The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if Leroy knew how to swim

 

He may have one battle of the exes 2. But i dont think that why he lost. i feel when they stopped at the top of the hill they lost alot of time .

look at how far away they were from sarah/Jordan when they got on the kayak. The swim is definitely what destroyed them 

 

No not really because no matter what the first team of the first day of the final would have gotten a five minute head start . so it really didnt matter how long leroy and theresa took swimming because jay and jenna were going to quit . so they didnt have to worry about being third .... they could have made laps in the water and still only been 5 minutes behid sarah and jordan day 2......... just look at rivals 1 final. kenney and wes finished like hours before johnny and tyler day 1 . But only had like a 2 minute headstart or something day 2 .

What if Leroy knew how to swim

 

He may have one battle of the exes 2. But i dont think that why he lost. i feel when they stopped at the top of the hill they lost alot of time .

look at how far away they were from sarah/Jordan when they got on the kayak. The swim is definitely what destroyed them 

 

No not really because no matter what the first team of the first day of the final would have gotten a five minute head start . so it really didnt matter how long leroy and theresa took swimming because jay and jenna were going to quit . so they didnt have to worry about being third .... they could have made laps in the water and still only been 5 minutes behid sarah and jordan day 2......... just look at rivals 1 final. kenney and wes finished like hours before johnny and tyler day 1 . But only had like a 2 minute headstart or something day 2 .

they made up over 20 minutes when they got on foot according to sarah which shows that they had a much better pace on foot. if leroy could have somewhat kept up during the swim then they could have gotten the first place position the first day with their superior running pace

what if the ruins happened before the island?

a challengers team with ct, evan, brad and bananas vs a champions team with kenny, darrell, derrick and alton.  

 

 

What if Theresa beat Laurel in the Pryamid Puzzle. Who do you think would've won Free Agents? I would have to say Theresa.

What if Theresa beat Laurel in the Pryamid Puzzle. Who do you think would've won Free Agents? I would have to say Theresa.

I can't see Nany beating Theresa in final, even if Zach slowed Theresa down.

What if Theresa beat Laurel in the Pryamid Puzzle. Who do you think would've won Free Agents? I would have to say Theresa.

I can't see Nany beating Theresa in final, even if Zach slowed Theresa down.

That's true. Theresa is such an avid runner and has great endurance that she would've beat Nany. 

What if Theresa beat Laurel in the Pryamid Puzzle. Who do you think would've won Free Agents? I would have to say Theresa.

I can't see Nany beating Theresa in final, even if Zach slowed Theresa down.

That's true. Theresa is such an avid runner and has great endurance that she would've beat Nany. 

so if theresa had been in the free agents final and won, do you think she would have come back to do exes 2, or retired?

and if she had come back, would she have remained friends with nany?

nany seems to think theresa dislikes her because she feels nany took her spot in the free agents final - devyn's comments at the free agents reunion on how when she and nany got home theresa had blocked them both on social media makes me think this is at least part of theresa's reason for disliking nany

so would bananas and nany and wes and theresa have worked together on exes 2?





What if Theresa beat Laurel in the Pryamid Puzzle. Who do you think would've won Free Agents? I would have to say Theresa.



I can't see Nany beating Theresa in final, even if Zach slowed Theresa down.



That's true. Theresa is such an avid runner and has great endurance that she would've beat Nany. 



so if theresa had been in the free agents final and won, do you think she would have come back to do exes 2, or retired?


and if she had come back, would she have remained friends with nany?


nany seems to think theresa dislikes her because she feels nany took her spot in the free agents final - devyn's comments at the free agents reunion on how when she and nany got home theresa had blocked them both on social media makes me think this is at least part of theresa's reason for disliking nany


so would bananas and nany and wes and theresa have worked together on exes 2?



Theresa would have not retired. I think because of the Exes 2, she retired. she would have done the same thing to Nany even if she won FA. Actually, I think Theresa's ego would have been bigger

What if Theresa beat Laurel in the Pryamid Puzzle. Who do you think would've won Free Agents? I would have to say Theresa.

I can't see Nany beating Theresa in final, even if Zach slowed Theresa down.

That's true. Theresa is such an avid runner and has great endurance that she would've beat Nany. 

so if theresa had been in the free agents final and won, do you think she would have come back to do exes 2, or retired?

and if she had come back, would she have remained friends with nany?

nany seems to think theresa dislikes her because she feels nany took her spot in the free agents final - devyn's comments at the free agents reunion on how when she and nany got home theresa had blocked them both on social media makes me think this is at least part of theresa's reason for disliking nany

so would bananas and nany and wes and theresa have worked together on exes 2?

i don't think she would've retired. She would've come back for Exes 2. Maybe her and Nany would've been friends, who knows. I know they wouldnt have worked together because of the rivalry between Wes and Johnny.

i honestly feel like Theresa said those things about Nany because of Wes. Wes and Johnny had their thing and I kinda felt like Theresa had to have a fued with Nany just because of the dynamic of the two teams.

like if Leory and Theresa were partners, which I would've loved to see, I don't think she would've said those things because there was no tension between the two teams. Just my theory though.

