The Challenge: What Ifs

2775 posts / 0 new
Last post

what if Danny went against Big Easy in the final instead of Wes. i think Danny would have won, or it would have went to three rounds. 

Danny is pretty muscular. he gave Darrell a fight for his money in their elimination in the Ruins.

plus he was able to hold his own against Trey in wrestling. 

This may or have not been done before, but I'm too lazy to look through all the pages to find out.

What if CT didn't get DQ'd during his elimination againts Brad on The Duel?

Do you think he would have made the final? Do you think he would've beaten Wes in that final, granting him his first Challenge win?

This may or have not been done before, but I'm too lazy to look through all the pages to find out.What if CT didn't get DQ'd during his elimination againts Brad on The Duel?Do you think he would have made the final? Do you think he would've beaten Wes in that final, granting him his first Challenge win?

I think CT wins that entire challenge had he not been DQ'ed.

Wasn't Brad the only person standing in the way of CT and the final? 

It's a tough call, Wes was in really good shape back then (cough steroids), CT is great but his finals record leaves a little to be desired. Would be close in my opinion.

Wasn't Brad the only person standing in the way of CT and the final? It's a tough call, Wes was in really good shape back then (cough steroids), CT is great but his finals record leaves a little to be desired. Would be close in my opinion.

Also Wes still gets the headstart from the soccer shootout. 

Glimpse422 wrote:

What if the fresh meat team on BOTS was Pete, Cara Maria, Brandon , Mandi... How do y'all think this would've played out ?

i think they would have been out even earlier. 

no chance. They only reason they were losing the daily challenges was because of big easy. With this team I can see them winning some of the challenges and if not they may get sent in, but realistically I can see them beating most teams. If it was Pete/Mandi over big easy/Camila vs Jd\Devyn then Pete and Mandi easily would've won. Which would have changed the game up pretty drastically.

mickeyflo24 wrote:

Glimpse422 wrote:What if the fresh meat team on BOTS was Pete, Cara Maria, Brandon , Mandi... How do y'all think this would've played out ?

i think they would have been out even earlier. 

no chance. They only reason they were losing the daily challenges was because of big easy. With this team I can see them winning some of the challenges and if not they may get sent in, but realistically I can see them beating most teams. If it was Pete/Mandi over big easy/Camila vs Jd\Devyn then Pete and Mandi easily would've won. Which would have changed the game up pretty drastically.

Mandi is average. If anything, looking at your picks, keep Camila and just change Erick for Pete and have Cara/Camila/Brandon/Pete, that team could've maybe made it further. But there's no reason to add Mandi over Camila, especially if the intention is to make the team better lol.

If anything, make the Fresh Meat team Laurel/Pete/Theresa/Noor

deeper wrote:

Wasn't Brad the only person standing in the way of CT and the final? It's a tough call, Wes was in really good shape back then (cough steroids), CT is great but his finals record leaves a little to be desired. Would be close in my opinion.

Also Wes still gets the headstart from the soccer shootout. 

Wes would get the football headstart and would probably solve the puzzles faster than CT. Btw steroids enhance the way you gain muscles but that doesn't exactly translate into being athletic or good at stuff lol a lot of people give the "steroid" argument but there is a difference between being on steroids and still being an athlete and not being athletic and being on steroids either way Duel 1 was prime Wes and im glad he won that one.

OVOTyrone wrote:

This may or have not been done before, but I'm too lazy to look through all the pages to find out.What if CT didn't get DQ'd during his elimination againts Brad on The Duel?Do you think he would have made the final? Do you think he would've beaten Wes in that final, granting him his first Challenge win?

I think CT wins that entire challenge had he not been DQ'ed.

I agree.  Wes was in his prime then but CT was as well...CT.  It's still crazy thinking back about how good he was back in the day.  It was his 3rd challenge and coming off two losses on teams (where he was easily the best male) I just dont see him losing.

If anything, make the Fresh Meat team Laurel/Pete/Theresa/Noor

Nah. I'd make it Eric/Casey/Mandi/Luke

AlwaysAMess wrote:

If anything, make the Fresh Meat team Laurel/Pete/Theresa/Noor

Nah. I'd make it Eric/Casey/Mandi/Luke

LOL

Debut Album wrote:

OVOTyrone wrote:This may or have not been done before, but I'm too lazy to look through all the pages to find out.What if CT didn't get DQ'd during his elimination againts Brad on The Duel?Do you think he would have made the final? Do you think he would've beaten Wes in that final, granting him his first Challenge win?

I think CT wins that entire challenge had he not been DQ'ed.

I agree.  Wes was in his prime then but CT was as well...CT.  It's still crazy thinking back about how good he was back in the day.  It was his 3rd challenge and coming off two losses on teams (where he was easily the best male) I just dont see him losing.

