The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

I agree, nobody is saying she isn't good now, we're saying she wasn't always good.

Caramaria is a great competitor but her personality sucks. Point Blank

She's not a good competitor. She's decent at best. People just overrate her so much now. She is FAR from elite still.

To me, Cara Maria is hit or miss. She has her moments where I would love having her on my team and can hold her own, and it's obvious she can get physical and has the strength and athleticism to do well. But being a great competitor involves consistent mental strength and Cara Maria lets herself deteriorate when something doesn't go her way, even though she is capable of overcoming it. She has held her partner's back at times and hasn't always had the greatest of showings, but when she's on her game, she's a pretty good competitor.

Still ridiculous to say that because someone made a final, they are better than everyone who didn't. And Jonna and Nany outperformed CM on Rivals 2, no question. They consistently competed almost as well as Emily and Paula, but Emily is a beast so that's saying a lot. Every female team had a male team who had their back and Nany and Jonna were basically scapegoated into their elimination and it was a **** elimination anyways.

What if Theresa faced Anessa in Openheimer if Laurel didn't pulled the killed card? Do you guys think Theresa would drag Anessa how she did to Nia?

What if Theresa faced Anessa in Openheimer if Laurel didn't pulled the killed card? Do you guys think Theresa would drag Anessa how she did to Nia?

No but I do think Theresa would win.

What if Theresa faced Anessa in Openheimer if Laurel didn't pulled the killed card? Do you guys think Theresa would drag Anessa how she did to Nia?

I see Aneesa losing Openheimer against half of the FA cast.. 

What if Theresa faced Anessa in Openheimer if Laurel didn't pulled the killed card? Do you guys think Theresa would drag Anessa how she did to Nia?

I see Aneesa losing Openheimer against half of the FA cast.. 


No way in ****... Laurel possibly Theresa and maybe maybe Cara and probably all that would beat her.

What if Theresa faced Anessa in Openheimer if Laurel didn't pulled the killed card? Do you guys think Theresa would drag Anessa how she did to Nia?

I see Aneesa losing Openheimer against half of the FA cast.. 

No way in ****... Laurel possibly Theresa and maybe maybe Cara and probably all that would beat her.

Yeah I see Aneesa beating most of the girls in Oppenheimer except the three girls that are listed. Free Agents had a very weak female cast. 

What if Theresa faced Anessa in Openheimer if Laurel didn't pulled the killed card? Do you guys think Theresa would drag Anessa how she did to Nia?

I see Aneesa losing Openheimer against half of the FA cast.. 

No way in ****... Laurel possibly Theresa and maybe maybe Cara and probably all that would beat her.

Yeah I see Aneesa beating most of the girls in Oppenheimer except the three girls that are listed. Free Agents had a very weak female cast. 

Laurel, Theresa, Cara, I'd even Add Nany/Nia/Jonna.. Its about speed, Agility & balance which all of the listed girls have including Aneesa to an extent.

Aneesa would powerhouse all of them if she could get physical like in hallbrawl but due to the curvature of the structure it makes it less likely.

What if both freshmeat challenges would have been Alumni vs Fresh Meat. Who would have won each challenge:

Fresh meat 1:

Alumni- Darrell, Tina, Wes, Derrick, Theo, Shane, Coral, Katie, Tonya, Melinda, Johanna, Danny

FreshMeat- Aviv, Kenny, Casey, Diem, Chanda, Linette, Evan, Johnnie, Ryan, Jessi, Evelyn, Eric

 

Fresh Meat 2:

Alumni- Landon, Jillian, Kenny, Jenn, Ryan, Evelyn, Wes, CJ, Danny, Katelyn, Paula, Sarah, Darrell

Freshmeat- Carley, Pete, Laurel, Noor, Theresa, Luke, Mandy, Sydney, Sandy, Brandon, Jeff, Vinny, Cara Maria

My money would have been on the alumni for the first one and the Freshmeat for the second.

What if both freshmeat challenges would have been Alumni vs Fresh Meat. Who would have won each challenge:

Fresh meat 1:

Alumni- Darrell, Tina, Wes, Derrick, Theo, Shane, Coral, Katie, Tonya, Melinda, Johanna, Danny

FreshMeat- Aviv, Kenny, Casey, Diem, Chanda, Linette, Evan, Johnnie, Ryan, Jessi, Evelyn, Eric

 

Fresh Meat 2:

Alumni- Landon, Jillian, Kenny, Jenn, Ryan, Evelyn, Wes, CJ, Danny, Katelyn, Paula, Sarah, Darrell

Freshmeat- Carley, Pete, Laurel, Noor, Theresa, Luke, Mandy, Sydney, Sandy, Brandon, Jeff, Vinny, Cara Maria

My money would have been on the alumni for the first one and the Freshmeat for the second.


