The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if TJ had confessionals lol

 

I would be so weak


In the knees?

You could hardly speak?

I would like to see TJ turn up with the cast on the first night. 

No one cost Nany that final. Nany cost Nany that final when she had a mental, emotional, and physical breakdown over riding on a stationary bike.

Laurel probably got Zach at his worst during that final challenge and she still won. 

 

That's a bit dramatic, it wasn't that serious at all. She freaked out for like 2 seconds and got right back on. It was her first final, give her a break. She killed the rest of it.

What if Ev didn't throw the elimination to Kelly Anne in the ruins?

 

& Nany did well, but her not having that freakout wouldn't have changed the outcome, regardless.

No one cost Nany that final. Nany cost Nany that final when she had a mental, emotional, and physical breakdown over riding on a stationary bike.

Laurel probably got Zach at his worst during that final challenge and she still won. 

 

That's a bit dramatic, it wasn't that serious at all. She freaked out for like 2 seconds and got right back on. It was her first final, give her a break. She killed the rest of it.

so in essence she still cost herself the final Smile

No one cost Nany that final. Nany cost Nany that final when she had a mental, emotional, and physical breakdown over riding on a stationary bike.

Laurel probably got Zach at his worst during that final challenge and she still won. 

 

That's a bit dramatic, it wasn't that serious at all. She freaked out for like 2 seconds and got right back on. It was her first final, give her a break. She killed the rest of it.

so in essence she still cost herself the final Smile

Even if the bike incident didn't happen, Nany wouldn't have won. Laurel is elite and she was winning that final regardless. It doesn't take away from Nany's ability though. She still killed the final and did better than many others who have competed in finals.

She drank and smoked all season long and still beasted the mountain with Bananas. #Impressive

No one cost Nany that final. Nany cost Nany that final when she had a mental, emotional, and physical breakdown over riding on a stationary bike.

Laurel probably got Zach at his worst during that final challenge and she still won. 

 

That's a bit dramatic, it wasn't that serious at all. She freaked out for like 2 seconds and got right back on. It was her first final, give her a break. She killed the rest of it.

so in essence she still cost herself the final Smile

Even if the bike incident didn't happen, Nany wouldn't have won. Laurel is elite and she was winning that final regardless. It doesn't take away from Nany's ability though. She still killed the final and did better than many others who have competed in finals.

She drank and smoked all season long and still beasted the mountain with Bananas. #Impressive

i know. so in essence she still cost herself the Final.

No one cost Nany that final. Nany cost Nany that final when she had a mental, emotional, and physical breakdown over riding on a stationary bike.

Laurel probably got Zach at his worst during that final challenge and she still won. 

 

That's a bit dramatic, it wasn't that serious at all. She freaked out for like 2 seconds and got right back on. It was her first final, give her a break. She killed the rest of it.

so in essence she still cost herself the final Smile

Even if the bike incident didn't happen, Nany wouldn't have won. Laurel is elite and she was winning that final regardless. It doesn't take away from Nany's ability though. She still killed the final and did better than many others who have competed in finals.

She drank and smoked all season long and still beasted the mountain with Bananas. #Impressive

i know. so in essence she still cost herself the Final.

Did I miss it where someone said otherwise? 

No one cost Nany that final. Nany cost Nany that final when she had a mental, emotional, and physical breakdown over riding on a stationary bike.

Laurel probably got Zach at his worst during that final challenge and she still won. 

 

That's a bit dramatic, it wasn't that serious at all. She freaked out for like 2 seconds and got right back on. It was her first final, give her a break. She killed the rest of it.

so in essence she still cost herself the final Smile

Even if the bike incident didn't happen, Nany wouldn't have won. Laurel is elite and she was winning that final regardless. It doesn't take away from Nany's ability though. She still killed the final and did better than many others who have competed in finals.

She drank and smoked all season long and still beasted the mountain with Bananas. #Impressive

i know. so in essence she still cost herself the Final.

Did I miss it where someone said otherwise? 

not directly. the above quote is defending Nany's abilities like i was questioning them. when i wasn't that's all.  

No one cost Nany that final. Nany cost Nany that final when she had a mental, emotional, and physical breakdown over riding on a stationary bike.

Laurel probably got Zach at his worst during that final challenge and she still won. 