I think it would have been very close and either one could have edged the outher out. I definitely don't think its a certainty that CT wins that, same for Wes. Wes would most likely have won the soccer shootout due to his experience.. I think the puzzle is the most important. From what I remember, Brad got done with his puzzle moments after Wes did. Who knows if CT would have solved it that fast..  That puzzle was a bit weird though, the other opponent could have easily just looked at the other person's and gotten some sort of information which maybe explains Brad solving the puzzle so quick, who knows.. Brad and Wes were neck and neck at one point so Wes did beat him in a foot race.  CT probably would have outran Wes but it just depends on the puzzles. 

Also, I really wish during that time that the show was an hour long, because that final challenge seemed a lot longer than what we actually saw on TV, at least imo. Maybe not an hour long, but just a little longer.  Also I remember Wes in an interview stating such if I'm not mistaken. 

Glimpse422 wrote:

mickeyflo24 wrote:

Glimpse422 wrote:What if the fresh meat team on BOTS was Pete, Cara Maria, Brandon , Mandi... How do y'all think this would've played out ?

i think they would have been out even earlier. 

no chance. They only reason they were losing the daily challenges was because of big easy. With this team I can see them winning some of the challenges and if not they may get sent in, but realistically I can see them beating most teams. If it was Pete/Mandi over big easy/Camila vs Jd\Devyn then Pete and Mandi easily would've won. Which would have changed the game up pretty drastically.

Mandi is average. If anything, looking at your picks, keep Camila and just change Erick for Pete and have Cara/Camila/Brandon/Pete, that team could've maybe made it further. But there's no reason to add Mandi over Camila, especially if the intention is to make the team better lol.

Camilla isn't fresh meat though lol , personally why I changed it.  And I guess I'll say my opinion again, I think with Mandi Pete put on that team that they'd make it significantly farther

Daddy DAF
Anonymous's picture

What if we had the island cast for a format that wasnt the island? the cast was probably the only quality i liked from the island.

What if they stopped calling Bananas after his Seasons tantrum? How different would these past challenges have been

What if they stopped calling Bananas after his Seasons tantrum? How different would these past challenges have been

Very different and a bit more enjoyable.

AshtonMartin wrote:

What if they stopped calling Bananas after his Seasons tantrum? How different would these past challenges have been

Very different and a bit more enjoyable.

Except for Exes 2. I enjoyed him being screwed over on that season.

What if Chet wasn’t sent home on Cutthroat due to injury? This would put one more guy in the final, but who? I see Chet getting thrown in against Dan instead of Dunbar and possibly losing. Those final three eliminations definitely would have been different on the male side.

I HIGHLY doubt Chet would have lost that elimination, which requires major strategy. 

What if Kenny was never banned and was partnered up with Sarah on Exes 1 instead of Vinny? Would they have won? 

I think they would have made the finals too

What if Kenny was never banned and was partnered up with Sarah on Exes 1 instead of Vinny? Would they have won? I think they would have made the finals too

Absolutely they make the final. There wasn't a lot of heights/climbing stuff on that challenge for Kenny to be bad at, nor were there any heavy endurance challenges for Sarah to have a problem with so I doubt they would've come in last at anything. Plus, they had Johnny, Paula, Mark, etc. there to never be voted in.

I think they definitely make the final but probably don't win. Kenny would've been the best guy on that show at finals by FAR, but Sarah didn't have any cardio at that point.

Daddy DAF
Anonymous's picture

Kenny the best guy by far? Did you not see how he was all during the previous season in rivals? he only performed in the final, the whole season he got carried by wes.

Kenny the best guy by far? Did you not see how he was all during the previous season in rivals? he only performed in the final, the whole season he got carried by wes.

"Kenny would've been the best guy on that show at finals"

Daddy DAF
Anonymous's picture

good call. 

What if Kenny was never banned and was partnered up with Sarah on Exes 1 instead of Vinny? Would they have won? I think they would have made the finals too

They would have dominated the house. Bananas/Kenny/Mark/Paula alliance. It would have been interesting too because that probably means Bananas and CT never have their low key alliance.

rwportland2 wrote:

What if Kenny was never banned and was partnered up with Sarah on Exes 1 instead of Vinny? Would they have won? I think they would have made the finals too

They would have dominated the house. Bananas/Kenny/Mark/Paula alliance. It would have been interesting too because that probably means Bananas and CT never have their low key alliance.

I think the alliance was more so, Diem and Bananas, rather than CT and Bananas. I still think with Diem in the house, Paula would have been thrown before Diem would.

What if instead of casting Adam & Brittany and JJ & Simone they cast Chris & Shanley,Scali & Jacy, or even Dre & Simone.

I feel like it would've helped them being accepted the people they picked/ continue to pick haven't been the ones worth seeing

What if Tony & Camila weren't a team on rivals 3, and instead had Brad & Camila and Tony & Sylvia? 

How do you think both teams would've faired? 

Tony and Camila's problems were all with their lack of communication bc they could've been a force later on (not sure how they would've done in the puzzle heavy final). I think that Brad and Camila would have done well. I'm not sure about Tony and Sylvia since we have yet to see her compete but I do believe either options would have been less dysfunctional. And that's the most important part about winning those partner seasons 

Pages