Nah the alumni guys are much stronger than the FM2.

I think laurel could have beaten paula , sarah and katelyn easy . if it was almui vs freshmeat .

I think laurel could have beaten paula , sarah and katelyn easy . if it was almui vs freshmeat .

Laurel vs Evelyn

and never again question: who is better?

What if both freshmeat challenges would have been Alumni vs Fresh Meat. Who would have won each challenge:

Fresh meat 1:

Alumni- Darrell, Tina, Wes, Derrick, Theo, Shane, Coral, Katie, Tonya, Melinda, Johanna, Danny

FreshMeat- Aviv, Kenny, Casey, Diem, Chanda, Linette, Evan, Johnnie, Ryan, Jessi, Evelyn, Eric

 

Fresh Meat 2:

Alumni- Landon, Jillian, Kenny, Jenn, Ryan, Evelyn, Wes, CJ, Danny, Katelyn, Paula, Sarah, Darrell

Freshmeat- Carley, Pete, Laurel, Noor, Theresa, Luke, Mandy, Sydney, Sandy, Brandon, Jeff, Vinny, Cara Maria

My money would have been on the alumni for the first one and the Freshmeat for the second.

Nah the alumni guys are much stronger than the FM2.

Yeah I think the alumni would have won both seasons. 

Laurel doing that wouldn't change the fact the alumni had people like Landon Kenny Evelyn and Darrell who are all great at finals.

Dont get me wrong evelyn is one of the strongest girls thats ever been on the show . 3 wins is impressive . But then again laurels never been eliminated in 4 seasons . Whats her record like 8-0 .

i think the alumni would have won both seasons because of their males.  though the fm teams did have good girls

Yeah they have some of the best people to ever do finals on their side like Evelyn, Kenny, Landon, and Darrell, no way the alumni lose there.

FM1 had Kenny, Evan, Evelyn, Diem, Aviv = not that bad imo. 

I think first season would have been more close than second one. Season 2 alumni side is clearly stronger.

I think first season FM would have won and second alumni

FM1 had Kenny, Evan, Evelyn, Diem, Aviv = not that bad imo. 

I think first season would have been more close than second one. Season 2 alumni side is clearly stronger.

I think first season FM would have won and second alumni

I still think that evelyn is stronger than laurel

I still think that evelyn is stronger than laurel

I think Evelyn is more well rounded but Laurel has a huge size advantage so Laurel could probably take her out in some eliminations. 

I still think that evelyn is stronger than laurel

I think Evelyn is more well rounded but Laurel has a huge size advantage so Laurel could probably take her out in some eliminations. 


Size really does matter!!! The ability to reach!!! Hahaha!!

What if Issac sent bananas home on free agents lol.

What if Issac sent bananas home on free agents lol.

Isaac would've been a god among men and would've single handedly made that season better.

But CT probably wins on the guys side.

What if Issac sent bananas home on free agents lol.
Isaac would've been a god among men and would've single handedly made that season better. But CT probably wins on the guys side.

i don't know. Johnny Reilly had animpressvetime the moutain.

What if the elimination on Free Agents between Bananas/Isaac and Jasmine/Laurel was Puzzle Pyramid and Isaac/Jasmine ended up winning?

What if the elimination on Free Agents between Bananas/Isaac and Jasmine/Laurel was Puzzle Pyramid and Isaac/Jasmine ended up winning?

I would've laughed my *** off.

Well, Jordan wouldn't have a reason to throw himself in then. Not sure how far he would've gone since his mission performances were lackluster that season (even before he wanted to go into the draw), but if he made the final I think he would win. If not him, then either Johnny Reilly or CT. For the females, I would guess either Theresa or Nany since CM would've (unfortunately) still had her hand broken from facing Jessica.

What if the elimination on Free Agents between Bananas/Isaac and Jasmine/Laurel was Puzzle Pyramid and Isaac/Jasmine ended up winning?


Idk if they would win tbh we have no idea how good those two are at puzzles

What if Leroy still had Adam R. as a partner on Rivals 1? Do you think they would have still made it to the finals?

What if Brad and Darrell didn't get kicked off of the Ruins? Do you think the results would still have been the same? I know that Darrell had a free pass to the finals but Brad had to go into the final Ruins most likely against someone.

 

Pages