The Challenge: Unpopular Opinions

10051 posts / 0 new
Last post

Jenn has always been a 2nd tier competitor IMO

1st Tier (elite) - Emily, Ev, Rachel R., Laurel, Kellyanne

2nd Tier (above average) - Jenn, Diem, CM, Theresa, Tori, Paula, Tonya

3rd Tier (average) - Jonna, Jessica,  Nany

4th Tier (decent) - Devyn, Robin, Johanna

Bottom - Casey, Shavoun, Emillee

 

I detest Jenn, but I can't deny that she should have at least won a challenge. Jenn, Kellyanne and Diem (R.I.P) all are/were due for a win. If Jenn & Emily still had Derrick (or even Bananas), Blue would have won easily on Cutthroat. Kellyanne/Sarah should have (and could have) won The Ruins if it wasn't for that damn puzzle. Diem got screwed twice (Big Easy in the Gauntlet 3 and CT in Exes 1)

kelly Anne might have the potential for tier 1 but she needs to show viewers more. one excellent showing but preferably two

If theresa came back And gave us just one more season or even half a season on par with exes then she could sit safely at tier 1. I consider her last season as tier 1 work but not cutthroat or free agents. Her baby will more than likely hold her at tier 1.5 tho since she won't come back because of it 

Cooke is the same

sarah is iffy. She's had 8ish seasons but almost every time there's one chick who makes her look like the back up ***** that you only go to if the #1 gets jfk'd. On ruins it was KA, exes was theresa, cutthroat was Laurel. Only on seasons was she #1 and that was because that season was filled with a bunch of "special" people. Being top student in remedial cl*** doesn't mean anything

I tend to think of tier 1 people as those that have more than one season as established alphas

ka, theresa and Cooke and camila are all noticeably better than #2s  like Paula and tori, diem but are pending admittance to #1

i think nany is tier 2

cara Maria? I don't even care. I lost interest in her rusty stale moldy *** after challenge/failure 357 with Rachel or Landon or <insert elite partner> as babysitter. Don't give a shit if she sends everyone home singlehandedly and wins on challenge 358. ***** already missed her deadline to get me to care like 100 seasons ago. Too late  

 



Omggg!!!! THISSSSSSS!!!!!!!

I love KellyAnne but I don't think she is an elite competitor yet. KellyAnne is good but she has not proven that she is one of the best. On The Island, she outperformed Rachel R. in a face-off which was impressive but she didn't really impress me in anything else since there were no other challenges that season. On The Ruins, she did good on the challenges but Sarah outperformed her a few times, particularly in the Wall Walker mission right before the finals. Also, KellyAnne was the weak link in the final while Sarah did better than her.

Next season, we'll see if KellyAnne has gotten stronger so I can't wait! 

I think Darrell is creepy and has that vibe that you want to punch him.

I've been an occasional lurker forever, but I had to pop in because I'm still clutching my chest, laughing at the bold commenter who admitted to liking Dunbar.

As far as unpopular opinions go, I love Frank S. and I hope he returns! I find his antics mostly amusing, and I think he could beat almost any other current Challenge male in an individual final.
Also, I can't stand Sarah Rice. She seems like a nice person, but something about her personality and style of gameplay just grates on my nerves.

I've been an occasional lurker forever, but I had to pop in because I'm still clutching my chest, laughing at the bold commenter who admitted to liking Dunbar.

As far as unpopular opinions go, I love Frank S. and I hope he returns! I find his antics mostly amusing, and I think he could beat almost any other current Challenge male in an individual final.

Also, I can't stand Sarah Rice. She seems like a nice person, but something about her personality and style of gameplay just grates on my nerves. 

Please, marry me.

I love KellyAnne but I don't think she is an elite competitor yet. KellyAnne is good but she has not proven that she is one of the best. On The Island, she outperformed Rachel R. in a face-off which was impressive but she didn't really impress me in anything else since there were no other challenges that season. On The Ruins, she did good on the challenges but Sarah outperformed her a few times, particularly in the Wall Walker mission right before the finals. Also, KellyAnne was the weak link in the final while Sarah did better than her.

Next season, we'll see if KellyAnne has gotten stronger so I can't wait! 

I agree. Don't get why people think she is so good. I mean she has merit but she's nowhere near elite.

Caria maria ........ . . . Beasting this season

Watching KellyAnne eliminate overrated Rachel on The Island was everything.

Watching KellyAnne eliminate overrated Rachel on The Island was everything.

