The Challenge: What Ifs

2775 posts / 0 new
Last post

Damn Tonya vs KA... No clue who would have won lol, which elemination round was played when Tonya DQ'ed? & I honestly dont think Tonya would have cared either .. 

The elimination they played was Oh Ring, the game Katie and Sarah played when they were cussing each other out lol Danny and Darell also played it. I feel like that elimination round between Tonya and KellyAnne could've gone either way.

X Battle

What if these match ups were to happen... Who would win?

Jenna vs. Nany

Jenna vs. KellyAnne

Jenna vs. Jessica

Jenna vs. Nicole R.

Jenna vs. Nia

Jenna vs. Averey

Jenna vs. LaToya

Jenna vs. CT

I remember watching The Ruins dailies where the girls planned to send Tonya into the elimination to face KellyAnne. Too bad she ended up getting disqualified. I think that would have been a good match up. Who do you guys think would've won? I think Tonya is really underrated. It annoyed me how Johanna was like "Tonya wouldn't have cared if we sent her in every time. She'd be fine with it."

Yeah, Tonya vs KellyAnne would have been a good match up. I still think KellyAnne would have won but I do think it would've been somewhat close. 

Plus I like watching Tonya in eliminations. She has like a crazyness inside of her and is unpredictable, while still performing good. Her elimination with Julie on Inferno 2 was hilarious lol.

X Battle

What if these match ups were to happen... Who would win?

Jenna vs. Nany

Jenna vs. KellyAnne

Jenna vs. Jessica

Jenna vs. Nicole R.

Jenna vs. Nia

Jenna vs. Averey

Jenna vs. LaToya

Jenna vs. CT

X Battle

What if these match ups were to happen... Who would win?

Jenna vs. Nany

Jenna vs. KellyAnne

Jenna vs. Jessica

Jenna vs. Nicole R.

Jenna vs. Nia

Jenna vs. Averey

Jenna vs. LaToya

Jenna vs. CT

X Battle

What if these match ups were to happen... Who would win?

Jenna vs. Nany

Jenna vs. KellyAnne

Jenna vs. Jessica

Jenna vs. Nicole R.

Jenna vs. Nia

Jenna vs. Averey

Jenna vs. LaToya

Jenna vs. CT

Jenna vs. Bananas

Jenna vs. Emily

Jenna vs. Laurel

Jenna vs. Zach

X Battle

What if these match ups were to happen... Who would win?

Jenna vs. Nany

Jenna vs. KellyAnne

Jenna vs. Jessica

Jenna vs. Nicole R.

Jenna vs. Nia

Jenna vs. Averey

Jenna vs. LaToya

Jenna vs. CT

Jenna vs. Bananas

Jenna vs. Emily

Jenna vs. Laurel

Jenna vs. Zach

Jenna vs. Casey

Jenna vs Shauvon

X Battle

What if these match ups were to happen... Who would win?

Jenna vs. Nany

Jenna vs. KellyAnne

Jenna vs. Jessica

Jenna vs. Nicole R.

Jenna vs. Nia

Jenna vs. Averey

Jenna vs. LaToya

Jenna vs. CT

X Battle

What if these match ups were to happen... Who would win?

Jenna vs. Nany

Jenna vs. KellyAnne

Jenna vs. Jessica

Jenna vs. Nicole R.

Jenna vs. Nia

Jenna vs. Averey

Jenna vs. LaToya

Jenna vs. CT

Jenna vs. Bananas

Jenna vs. Emily

Jenna vs. Laurel

Jenna vs. Zach

Jenna vs. Casey

Jenna vs Shauvon

Jenna vs. Jenna

#sorrynotsorry, but Jenna would have won with Jenna tbh

no it wouldnt

 

What if Season 27 gets killer ratings like 2 or 3 million viewers?

 

What if Season 27 gets killer ratings like 2 or 3 million viewers?

 

 

I would cry and my hopes would rise so much... xD

What if BOTS2 were same sex elimination rounds instead of co-ed? Either Male elimination days and female day or winning team chooses which sex plays that day unless the team they put in only has 2 left ofc.. lol ik this format kinda has problems especially towards the end if last place team is females and there's only all male teams but I'm not trying to be realistic, this is the what if thread!

LOL just thinking of some of the pairs.

Sarah and Devyn
McKenzie and Jemmye
Cara and Camilla
Brandon and Easy
Zach and Frank
Oh God Melinda and Lacey

LOL just thinking of some of the pairs. Sarah and Devyn McKenzie and Jemmye Cara and Camilla Brandon and Easy Zach and Frank Oh God Melinda and Lacey

They would destory everybody. Sadly even Jonna and Jas.