I definitely think Theresa's problem with Nany had to do with jealously. She was jealous Nany got to see a final and did well and then she was going to be partnered with Bananas.

Theresa talked to Nany right before they left for filming and was excited to be on the challenge with her and then all the sudden they go to film and she hates her? She definitely saw that Averey disliked Nany so it was perfect for Theresa just to team up with her and hate her.

I definitely think Theresa's problem with Nany had to do with jealously. She was jealous Nany got to see a final and did well and then she was going to be partnered with Bananas.

Theresa talked to Nany right before they left for filming and was excited to be on the challenge with her and then all the sudden they go to film and she hates her? She definitely saw that Averey disliked Nany so it was perfect for Theresa just to team up with her and hate her.

like Wes is a bad partner.

I definitely think Theresa's problem with Nany had to do with jealously. She was jealous Nany got to see a final and did well and then she was going to be partnered with Bananas.

Theresa talked to Nany right before they left for filming and was excited to be on the challenge with her and then all the sudden they go to film and she hates her? She definitely saw that Averey disliked Nany so it was perfect for Theresa just to team up with her and hate her.

like Wes is a bad partner.

Please every one knows that if the exile twist wouldnt have happend wes and theresa would have one easily ..... I mean im sorry but they were way above the other teams ... like way , way above.

What if Theresa beat Laurel in the Pryamid Puzzle. Who do you think would've won Free Agents? I would have to say Theresa.

I can't see Nany beating Theresa in final, even if Zach slowed Theresa down.

That's true. Theresa is such an avid runner and has great endurance that she would've beat Nany. 

It would have been much closer and if Nany won I wouldn't have been suprised. She didn't lose to Laurel by much and Laurel >>>>>>>>>>>> Theresa. Zach slowing her down actually may have cost her the final. 

It probably wouldn't have been that close. Just look at the swamp challenge they had where theresa pretty much smoked nany until the puzzle. There had to have been a good several minute difference there which is huge when you consider that the course wasn't so long. Assuming they wOuld both sustain that pace over a longer period of time, the gap would have been widened in something as long as a final

It probably wouldn't have been that close. Just look at the swamp challenge they had where theresa pretty much smoked nany until the puzzle. There had to have been a good several minute difference there which is huge when you consider that the course wasn't so long. Assuming they wOuld both sustain that pace over a longer period of time, the gap would have been widened in something as long as a final

Zach smoked Bananas on that challenge too until the puzzle and I don't have to tell you how he did in the final. lol I think that if Nany lost to Laurel by a small margin then the gap between Nany and Theresa would have been much smaller (that's assuming Zach gassed out on Theresa like he did Laurel).  It would have been much closer because again Laurel >>>>>>>>Theresa. 

zach had issues with the high elevation because of his body type. theresa has done high elevation endurance before and is isnt anymore muscular than nany. there isnt any proof that she would struggle with it outside of the incorrect thinking that shes physically related to zach. all we know is that she beat nany in the swamp by an appreciable margin.

also there really isnt much proof that demonstrates that laurel > theresa, especially significantly, in a final. theyve never done a high endurance course against one another and the only connection you can make between the two of them is how they have performed relative to nany in which case that would show that they are a lot more even matched than you suggest. to say that laurel would absolutely and completely win against theresa in a final that is heavy on endurance doesnt really have a solid base of proof but just goes off the myth that laurel is some unstoppable machine in FINALS because shes great in missions and elimination rounds. laurel being better than theresa in other things doesnt mean she would be better in an endurance related final where there isnt much heavy lifting involved

It probably wouldn't have been that close. Just look at the swamp challenge they had where theresa pretty much smoked nany until the puzzle. There had to have been a good several minute difference there which is huge when you consider that the course wasn't so long. Assuming they wOuld both sustain that pace over a longer period of time, the gap would have been widened in something as long as a final

Zach smoked Bananas on that challenge too until the puzzle and I don't have to tell you how he did in the final. lol I think that if Nany lost to Laurel by a small margin then the gap between Nany and Theresa would have been much smaller (that's assuming Zach gassed out on Theresa like he did Laurel).  It would have been much closer because again Laurel >>>>>>>>Theresa. 

and Theresa>>>>>>>>> Nany

It probably wouldn't have been that close. Just look at the swamp challenge they had where theresa pretty much smoked nany until the puzzle. There had to have been a good several minute difference there which is huge when you consider that the course wasn't so long. Assuming they wOuld both sustain that pace over a longer period of time, the gap would have been widened in something as long as a final