Rachel isn't overrated at all for me.

Watching KellyAnne eliminate overrated Rachel on The Island was everything.

Rachel isn't overrated at all for me.

Good for you. But for me she's extremely overrated and at the bottom of the Elite. She's no match for Evelyn, Emily, Laurel. KellyAnne took her out in an elimination, which none of the other Elites would have lost to. Jodi outlasted her in another endurance challenge on Inferno 2. Britanny also outlasted her in another endurance challenge at Duel 2. There's several girls Elite and non-Elite that could take her out in an elimination. Don't get me wrong, she's a great competitor, I'll put her in the Elite category (Even tho at the very bottom of it) but not the best or near the best (As if Top 3) like allot of people make her out to be.

And remember this is my unpopular opinion, which is why I posted it here Wink

Watching KellyAnne eliminate overrated Rachel on The Island was everything.

Rachel isn't overrated at all for me.

Good for you. But for me she's extremely overrated and at the bottom of the Elite. She's no match for Evelyn, Emily, Laurel. KellyAnne took her out in an elimination, which none of the other Elites would have lost to. Jodi outlasted her in another endurance challenge on Inferno 2. Britanny also outlasted her in another endurance challenge at Duel 2. There's several girls Elite and non-Elite that could take her out in an elimination. Don't get me wrong, she's a great competitor, I'll put her in the Elite category (Even tho at the very bottom of it) but not the best or near the best (As if Top 3) like allot of people make her out to be.

And remember this is my unpopular opinion, which is why I posted it here Wink

Everyone has a weakness. Rachels- endurance (btw I don't remeber that wasn;t so great), Emily's-swimming and puzzle, even Evelyn has moments of weakness, e.g Inferno's III challenge with girrafes. For me Rachel is elite, and before FM2 (Laurel, then Emily etc) she was 2nd or 3rd best girl in this show.

Watching KellyAnne eliminate overrated Rachel on The Island was everything.

Rachel isn't overrated at all for me.

Good for you. But for me she's extremely overrated and at the bottom of the Elite. She's no match for Evelyn, Emily, Laurel. KellyAnne took her out in an elimination, which none of the other Elites would have lost to. Jodi outlasted her in another endurance challenge on Inferno 2. Britanny also outlasted her in another endurance challenge at Duel 2. There's several girls Elite and non-Elite that could take her out in an elimination. Don't get me wrong, she's a great competitor, I'll put her in the Elite category (Even tho at the very bottom of it) but not the best or near the best (As if Top 3) like allot of people make her out to be.

And remember this is my unpopular opinion, which is why I posted it here Wink

Everyone has a weakness. Rachels- endurance (btw I don't remeber that wasn;t so great), Emily's-swimming and puzzle, even Evelyn has moments of weakness, e.g Inferno's III challenge with girrafes. For me Rachel is elite, and before FM2 (Laurel, then Emily etc) she was 2nd or 3rd best girl in this show.

That wasn't a weakness, lol, it was a mistake, which is a difference, because she picked the wrong orders of giraffes. She even said it on the "ask thingy" on how she regrets the order that she picked the giraffes and that she wished she picked a different order. Evelyn is the most well-rounded female competitor without any important challenge weakness. A true certified HBIC Elite.

And if you have a different opinion that's fine. This is a thread for everyone to post there unpopular opinion and move on, not argue about it because it won't go anywhere.

And yes, I still think Rachel is overrated Smile

His opinion is super unpopular MCM! Everyone else sees what an elite beast Rachel is! Biggrin

His opinion is super unpopular MCM! Everyone else sees what an elite beast Rachel is! Biggrin

IMAGE(http://media0.giphy.com/media/Rhhr8D5mKSX7O/giphy.gif)

Watching KellyAnne eliminate overrated Rachel on The Island was everything.

Rachel isn't overrated at all for me.

Good for you. But for me she's extremely overrated and at the bottom of the Elite. She's no match for Evelyn, Emily, Laurel. KellyAnne took her out in an elimination, which none of the other Elites would have lost to. Jodi outlasted her in another endurance challenge on Inferno 2. Britanny also outlasted her in another endurance challenge at Duel 2. There's several girls Elite and non-Elite that could take her out in an elimination. Don't get me wrong, she's a great competitor, I'll put her in the Elite category (Even tho at the very bottom of it) but not the best or near the best (As if Top 3) like allot of people make her out to be.