DarkFights wrote:
schaboszczak wrote:
DarkFights wrote:
bluehatchet2 wrote:

X BattleWhat if these match ups were to happen... Who would win?Jenna vs. NanyJenna vs. KellyAnneJenna vs. JessicaJenna vs. Nicole R.Jenna vs. NiaJenna vs. AvereyJenna vs. LaToyaJenna vs. CT

Jenna vs. BananasJenna vs. EmilyJenna vs. LaurelJenna vs. Zach

Jenna vs. CaseyJenna vs Shauvon

Jenna vs. Jenna#sorrynotsorry, but Jenna would have won with Jenna tbh

i ******* love y'all lmao

 

What if the Rivals 2 final actually happened in Japan? I never got why Wes was complaining "This is the weather we've been training in, this is the weather I expect to do the final in." Wes knows about the location change by this point having experienced it. I think the Rivals 2 final would have been so much nbetter had they done the change. I guess when they couldn't, they had to scrap something together last minute because compared to recent finals at that point it was pretty weak.

I remember watching The Ruins dailies where the girls planned to send Tonya into the elimination to face KellyAnne. Too bad she ended up getting disqualified. I think that would have been a good match up. Who do you guys think would've won? I think Tonya is really underrated. It annoyed me how Johanna was like "Tonya wouldn't have cared if we sent her in every time. She'd be fine with it."

VERY underrated but it was because she was insane lmao. Had Inferno 3 Tonya came to play I believe she would've beat Kellyanne honestly.

What if Jasmine beat Laurel in Balls in.

When Bananas and Laurel were voted into the elimination on Free Agents in episode 5, what if they played Puzzle Pyramid instead of Balls In? What if they lost their elimination rounds? The outcome of the game could have been completely different.

When Bananas and Laurel were voted into the elimination on Free Agents in episode 5, what if they played Puzzle Pyramid instead of Balls In? What if they lost their elimination rounds? The outcome of the game could have been completely different.

Laurel losing to Jazzy in puzzle? Hmmm

What if Jasmine beat Laurel in Balls in.

Production would be ***** to make laurel compete with a broken leg considering that's the only way jasmine stands half a chance against laurel. 

justintime wrote:

When Bananas and Laurel were voted into the elimination on Free Agents in episode 5, what if they played Puzzle Pyramid instead of Balls In? What if they lost their elimination rounds? The outcome of the game could have been completely different.

Laurel losing to Jazzy in puzzle? Hmmm

That would be the funniest shit ever.

justintime twrote:

When Bananas and Laurel were voted into the elimination on Free Agents in episode 5, what if they played Puzzle Pyramid instead of Balls In? What if they lost their elimination rounds? The outcome of the game could have been completely different.

Laurel losing to Jazzy in puzzle? Hmmm

what makes you think she'd win? Jonna was the one wjo solved the puzzle when they were paired together.

schaboszczak wrote:

justintime twrote:When Bananas and Laurel were voted into the elimination on Free Agents in episode 5, what if they played Puzzle Pyramid instead of Balls In? What if they lost their elimination rounds? The outcome of the game could have been completely different.

Laurel losing to Jazzy in puzzle? Hmmm

what makes you think she'd win? Jonna was the one wjo solved the puzzle when they were paired together.

Read the ******* question again. " What if they lost their elimination rounds?"

What if Frank was d/qed for pushing Sam in the BOTS final and Chet was d/qed for calling Devyn a dumby and Trashelle got med evaced after she fell in the sand? 

What if on The Duel, the final was 3 each sex, meaning Aneesa and CT actually ran it? 

What if on The Duel, the final was 3 each sex, meaning Aneesa and CT actually ran it? 

Jodi still wins for the girl. Nobody was beating Jodi that season, except for Beth, in the Duel. The only person I think could've gave Jodi a run for the money in the final was Kina, possibly Diem.

The men still comes down to the soccer shootout. The only reason Brad lost was because of that.

What if Frank was d/qed for pushing Sam in the BOTS final and Chet was d/qed for calling Devyn a dumby and Trashelle got med evaced after she fell in the sand? 

I hope you're just playing cause this is by far the dumbest question I've ever heard. 

LOL i've posted other stupid ones on here before. It's just funny to me when people make random comments on here like Jasmine beating Laurel on FA.

Pages