Zach smoked Bananas on that challenge too until the puzzle and I don't have to tell you how he did in the final. lol I think that if Nany lost to Laurel by a small margin then the gap between Nany and Theresa would have been much smaller (that's assuming Zach gassed out on Theresa like he did Laurel).  It would have been much closer because again Laurel >>>>>>>>Theresa. 

and Theresa>>>>>>>>> Nany

....Never said she wasn't soooo

What if Theresa's partner was with Leroy from the beginning. Would she have done good in those eliminations (Strung Out, Hooking Up, Hall Brawl)? I think Theresa is a great competitor but she seems like she is mentally weak and not good at eliminations.

What if Theresa's partner was with Leroy from the beginning. Would she have done good in those eliminations (Strung Out, Hooking Up, Hall Brawl)? I think Theresa is a great competitor but she seems like she is mentally weak and not good at eliminations.

I don't think they would have seen as many eliminations honestly. They wouldn't have come in last and been in Bananas alliance. With no Wes there (unless he had another partner) they would have skated close towards the end probably only seeing one elimination and making a final losing to either Jordan/Sarah or Bananas/Nany or both. If she did see those eliminations I think she would have done well because she's tall too and I think has more gas in the tank than Nia so she would have done well in Strung Out and Hooking Up.

What if Casey was sent in to face Susie in the Ruins instead of Brianna? Would the Challengers have won more challenges? Win the whole thing?

What if Casey was sent in to face Susie in the Ruins instead of Brianna? Would the Challengers have won more challenges? Win the whole thing?

Not at all IMO

Wasn't Casey throwing missions on purpose? Didn't brad and her have an alliance with the champions

Wasn't Casey throwing missions on purpose? Didn't brad and her have an alliance with the champions

supposedly, yes

wes mentions it to kellyanne in the letter he leaves her when he gets eliminated

someone here posted screenshots of it awhile ago. it said something like don't trust brad he's working with evan 

Makes me dislike brad more

Makes me dislike brad more


Yeah, that dude is a creep

I definitely think Theresa's problem with Nany had to do with jealously. She was jealous Nany got to see a final and did well and then she was going to be partnered with Bananas.

Theresa talked to Nany right before they left for filming and was excited to be on the challenge with her and then all the sudden they go to film and she hates her? She definitely saw that Averey disliked Nany so it was perfect for Theresa just to team up with her and hate her.

like Wes is a bad partner.

Never said that. But Theresa knows that Bananas usually has the numbers and basically always makes the final so in her head she probably just expected them to make it to the end. Bananas/Nany have history of performing very well together leading up to Exes 2 on Free Agents.

I never expected Wes to play as of a good political game as he did on Exes 2. Wes has always been a mastermind but the most recent challenges Wes hasn't really been as a good. The Wes on Exes 2 reminded me of Duel/FM Wes. Also Wes is a lot scrawnier nowadays so she could have thought they wouldn't be as strong. Clearly they ended up being the best overall time and Wes was MVP of the season but coming into the challenge I don't think Theresa expected it.

Wasn't Casey throwing missions on purpose? Didn't brad and her have an alliance with the champions

Yeah it was very obvious Casey was throwing it. I mean she didn't suck that bad on G3. She never costed her team a mission and then all the sudden on the Ruins she legit can't do a signle thing..

I definitely think Theresa's problem with Nany had to do with jealously. She was jealous Nany got to see a final and did well and then she was going to be partnered with Bananas.

Theresa talked to Nany right before they left for filming and was excited to be on the challenge with her and then all the sudden they go to film and she hates her? She definitely saw that Averey disliked Nany so it was perfect for Theresa just to team up with her and hate her.

like Wes is a bad partner.

Never said that. But Theresa knows that Bananas usually has the numbers and basically always makes the final so in her head she probably just expected them to make it to the end. Bananas/Nany have history of performing very well together leading up to Exes 2 on Free Agents.

I never expected Wes to play as of a good political game as he did on Exes 2. Wes has always been a mastermind but the most recent challenges Wes hasn't really been as a good. The Wes on Exes 2 reminded me of Duel/FM Wes. Also Wes is a lot scrawnier nowadays so she could have thought they wouldn't be as strong. Clearly they ended up being the best overall time and Wes was MVP of the season but coming into the challenge I don't think Theresa expected it.

He probably stepped it up because he knew he had a shot with Theresa but knew he would be on the outside of the main alliance going into it. Rivals 1 and 2 he was set with alliances. Exes he was with Mandi and probably didn't think he would make it far. WIth Theresa he knew they could actually do well if they just avoided eliminations. 

Pages