And remember this is my unpopular opinion, which is why I posted it here Wink

Everyone has a weakness. Rachels- endurance (btw I don't remeber that wasn;t so great), Emily's-swimming and puzzle, even Evelyn has moments of weakness, e.g Inferno's III challenge with girrafes. For me Rachel is elite, and before FM2 (Laurel, then Emily etc) she was 2nd or 3rd best girl in this show.

That wasn't a weakness, lol, it was a mistake, which is a difference, because she picked the wrong orders of giraffes. She even said it on the "ask thingy" on how she regrets the order that she picked the giraffes and that she wished she picked a different order. Evelyn is the most well-rounded female competitor without any important challenge weakness. A true certified HBIC Elite.

I think that Ev is #1 girl, but that was kinda weakness. She always was the best girl on the team, and then something went wrong and she breaks. If she walks to this calmly, I see her finished before dq time. And person who has no wekaness is like a  robot, like Laurel. (still love her so much)

His opinion is super unpopular MCM! Everyone else sees what an elite beast Rachel is! Biggrin

IMAGE(http://media0.giphy.com/media/Rhhr8D5mKSX7O/giphy.gif)


IMAGE(http://i.imgur.com/69cdXSk.gif)

Darrell is one of the only old-schoolers I wouldn't mind returning. Mainly because he needs some redemption given how he went out his last 2 shows.

I think Bananas has more purpose being on a season than CT now that his major plot point is done (RIP Diem). 

I also don't completely mind AYTO to come in, nor would I be opposed if the bloods from this upcoming season get offered to participate in future challenges.

I also wouldn't mind if the show gets canceled in two to three seasons. It really feels like a chicken running around without it's head. Go balls to the wall next two seasons with anyone interested to do a challenge and pull the curtains. 

I also think that Darrel is overrated and so is Rachel. I wouldn't mind seeing Jenn and Paula, to be honest, I think she has quite humorous commentary. 

I also think a mercedes is over priced, and I don't think shwarma is that good. And Obama isn't that effective as a president. And I think Europe is overated of a continent and their people aren't that great either.

I also wouldn't mind if the show gets canceled in two to three seasons. It really feels like a chicken running around without it's head. Go balls to the wall next two seasons with anyone interested to do a challenge and pull the curtains. 

This. They don't have the slightest clue of what to do with this & show & RW anymore.

Watching KellyAnne eliminate overrated Rachel on The Island was everything.

I don't think she's overrated but she definitely thought she had the challenge in the bag so it was funny Kellyanne beat her.

Watching KellyAnne eliminate overrated Rachel on The Island was everything.

I don't think she's overrated but she definitely thought she had the challenge in the bag so it was funny Kellyanne beat her.

I also wouldn't mind if the show gets canceled in two to three seasons. It really feels like a chicken running around without it's head. Go balls to the wall next two seasons with anyone interested to do a challenge and pull the curtains. 

This. They don't have the slightest clue of what to do with this & show & RW anymore.

Sad thing about it is the problems with this show are fixable but they just refuse to fix them. They just keep going in a direction this show isn't really designed to go in and it's gonna reach a dead end at one point.

I really liked Spring Break Challenge because:

1) The throwback to some challenges and eliminations that we haven't seen in a while. 

2) The awesome Balls In challenge and Pole Wrestle elimination. 

3) The underdog winning. Everyone thought Team Kenny would win, but Team Susie pulled off the victory. 

 

And with the limited time production had, I think they did a good job at editing it all. 

you cant say if any of the elites would have lost to kelly anne in that elimination round. none of the other elites, including jodi, have shown that they could do something like that. emily especialyl is notorious for sucking or being totally unremarkable at things that have nothing to do sitting on smaller girls. "the rack" was a weird elimination round and both rachel and kelly anne put up exceptional performances considering that robin is traditionally an average to above average competitor and she didnt even come close to matching KA and rachel. i could easily see laurel and emily losing to KA in that or at the very least being pushed to their uncomfortable limits on.

and yeah the entire season thats the one time brittani outperformed rachel...and barely might i add considering that rachel smoked brittani in every single heat up until then. rachel was the dominant force in the missions for the females. she was usually 1 or 2 and if she was 2 it was during a partner mission where landons abilities eclipsed mark's. besides all the elites get outperformded at one point or another. evelyn had a few nightmares on inferno 3 AND fresh meat 2. laurel has been more consistent than ev but even she flopped on her face in bed head from cutthroat and looked bad on rivals, emily doest even need a mention. every season shes on there are at least a couple of instances where someone makes her look bad.


