabula:

Derrick

Jenna

Jeremy

Paulie

Peih-Gee

Sylvia

 

Immunity: Takali and Vanua

Voted out: Jenna (4-2)

 

Episode 6:

Immunity: Ikabula and Vanua

Voted out: Kayleigh (4-1)

 

Episode 7:

Immunity: Vanua and Ikabula

Voted out: Sylvia (Quit)

 

Episode 8: Merge

Amanda

Varner

Derrick

Jeremy

Joss

Kailah

Melissa

Natalie

Nelson

Paulie

Peih-Gee

Fishbach

Boston Rob

 

Immunity: Kailah

Voted out: Varner (11-2)

 

Episode 9:

Immunity: Derrick

Voted out: Kailah (10-2)

 

Episode 10:

Immunity: Natalie

Voted out: Derrick (9-2)

 

Episode 11:

Immunity: Joss

Voted out: Peih Gee (6-2) based on revote because Natalie nullified 4 votes with her idol when original vote was 4-3-3

 

Episode 12:

Immunity: Fishbach

Voted out: Amanda (4-3-2)

 

Episode 13:

Immunity: Jeremy

Voted out: Melissa (4-2-2)

 

Episode 14:

Immunity: Paulie

Voted out: Fishbach (3-2) after revote, original vote was 3-3-1

 

Episode 15:

Immunity: Joss

*Joss uses legacy advantage on Jeremy*

*Jeremy uses idol on Natalie*

Voted out: Paulie (4-0) after revote, Original vote was 2-2-2 and natalies 2 votes were nullified

 

Episode 16:

Immunity: Jeremy

Voted out: Joss (3-2)

 

Episode 17:

Immunity: Nelson

Voted out: Boston Rob (2-1-1)

 

Reunion:

Winner: Nelson (5 votes) (From: Amanda, Derrick, Kailah, Paulie, Boston Rob_

2nd: Natalie (3 votes) (From: Peih-Gee, Melissa, Fishbach)

3rd: Jeremy (2 votes) (From: Varner and Joss)

 

Fan Favorite: Marie

if All Stars 2 was season 16 instead of Micronesa who would ya'll choose from Season 9-15?

if All Stars 2 was season 16 instead of Micronesa who would ya'll choose from Season 9-15?

Men:

Yau-man Chan

James Clements

Jonathon Penner

Ozzy Lusth

Edgardo Rivera

Terry Deitz

Shane Powers 

Rafe Judkins

Ian Rosenberger

Jean-Robert Bellande

Alternate: Brian Corridan

Women:

Parvati Shallow

Cirie Fields

Ami Cusack

Eliza Orlins

Amanda Kimmel

Michelle Yi

Twila Tanner

Candice Woodcock

Lydia Morales

Peih-Gee Law

Alternate: Courtney Yates

 

if All Stars 2 was season 16 instead of Micronesa who would ya'll choose from Season 9-15?

Men:

Yau-man Chan

James Clements

Jonathon Penner

Ozzy Lusth

Edgardo Rivera

Terry Deitz

Shane Powers 

Rafe Judkins

Ian Rosenberger

Jean-Robert Bellande

Alternate: Brian Corridan

Women:

Parvati Shallow

Cirie Fields

Ami Cusack

Eliza Orlins

Amanda Kimmel

Michelle Yi

Twila Tanner

Candice Woodcock

Lydia Morales

Peih-Gee Law

Alternate: Courtney Yates

I love this cast! It's sad half of them were already on Micronesia. What could have been lol

if All Stars 2 was season 16 instead of Micronesa who would ya'll choose from Season 9-15?

Oh Good One

Men

  1. Tom Westman
  2. Ian Rosenberger
  3. Shane Powers
  4. Terry Deitz
  5. Ozzy Lusth
  6. Yul Kwon
  7. Earl Cole
  8. Yau Man Chan
  9. James Clement
  10. Todd Herzog

Women

  1. Eliza Orlins
  2. Twila Tanner
  3. Ami Cusack
  4. Danni Boatwright
  5. Cirie Fields
  6. Danielle DiLorenzo
  7. Parvati Shallow
  8. Candice Woodcock
  9. Amanda Kimmel
  10. Courtney Yates

Pages