 

That's a bit dramatic, it wasn't that serious at all. She freaked out for like 2 seconds and got right back on. It was her first final, give her a break. She killed the rest of it.

so in essence she still cost herself the final Smile

Even if the bike incident didn't happen, Nany wouldn't have won. Laurel is elite and she was winning that final regardless. It doesn't take away from Nany's ability though. She still killed the final and did better than many others who have competed in finals.

She drank and smoked all season long and still beasted the mountain with Bananas. #Impressive

i know. so in essence she still cost herself the Final.

Did I miss it where someone said otherwise? 

^^^^^

What if prime-Nany had t go into X Battle against prime-Susie?

 

What if prime-Nany had t go into X Battle against prime-Susie?

I think Nany would win. Susie is good, but I think she's a little overrated. And we haven't really seen her on a physical match except for with Kim. 

Susie is the smartest girl to ever play the game IMO but she would get beat in physical eliminations.

Susie is the smartest girl to ever play the game IMO but she would get beat in physical eliminations.

I agree. She excels in team formats (The Gauntlet 2, The Inferno 3, The Ruins) but I don't think she'd make it to the end if she was in an individual format. 

What if the cast actually got Jo to stay after her freakout lol I would've liked to see how Jo would've done throughout the season. Her freakout on The Gauntlet 2 premiere will always be TV gold. 

Susie is the smartest girl to ever play the game IMO but she would get beat in physical eliminations.

This I agree with but she is not as weak in physical eliminations as people think. I personally think she'd beat most of the girls on the show now a days like Nany and Jonna.

Susie is the smartest girl to ever play the game IMO but she would get beat in physical eliminations.

This I agree with but she is not as weak in physical eliminations as people think. I personally think she'd beat most of the girls on the show now a days like Nany and Jonna.

I don't think so.

Susie is the smartest girl to ever play the game IMO but she would get beat in physical eliminations.

This I agree with but she is not as weak in physical eliminations as people think. I personally think she'd beat most of the girls on the show now a days like Nany and Jonna.


Jonna no question Nany probably not.

What if Rivals 2's 2nd day had Jordan/Marlon & Camila/Jemmye? I know Camila and Jemmye would still have been 3rd place but do you think Jordan/Marlon could have taken runner up away from Frank/Bananas?

What if Rivals 2's 2nd day had Jordan/Marlon & Camila/Jemmye? I know Camila and Jemmye would still have been 3rd place but do you think Jordan/Marlon could have taken runner up away from Frank/Bananas?

This final has a lot of puzzles, so I don't think so.

What if Rivals 2's 2nd day had Jordan/Marlon & Camila/Jemmye? I know Camila and Jemmye would still have been 3rd place but do you think Jordan/Marlon could have taken runner up away from Frank/Bananas?

This final has a lot of puzzles, so I don't think so.

well Johnny Bananas and Frank didn't solve the first puzzle just as Jordan and Marlon didn't. so i think there would be a good chance for Jordan and Marlon to beat them.

nany would destroy susie in x battle imo.

thats not to take away from Susie though because she is a good conpetitor and better than average. just nany is better and more aggressive in contact

Susie vs jonna would be a fair and unpredictable match up

nany would destroy susie in x battle imo.

thats not to take away from Susie though because she is a good conpetitor and better than average. just nany is better and more aggressive in contact

Susie vs jonna would be a fair and unpredictable match up

 

If Jonna could get a bit more muscle and improve her swimming she could be a tier 2 girl imo.

Susie probably would have the edge with current jonna though idk. 

I think Susie would be able to beat Nany tbh

I think Susie would be able to beat Nany tbh

I think Susie would kick Jonna's *** lol. I love Jonna but Susie beat Kim and Kim is bigger than Jonna.

I think Susie vs Nany could go either way.  Nany is just a bigger girl.

I love Susie but there's no way she will beat Nany in an X Battle/Rag Doll

I love Susie but there's no way she will beat Nany in an X Battle/Rag Doll

I think Susie has more endurance then her plus she's a lot smarter so she'd be simliar to Theresa in which she'd tire Nany out.

Eh Susie didnt play the game smart when she went against Kim. & Im not trying to discredit susies win but c'mon kim hates physical contact so she probably wasn't even playing with her heart.. I feel like Nany would toss her. 

Kim hates physical contact but she still beat Ruthie so I do think she gave it her all against Susie. I mean it was a tough battle/great elimination.

Pages