you cant say if any of the elites would have lost to kelly anne in that elimination round. none of the other elites, including jodi, have shown that they could do something like that. emily especialyl is notorious for sucking or being totally unremarkable at things that have nothing to do sitting on smaller girls. "the rack" was a weird elimination round and both rachel and kelly anne put up exceptional performances considering that robin is traditionally an average to above average competitor and she didnt even come close to matching KA and rachel. i could easily see laurel and emily losing to KA in that or at the very least being pushed to their uncomfortable limits on.


and yeah the entire season thats the one time brittani outperformed rachel...and barely might i add considering that rachel smoked brittani in every single heat up until then. rachel was the dominant force in the missions for the females. she was usually 1 or 2 and if she was 2 it was during a partner mission where landons abilities eclipsed mark's. besides all the elites get outperformded at one point or another. evelyn had a few nightmares on inferno 3 AND fresh meat 2. laurel has been more consistent than ev but even she flopped on her face in bed head from cutthroat and looked bad on rivals, emily doest even need a mention. every season shes on there are at least a couple of instances where someone makes her look bad.



Robin sucks. Her size is her only strength. She's been on 9 challenges and won only 1 elimination (against Casey out of all people). She cost her team the win in the Gauntlet 2 final, cried to get a key on the Island and basically underperforms challenge after challenge. She's below average IMO.

I also realized why I hated Tori. She's a quitter. Every challenge she was on, she wanted to quit. On Gauntlet 3, she wanted to quit when her team threw her in against Melinda because she didn't want to play Ball Brawl (she hates physical eliminations). On Duel 2, she wanted to quit after her fight with Brad. On Cutthroat, she was about to throw the elimination because she didn't want to "slow" her team down in the final. Tori does suck and I was happy that she lost to Aneesa in Duel 2 after she gloated that she didn't want to face her in anything physical. Glad she got a bloody nose in Riot Act on Cutthroat

you cant say if any of the elites would have lost to kelly anne in that elimination round. none of the other elites, including jodi, have shown that they could do something like that. emily especialyl is notorious for sucking or being totally unremarkable at things that have nothing to do sitting on smaller girls. "the rack" was a weird elimination round and both rachel and kelly anne put up exceptional performances considering that robin is traditionally an average to above average competitor and she didnt even come close to matching KA and rachel. i could easily see laurel and emily losing to KA in that or at the very least being pushed to their uncomfortable limits on.

and yeah the entire season thats the one time brittani outperformed rachel...and barely might i add considering that rachel smoked brittani in every single heat up until then. rachel was the dominant force in the missions for the females. she was usually 1 or 2 and if she was 2 it was during a partner mission where landons abilities eclipsed mark's. besides all the elites get outperformded at one point or another. evelyn had a few nightmares on inferno 3 AND fresh meat 2. laurel has been more consistent than ev but even she flopped on her face in bed head from cutthroat and looked bad on rivals, emily doest even need a mention. every season shes on there are at least a couple of instances where someone makes her look bad.

Robin sucks. Her size is her only strength. She's been on 9 challenges and won only 1 elimination (against Casey out of all people). She cost her team the win in the Gauntlet 2 final, cried to get a key on the Island and basically underperforms challenge after challenge. She's below average IMO.

I don't really remember her underperforming as she's always been solid in challenges. She buckles under pressure but she's always been average/solid in challenges. 

I also realized why I hated Tori. She's a quitter. Every challenge she was on, she wanted to quit. On Gauntlet 3, she wanted to quit when her team threw her in against Melinda because she didn't want to play Ball Brawl (she hates physical eliminations). On Duel 2, she wanted to quit after her fight with Brad. On Cutthroat, she was about to throw the elimination because she didn't want to "slow" her team down in the final. Tori does suck and I was happy that she lost to Aneesa in Duel 2 after she gloated that she didn't want to face her in anything physical. Glad she got a bloody nose in Riot Act on Cutthroat

Watching Exes II over again, I found Nia's behavior after Sarah/Jordan voted in Bananas to be legimitately terrifying and gross. That was straight-up bullying and harrassment imo, and not just the sexual harrasment aspect with Jordan. 

Watching Exes II over again, I found Nia's behavior after Sarah/Jordan voted in Bananas to be legimitately terrifying and gross. That was straight-up bullying and harrassment imo, and not just the sexual harrasment aspect with Jordan. 

Still hilarious as hell when Nia call out this Fat Fake ***** LMAO

Love every second of this Smile

Pages